V
valient_Lucy
Guest
History is often illogical.Read your second sentence again. It’s inherently illogical.
It happened somewhat with anti-semitism. The Church has always opposed antisemitism, even in the Middle Ages, but unfortunately this belief never took hold. Though I agree this is a more extreme case, but it’s certainly not impossible.With what other teaching has every single saint and theologian in the Church believed something, and then all of a sudden the Church turned around and taught something completely different?
The Church didn’t teach that sex was a necessary evil. The saints and theologians did, and that’s not the same thing.Don’t you think there would be some historical record of an outcry when the Church taught for a thousand years that sex was a “necessary evil,” and then all of a sudden started teaching the opposite? How could this even be taught if everyone from the Pope down believed otherwise?
Close but no cigar. St. Augustine said that the only moral reason to engage in sexual intercourse is to attempt to conceive. If a married couple engages in sex for any other reason, it is venially sinful, even if they do nothing to contracept. If they contracept, it’s a mortal sin. Go back and reread On the Good of Marriage if you don’t believe me.I’m guessing one of your biggest issues is St. Augustine. Nowhere in this specific document “The Good of Marriage” does he say that the marital act in and of itself is an evil. He says that having sex within marriage with the intent to close the marital act to procreation is sinful. That is EXACTLY what the Church has always taught, and what the Church teaches today.
And it’s not just St. Augstine who thought this way. He’s the rule, not the excpetion.
I don’t believe that sex is a necessary evil. I certainly agree that it’s illogical. If I believed that sex was a necessary evil, I would not have been scandalized by what Catholics had written throughout the centuries. Catholics, mind you, not the Church.Think of this - if sex was considered a “necessary evil” then this teaching would contradict Scripture. Jesus spoke of two becoming one flesh as a *good *thing. So if we go with the logic that sex is a “necessary evil,” then Jesus told us to do evil! Yet in Romans 3:8, St. Paul condemns the philosophy, “Let us do evil so that good may come of it.”
Like I said, it’s illogical.
But, like I said before, the saints and theologians are not the Church, and they don’t speak for the Church. They speak for themselves. If they did speak for the Church, I would have left the Church.