Must we believe this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Annie_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No. You can disbelieve if a given idea doesn’t make sense to you. That’s okay, you know.
What you just said is “No. You can disbelieve if a given revelation from God doesn’t make sense to you. That’s okay, you know.”

You really think so?
 
Annie B also now this is what i was taught, That really the reason Joseph married the Blessed Mother was because in those days she would have been stoned to death, (the Jewish law in those days). I was also taught that Joseph was much older than the Blessed Mother thats why he didnt want to marry her, she was a kid compared to him. Buy when the Angel came to him and told him it would be okay he did what God asked. But that kind of makes sense too, because where was Joseph when Jesus was crucified? If he was much older Joseph would have longed passed. That kind of makes sense with scripture also, you really dont hear much about him after Jesus got older. Its just his Mother, and think about it, if Joseph had enough faith and Love for God to trust the Angel, he surely would not have left Jesus and the Blessed Mother in such a horrible time. If he was on this earth Im sure he would have been there also.
 
I am just trying to learn and understand.

Annie
I do believe; help me overcome my unbelief!
  • Mark 9:24
Annie,
I had a tough time believing in the perpetual virginity of Mary because of my protestant upbringing. It took me about two years of reading, studying, and praying.

Now I am trying to understand another Catholic teaching and going through the same process.

God bless you.
 
Incidentally, does anyone reading this thread know whether nor not Mary was a consecrated virgin even before the Angel Gabriel visited her and before she married Joseph? I know I heard that somewhere - can someone shed some light? I brought up this issue in an earlier post, but no one responded to it.
 
Incidentally, does anyone reading this thread know whether nor not Mary was a consecrated virgin even before the Angel Gabriel visited her and before she married Joseph? I know I heard that somewhere - can someone shed some light? I brought up this issue in an earlier post, but no one responded to it.
I am under that impression, because of what I read in the Protoevangelium of James. There are several versions of this work, though, some of which are heretical and offensive in nature. I don’t have a link to the good one.
 
Through my years (and that is more than a few:p ) I have “been” Cathoic (at infancy), Baptist, Mormon and recently come home to the Catholic church.
Well this explains things more fully.
All that aside, when I see the verse in question (in ANY version), to me, it begs discussion - at the very least. As much as some Catholics here would like to believe, not all Catholics accept blindly the Church’s interpretation of scripture.
When there is a verse in question, we may certainly discuss it.
We use it as a guideline and then use the brain that God gave us to form our opinion.
Yes, we can. What we cannot do is reach a conclusion that contradicts defined doctrine. The Church is infallible in matters of faith and morals.

Therefore, with this verse as an example-- one may ponder the language used (recognizing of course that the English translation may not do justice to the original Greek) but one must always do so in light of what the Church teaches. Therefore, one cannot reach the conclusion this verse support sexual relations between Mary and Joseph.
ALL I wanted to do was understand the RCC’s teaching on this subject. I did NOT want to start such a heated debate…
You’ve been given some excellent links to read. I’m not sure how this turned into a heated debate. When I posted there were only a few posts, and I come back some hours later to 5 pages!

Also, you asked about a non-consummated marriage and its validity. The answer is that a non-consummated marriage is valid. But, until it is *consummated *it can be dissolved by the Pope:

Can. 1141 A marriage that is ratum et consummatum can be dissolved by no human power and by no cause, except death.

Can. 1142 For a just cause, the Roman Pontiff can dissolve a non-consummated marriage between baptized persons or between a baptized party and a non-baptized party at the request of both parties or of one of them, even if the other party is unwilling.
 
Incidentally, does anyone reading this thread know whether nor not Mary was a consecrated virgin even before the Angel Gabriel visited her and before she married Joseph? I know I heard that somewhere - can someone shed some light? I brought up this issue in an earlier post, but no one responded to it.
The teaching on the perpetual virginity is not based on this highly tenuous claim.

I believe the idea of Our Ladyl’s consecrated virginity is mentioned in the Protoevangelium of James. It is also my understanding that first century Jews know nothing of consecrated virginity.
 
Incidentally, does anyone reading this thread know whether nor not Mary was a consecrated virgin even before the Angel Gabriel visited her and before she married Joseph?
This is not a doctrine of the Church and there is no definitive teaching on this topic.
 
No. You can disbelieve if a given idea doesn’t make sense to you. That’s okay, you know.
What you can’t do (because it’s impossible) is disbelieve any dogma of the Church and claim to still be in communion with that Church.

Being in communion with the Church means you accept ALL its dogmas - even the ones that you don’t quite understand, like the Trinity or PV. Just like being an American citizen in good standing means you abide by all the laws of the country - even those that don’t make sense to you.
 
You’ve been given some excellent links to read. I’m not sure how this turned into a heated debate. When I posted there were only a few posts, and I come back some hours later to 5 pages!

.
Anytime anyone questions any doctrine/teaching of the RCC around here, it seems to turn into a heated debate…😦 Too many, it seems, seem to think that an honest question is a serious challenge to the RCC. This is SUPPOSED to be Catholic ANSWERS; some seem to feel that those seeking answers are truly defective Catholics…To those who are disturbed by the question I asked, I ask you this: Would it be better to not ask my question and continue in ignorance along a path that could lead me away from the RCC or is it better to ask the question and be brought to a place of understanding which will keep me on the right path? Also, I should not have needed to explain my background to get an answer…The answer should be the same answer, answered in LOVE, no matter what church I amy or may not belong to!

I really appreciate all the supportive responses that I have had here. The non-supportive, I do not appreciate as much:p I think I have more than enough information to chew on for a while…

Annie
 
I don’t know. I tend to think that she gave birth in the normal manner. If Jesus healed her at that moment, then this would have been His first miracle, rather than the changing of the water into wine at Cana.

Giving birth in the normal manner would not have taken away her virginity, any more than horseback riding takes away anyone’s virginity, even though physically, the hymen may be broken.
I thought the same. However, the church’s teaching is that Mary was physically intact both before and after Jesus’ birth and that there was no injury, lesion, or blood of hers shed during the birth. I questioned this several years ago in the EWTN Ask the Experts forum. Fr. Most, who has since died, privately emailed me the document which I didn’t keep but is probably on the EWTN website. He felt it was improper to speculate how this came about. However, as a woman, I don’t think it is improper to imagine that the birth took place through the birth canal but in such a manner that no tearing or injury took place.
 
What you can’t do (because it’s impossible) is disbelieve any dogma of the Church and claim to still be in communion with that Church.

Being in communion with the Church means you accept ALL its dogmas - even the ones that you don’t quite understand, like the Trinity or PV. Just like being an American citizen in good standing means you abide by all the laws of the country - even those that don’t make sense to you.
I may “abide” by all the laws, but I certainly do NOT agree with all of them, and I will pretest and try to change them if I can. For instance, legalized murder…Must I abide by that law to be “in good standing”? Hardly… There are plenty citizens in good standing who ask questions and disagree with the laws of the country. Your definition of “in good standing” does not make sense…If God had wanted mindless robots, he would have made us that way. But you know, that is WAAAAYYYY off topic of this thread.

By the way, I may accept the teachings/dogmas of the church, but how on earth can I agree if I don’t understand? THAT is why I started this thread - I just wanted to understand!! Acceptance and agreement do not always immediately go hand in hand. It may take time…

Annie
 
I may “abide” by all the laws, but I certainly do NOT agree with all of them, and I will pretest and try to change them if I can. For instance, legalized murder…Must I abide by that law to be “in good standing”? Hardly… There are plenty citizens in good standing who ask questions and disagree with the laws of the country. Your definition of “in good standing” does not make sense…If God had wanted mindless robots, he would have made us that way. But you know, that is WAAAAYYYY off topic of this thread.

By the way, I may accept the teachings/dogmas of the church, but how on earth can I agree if I don’t understand? THAT is why I started this thread - I just wanted to understand!! Acceptance and agreement do not always immediately go hand in hand. It may take time…

Annie
So when Jesus told people that ‘he who looks at a woman with lust in his heart commits adultery’ they were free not just to disagree but to argue with Him while still claiming to be His followers? Doesn’t work that way with God’s laws and teachings, I’m afraid.

And the reason I am Catholic, the only reason anyone should be Catholic, is that I (they) believe the Catholic Church was insituted by Christ and preserves His teaching in all its fulness, free from error, by special protection and guidance of the Holy Spirit. 🤷 It’s called faith - not in our human teachers or our human intelligence, but in Christ’s promises about His church.

God is Truth, just as He is Love. We don’t need to understand His love to receive it, just ask for and accept it. Neither do we need to rack our brains to understand His Truth when He reveals it - just accept.

Sometimes we give ourselves far too much importance and too much credit - as if God wouldn’t dare do anything that is beyond our poor measly sluggish little human intelligences. Do you understand the doctrine of the Trinity? Will you EVER understand it in a million years of study and pondering? Do you accept it nonetheless?
 
Surely the fact that ‘ever-virgin’ is said in every Mass can’t simply be put down to blurring between dogma and devotion.

The Mass permits of no such blurring. Do the prayers of the Mass ever refer to, for example, the Rosary? Or Our Lady’s apparitions to various saints over the centuries? How often does Mass even include a Hail Mary, the words of which are mostly biblical in origin? I can recall very few occasions in my 20-some years of Mass attendance.

Sounds like someone just hasn’t been paying attention to what is being said!
Wow!!! I think your jumping the gun a little. First off, no where in my post did I even elude to MY blurring or miss understanding on what we as Catholics must believe. My post was an oppinion on one aspect as to why people are not clear on what they as Catholics must believe concerning Mary.
Second, I agree with everything you posted except for your last statment. I would sugest in the future to enquire a little more with others to find out what they do believe, before spouting off at the keyboard.
 
So when Jesus told people that ‘he who looks at a woman with lust in his heart commits adultery’ they were free not just to disagree but to argue with Him while still claiming to be His followers? Doesn’t work that way with God’s laws and teachings, I’m afraid.

And the reason I am Catholic, the only reason anyone should be Catholic, is that I (they) believe the Catholic Church was insituted by Christ and preserves His teaching in all its fulness, free from error, by special protection and guidance of the Holy Spirit. 🤷 It’s called faith - not in our human teachers or our human intelligence, but in Christ’s promises about His church.

God is Truth, just as He is Love. We don’t need to understand His love to receive it, just ask for and accept it. Neither do we need to rack our brains to understand His Truth when He reveals it - just accept.

Sometimes we give ourselves far too much importance and too much credit - as if God wouldn’t dare do anything that is beyond our poor measly sluggish little human intelligences. Do you understand the doctrine of the Trinity? Will you EVER understand it in a million years of study and pondering? Do you accept it nonetheless?
LillyM -
as far as the “only reason anyone should be Catholic” being becasue they choose to/they beleive I agree with you. HOWEVER, many are Catholic because they were baptized as infants and had no choice in the matter. I have read it mayn times here at CA:“Once a Cathoic - Always a Catholic” and there have been discussions on this plenty of times. After my many travels to and through other churches, I was told by my priest that I was still a Catholic - even thought I had joined those other churches. Yes, we should only be Catholic if we CHOOSE to be Catholic…Too bad the Catholic Church does not see it that way.

Annie
 
LillyM -
as far as the “only reason anyone should be Catholic” being becasue they choose to/they beleive I agree with you. HOWEVER, many are Catholic because they were baptized as infants and had no choice in the matter. I have read it mayn times here at CA:“Once a Cathoic - Always a Catholic” and there have been discussions on this plenty of times. After my many travels to and through other churches, I was told by my priest that I was still a Catholic - even thought I had joined those other churches. Yes, we should only be Catholic if we CHOOSE to be Catholic…Too bad the Catholic Church does not see it that way.

Annie
As a person well over the age of reason you always have a choice - and what a priest or someone on CAF tells you, if you in your heart don’t accept Catholicism as your faith, shouldn’t make a blind bit of difference to you anyway. It doesn’t to my family members who are lapsed Catholics. Although of course it does make a difference to the priest and those of us who DO ‘buy into’ it (for want of a better term).

So stop the handwringing and the ‘poor me’s’. You are Catholic by choice, and not by brainwashing or torture, correct? Since you choose to be Catholic, BE Catholic! Accept that there are some Catholic truths - some Christian truths for that matter - that no amount of intellectualising is going to help you with, and choose, as Our Lord said, to ‘have not seen, and yet believe’.
 
(( I just HAD to correct your spelling of “relations” “realations”] above. My deceased english-teacher Grandmother “made me do it!”. 🙂 ))

She didn’t have “physical relations” per se with the Holy Spirit (for obvious reasons), of course, but she was made pregnant by an operation of the Holy Spirit.

That operation made her having an analog of that “operation” with any other person an unchaste act on her part.

See also: Mary, Ever Virgin.

It was a “typo”…If you are sooo smart, then why did you not give me credit for the correct spelling in the same post?? You must be very busy with all the incorrect spelling here at CA:p

Annie

Plus… of course, it’s simply a dogma of the Church that she is ever virgin, which we are obliged to know as a simple truth. 🙂
 
As a person well over the age of reason you always have a choice - and what a priest or someone on CAF tells you, if you in your heart don’t accept Catholicism as your faith, shouldn’t make a blind bit of difference to you anyway. It doesn’t to my family members who are lapsed Catholics. Although of course it does make a difference to the priest and those of us who DO ‘buy into’ it (for want of a better term).

So stop the handwringing and the ‘poor me’s’. You are Catholic by choice, and not by brainwashing or torture, correct? Since you choose to be Catholic, BE Catholic! Accept that there are some Catholic truths - some Christian truths for that matter - that no amount of intellectualising is going to help you with, and choose, as Our Lord said, to ‘have not seen, and yet believe’.
There is no “handwringing and poor me’s”…For heaven’s sake! I merely made a statement in regard to something you said.

This whole thread has gone way too far off topic.

To you and the others who have less than a small amount of understanding I say I pitty you all.

ALL I wanted to do was to try to understand a churhc teaching! Since when is it a crime to ask a question??? Again, is this not Catholic ANSWERS???

Good bye to everyone. I appreciate the few possitive and informational answers I have received, but there is too much of the opposite here. I am so very grateful that not all Catholics are this way, but from the response of many here, one would never guess it to be otherwise…

Annie
 
And you may want to talk to your priest about how you handle it when another Catholic is merely trying to understand a teaching and YOU disagree with them.
You were disagreeing with Church teaching. I was merely pointing out that you were doing so. No need to be defensive while one is being corrected.
I am LEARNING church teachings and NEVER accept BLINDLY what anyone teaches. I figure if it is really a church teaching (whatever “it” is) then it will hold up through discussions AND disagreements to show itself to be the truth.
That’s good that you ask for references to dogma.

But once dogma is presented authentically as dogma your disagreement with it needs to stop, your thinking needs to shift into how to change your thinking to accept that dogma.

Matters of Church discipline and theological conjecture are things we can “kick around”, but dogma is not a matter of disagreement, but only acceptance and self-change to suit the dogma.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top