Muhammad timeline.

[paarsurrey]

Sorry to be blunt here paarsurrey, but I don’t think anyone here will agree to just ‘wipe out’ Muhammad’s last 12 years just because his first 55 years were ‘peaceful’.

I think you would probably agree with me, that the fighting age of a man is while one is young, energetic and powerful.
One needs a whole life’s experience to become a good general to fight with the Powers of the World, a lay-man who has spent most of his life only in peaceful religious pursuits, never getting any worthwhile warfare training/experience; who had never killed a person personally, never got training of the professional use of the weapons, never harmed a person. If such a person thinks to do all these things overnight; it would be impossible for him to even dream of such acts at the age of 53, not to speak of doing that even if he so wished. Is it not a miracle, on merit?

 

[Rodrigo_Bivar]

1. Muhammad did not acquire the force required to fight wars until he went to Medina. So your argument above is irrelevant.
2. Muhammad was a personal coward who wore two coats of armour while commanding from the REAR.
3. God judges a man by his actions all the days of his life. It doesn’t matter if he lives 99 years as a saint but in his last year he kills people. - He is still a murderer.

God does not judge a man solely by his first 55 years. Nobody gets a free pass to commit crimes and immorality after being ‘peaceful’ for 55 years.

You will never convince people here that Muhammad was a good man because most people (i.e. non-Muslims) understand that rape, pillage, robbery, killing, torture, genocide, ethnic-cleansing, polygamy, lechery and pedophilia are immoral acts.

Muslims, though, regardless of sect, thing those acts are good, so long as committed by Muslims. We know that - which is why the world has had so much problems with Islam and Muslims for the past 1400 years.

Note of course we don’t have the same problems with Buddhism/Buddhists because their founder was a true man of peace.

I hope you will see this one day.

 

[paarsurrey]

The problem with most books about Muhammad are either they heap so many superlatives on him that it becomes aggravatingly tiresome, or they call him an outright demon-spawn. Neither of which allow the man to come through clearly.

Put Jesus Christ in the picture (for comparison with Muhammad)

Hi

First of all , if at all needed , a comparison of both peaceful human ProphetsMessengers should be made for an equal age as Jesus did live for only some thirty years in this world, as Catholic believe . Then comparison of Jesus life should be made with Muhammad’s peaceful life in his first thirty years. We see both are princes of peace.

Thanks

 

[paarsurrey]

I’ll think about spending more money to discover more about Muhammad.

The problem with most books about Muhammad are either they heap so many superlatives on him that it becomes aggravatingly tiresome, or they call him an outright demon-spawn. Neither of which allow the man to come through clearly.

Hi

There is no need to spend any money.

I suggest you to access:
alislam.org/library/books/Life-of-Muhammad.pdf
and read the book titled “Life of Muhammad”.

Thanks

 

[inJESUS]

I heard recently that Muhammad;s father Abdallah is not his father since he died 4 years before his birth. I couldn’t check this so if anyone has info i’d appreciate it. thx