NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That is what the church teaches; does not mean that it is the case at all times.
I fail to see how it isn’t the case in every circumstance, even if the couple in question don’t realize it.
Because it is not all the same.
Why? How is it not the same? Please elaborate.
And you just don’t get it either - just because I disagree on something doesn’t mean I can’t figure it out.
No. But based on the comments you’ve offered so far, it’s plainly obvious you can’t figure it out.
And who the heck are you to tell me I don’t understand the purpose of morality? Or that I’m tossing out teachings because they don’t make me happy? Who is ignorant of what?
I’m the person who is reading the comments you have voluntarily posted on a public message board for the purposes of discussion, and that’s what I base my opinions on.
We disagree, period. But you don’t like it.
No, I can’t say I like it when someone who claims to be Catholic dissents from binding Church teaching.
Didn’t dispute it, I asked where it is, and the article covers a few hundred years, not 2000. Questions still stands, so no, I don’t concede it - I’m actually curious.
Well, good, thanks for acknowledging that at least. Here are some quotes from the early Church fathers; are they early enough for you? staycatholic.com/ecf_contraception.htm

How about Matthew 19:5, when Jesus talks about a man and woman becoming one flesh (i.e., the unitive aspect of the marital act)? Condoms prevent a man and a woman from becoming one flesh. So does withdrawal.
He wasn’t talking entitled to conscience - he was talking entitled to make a decision. Huge difference. And again, you assume that couples will automatically apply such decision making to all things and throw morality to the wind. In deciding not to do that, couples do indeed exercise morality.
Everyone is entitled to make decisions according to their conscience. I really think you’re misunderstanding Fr. Harrison. He’s not saying that couples SHOULDN’T make the decision for themselves – that would go against Church teaching. He’s saying that a couple who is not informing their conscience according to Church teaching are thus not properly disposed to make a decision about using NFP to space pregnancies.

As to your comments about morality, I’m not sure what you’re talking about. Many couples do indeed throw morality to the wind as long as they can get what they want – look at the “Catholic” couples who are using contraception, or using IVF to conceive.
And THAT is the disagreement, that sex must be both. Nothing else. Well, part of it. Yep, sex is for making babies. You JUST AGREED WITH ME !
Yes, sex is for making babies. This is true for all people, regardless of their religion. In fact, it’s biology. I wasn’t aware that “sex makes babies” was in dispute; I thought it was common knowledge in both the scientific and religious communities…? I’m not aware of any religion that teachings sex does not cause conception.
The point I keep trying to make - and with which you obviously disagree - is that sex can indeed be for bonding without babies; it is just that the church says no.
IF THIS WERE TRUE, then the Church would teach that it is sinful to have sex in a woman’s infertile period, or during pregnancy, or during menopause. The Church does not teach that; ergo, it is not true.
other than If we are not allowed to have sex without having intercourse, which is dictated by the church, then the church is saying that sex is for making babies. It also says it has to be unitive. The difference is you think it has to both; I do not.
Correction: The difference is that the Catholic Church, who is guided by the Holy Spirit, and given teaching authority by Jesus Christ, says that it has to be both.
But because of the exact fact that the church tells us it has to be both or not at all, then sex is for making babies - as you mentioned above. If you can’t have one without the other, there is no divorcing that sex is for making babies.
As I mentioned above, that’s not simply Church teaching, that’s biology. But the key difference which you can’t seem to comprehend is that sex doesn’t always make babies, and that’s okay. That’s why couples can have sex during a woman’s infertile period, or during menopause, or if one of them is infertile. The Church does not teach that each and every sex act must produce a child.
And again, I never said that the church said sex is only for making babies; I said that because the church prohibits sex without leaving open the chance for a baby, that it does indeed teach that sex is for having babies.
You do realize (once again) that this is not merely a teaching of the Church, but also biological fact?
If not, it would allow for other things. As for your last sentence, that once again makes my point - the intent may not have to be to have a child, but the act must be open to it; by its very nature, as is so often pointed out, sex=biology=babies (in most cases).
By church dictate, unless we want a baby or to have the chance of a baby, we are not to have sex. So sex is for having babies.
Again, this is BIOLOGY. Each and every completed sex act has the chance of conceiving a child, no matter how many layers of contraception are used. Exceptions are rare, but they do not define the norm. Sex is for having babies no matter what religion you’re in. Why are you so opposed to biology?
 
My marriage is in trouble right now so I may have slighted view, but I a have comment.

Do anyone else find it slightly disturbing that if do chart with NFP from you wedding day, you could count exactly how many time you had sex\intercourse. That you are going to have this information in a folder or binder and that someday someone else could look it.

I do beleive that NFP is a great and wonderful thing. I encourge others to use it all the time. I just had this thought.
 
My marriage is in trouble right now so I may have slighted view, but I a have comment.

Do anyone else find it slightly disturbing that if do chart with NFP from you wedding day, you could count exactly how many time you had sex\intercourse. That you are going to have this information in a folder or binder and that someday someone else could look it.

I do beleive that NFP is a great and wonderful thing. I encourge others to use it all the time. I just had this thought.
Actually, I use computer software and an iPhone application for my charting purposes, and both are password protected. So it really doesn’t bug me at all. 🙂
 
My marriage is in trouble right now so I may have slighted view, but I a have comment.

Do anyone else find it slightly disturbing that if do chart with NFP from you wedding day, you could count exactly how many time you had sex\intercourse. That you are going to have this information in a folder or binder and that someday someone else could look it.

I do beleive that NFP is a great and wonderful thing. I encourge others to use it all the time. I just had this thought.
:rotfl:
We actually enjoy looking back at our “stats”… I like to tease my husband about “meeting quota” for the month…
We’ll “kid proof” the information when the time becomes necessary… but until then… happy charting! 😃

Editing to add…
And yes… we have an entire drawer in the bathroom dedicated to this collection of paperwork! 10 years is a lot of charts! 😛
 
:rotfl:
We actually enjoy looking back at our “stats”… I like to tease my husband about “meeting quota” for the month…
We’ll “kid proof” the information when the time becomes necessary… but until then… happy charting! 😃

Editing to add…
And yes… we have an entire drawer in the bathroom dedicated to this collection of paperwork! 10 years is a lot of charts! 😛
Lol Emily, you have charts which reach back to 10 years!
 
Compendium issued Pope Benedict XVI
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for serious reasons; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
2370-2372

Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation.
There’s an interesting and relevant article in the latest issue of Latin Mass Magazine, which points out that indeed NFP is only to be used for spacing children for GRAVE reasons.

“Serious” is a bad translation from the Latin to English.

Pax and God bless.
 
There’s an interesting and relevant article in the latest issue of Latin Mass Magazine, which points out that indeed NFP is only to be used for spacing children for GRAVE reasons.

“Serious” is a bad translation from the Latin to English.

Pax and God bless.
I do not subscribe to that magazine (but loved an article Susie Lloyd published in it a while back about “Mass Cops”), so I don’t have access to the above referenced article you are speaking of. Did the article mention what was considered “grave”?

Would the reasons given by a CAF member on this thread (post # 52) be considered “grave”? : forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=606771

I think once again it goes back to what may be considered “grave” for one couple may not be considered “grave” for another.

Here’s the link to the Susie Lloyd article I mentioned: susielloyd.sophiainstitute.com/userfiles/file/TLM_Summer_2009_MassCops.pdf
 
There’s an interesting and relevant article in the latest issue of Latin Mass Magazine, which points out that indeed NFP is only to be used for spacing children for GRAVE reasons.

“Serious” is a bad translation from the Latin to English.

Pax and God bless.
Try reading this:
nccbuscc.org/prolife/issues/nfp/seriousq.shtml

<<“Grave and Serious”]
Paul VI in his encyclical, Humanae vitae (1968), while condemning the use of all contraceptive methods for even grave (gravia) reasons declared licit the recourse to the infertile periods if the spouses have good (just and seria) reasons to postpone even indefinitely another pregnancy. (HV, nos. 16, 10). The language here is similar to Gaudium et Spes no. 10. But first those spouses are commended who, with prudent deliberation and generosity, choose to accept a large family. The spouses are to consider their responsibilities towards God, themselves, the family, and human society. Each of these factors may be taken into account in right order in determining “serious and just reasons.”

In other words the spouses are to discern together first, what is God’s plan for their family here and now, then, their own physical and emotional resources for accepting another child, the needs of other family members, and lastly the good of the human society in which they live. The pope gives special encouragement to scientists to perfect the natural methods, (HV, no. 24) declaring that the discipline of chastity exercised in periodic continence enhances married life provided the spouses value the true blessings of family. (HV, no. 21) >>
 
Do YOU think the church is teaching in error on homosexuality? Do you not see a difference between homosexual sex and heterosexual sex?

Good question - why should couples abide by church teachings on sex if it is hurting the marriage? And don’t just say “it shouldn’t be hurting the marriage”.

I don’t believe it is just “moral teachings” because the pieces are not logical.

Where in that last 1900 years, or before the 1930s - shoot, where in the times of the Apostles and after for a few hundred years or so - did anything say what the church now says on sex?

Darn it, I wish these things would give all of the post I’m responding to!
Marriage is a sacrament. If we live the sacrament the way God intended, it will not “hurt our marriage”. Any hurt done to the marriage is from our own sin and disobedience.

If the Church has it wrong about marriage, if marriage cannot survive when you do it the way the Church says to do it, then, how on EARTH can God do something like change a wafer to flesh or raise from the dead.

If the Church is wrong about marriage, She is wrong about everything.
 
And that is awesome, it really is. But there are just as many cases which are just as real where church teachings and NFP have absolutely had the opposite effects. It doesn’t matter what the church says is *supposed *to happen; it doesn’t mean that couples’ experiences are not happening.
I know just as many couples whose marriage improved after using contraception, I don’t think one mold fits all. For many couples I know NFP is a destructive force.
 
I know just as many couples whose marriage improved after using contraception, I don’t think one mold fits all. For many couples I know NFP is a destructive force.
If NFP is destroying the marriage, then, the reason for using NFP or other sin is deeply entangled in the marriage. Get to a good Catholic counselor, find a spiritual director, seek God to heal your broken marriage and make sure you are discerning that there is a real reason to delay children at this point.
 
If NFP is destroying the marriage, then, the reason for using NFP or other sin is deeply entangled in the marriage. Get to a good Catholic counselor, find a spiritual director, seek God to heal your broken marriage and make sure you are discerning that there is a real reason to delay children at this point.
Yup. All contraception does is put a temporary band-aid on a problem (e.g., selfishness on the part of one of the spouses) that will eventually rear its ugly head in other forms down the road.

It’s like using hormonal contraception for menstrual problems. The drugs may help with the symptoms but they won’t cure the underlying problem that’s causing the symptoms; in fact, they might make it worse by delaying treatment until the problem becomes serious.
 
Personally, I believe there is a very good reason why the Church has said “serious” or “grave” (whichever document or translation of document you want to refer to). It kind of gauls me when people come on to the forum and try to define what the Church has decided to leave to prayerful consideration to a married couple. In all the years I’ve been going to Church, I have never, ever heard a priest give a homily on what “grave” or “serious” reasoning meant. If you’ve chosen to use NFP and go by the guide lines of the Church, I expect that you and your spouse are aware of each time you decide not to be together because of the serious or grave reasoning. I’m sure there are plenty of couple out there using NFP who are not thrilled that sometimes if you’re using NFP to avoid pregnancy, that the times you most want to be together are the times it would most dangerous to be with each other. I completely disagree when someone says that because you’re avoiding that’s the same as using birth control. Birth Control doesn’t take patience and occaisionally gritting of teeth.
Also, remember BOTH spouses have to be on the same page with this. I’ve seen plenty of marriages where there have been major problems because one spouse wanted to use NFP and one didn’t - or when NFP wasn’t effective for certain couples. If the Church in it’s wisdom isn’t going to define what serious or grave reasons are and is leaving it to the couples, then each couple needs to decide - no marriage is the same and not circumstances are the same. Telling someone their reasons are not “serious” enough or that they are being “selfish” just insults others. Let each couple use their own reasoning. If the Church ever decides (which I doubt and hope it won’t) to define what serious or grave reasons are then I’m sure there will be plenty of talk about it then. Until then all we can each do is work on our own marriages and testify about them- none of us know exactly what’s going on in anyone else’s marriage.
God Bless
Rye
 
My cycles are extremely predictable, every single cycle spot on month after month for years. This makes NFP very easy. Someone like me with a very predictable cycle makes NFP to avoid pretty close to as effective as ABC.
 
My cycles are extremely predictable, every single cycle spot on month after month for years. This makes NFP very easy. Someone like me with a very predictable cycle makes NFP to avoid pretty close to as effective as ABC.
You are VERY, VERY blessed and lucky - wish it was that simple for everyone.
God Bless
Rye
 
You are VERY, VERY blessed and lucky - wish it was that simple for everyone.
God Bless
Rye
I wonder how many people are like that. Do you think most people are not? What is your experience?
Hopefully when actively trying to conceive it will be as effective as it is on the flip side.
Since NFP follows a boring predictable pattern for us I wonder if it is even less so “leaving it all up to God”. Makes sense why it is suggested that married couples do not use NFP lightly.
 
You are VERY, VERY blessed and lucky - wish it was that simple for everyone.
I am blessed with a great spouse and thankful for him.
However I have wanted children for years even while using NFP to avoid. So not sure about lucky…
 
Marriage is a sacrament. If we live the sacrament the way God intended, it will not “hurt our marriage”. Any hurt done to the marriage is from our own sin and disobedience.

No one ever said marriage isn’t a sacrament. As for what hurts a marriage or not, if you’re not in it with couples who are struggling, than you have no idea, and this kind of statement is arrogance…

If the Church has it wrong about marriage, if marriage cannot survive when you do it the way the Church says to do it, then, how on EARTH can God do something like change a wafer to flesh or raise from the dead.

If the Church is wrong about marriage, She is wrong about everything.
 
How can you trust God with other sacraments if He has the design marriage so wrong?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top