I need advice about music during Lent and Good Friday. Yesterday I introduced 2 pieces of music to our seasonal choir, “God Weeps” to be sung at a penitential service and “Surrexit Christus” by Pegolesi to be sung on Easter, and a reminder that “The Seven Last Words of Christ” should be sung on Good Friday again as we have the previous 2 years…
One of our 3 musicians, she the keystone of our music liturgy, whom I respect and love, attended our first choir practice of this season at my invitation. She has not sung with our 10-12 voice choir, but she sings and plays for mass every other Sunday, Easter Vigil, etc., and is my dear friend.
Last year she and I wanted to begin mass during Lent differently from usual here. We had a silent processional, the antiphon being chanted at the rear of the church, and the ministers, servers, etc. processing silently afterwards. We also sing a penitential litany/Kyrie during this season. The atmosphere is so reverent, and different from the other seasons.
I was dismayed yesterday to hear her not wanting any special music during Good Friday service. She said therewere so many things to do [within the mass] that there shouldn’t be extra music. Further, she said we should have less music during Lent.
“Sing to the Lord”, section 114 speaks to musical instrument “restraint”. I take this to mean, no trumpets, no exuberant music, more solumn music in general, “toning” music down, etc. I don’t read this area 110 - 118 as meaing no choral pieces. She doesn’t want preludes, postludes either
How can I mediate this situation? Our priest is “hands off”, leaving the music to us. This dear woman is my friend, I always defer to her decision. But this year, she seems to have set new barriers for our choir and I am at a loss.
I hesitate to post this. But I read this board everyday and the guidance given has certainly led me down a more proper path, muscially speaking!
Thank you for reading. If I am in error or off-base, please redirect me. I look forward to any help you may offer.