“You looked so pretty in that, why did you change?”
This would bug me. DH and I are very close and I know I can say anything. Honestly, if he said that to me, I’m quite certain I’d respond with “I look pretty in anything! and NOW I’m pretty and comfy!”
Much of women’s clothing falls into the category of torture device. As a former dancer I could wear any height of heel, and could never understand all the whining about uncomfy shoes. Until I had an injury involving my ankle, and was informed the grotesque range of motion that I was then plagued with was considered “average.” Oh My, how any woman would suffer through what was easy for me was finally understood. How any person would want them too then seemed cruel.
OP, perhaps the thing you can say, I use this with friends asking for an honest opinion about an outfit. If it looks bad, I say, “That does not flatter you.” That just gave you a short waist you don’t have. It makes your bum look a mile wide when it isn’t. Your legs just shrank 3 inches, or your bust is now HUGE or tiny compared to reality. Do NOT, I repeat, DO NOT, say these things just as you need to leave, and she has nothing else to wear.
I do feel you’ve picked a bit of a style you’d like to see. You ask why she can’t wear a blouse. I would respond ICK! I don’t like most blouses. Sure for a bank job. But I’d be stripping down to a sweats and a t quickly. That’s why. Maybe she doesn’t like what’s in her closet. I have a mound of clothing that I can’t stand. Usually things purchased for me.
From your description, she clearly has a self image issue. And sadly whatever you say will not change that. If it were only so easy, anorexia, bulima, body dismorphic disorder would not exist today.
Cut out all the middle descriptions, and you reach the fact that she doesn’t have a good self image, and you feel disrespected by that. You have a need that currently she can’t fulfil because she has a problem.
A person with a poor self image is going to have a very hard personal time getting to thinking they could actually look pretty or handsome. It’s possible she will actually start to feel pressure in this arena, and feel unable to meet the challange. She may truly not know how to put an outfit together. Have you seen what some people walk around in, head held high?
When you get to the point of talking to her about it, remove yourself from the equation. Let her know that you’ve noticed she never dresses up, and that you’re worried it’s a reflection of how she feels with regard to self worth, and what not. With a poor body image, I think you have to be very careful not to make it worse. Depression and poor body image go hand in hand. No one is excited about a body they think is ugly, or unattractive. They are generally sad about this. They may easily be able to function, as they realize it’s not the worst thing in the world, but there is an element of sadness that will exist. IMO And I can’t even imagine where her self image will head to when she gets pregnant, feels sick all the time, and feels like there are houses smaller than her on the market.
She does need help. But you need to realize it’s for her. Not you.
Just think, let’s say tomorrow she started dressing as you wished.Would the problem be solved? Could you be happy knowing that her self image was still in the tank?
Dig deeper. This situation sounds like an opportunity to grow within your relationship.