S
searching04
Guest
That is the logical conclusion of your beliefs, searching04. If it’s “silly,” then it says something about your initial premises.
No, it says you are making silly and unrealistic comparisons. Menopause - maybe.
I repeat, once again:
If the Church taught that sex was only for having kids, then Her teaching would be, “Each and every sex act MUST be with the sole intent of conceiving a child.” If the Church actually taught what you thought it did, then it would be immoral to have sex during a woman’s infertile period.
Then what is sex for? And you are presuming to know what church teaching would be. I repeat, once again - the church requires, dictates, etc that all sex end with the man climaxing via intercourse; we cannot have sex otherwise. We cannot use ABC of any type. It is intercourse, which obviously leads to pregnancy (yeah, yeah, menopause, hysterectomy, etc) or abstaining. Period. So if sex is not for having kids, then why? As I said before, it cannot be only for untive, because that is prohibited. It must be procreative, which means to have kids. Whether each and every act results in a child is irrelevant. The purpose, possibility is the same. Why is that hard to understand?
Furthermore, if sex is “only for having kids,” then what of this quote from Gaudiem et Spes?
Will have to go back to the post to find the link.
Do you see that? This is a papal encyclical promulgated by Pope Paul VI. It is authoritative teaching from the Church that marriage (and, following, the marital act) is not instituted SOLELY for procreation.
I don’t see how you can read the above and still believe that the Church teaches that sex is ONLY for having kids.