Modesty Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeanne71350
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“The Church is the house of God. It is forbidden for men to enter with bare arms or in shorts. It is forbidden for women to enter in trousers, without a veil on their head, in short clothing, low necklines, sleeveless or immodest dresses.”
  • Sign on the doors of San Giovanni Rotondo
‘Women, claiming to try to be graceful, that their lips may not be rent apart by stretching them on broad drinking cups. . . drink in an unseemly way out of alabastra quite too narrow in the mouth. They throw back their heads and bare their necks indecently, as I think. They distend the throat in swallowing, gulping down the liquor as if to make bare all they can to their companions. They hiccup like men, or rather like slaves, and revel in luxurious riot.’

St. Clement of Alexandria, Father of the Church

There’s the purity issue, and not only purity, but the issue with display, showing off… women understand when they wear strapless dresses, they’re showing off. . putting their body on display…

There’s the issue with one not being able to move around in these morally, i.e. leaning forwards, to the side, etc. and revealing more.

And there’s the simple modesty issue, without any purity involved… It’s more modest to be more covered. To be more plain and concealed rather than revealed.

So you see men, wearing long sleeves, rather than short sleeves, is more modest in general.

If you unclothe an area of the body, close to an area of the body that must be clothed for purity issues, that is a problem. You have to go further. The body should be clothed in such a way that shows it is -clothed- rather than implies nakedness, the body, or potential nakedness.

In other words… the entire spirit behind Christian modesty is covering and concealing, simplicity rather than extravagance.

I think that most women can feel the sense of display that comes with the bared shoulders and so then, make the next step of understanding, it is not modest to display.

Tight clothing is also immodest. The figure should be concealed, not revealed.
 
Happy Easter. 😃

‘It is suitable, therefore, for women who serve Christ to adopt simplicity. For in reality simplicity provides for sanctity, by reducing redundancies to equality, and by furnishing from whatever is at hand the enjoyment sought from superfluities. For simplicity, as the name shows, is not conspicuous, is not inflated or puffed up in aught, but is altogether even, and gentle, and equal, and free of excess, and so is sufficient. And sufficiency is a condition which reaches its proper end without excess or defect.’

St. Clement of Alexandria

Simplicity, I might add is a Christian virtue.
 
‘Women, claiming to try to be graceful, that their lips may not be rent apart by stretching them on broad drinking cups. . . drink in an unseemly way out of alabastra quite too narrow in the mouth. They throw back their heads and bare their necks indecently, as I think. They distend the throat in swallowing, gulping down the liquor as if to make bare all they can to their companions. They hiccup like men, or rather like slaves, and revel in luxurious riot.’
😃

I guess there were always certain ladies who wanted to go just one step further than what was generally considered modest in their time.

I can see a very practical reason to why the Vatican, and the churches in Rome, enforce a dress code according to which shoulders and knees must be covered. If they concede to uncovered knees, there will be people (mostly women, but men, too) starting to wear shorter and shorter shorts until their butt cheeks will peak out. If they allow uncovered shoulders, lower and lower necklines and exposed backs will follow. If they allow the midriff to be exposed, those pants will get so low that the pubic areas will be in plain sight for everybody, and tops will shrink to the point of becoming sports bras.

This is what a beach guard said recently, when he was asked about the legal requirements to cover up on the beaches of the USA: “if I don’t see exposed nipples, anus, or vagina, you are fine”. And we have those beachgoers who act exactly like that - bras keep shrinking to the point that the only area covered is the nipples, and perhaps the lower part of breasts. The back of some thongs is like a dental floss - but hey, it’s all fine as long as the anus is covered. And the same thing applies in the front. We are living in the era of the incredibly shrinking dresses on the streets, and the era of beachwear that barely covers the nipples, anus, and the vagina.

I guess the Vatican just doesn’t want to go down that road, and setting some clear, easy to understand boundaries for what should be covered, is a practical way to ensure that.

As an aside, the other day I was kneeling in prayer before the Blessed Sacrament. A woman with a shoulder-baring dress came and knelt beside me, her right arm was almost touching my left arm. Call me a prude, but I don’t feel comfortable with a woman, dressed like that, being so close to me.
 
No offesne guys, but I really did not get an answer to my original question, WHY should shoulders be covered…
This is up to the individual. My husband and I always have covered shoulders. Why? We can’t really explain it. For some reason both of us just don’t feel right with them being uncovered. It’s a feeling for us, and we can’t really explain why we feel this way. I wasn’t brought up to think that bare shoulders are immodest, but I am not sure about him. He very well may have been raised that way.
 
I don’t know if you are interested in that particular dress, but the bare shoulders are the least of its worries. It’s much too tight in my opinion.
 
I don’t know if you are interested in that particular dress, but the bare shoulders are the least of its worries. It’s much too tight in my opinion.
The dress was an example of the type of sleeveless dress I meant, I just pulled a random picture

-Jeanne
 
Franky, I see nothing wrong with the shoulders… I have no explanation as to why, they are not really a sexualized part of the body.
But the sides of body can be, and it is hard to cover them while leaving the shoulders bare.

The neck, also, is a body region that is heavily sexualized, and uncovered shoulders might draw attention to it.

I kind of like Joseph Varga’s explanation of the Vatican’s ban on shorts and bare shoulders. At least, an explanation about clothing that makes sense: if body-covering is to be made an isssue, fixed standards are very important.

ICXC NIKA
 
I think I can clear this up pretty quickly. When I visited the St. Peter’s 6 years ago, they have these large paper towel like things they hand out to the women who are inappropriately dressed to cover their shoulders (American women dressed in shorty shorts and spaghetti straps in Europe irks me to begin with, not to mention them trying to get into a Cathedral dressed like that!) I was wearing a top that was cut much like the top of the dress in the picture and a flowy skirt that hit my knee. I was not told to cover my shoulders/arms. I think the main issue with these tops is the low-cut nature of them as well as the propensity to show undergarments. A sleeveless top really does not show much more of the arm than a stylish t-shirt does these days (most have cap sleeves as it is) and usually covers all of your undergarments.

I think the full arms are fine and was told such by my Confirmation teacher when she was asked what we should wear to the Confirmation mass.

For my convalidation I have chosen a simple white dress that is sleeveless (try finding anything with sleeves these days-- really!!) but has a high collar.
 
Oh, I knew it wouldn’t be long before we had someone post on here with the ruckus about women wearing pants in Church and quoting Padre Pio. While he is a saint, he was not/is not the Pope (athough a few people on CAF take his opinions as Ex Cathedra…).

Here is what is required for attendence at St Peter’s Basilica in the Vatican:saintpetersbasilica.org/Pics/SQR/DressCode-JG.jpg
 
Thankfully for the sake of our souls, what people wear or do in the Vatican is not an authoritative standard for Catholics. 🙂

As I’m sure a little knowledge of history would help understanding the thankfulness of, and what has magisterial weight and what does not.
 
In my opinion, I consider modest dress for Mass to be:

Men - no chest hair exposure, no sleeveless shirts, shorts to the knee in summer time/summer like climates. Typical dress for business professional or business casual offices is good for men - polo shirts, button down dress shirts, khakis, dress pants, dress shoes, casual or dress shoes that are not tennis shoes/trainers (unless they need to wear them for health reasons), Ties optional, sweaters/cardigans when the weather is cold, blazer/dress jacket. No hats of any kind in church. Clothing not tight fitting.

Women - no cleavage exposure. Dresses, skirts, and shorts/culottes/capris to the knees or below the knees. Typical dress for business professional or business casual offices is good for women which includes no tees, tank tops, spaghetti straps, strapless tops/dresses, no tight pants/slacks/skirts/dresses. Blazers/dress jackets or sweaters/cardigans based on weather & personal preference. Shawls/scarves etc should be used to cover shirts/dresses that are strapless, spaghetti strap etc in church. Dressy type hats or scarves/veils/mantillas (ivory, white, or black) on head - optional but would be nice to see more often. Tight fitting clothing/revealing clothing not allowed. Shoes should be casual or dressy, tennis shoes/trainers only if needed for health reasons not allowing for wearing of normal shoes.

Sandals on both genders - dressy sandals fine in summer/summer climates, flip flop types - NO.
 
Jeanne, I think it’s just because it’s hard to construct a sleeveless top that doesn’t accidentally show too much when we move. There was a woman at Easter Vigil who had on an ankle-length dress that was sleeveless but still modest, and then when she stood up, the dress didn’t quite move with her and I got such an eyeful through the arm hole that I could tell she had some kind of inserts in her bra. Yikes!
 
Also, with some guys, not all, it makes it easier to fantasize about women when something like the shoulders are revealed… I mean, the less cloth, the easier it is for him to imagine removing the clothing.… The man’s mind is wired this way. So the more clothing, the easier it is for the man to resist temptation!
REALLY? Really? ALL men are wired to automatically undress a woman just because her shoulders are exposed? What a way to make all men appear as lecherous beta-male creeps, man!

Here’s the simple answer to WHY shoulders should be covered-- in the context of a church, they should be covered for modesty’s sake. Showing shoulders is more of a “casual” thing that is more suitable for other settings, but not church. In church we need to be reverent.

Outside of church, I don’t see why it would be a problem by any means, as long as one’s chest isn’t exposed or you can see through the armhole like another poster mentioned.
 
What type of “shoulder-revealing-tops/dresses” would be modest enough to where cleavage or anything isn’t showing? Usually the two go hand in hand…

Also, with some guys, not all, it makes it easier to fantasize about women when something like the shoulders are revealed… I mean, the less cloth, the easier it is for him to imagine removing the clothing… The man’s mind is wired this way. So the more clothing, the easier it is for the man to resist temptation!

Good question and thanks for trying to keep men from having impure thoughts! It really helps to gain respect from the RIGHT guys. Which is really hard in this modern day 'n age where anything goes!

Peace and God bless!
Women should be dressing with decorum in church out of respect for Christ, not to keep men from mentally undressing them. Sufficiently motivated, a man can become turned on by a woman in a long-sleeved, shapeless caftan. In fact, I’ve had more than one man tell me that he gets more aroused the less he can see; it makes him wonder what’s underneath all those clothes.

I’ve known beautiful women who dress very conservatively and they still get ogled and “mentally undressed.” Do they “cause scandal” in their lawyerly business attire? Absolutely not. Have they led men to become sexually aroused simply because they have beautiful faces and obviously take care of themselves? Perhaps, but it’s on the guys to control their thoughts and do appropriate ablutions if they can’t. To suggest otherwise leads us down the well-beaten path of body shaming, which women in our society get in abundance without getting another heaping dose in church.
 
I’ve known beautiful women who dress very conservatively and they still get ogled and “mentally undressed.” Do they “cause scandal” in their lawyerly business attire? Absolutely not. Have they led men to become sexually aroused simply because they have beautiful faces and obviously take care of themselves? Perhaps, but it’s on the guys to control their thoughts and do appropriate ablutions if they can’t. To suggest otherwise leads us down the well-beaten path of body shaming, which women in our society get in abundance without getting another heaping dose in church.
In addition to men. Beautiful women will most likely catch the attention of a man but that does not mean he’s undressing her. I think these attitudes are damaging for both men and women, but in different ways.

I daresay, if exposed shoulders are such a deal outside of church, they are sexualized and it will only be a matter of time before ankles are back in that list, too.:rolleyes: People, they’re just joint sockets!
 
In addition to men. Beautiful women will most likely catch the attention of a man but that does not mean he’s undressing her. I think these attitudes are damaging for both men and women, but in different ways.
And men. You are correct. They are extremely damaging to all sexes. You are right again. But these CAF threads don’t usually talk about masculine modesty or how a provocatively-dressed man will cause women to sin.

And who said male privilege was dead? 🤷
 
Hi everyone,

First of, I’m not trying to start an argument about what’s appropriate and what’s not. I listen to what the Church says, but I’m asking this question mainly for my own knowledge. Now, I understand why women must cover the chest area, lower back area, and keep skirts and dresses around knee-length, but why is it considered immodest for a women to have bare shoulders?

Any answer is appreciated!

Thanks, God bless, and Happy Easter!

-Jeanne
I’ve asked my husband this before, since he’s the best insight I have into a man’s thought life. He says bare shoulders (as pictured in your link) are right on the line between modest and immodest, because they cover the upper body but invite the imagination to consider the rest of the shoulders uncovered.

So, personally, I wouldn’t wear this to Mass, but I’d wear it around my house or outside in really hot weather, such as to the beach, the park, or a sporting event.

Oddly enough, I was almost bounced from St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome on Ascension Thursday for being ignorant enough to wear a sleeveless shirt. The Swiss Guard debated for a minute with each other and then let me go in anyway. I think I got lucky. :o
 
Jeanne, I think it’s just because it’s hard to construct a sleeveless top that doesn’t accidentally show too much when we move. There was a woman at Easter Vigil who had on an ankle-length dress that was sleeveless but still modest, and then when she stood up, the dress didn’t quite move with her and I got such an eyeful through the arm hole that I could tell she had some kind of inserts in her bra. Yikes!
Good point. I’ve started wearing camis under all my cap-sleeve shirts because they also tend to gape when I move. If I can peek at my own bra in the mirror, I’m sure Anonymous Dude at Wal-Mart can do the same thing! :eek:
 
Also, with some guys, not all, it makes it easier to fantasize about women when something like the shoulders are revealed… I mean, the less cloth, the easier it is for him to imagine removing the clothing… The man’s mind is wired this way. So the more clothing, the easier it is for the man to resist temptation!
Or… the less clothing, the less stuffiness and restriction of movement to keep her from dealing a 10-hit combo to every bone in your body then finishing with a flying kick to the face?

Frankly, when I see a girl in shorts and sleeveless, the sensation of a broken nose and a bashed skull are more likely to come first to my head than anything sexual.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top