NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Read your second sentence again. It’s inherently illogical.
History is often illogical.
With what other teaching has every single saint and theologian in the Church believed something, and then all of a sudden the Church turned around and taught something completely different?
It happened somewhat with anti-semitism. The Church has always opposed antisemitism, even in the Middle Ages, but unfortunately this belief never took hold. Though I agree this is a more extreme case, but it’s certainly not impossible.
Don’t you think there would be some historical record of an outcry when the Church taught for a thousand years that sex was a “necessary evil,” and then all of a sudden started teaching the opposite? How could this even be taught if everyone from the Pope down believed otherwise?
The Church didn’t teach that sex was a necessary evil. The saints and theologians did, and that’s not the same thing.
I’m guessing one of your biggest issues is St. Augustine. Nowhere in this specific document “The Good of Marriage” does he say that the marital act in and of itself is an evil. He says that having sex within marriage with the intent to close the marital act to procreation is sinful. That is EXACTLY what the Church has always taught, and what the Church teaches today.
Close but no cigar. St. Augustine said that the only moral reason to engage in sexual intercourse is to attempt to conceive. If a married couple engages in sex for any other reason, it is venially sinful, even if they do nothing to contracept. If they contracept, it’s a mortal sin. Go back and reread On the Good of Marriage if you don’t believe me.

And it’s not just St. Augstine who thought this way. He’s the rule, not the excpetion.
Think of this - if sex was considered a “necessary evil” then this teaching would contradict Scripture. Jesus spoke of two becoming one flesh as a *good *thing. So if we go with the logic that sex is a “necessary evil,” then Jesus told us to do evil! Yet in Romans 3:8, St. Paul condemns the philosophy, “Let us do evil so that good may come of it.”

Like I said, it’s illogical.
I don’t believe that sex is a necessary evil. I certainly agree that it’s illogical. If I believed that sex was a necessary evil, I would not have been scandalized by what Catholics had written throughout the centuries. Catholics, mind you, not the Church.

But, like I said before, the saints and theologians are not the Church, and they don’t speak for the Church. They speak for themselves. If they did speak for the Church, I would have left the Church.
 
This is 100% false. Read “The Good of Marriage” by St. Augustine posted above - he does not say that a married couple having sex in this instance would be sinful. What would be sinful is if they attempted to impede procreation (by using “potions of sterility” or herbs to induce miscarriage).
You need to go back and reread The Good of Marriage. St. Augustine specifically says that if a couple has sex for any other reason than to attempt to achieve conception, it is a venial sin. He says it repeatedly. There’s no way to ignore what he says without doing violence to his writing and simply ignoring him.
 
You need to go back and reread The Good of Marriage. St. Augustine specifically says that if a couple has sex for any other reason than to attempt to achieve conception, it is a venial sin. He says it repeatedly. There’s no way to ignore what he says without doing violence to his writing and simply ignoring him.
*For intercourse of marriage for the sake of begetting has not fault; but for the satisfying of lust, but yet with husband or wife, by reason of the faith of the bed, it has venial fault: but adultery or fornication has deadly fault, and, through this, continence from all intercourse is indeed better even than the intercourse of marriage itself, which takes place for the sake of begetting. *

For necessary sexual intercourse for begetting is free from blame, and itself is alone worthy of marriage. But that which goes beyond this necessity, no longer follows reason, but lust.

St. Augustine, On the Good of Marriage.
 
You need to go back and reread The Good of Marriage. St. Augustine specifically says that if a couple has sex for any other reason than to attempt to achieve conception, it is a venial sin. He says it repeatedly. There’s no way to ignore what he says without doing violence to his writing and simply ignoring him.
Actually, you need to go back and read it. He says that couples shouldn’t have sex if their intent is not to procreate. That is not the same as saying that every single sex act needs to produce a child.

For example:
Further, in the very case of the more immoderate requirement of the due of the flesh, which the Apostle enjoins not on them by way of command, but allows to them by way of leave, that they have intercourse also beside the cause of begetting children; although evil habits impel them to such intercourse, yet marriage guards them from adultery or fornication. For neither is that committed because of marriage, but is pardoned because of marriage. Therefore married persons owe one another not only the faith of their sexual intercourse itself, for the begetting of children, which is the first fellowship of the human kind in this mortal state; but also, in a way, a mutual service of sustaining one another’s weakness, in order to shun unlawful intercourse: so that, although perpetual continence be pleasing to one of them, he may not, save with consent of the other. For thus far also, “The wife has not power of her own body, but the man: in like manner also the man has not power of his own body, but the woman.” That that also, which, not for the begetting of children, but for weakness and incontinence, either he seeks of marriage, or she of her husband, they deny not the one or the other; lest by this they fall into damnable seductions, through temptation of Satan, by reason of incontinence either of both, or of whichever of them.
Notice he says here that sex for the purpose of pleasure in marriage is acceptable in order to prevent adultery or fornication. He even says it’s not acceptable for one spouse ot deny the other! He does not say that the sex act* in and of itself* is evil or even a necessary evil.

And later:
“Honorable,” therefore, “is marriage in all, and the bed undefiled.” And this we do not so call a good, as that it is a good in comparison of fornication: otherwise there will be two evils, of which the second is worse: or fornication will also be a good, because adultery is worse: for it is worse to violate the marriage of another, than to cleave unto an harlot: and adultery will be a good, because incest is worse; for it is worse to lie with a mother than with the wife of another: and, until we arrive at those things, which, as the Apostle says, “it is a shame even to speak of,” all will be good in comparison of what are worse. But who can doubt that this is false?** Therefore marriage and fornication are not two evils, whereof the second is worse: but marriage and continence are two goods, whereof the second is better**, even as this temporal health and sickness are not two evils, whereof the second is worse; but that health and immortality are two goods, whereof the second is better. Also knowledge and vanity are not two evils, whereof vanity is the worse: but knowledge and charity are two goods, whereof charity is the better. For “knowledge shall be destroyed,” says the Apostle: and yet it is necessary for this time: but “charity shall never fail.” Thus also this mortal begetting, on account of which marriage takes place, shall be destroyed: but freedom from all sexual intercourse is both angelic exercise here, and continues for ever. But as the repasts of the Just are better than the fasts of the sacrilegious, so the marriage of the faithful is to be set before the virginity of the impious. However neither in that case is repast preferred to fasting, but righteousness to sacrilege; nor in this, marriage to virginity, but faith to impiety. For for this end the righteous, when need is, take their repast, that, as good masters, they may give to their slaves, i.e., their bodies, what is just and fair: but for this end the sacrilegious fast, that they may serve devils. Thus for this end the faithful are married, that they may be chastely joined unto husbands, but for this end the impious are virgins, that they may commit fornication away from the true God. As, therefore, that was good, which Martha was doing, being engaged in the ministering unto the Saints, but that better, which Mary, her sister, sitting at the feet of the Lord, and hearing His word; thus we praise the good of Susanna in married chastity, but yet we set before her the good of the widow Anna, and, much more, of the Virgin Mary. It was good that they were doing, who of their substance were ministering necessaries unto Christ and His disciples: but better, who left all their substance, that they might be freer to follow the same Lord. But in both these cases of good, whether what these, or whether what Martha and Mary were doing, the better could not be done, unless the other had been passed over or left. Whence we are to understand, that we are not, on this account, to think marriage an evil, because, unless there be abstinence from it, widowed chastity, or virgin purity, cannot be had. For neither on this account was what Martha was doing evil, because, unless her sister abstained from it, she could not do what was better: nor on this account is it evil to receive a just man or a prophet into one’s house, because he, who wills to follow Christ unto perfection, ought not even to have a house, in order to do what is better.
Right here he’s speaking against the very belief you claim he advocates! Saying that celibacy is the greater good is not saying marriage (and the marriage act) is an evil or even a *necessary *evil. It’s simply the lesser of two goods.
 
You need to go back and reread The Good of Marriage. St. Augustine specifically says that if a couple has sex for any other reason than to attempt to achieve conception, it is a venial sin. He says it repeatedly. There’s no way to ignore what he says without doing violence to his writing and simply ignoring him.
For they had them in the work of begetting children, not in the disease of desire, as the nations which know not God. And this is so great a thing, that many at this day more easily abstain from all sexual intercourse their whole life through, than, if they are joined in marriage, observe the measure of not coming together except for the sake of children. Forsooth we have many brethren and partners in the heavenly inheritance of both sexes that are continent, whether they be such as have made trial of marriage, or such as are entirely free from all such intercourse: forsooth they are without number: yet, in our familiar discourses with them, whom have we heard, whether of those who are, or of those who have been, married, declaring to us that he has never had sexual intercourse with his wife, save with the hope of conception?

St. Augustine, On the Good of Marriage.
 
*For intercourse of marriage for the sake of begetting has not fault; but for the satisfying of lust, but yet with husband or wife, by reason of the faith of the bed, it has venial fault: but adultery or fornication has deadly fault, and, through this, continence from all intercourse is indeed better even than the intercourse of marriage itself, which takes place for the sake of begetting. *

For necessary sexual intercourse for begetting is free from blame, and itself is alone worthy of marriage. But that which goes beyond this necessity, no longer follows reason, but lust.

St. Augustine, On the Good of Marriage.
Holy taking quotes out of context, Batman. Let’s look at the entire paragraph, shall we?
  1. And yet not to these themselves is marriage a sin; which, if it were chosen in comparison of fornication, would be a less sin than fornication, and yet would be a sin. But now what shall we say against the most plain speech of the Apostle, saying, “Let her do what she will; she sins not, if she be married;” and, “If you shall have taken a wife, you have not sinned: and, if a virgin shall have been married, she sins not.” Hence surely it is not lawful now to doubt that marriage is no sin. Therefore the Apostle allows not marriage as matter “of pardon:” for who can doubt that it is extremely absurd to say, that they have not sinned, unto whom “pardon” is granted. But he allows, as matter of “pardon,” that sexual intercourse, which takes place through incontinence, not alone for the begetting of children, and, at times, not at all for the begetting of children; and it is not that marriage forces this to take place, but that it procures pardon for it; provided however it be not so in excess as to hinder what ought to be set aside as seasons of prayer, nor be changed into that use which is against nature, on which the Apostle could not be silent, when speaking of the excessive corruptions of unclean and impious men. For necessary sexual intercourse for begetting is free from blame, and itself is alone worthy of marriage. But that which goes beyond this necessity, no longer follows reason, but lust. And yet it pertains to the character of marriage, not to exact this, but to yield it to the partner, lest by fornication the other sin damnably. But, if both are set under such lust, they do what is plainly not matter of marriage. However, if in their intercourse they love what is honest more than what is dishonest, that is, what is matter of marriage more than what is not matter of marriage, this is allowed to them on the authority of the Apostle as matter of pardon: and for this fault, they have in their marriage, not what sets them on to commit it, but what entreats pardon for it, if they turn not away from them the mercy of God, either by not abstaining on certain days, that they may be free to pray, and through this abstinence, as through fasting, may commend their prayers; or by changing the natural use into that which is against nature [e.g., coitus interruptus or other contraceptive sexual acts], which is more damnable when it is done in the case of husband or wife.
 
For they had them in the work of begetting children, not in the disease of desire, as the nations which know not God. And this is so great a thing, that many at this day more easily abstain from all sexual intercourse their whole life through, than, if they are joined in marriage, observe the measure of not coming together except for the sake of children. Forsooth we have many brethren and partners in the heavenly inheritance of both sexes that are continent, whether they be such as have made trial of marriage, or such as are entirely free from all such intercourse: forsooth they are without number: yet, in our familiar discourses with them, whom have we heard, whether of those who are, or of those who have been, married, declaring to us that he has never had sexual intercourse with his wife, save with the hope of conception?

St. Augustine, On the Good of Marriage.
Once again, IN CONTEXT, he is saying that marriage and celibacy are both good, with celibacy being the greater good. This does not mean that marriage (or sex) is evil, only that they are a lesser good.
 
Let’s look at the entire paragraph, shall we?
So St. Augustine is saying that if a married couple want to have sex for a reason other than conception is a fault, but not a sin, comparable to having a sweet tooth.

He also says that marriage pardons this fault and permits them to have sex for reasons other than for conception, which would normally be sinful, because it prevents them from sinning greatly, either through fornication or adultery.

By comparison, it is good to eat in order to nourish the body, and to eat simply because a person enjoys eating is intemperate and a personal fault, but not in and of itself sinful. However, it is acceptable to eat fruit for desert simply to satisfy a sweet tooth, if eating the fruit prevets a person from gorging on ice cream or cheesecake.

Is that how you interpret it?
 
Once again, IN CONTEXT, he is saying that marriage and celibacy are both good, with celibacy being the greater good. This does not mean that marriage (or sex) is evil, only that they are a lesser good.
True, but he also states in this quote that the only blameless reason for a man to sleep with his wife is in order to attempt conception.
 
So St. Augustine is saying that if a married couple want to have sex for a reason other than conception is a fault, but not a sin, comparable to having a sweet tooth.

He also says that marriage pardons this fault and permits them to have sex for reasons other than for conception, which would normally be sinful, because it prevents them from sinning greatly, either through fornication or adultery.

By comparison, it is good to eat in order to nourish the body, and to eat simply because a person enjoys eating is intemperate and a personal fault, but not in and of itself sinful. However, it is acceptable to eat fruit for desert simply to satisfy a sweet tooth, if eating the fruit prevets a person from gorging on ice cream or cheesecake.

Is that how you interpret it?
That is St. Augustine’s view, essentially (and even today the Church teaches that eating for the pure pleasure of it as opposed for nutrition can be the sin of gluttony).

But remember that back in his day couples didn’t have the knowledge about a woman’s cycles that they do now. Couples generally had no idea if that particular sex act would result in the conception of a child, so there was no way they could have sex without the intent to procreate unless they were also engaging in immoral sex acts (e.g., coitus interruptus) or taking “potions of sterility,” or what have you. The only exception would be if the woman was already pregnant or past menopause (but even in the latter case there was precedent for older women conceiving – cf. Abraham and Sarah).

“The Good of Marriage” was written around the year 400 A.D. So, Augustine’s words can’t be read in the context of a 21st century couple who use NFP and know on which days they’re most likely to conceive and which days they’re not.
 
True, but he also states in this quote that the only blameless reason for a man to sleep with his wife is in order to attempt conception.
See above. In the context of Augustine’s day, the only way you could have sex within marriage WITHOUT attempting conception was to commit the sin of Onan (forbidden), use potions of sterility or miscarriage-inducing herbs (forbidden) or have sex when the woman was already pregnant (acceptable to prevent lust from causing a greater sin to be committed). Even post-menopausal women were considered potentially fertile given the example of Abraham and Sarah.

Also remember that St. Augustine’s views don’t represent infallible Church teaching – they represent the teaching of one man. A great man, a saint, a doctor of the Church, but still a man. He’s not infallible, and his writings represent his private opinion, not the infallible teaching of the Magisterium.

That’s why Jesus established a Church and created the Papacy + Magesterium, so they could glean what was good and true from such writings and discard what was in error, and thus promulgate authentic teaching, inspired by the Holy Spirit, to the faithful.

Bottom line is that the Church has never taught that sex was a “necessary evil.” It has always taught that sex within marriage is a lesser good than celibacy, and that we are not all called to celibacy. That is an important distinction,
 
The doctrines on faith and morals have never changed. If they had changed, the Church would be a lie.
Maybe doctrines and morals have not. Interpretation surely has. Sex in marriage is not doctrine or dogma. It is a teaching based on tradition. And no, the church would nto be a lie.
 
…that the Church taught that sex was a necessary evil…
I never said that the Church did. I said that the saints and theologians did.
The Saints and Theologians did not teach this…nor the Church. People who quote Augustine often forget what time period he was living in and what evils he was defending against. They also fail to read all his writing before jumping on the many convenient quotes that support their claim that he thought sex was sinful yet necessary.

Here is one bit from Augustine that tends to go largely overlooked:
“For of these certain [goods] are necessary for the sake of wisdom, as learning: certain for the sake of health, as meat and drink and sleep: certain for the sake of friendship, as marriage or sexual intercourse: for hence subsists the propagation of the human kind, wherein friendly fellowship is a great good.” (Of the Good of Marriage, Section 9).

And this from Saint Pope Gregory The Great:
“…when the married have intercourse with each other even incontinently, they still avoid lapse into sin, and are still saved through mercy. For they find as it were a little city, wherein to be protected from the fire; since this married life is not indeed marvellous for virtue, but yet is secure from punishment…But the married, in this course of conduct, then preserve their lives as it were in a small city, when they intercede for each other by continual supplications. Whence it is also rightly said by the Angel to the same Lot, See I have accepted your prayers concerning this thing also, that I will not overthrow the city for the which you have spoken Genesis 19:21. For in truth, when supplication is poured out to God, such married life is by no means condemned. Concerning which supplication Paul also admonishes, saying, Defraud not one the other except it be with consent for a time, that you may give yourselves to prayer 1 Corinthians 7:5.” (Regula Pastoralis, Part III, Caput xxvii)

And Saint Thomas Aquinas:
"There are some who say that intercourse between married persons is not devoid of sin. But this is heretical, for the Apostle says: “Let marriage be honorable in all and the bed undefiled.”[15] Not only is it devoid of sin, but for those in the state of grace it is meritorious for eternal life. "(Catechism of St. Thomas Aquinas, pg. 80)

And Saint Francis De Sales:
“2. To eat not only for preserving life but also for promoting fellowship and sociability, which we must have for one another, is something very just and honest. In the same way, the mutual and lawful satisfaction of the husband and the wife in marriage is called marital duty (1 Cor. 7:3) by St.Paul…
3. Those who eat because of the obligation of mutual sociability must eat freely and not by force. Moreover, they are to show some appetite. Similarly the marriage debt should always be rendered faithfully, frankly and just as if it were with the hope of begetting children, even though sometimes there may be no such hope.” (Introduction to the Devout Life, Part 3, Chapter 39 “Chastity in the Married Life”)
 
This is by and far the most crazy forum I have ever encountered. Those who stand by Church teaching are mocked. Perhaps this is not an authentic or moderated Catholic forum?
It isn’t that you may stand by church teachings. It is how you approach and handle the discussions.

This is indeed a crazy forum - those who have questions about and disagree with teachings are mocked.
 
Very true.

It’s interesting in a way that we assume that the couple with a large family is the virtuous family. The Early Church Fathers held that the desire for a large family was a sign of spiritual immaturity. It’s possible that a couple has a large family because they are being open to life. However, they may also choose to have a large family because they do not believe in the resurrection of the dead and the next world.
And there was a time when having a large family, Catholic or not, meant having someone to keep the farm and ranch going. It was a necessity or at least a benefit in that aspect; it was not in the least always spiritual or religious.
 
True, but he also states in this quote that the only blameless reason for a man to sleep with his wife is in order to attempt conception.
That is your own interpretation, or you missed the part I quoted from him in post #237. His writing are indeed difficult for us to understand in this day and age because we cannot relate to the period during which he was writing. Thankfully, we have other Theologians and the Church to clarify what he meant and what the Church actually teaches. I have provided you some other, more clear, quotes in Post # 237 as well and you can also refer to the Catechism…which clearly contradicts what you are claiming.
 
You do realize that the saints and theologians were* members of the Church*, right? Doctrine is not formed in a vacuum.
No, I didn’t. I thought the saints and theologians were Hare Krishnas.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top