Neo-Paganism Q&A

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberwolf001
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m just wondering, how do you and cyberwolf feel about about atheists in general? And what about the atheists that are politically active in trying to limit or confine religion or those of religion?
I’m not against atheism, as a philosophical view for an individual. Where I have an issue is where it interferes with someone else’s personal practice of religion. This applies pretty universally, not just to atheists, but to anyone who tries to limit the free practice of religion.
 
Why do you need to come onto a Catholic forum to get me to consider that you have depth and meaning in your religion? I understand you don’t seek converts. You guys have said that over and over. You act as apologists for this philosophy. That’s fine. Like I said several times, it’s your right. But for some reason you want me to respect it? That is always the tone and tenor of these posts from you and your pagan cohorts. I respect you as a person. You seem like a charitable, caring, kind person with solid intellect. I respect you. I just don’t respect the paganism you’ve embraced. It’s truly, truly nothing personal, it’s theological. It’s like Ian McKellan. That dude blows me away as Gandalf or Magneto. Love the actor, hate the sinful gay lifestyle he’s engaged in. Love the magneto!
I never said you’re “full of manure.” I think you’re misguided religiously and very wrong, but not full of fertilizer. I think it’s a rebellious, strange, sad choice but not manure-laden. My heroes are guys like St. Patrick that converted people away from paganism, I don’t especially respect the idea of moving back toward it. It’s a step in the wrong direction. If it makes you feel any better, I think the same thing of Mormons, J-Dubs, hardcore born-again vangies, atheists, Scientologists, Twilight New Moon worshippers, and a few other groups. I have a real respect for the Orthodox despite many disagreements I have with them, for Anglicans of a conservative brand, for conservative Lutherans, etc.
I don’t expect anyone to “get” paganism or make any admission that it is as valid as their own path, and I would expect that any Catholic with even a half measure of faith would not be converted by my ramblings, and I have no interest in seeking converts in any case. What I do hope is that you would consider the possibility that our paths have considerable depth and meaning to US. More than what you infer from pop culture representations of us and more than your preconceptions of us. If you’re determined to believe that we’re completely full of manure and/or ill will, what’s the point of entering into a conversation with folks on a pagan thread? For a guy who seems to believe that our faith is nothing more than Ren Faire fantasy, you spend a lot of time engaging us. There’s enough substance in what we do that you’re either concerned, galled or facinated on some level.

Don’t flatter yourself ken. 😃 I simply commented on a message board several times answering what I consider a silly cult as a Catholic on a Catholic message board. I don’t think paganism should be taken too seriously and I hope other Christians and Catholics don’t take it too seriously either. My point is to make sure this silly stuff isn’t taken seriously. That’s all. No gall. That’s too strong. If I had gall I’d really be dropping the nukes. No gall at all. Fascinated? Again, self-flattery. People doing primitive rituals that don’t accomplish anything, reading old, dead stories and trying to revive fantastical man-centered pseudo-religion isn’t fascinating. I suppose I’m guilty of wondering what in the name of all that’s holy would possess a person to embrace this stuff?

Arguing whose faith is the ultimate truth to each other is rather pointless. Maybe yours is, maybe mine is. Quite probably neither is. What I can say is that my practice and beliefs at this time lead me to be the best person I know how to be better than any other paths I know of. I presume the same can be said for you.
I don’t think it is pointless. The Great Commission Christ gives us is to spread the Gospel to all. As a Catholic I am to defend the faith as well as debate it. Your statement “quite probably neither is” is very telling. It shows you’re standing on shaky ground with your religion. I am absolutely 100% convinced of the validity of Christ Jesus and His Church. No buts. If I am to see on a Catholic message board people spreading the word of paganism, I will rebutt and debate it within reason. I don’t believe in moral relativism, which is really what your last sentences demonstrate. I say that respectfully. I’m not trying to trash or denegrate you, honestly. But when we believe that, “this path works for me, your path works for you,” etc. then we’ve entered moral relativism. I share the Holy Father’s distaste for M.R. We all find our “own truths” and think there are different paths that are actually divergent that somehow converge. We steadily find ourselves as a human race trapped into our own little prisons of self-understanding and views of what is truth. Pontius Pilate, a pagan, asked Christ, “what is truth?” He couldn’t see it standing in front of him. I am sad to see that you feel fullfilled and that your best is found deliberately without Christ rather than with Him.
 
There are, I suspect, things we can talk about productively, and must, if we are to keep this country from going down the sewer in the next few years. At the very least we might find ourselves united in common hatred. During the Middle Ages, Jews and Muslims kept European Christianity tied together more than culture or roads ever could. Maybe our shared straw man will be terrorists, or strident atheists, or people who are openly and notoriously Canadian, or exceptionally ugly reality TV contestants or the lowlifes who make commercials 140 decibles at night.

**Well I don’t want to go on a shared enemy manhunt but you’re probably right. Catholics have a million enemies attacking from all sides. So we are to defend and fight, but love our enemies. I see atheism as a great enemy yes. Reality TV? Oh yeah. Jerry Springer, yep. Oprah, two yeps. Canadians? Naw, not at all. That hockey team has blessings most obviously. Despite their proclivities for socialism I like Canadians. Americans and our friends to the North are just too similar. Terrorists? Sure, I take the terrorist threat seriously. I wish my president did! Loud commercials, yeppers. I hate loud anything, except for my Fender guitar amp that can produce serious decibals when my Stratocaster gets plugged in! Your last paragraph reminds me of an episode of the 60’s show The Outer Limits where Robert Culp is transformed into a hideous monster by the U.S. government and sent up into space in a ship in order to terrify the human race into coming together against a common “alien” foe. 😛 I sure will agree with you that common culture is going down the ole sewer. No argument there. Where you’ll disagree with me is my hypothesis as to why…a loss of Judeo-Christian values. **
 
I do know indeed. And I am not of a mindset to want to see you perish. I only hope the best for you, Wolf. My opinion is that Christianity is best. You might be surprised, but a Catholic like me genuinely cares. I’m not trying to make a mockery of you or trash you. I genuinely want you to find Heaven. That’s the truth. I do think you’re taking an unnecessary bet with your soul. And I think we’d agree that I’d be a pretty lousy Catholic if I didn’t feel that way.
Well we all know what will happen to us if it turns out you guys are right… Need I say more we are wagering our eternal souls on this being right.

**I don’t believe it 😛 But that’s ok. I don’t look at good and evil in those terms but often that is true. **
Believe it or not we can do it without someone else telling us. Good: That which is beneficial to society. Bad: That which is detrimental to society.

What do you supplement the legends with to find your truth?
Catholics don’t do Bible alone and we Pagans do not do Legends alone.

An different Catholics around the world hold different values, yet share alot of the same core view points. The same with the Pantheons.

**That is precisely what disturbs me about paganism, that it is an extension of pseudo-atheistic, secular thought projected at nature and old gods of legend. Secularism is usually hostile to Christ’s Church. And the term “Post-Christian” implies we’re gone and no longer relevent. I’d disagree respectfully. **
Obviously who can exist in a vacuum? Believe it or not most Pagans don’t lose alot of sleep over the idea of there thought patterns being influenced by Secular
Judeo-Christian-Islamic thought. Infact we are probably being influenced more by
Post-Christian American Secularism (in the US) than by monotheism at this point.

I don’t look at your like an El Camino with a bad distributor. I think you’re misguided in religion. I don’t know what led you down this path really and don’t want to treat you like a lab rat in a study of where you went wrong. I know God loves you and I care as well. I might well be a far worse sinner than you, wolf, probably so. God knows I sin, jeez I sin. That’s why I need Christ. I’m not Mr. Perfect by any stretch!
Most Christians would love to think we are in denial or if they can find that ONE sin keeping us away we can be fixed and brought back. It would certainly be an easier way to re-evangelize us and eventually evangelize our children.

Even if you reject Him, he’s your God, too. A fact you can never shake. I’m not sure what you mean by that last statement and probably don’t want to know. It sounds grim and dark. Sounds bitter. God bless you.
I hope not. I’ve seen your Gods way of intervening. It always leaves the victim a broken man. The Holy Spirit intervened in my life when I had actually embraced Buddhism as a teenager. It didn’t leave me a broken man? I’m actually pretty whole ;)…I have the greatest wife in the world, three kids ages 4, 3, and 2, a faith I love and care about, and my life has not been broken. If anything has left me a broken man it has been being a teacher in public education dealing with parents!! I’m sad to hear you feel that way about the Holy Spirit. You hope not. I’ll hope for you then. Good night…
 
I genuinely want you to find Heaven. That’s the truth. I do think you’re taking an unnecessary bet with your soul. And I think we’d agree that I’d be a pretty lousy Catholic if I didn’t feel that way.
I admit the Christian view of there here after is depressing. Eternal torment or standing around looking at god forever in 24/7 silent adoration mass.
What do you supplement the legends with to find your truth?
Historical records, conversations with the Gods, trail and error.
That is precisely what disturbs me about paganism, that it is an extension of pseudo-atheistic, secular thought projected at nature and old gods of legend.
I’ve noticed this as well and it bothers me. Reminds of the Screwtape letters sort of, when they talk about the materialist magician. Heck the founder of my Order took a materialist view to magic. But not you got new generations coming in with a more mystical bent on there view points, this ain’t our grandparents Neo-Paganism anymore.
Secularism is usually hostile to Christ’s Church. And the term “Post-Christian” implies we’re gone and no longer relevent. I’d disagree respectfully.
You disagree there is a growing Post-Christian current in America? Even some Protestants refuse to use the term Christian now a days.
I don’t look at your like an El Camino with a bad distributor. I think you’re misguided in religion. I don’t know what led you down this path really and don’t want to treat you like a lab rat in a study of where you went wrong. I know God loves you and I care as well. I might well be a far worse sinner than you, wolf, probably so. God knows I sin, jeez I sin. That’s why I need Christ. I’m not Mr. Perfect by any stretch!
Oh trust me when I left I became subject to a lot of experiments by my Catholic friends wanting there hard-core, no compromise, Traditionalist, Rome said it the matter is settled, ect. Catholic friend back. Most of it centered on finding just one reason and then undoing it.
Even if you reject Him, he’s your God, too. A fact you can never shake. I’m not sure what you mean by that last statement and probably don’t want to know. It sounds grim and dark. Sounds bitter. God bless you.
Normally when I hear of God intervening the victim of this has ended up very sick, severely crippled, or striped of all his friends. Literally it’s like a wealthy stalker using his money and influence to ruin the life of his target so that she has no option but to turn to him.
 
Wow, we are worlds apart on our perceptions of the hereafter indeed. You have a very limited and unenlightened vision of God obviously if you think that Heaven is just a bunch of mindless drones staring at a totem pole. God is boundless love, joy, kindness, perfection, and is 100% free of sin or pain. Heaven is unimaginable really because it is free of all the fetters that bind and constrain us here on earth. We will be with loved ones on a new earth in glorified form and we’ll finally be able to live without constant addictions, desires, boredom, angst, jealosy, lust, gluttony, and the need for change to make us happy. We’ll be in a totally different state of mind that is completely unimaginable now. God will reveal Himself in His totality to us and show us the entire point of existence. How that is mundane or gloomy to you I’ll never know. I think the pagan notion of living on Mt. Olympus with greek gods that get bored and come down to earth to have intercourse with human beings has influenced your thinking of the afterlife. As for hell, hell is earned and deserved. Eternal torment comes to those who openly know and reject God and they will receive their reward. As for that 24/7 adoration Mass for the God of the Universe who is infinite power, love, understanding, and wisdom who died for my sins? Sign me up.
I admit the Christian view of there here after is depressing. Eternal torment or standing around looking at god forever in 24/7 silent adoration mass.

Historical records, conversations with the Gods, trail and error.

I’ve noticed this as well and it bothers me. Reminds of the Screwtape letters sort of, when they talk about the materialist magician. Heck the founder of my Order took a materialist view to magic. But not you got new generations coming in with a more mystical bent on there view points, this ain’t our grandparents Neo-Paganism anymore.

I disagree that Christianity is dead and that Judeo-Christian morality is gone forever. I think the bad guys have done their damage and people seem to be handed over to a reprobate hedonism and liberal secular slime mold, yes. Obviously idiotic notions like gay marriage, abortion, euthanasia, and the idea that anything that goes against secular catechesis is bigotry are secular corruption. But there are many Christians in this country still who give a dang and who will fight the system. Between my wife and three kids and I there are five people I know who aren’t post-Christian! 😉
You disagree there is a growing Post-Christian current in America? Even some Protestants refuse to use the term Christian now a days.

They sound like great guys! 😉
Oh trust me when I left I became subject to a lot of experiments by my Catholic friends wanting there hard-core, no compromise, Traditionalist, Rome said it the matter is settled, ect. Catholic friend back. Most of it centered on finding just one reason and then undoing it.

That paragraph made about as much sense to me as the first time I saw Pink Floyd’s “The Wall!” Come again? :confused:🤷
Normally when I hear of God intervening the victim of this has ended up very sick, severely crippled, or striped of all his friends. Literally it’s like a wealthy stalker using his money and influence to ruin the life of his target so that she has no option but to turn to him.
 
**Wow, we are worlds apart on our perceptions of the hereafter indeed. You have a very limited and unenlightened vision of God obviously if you think that Heaven is just a bunch of mindless drones staring at a totem pole. **
I actually got this from my time in RCIA and the Catholic Show “One True Faith.”
I disagree that Christianity is dead and that Judeo-Christian morality is gone forever. I think the bad guys have done their damage and people seem to be handed over to a reprobate hedonism and liberal secular slime mold, yes. Obviously idiotic notions like gay marriage, abortion, euthanasia, and the idea that anything that goes against secular catechesis is bigotry are secular corruption. But there are many Christians in this country still who give a dang and who will fight the system. Between my wife and three kids and I there are five people I know who aren’t post-Christian!
What does that have to do with there being a growing current? Never said it was dead and gone forever.
They sound like great guys!
Actually meeting one of them for coffee on Saturday. Well no coffee for me, hate the stuff.
That paragraph made about as much sense to me as the first time I saw Pink Floyd’s “The Wall!” Come again?
Break it down for me how I lost you an I’ll try walking you through it.
 
Got what? The totem pole-style adoration image with nothing more added to it? “One True Faith” has no clue what heaven is like. No one does period. It’s beyond imagination and too awesome for our pea brains to fathom. I’d be careful listening to the intepretations of folks like that host (can’t remember his name…all I know is he wears the worst hair piece I’ve ever seen!)
I actually got this from my time in RCIA and the Catholic Show “One True Faith.”

Post Judeo Christian implies strongly there is no more Judeo-Christian values…post means after, an era being gone and dead…
What does that have to do with there being a growing current? Never said it was dead and gone forever.

We actually agree here…hate coffee…
Actually meeting one of them for coffee on Saturday. Well no coffee for me, hate the stuff.

**You lost me with the whole analogy. **
Break it down for me how I lost you an I’ll try walking you through it.
 
Got what? The totem pole-style adoration image with nothing more added to it? “One True Faith” has no clue what heaven is like. No one does period. It’s beyond imagination and too awesome for our pea brains to fathom. I’d be careful listening to the intepretations of folks like that host (can’t remember his name…all I know is he wears the worst hair piece I’ve ever seen!)
Yeap the whole totem pole thing as you put it. An interesting way to look at Eucharistic Adoration which is how they described Heaven, if you follow me. Just as in adoration you sit and adore in silence in Heaven you’d silently adore the trinity sitting on there thrones.

In contrast I see the coming next life as a great adventure and new challenges. Feasting with my ancestors and sitting out on adventures and enjoying festivals.

Also yes Michael Boris does have a bad hair piece and he seems overly focused on pain and suffering. His show helped send me BACK to Paganism.
Post Judeo Christian implies strongly there is no more Judeo-Christian values…post means after, an era being gone and dead…
Ahhh never thought of it that way. Always heard other Christians talk about our Post-Christian world and could see the rising of group calling themselves Post-Christian
We actually agree here…hate coffee…
You should see me when I did drink it. LOTS of sugar, LOADS of cream hold nose, gulp. Gargle fruit juice to kill taste. Had to get it in me to stay awake.
You lost me with the whole analogy.
Ahhh well you know how Christ is described as a lover pursing and wooing us right?

Okay whenever I hear talk of your god interrupting and intervening in our lives it is usually, in what I read and teachings I’ve heard, to the effect of stripping us of everything. Health, wealth, lovers, friends, family ect. So that there is only us and him.

To wit as I entered the church I lost in this order: My my friends, my job and my girlfriend and lost a good bit of my health. My Catholic friends said it was good ripping everything away so I could only love him.

I had an atheist friend that was horrible mangled in a car wreck. He converted and said it was god intervening in his life.

This leaves me seeing your god as more like a very wealthy and connect stalker. Who can really mess up the life of the person he is after till they have no option but to turn to him.

Heck I was prayed over for god to intervene and interrupt my life. The pray was to the effect of me god do to me what he allowed to be done to Job. -shivers-
 
Oh Gunney if your interested here is the 3rd Order I was going to join Link an if you want to see the kind of Catholic I was I can even add in private devotions I did.
 
**That may be Boris’ vision but it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the beatific vision we’ll enjoy. God is unfathomable and infinite love, depth, meaning, and truth itself. I always imagine myself full of tears of joy, an emotionally powerful experience, jaw-dropping. Seeing the purpose for my life laid out before me. God will reveal the good in me that I never realized. He will instill a love in me that I lacked for others. I won’t have enemies or petty jealosy, I won’t be possessive. And I’ll be in a mindset where I am not clinging to ego and the false notions that I’m better than others. I won’t covet or need more of this and that to feel fullfilled. And that constant boredom that pervades the human condition will be extinguished. And quite frankly, wolf, who’s to say there won’t be adventures and singing and the jolly laughter you’d think of with elves and hobbits in the LOTR. Heaven will be a happy place. We know from Scripture there will be animals there, a new earth, fields of green, song, and radiance. The earth will be made anew so we won’t be in some abstract, bizarre Sergeant Pepper video. We will have bodies, corporeal yet glorified. I actually picture heaven in a surreal joyful moment almost like when Frodo wakes up in Minas Tirith in that white room with Sam, Gandalf, Legolas, Gimli and the gang coming into the room and they all awaken into the happiest of circumstances. We don’t know the full extent of heaven. I know it’s happy from Scripture, I know God is revealed completely, and I know it’s a promise, THE promise of promises and God is capable of much! Don’t let the vision of one man cloud your vision or see things in gloomy light. There are Catholics coming from different personal vantage points. Speculation is all it is on his part. **
Yeap the whole totem pole thing as you put it. An interesting way to look at Eucharistic Adoration which is how they described Heaven, if you follow me. Just as in adoration you sit and adore in silence in Heaven you’d silently adore the trinity sitting on there thrones.

In contrast I see the coming next life as a great adventure and new challenges. Feasting with my ancestors and sitting out on adventures and enjoying festivals.
That’s really too bad. He only represents one facet of apologetics. He’s pretty hard-core and a tad triumphalistic, cocky. I favor more of the Father Corapi, JRR Tolkien, Chesterton vision of God and the Church. Powerful, One, triumphant, joyful, yet charming, loving, forgiving, and full of lifelines from God.
Also yes Michael Boris does have a bad hair piece and he seems overly focused on pain and suffering. His show helped send me BACK to Paganism.

Ahhh never thought of it that way. Always heard other Christians talk about our Post-Christian world and could see the rising of group calling themselves Post-Christian

You should see me when I did drink it. LOTS of sugar, LOADS of cream hold nose, gulp. Gargle fruit juice to kill taste. Had to get it in me to stay awake.

Ahhh well you know how Christ is described as a lover pursing and wooing us right?
**That can happen. But the fact of the matter is that life is full of bummer moments. They are not all direct obstacles from God but the result of fallen people affecting the other fallen folks around them. When I lost my job, wasn’t re-hired in my second year of teaching in my first gig at my first school district, I was devastated. I drove home having only been married less than a year, a fallen man, a loser, crushed. I didn’t blame God. I blamed the principal who had it in for me because, and she even admitted this, “you remind me of my ex husband as he looked when he was your age! You even drive an old Dodge like him!” She harrassed me and did things to me that’d knock your socks off, man. I didn’t blame God. I knew she as a sinful woman was after me. God didn’t pull her strings. It was her free will. It was part of my destiny, part of the path, the journey, it sucked, but it was life. I cried a bit on the way home to be honest. I was floored. But I went that Lent, prayed the Stations, reached out to God and had a simple faith, “wow, He really is in charge and despite being mistreated by this woman, He has plans for me.” And He did. I got hired a month later easily. I could’ve viewed it through cynical eyes. **
Okay whenever I hear talk of your god interrupting and intervening in our lives it is usually, in what I read and teachings I’ve heard, to the effect of stripping us of everything. Health, wealth, lovers, friends, family ect. So that there is only us and him.
God doesn’t want us to love only Him. He wants us to love His Blessed Mother, the saints, our neighbors, our friends, spouses, and even our enemies. They are extensions of Him. Christ exists in all of us and that fact makes it even harder to hate those that persecute us. I wouldn’t say all trials are like that of Job. Some people’s trials are intense and life-changing, sometimes horrific. But I would say that the pagan gods of old in mythology do the same thing. They can be downright petty, perverted, and they played for keeps. Whether you’re pagan or Christian, you’ll encounter trials. How do you view those trials? I view them as opportunities to grow, to get a thicker skin, and to know God’s mercy better. God doesn’t ONLY engage us and call us through sorrow, however. My wife, my children, and my friends and family have brought me closer to God than my suffering. It’s all individual experience.
To wit as I entered the church I lost in this order: My my friends, my job and my girlfriend and lost a good bit of my health. My Catholic friends said it was good ripping everything away so I could only love him.

I had an atheist friend that was horrible mangled in a car wreck. He converted and said it was god intervening in his life.
Who’s to say it wasn’t? It’s difficult to know God’s will. Perhaps the Holy Spirit enlightened him to know what God’s will was in that situation. The idea that we’ll never have accidents or suffer and that we’re only put on earth to dance like leprachauns and play the banjo with a big mug of beer is naive. We’re here to experience the joys and sufferings of life. Some have more of one than the other.
This leaves me seeing your god as more like a very wealthy and connect stalker. Who can really mess up the life of the person he is after till they have no option but to turn to him.
I’m sorry you feel that way. As I said, the gods of olympus or norse mythology weren’t exactly shrinking violets who never demanded anything painful or uncomfortable or mortal from the human race either. You sound, and I say this respectfully, like you ran away from Catholicism more than embraced something. Your pain will not go away with paganism. Your losses in life will continue. You will age, you will have setbacks, you’ll meet people you can’t stand. It’s all inevitable. You just don’t blame Christ now. I’m not sure how you rationalize it. As a Catholic, I believe my suffering has redemptive meaning and a purpose but also that God isn’t sitting in heaven with a suffering machine punching the button with abandon 24/7. Suffering happens but I think you (and I) fail to count our blessings as much as we add up our bad times and behave cynically. My wife is from the Philippines. She grew up in abject poverty with four siblings and her mom after he dad abandoned them. She had to go door to door at her mom’s behest sometimes begging for money because they had no $$$ for dinner. They’d have their electricity turned off sometimes because they didn’t pay the bill. They’d cook dinner over a campfire in the adjacent lot. My wife got one Christmas present a year, usually a blouse or pants. One gift, no more. My wife is a hard worker, very simple, always happy, very responsible, and full of character. Her upbringing built her character. It made her who she is. Her father’s abandonment played a role in her strength. It’s hard to tell if my Kate would be herself if she’d had him? Our fate is not all God’s puppetry as you might characterize it. It has much to do with our fallen humanity and the fallen sinners around us affecting our lives. God doesn’t guide a drunk driver toward a happless child in the street. The sinful drunk did his own dirty work. It’s all about free will, the capacity to love given us by God, and the sad reality that there is plenty of room to make the wrong choice in that free will. Gotta run. God bless, wolf.
Heck I was prayed over for god to intervene and interrupt my life. The pray was to the effect of me god do to me what he allowed to be done to Job. -shivers-
 
And quite frankly, wolf, who’s to say there won’t be adventures and singing and the jolly laughter you’d think of with elves and hobbits in the LOTR.
Never read LOTR man. 😛
You sound, and I say this respectfully, like you ran away from Catholicism more than embraced something.
I was wondering if I brought this up if you’d zero in on a quick and easy answer for why I might have left. I never said my gods don’t make harsh demands…

Remember earlier I stated in this thread I wear a pendant that basically means “Odin insert spear here at your leisure.” An yes in my meditations he has given me tasks to do and carry out.

As for the rest of your post, it goes against everything I was taught about Catholicism coming into the Church.
 
Yes I do. Around my neck I where a medallion that is an oath to Odin that says “I am ready to die at your will.” If that isn’t a sign of faith I dunno what is.
There it is, @Gurney…

So since this the Pagan Q&A Thread:
  • What is the difference between offering your life to Odin or to God? (see medallion quote above)
  • What has Odin done for you personally since you became his worshipper?
  • Does Odin recognize the existence of other deities or the worship of them, like God does in Hebrew Scripture?
  • What does Odin have to say about Christians? Jews? Muslims? Hindus? Buddhists?
  • Is Odin no better than Ra, who is no better than Shiva, etc etc? What about Discordianism? Would you accept that if it were found to be closer to the truth than the Druid faith tradition?
  • If Discordianism is wrong, then why so?
  • What are the major feasts of Odin? What do they represent?
  • What is your take on Balder and what happened to him?
  • What about the Twilight of the Gods? Is that just a campfire story or does it profess that nothing–absolutely nothing–lives eternally?
  • What are some of the recorded miracles in the Druid faith tradition?
Thanks for your time; I look forward to the answers of any Pagans on this thread.
 
There it is, @Gurney…
So since this the Pagan Q&A Thread:
  • What is the difference between offering your life to Odin or to God? (see medallion quote above)
  • A bit of autonomy, Odin wants us to ‘grow up’ as opposed to the spirtual childhood of the Christian. We will always be his children. But we will go from childhood, to adolesence and finally to adulthood.
  • When Odin withdraws it isn’t to make you ever more dependent upon him, but to see how far you’ve come and how well you can stand on your own two feet.
  • You can honor and worship other gods.
  • The dedication can be ended by one or both parties.
  • Odin sees nothing wrong with his children earning personal glory.
  • What has Odin done for you personally since you became his worshipper?
Helped me times of trail, as somehow managed to provide cash when I REALLY needed it out of no where and lead me to resources I needed.
  • Does Odin recognize the existence of other deities or the worship of them, like God does in Hebrew Scripture?
I’d say so. Germanic legends mention two tribes of gods after all.
  • What does Odin have to say about Christians? Jews? Muslims? Hindus? Buddhists?
Fine with Buddhism and Hinduism. As to the three monotheistic faiths about as happy with them as any god would be with a religion that wants to see his worship gone. With Christianity especially after the events last century he really doesn’t like it and worries there may be a repeat of that slaughter, but this time feels if something goes down it will go down differently.
  • Is Odin no better than Ra, who is no better than Shiva, etc etc?
Not in the way I think you mean it no.

What about Discordianism? Would you accept that if it were found to be closer to the truth than the Druid faith tradition?

What about Discordianism? Pagans can belong to multiple “denominations” at once.
  • What are the major feasts of Odin? What do they represent?
Here are some major holidays in the Northern Tradition Link
  • What is your take on Balder and what happened to him?
There are two separate accounts in the lore. One has him murdered by Loki or
Utgard-Loki. The other has him falling in battle, I lean towards the latter.
  • What about the Twilight of the Gods? Is that just a campfire story or does it profess that nothing–absolutely nothing–lives eternally?
I personally see it as little more the Christian influence on the lore but that is just me.
  • What are some of the recorded miracles in the Druid faith tradition?
Ever spell that worked might count as a miracle, I’ve also heard stories of miraculous healings, druids coming back from the dead and so on.
 
Hi Bouncing,
Is this post addressed to me? I was confused by the opening…?
There it is, @Gurney…

So since this the Pagan Q&A Thread:
  • What is the difference between offering your life to Odin or to God? (see medallion quote above)
  • What has Odin done for you personally since you became his worshipper?
  • Does Odin recognize the existence of other deities or the worship of them, like God does in Hebrew Scripture?
  • What does Odin have to say about Christians? Jews? Muslims? Hindus? Buddhists?
  • Is Odin no better than Ra, who is no better than Shiva, etc etc? What about Discordianism? Would you accept that if it were found to be closer to the truth than the Druid faith tradition?
  • If Discordianism is wrong, then why so?
  • What are the major feasts of Odin? What do they represent?
  • What is your take on Balder and what happened to him?
  • What about the Twilight of the Gods? Is that just a campfire story or does it profess that nothing–absolutely nothing–lives eternally?
  • What are some of the recorded miracles in the Druid faith tradition?
Thanks for your time; I look forward to the answers of any Pagans on this thread.
 
I don’t know which to get madder about? Your leaving Catholicism or NOT READING THE LORD OF THE RINGS! Now THAT’s blasphemy indeed!! heretic! LOL :D:D:p:p I am a raging LOTR fan lol…Tolkien’s my man! He was Catholic, too! 👍
Never read LOTR man. 😛

I was wondering if I brought this up if you’d zero in on a quick and easy answer for why I might have left. I never said my gods don’t make harsh demands…

Remember earlier I stated in this thread I wear a pendant that basically means “Odin insert spear here at your leisure.” An yes in my meditations he has given me tasks to do and carry out.

As for the rest of your post, it goes against everything I was taught about Catholicism coming into the Church.
 
  • A bit of autonomy, Odin wants us to ‘grow up’ as opposed to the spirtual childhood of the Christian. We will always be his children. But we will go from childhood, to adolesence and finally to adulthood.
  • When Odin withdraws it isn’t to make you ever more dependent upon him, but to see how far you’ve come and how well you can stand on your own two feet.
  • You can honor and worship other gods.
  • The dedication can be ended by one or both parties.
  • Odin sees nothing wrong with his children earning personal glory.
Helped me times of trail, as somehow managed to provide cash when I REALLY needed it out of no where and lead me to resources I needed.

I’d say so. Germanic legends mention two tribes of gods after all.

Fine with Buddhism and Hinduism. As to the three monotheistic faiths about as happy with them as any god would be with a religion that wants to see his worship gone. With Christianity especially after the events last century he really doesn’t like it and worries there may be a repeat of that slaughter, but this time feels if something goes down it will go down differently.

Ever spell that worked might count as a miracle, I’ve also heard stories of miraculous healings, druids coming back from the dead and so on.
Good morning, @Cyberwolf! Hope you are enjoying the start of a great weekend.

Well, since you are the only Pagan who is answering questions, I have some more of them.
  • You stated // With Christianity especially after the events last century he really doesn’t like it and worries there may be a repeat of that slaughter, but this time feels if something goes down it will go down differently.// ***What events of the last century displeased Odin? What repeat of slaughter is Odin referring to? The slaughter of Christians? ***
  • I cannot think of any reason why you would offer your life to Odin. (See, “I am ready to die at your will,” “insert your spear here” statements by you earlier in the thread). What offense could you possibly commit against Odin that Odin would deem needful of human sacrifice (the sacrifice being you) ?
  • In one of the Eddas, is it not stated that Odin died in battle? Is it not more reasonable to search out a living deity to follow?
  • What is the difference between Odinist and Wotanist? What are your views on the racist branch of Odin’s worshipers? Or, if you are one, what are your views on the non-racist branch of Odin’s worshipers? What does Odin have to say about both groups?
  • What is the White Order of Thule? Are they heterodox followers of Odin or are they in error?
Thanks again for any answers. Time for a smoke break.
 
Yes I do. Around my neck I where a medallion that is an oath to Odin that says “I am ready to die at your will.” If that isn’t a sign of faith I dunno what is.
Not like you have a choice. Your thread will be severed by Skuld when it’s time and you can’t get away from it.

How’s that Saxon poem go?

“No man lives til eve whom the Fates doom at dawn.”

😃
 
*]What is the difference between Odinist and Wotanist? What are your views on the racist branch of Odin’s worshipers? Or, if you are one, what are your views on the non-racist branch of Odin’s worshipers? What does Odin have to say about both groups?

*]What is the White Order of Thule? Are they heterodox followers of Odin or are they in error?
Ah… this again.
 
@ NoWings,

It may be “this again” for you, but not me. I’m new to these boards and @Cyberwolf is educating me. I think it’s a valid question. But I want to hear the answer from a real Pagan, not someone who hasn’t got a dog in this fight (agnostics, atheists). This is a question for those who have faith in Odin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top