NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That is the logical conclusion of your beliefs, searching04. If it’s “silly,” then it says something about your initial premises.

No, it says you are making silly and unrealistic comparisons. Menopause - maybe.

I repeat, once again:

If the Church taught that sex was only for having kids, then Her teaching would be, “Each and every sex act MUST be with the sole intent of conceiving a child.” If the Church actually taught what you thought it did, then it would be immoral to have sex during a woman’s infertile period.

Then what is sex for? And you are presuming to know what church teaching would be. I repeat, once again - the church requires, dictates, etc that all sex end with the man climaxing via intercourse; we cannot have sex otherwise. We cannot use ABC of any type. It is intercourse, which obviously leads to pregnancy (yeah, yeah, menopause, hysterectomy, etc) or abstaining. Period. So if sex is not for having kids, then why? As I said before, it cannot be only for untive, because that is prohibited. It must be procreative, which means to have kids. Whether each and every act results in a child is irrelevant. The purpose, possibility is the same. Why is that hard to understand?

Furthermore, if sex is “only for having kids,” then what of this quote from Gaudiem et Spes?

Will have to go back to the post to find the link.

Do you see that? This is a papal encyclical promulgated by Pope Paul VI. It is authoritative teaching from the Church that marriage (and, following, the marital act) is not instituted SOLELY for procreation.

I don’t see how you can read the above and still believe that the Church teaches that sex is ONLY for having kids.
 
She wouldn’t have to be if people didn’t so often abuse and misuse sex.

You know what’s interesting? My husband and I were born and raised Lutheran. We were married in the Lutheran Church. We contracepted the first two years of our marriage, until our conversion to Catholicism, and than we began using NFP only and following the Church’s teachings regarding sex.

It has drastically changed our marriage for the better, and we would NEVER go back to contraception. There are similar testimonies all over the place by other Catholic converts or reverts who have lived on both sides of the fence, so to speak.
And that is awesome, it really is. But there are just as many cases which are just as real where church teachings and NFP have absolutely had the opposite effects. It doesn’t matter what the church says is *supposed *to happen; it doesn’t mean that couples’ experiences are not happening.
 
That is the logical conclusion of your beliefs, searching04. If it’s “silly,” then it says something about your initial premises.

I repeat, once again:

If the Church taught that sex was only for having kids, then Her teaching would be, “Each and every sex act MUST be with the sole intent of conceiving a child.” If the Church actually taught what you thought it did, then it would be immoral to have sex during a woman’s infertile period.

Furthermore, if sex is “only for having kids,” then what of this quote from Gaudiem et Spes?

Do you see that? This is a papal encyclical promulgated by Pope Paul VI. It is authoritative teaching from the Church that marriage (and, following, the marital act) is not instituted SOLELY for procreation.

I don’t see how you can read the above and still believe that the Church teaches that sex is ONLY for having kids.
Quote from your post:
Marriage to be sure is not instituted solely for procreation; rather, its very nature as an unbreakable compact between persons, and the welfare of the children, both demand that the mutual love of the spouses be embodied in a rightly ordered manner, that it grow and ripen. Therefore, marriage persists as a whole manner and communion of life, and maintains its value and indissolubility, even when despite the often intense desire of the couple, offspring are lacking.

This quote has nothing to do with sex not being for kids; it talks about marriage not solely being for procreation. Though I would still argue that, based on all the quotes in these threads that say the primary end to marriage is procreation, then this quote needs to be expanded if you are going to use it in this context. Of course marriage is not soley for procreation - to your point, what about menopause and surgeries? Marriage is not solely for having kids; but sex is soley for having kids.
 
Once again, if you could put your responses outside the quote box, it’d make it easier (and quicker) to reply to you.
No, it says you are making silly and unrealistic comparisons. Menopause - maybe.
Obviously, I disagree.
Then what is sex for?
Take a look at what the Catechism says:
**2362 **“The acts in marriage by which the intimate and chaste union of the spouses takes place are noble and honorable; the truly human performance of these acts fosters the self-giving they signify and enriches the spouses in joy and gratitude.” Sexuality is a source of joy and pleasure:
‘The Creator himself . . . established that in the [generative] function, spouses should experience pleasure and enjoyment of body and spirit. Therefore, the spouses do nothing evil in seeking this pleasure and enjoyment. They accept what the Creator has intended for them. At the same time, spouses should know how to keep themselves within the limits of just moderation.’
And you are presuming to know what church teaching would be. I repeat, once again - the church requires, dictates, etc that all sex end with the man climaxing via intercourse; we cannot have sex otherwise.
Not true. The Church states moral truth. She proposes, not imposes. God gives us free will; you can freely choose to sin. But you must also accept the consequences of that sin.
We cannot use ABC of any type. It is intercourse, which obviously leads to pregnancy (yeah, yeah, menopause, hysterectomy, etc) or abstaining. Period. So if sex is not for having kids, then why?
Because ABC and/or ejaculation outside of the woman both violate the DUAL PURPOSES of the marital act: unity and procreation. If either of these purposes are violated or barred from the marital act, the couple is deliberately excluding God from an integral part of their marriage.
As I said before, it cannot be only for untive, because that is prohibited. It must be procreative, which means to have kids. Whether each and every act results in a child is irrelevant. The purpose, possibility is the same. Why is that hard to understand?
Because it’s not an accurate representation of Church teaching. The marital act must be unitive AND procreative, every time, regardless of external circumstances (infertility, etc.). Take my situation. I am currently pregnant; however, the Church teaches that the intercourse my husband and I have MUST still be unitive and procreative even though it is impossible for a second instance of procreation to take place while I have a child in my womb.
 
Of course marriage is not soley for procreation - to your point, what about menopause and surgeries? Marriage is not solely for having kids; but sex is soley for having kids.
But, again, you are missing the point. If the Church taught that sex is only for babies, then it would be immoral to have sex when a woman is pregnant, through menopause or infertile. There would be rules that you could only have sex DURING ovulation (the same rules that the Jewish people used to follow–day 14 of the cycle). This is not the case. The Church leaves us the WHEN of having sex to the couple. All the Church says is that sex needs to remain properly ordered when you engage in the act (done in a way that ‘could’ lead to procreation, ie procreative) but it doesn’t matter what the NATURAL fertility is of the couple for it to be properly ordered. Sex is for the unification of the couple and tied directly to that is the fact that sex makes babies. They are one and the same.
 
And that is awesome, it really is. But there are just as many cases which are just as real where church teachings and NFP have absolutely had the opposite effects. It doesn’t matter what the church says is *supposed *to happen; it doesn’t mean that couples’ experiences are not happening.
Oh, well then. Let’s let individual sin (selfishness, etc.) determine moral teaching. On the same token, those pesky moral laws against homosexuality and adultery are really holding a lot of couples back from being happy, so let’s abolish those while we’re at it, too.

Do you see where that logic leads? Jesus never said that being His follower would be EASY. Sin causes all sorts of trouble and strife, especially within marriage. But that doesn’t mean the Church could or should change Her immutable moral teachings in order to conform to our level of sinfulness. We’re called to be perfect as our Father in Heaven is perfect, not to be content in our sin.
 
Quote from your post:
*Marriage to be sure is not instituted solely for procreation; rather, its very nature as an unbreakable compact between persons, and the welfare of the children, both demand that the mutual love of the spouses be embodied in a rightly ordered manner, that it grow and ripen. Therefore, marriage persists as a whole manner and communion of life, and maintains its value and indissolubility, even when despite the often intense desire of the couple, offspring are lacking.
*
This quote has nothing to do with sex not being for kids; it talks about marriage not solely being for procreation. Though I would still argue that, based on all the quotes in these threads that say the primary end to marriage is procreation, then this quote needs to be expanded if you are going to use it in this context. Of course marriage is not soley for procreation - to your point, what about menopause and surgeries? Marriage is not solely for having kids; but sex is soley for having kids.
As Jennifer J explained, sex is NOT solely for having kids. Again, from the catechism:

2362 “The acts in marriage by which the intimate and chaste union of the spouses takes place are noble and honorable; the truly human performance of these acts fosters the self-giving they signify and enriches the spouses in joy and gratitude.” Sexuality is a source of joy and pleasure:

‘The Creator himself . . . established that in the [generative] function, spouses should experience pleasure and enjoyment of body and spirit. Therefore, the spouses do nothing evil in seeking this pleasure and enjoyment. They accept what the Creator has intended for them. At the same time, spouses should know how to keep themselves within the limits of just moderation.’
 
But, again, you are missing the point. If the Church taught that sex is only for babies, then it would be immoral to have sex when a woman is pregnant, through menopause or infertile. There would be rules that you could only have sex DURING ovulation (the same rules that the Jewish people used to follow–day 14 of the cycle). This is not the case. The Church leaves us the WHEN of having sex to the couple. All the Church says is that sex needs to remain properly ordered when you engage in the act (done in a way that ‘could’ lead to procreation, ie procreative) but it doesn’t matter what the NATURAL fertility is of the couple for it to be properly ordered. Sex is for the unification of the couple and tied directly to that is the fact that sex makes babies. They are one and the same.
Maybe that’s where our difference is - I didn’t say is only for having babies. Subtle nuances, I guess. Bottom line is we will have to agree to disagree, or we are just missing each others’ point. Just because the church says sex must be both unitive and procreative does not mean that sex is not for having babies because we are prohibited for having sex only for unitive purposes (obviously the cases you’ve mentioned are the exceptions). The differences and problems and even contradictions lie in the “both unitive and procreative” part. It is why I believe the church is simply being preemptive and assuming what couples will do, so it dictates rules.

In your example, the line is a fine one. We are not supposed to seek sex for pleasure only, though we are to enjoy it. So when couples engage in sex when the wife is already pregnant, are we hopping into bed thinking “this is unifying” or are we hopping into bed saying “woohoo! sex!” because we do in fact enjoy it, and are already pregnant. By what I read here, if the focus is on pleasure when we have pregnant sex, we’re wrong, but that is mostly where couples go. Unifying? Yep. The reason we go have sex when pregnant? Not necessarily. It is taking advantage of the time and freedom you have as a couple.

You almost make my point for me when you point out that even when pregnant, couples must have intercourse for the man to climax. If that doesn’t tell you sex is for having kids, what does? If not, we would be allowed to engage in other things.

Shoot, I’d almost even argue that your point of pregnant sex is in fact only unitive and violates church dictates. It cannot be procreative because you’re pregnant, so it is only unifyiing and actually, pleasure seeking with a lot of freedom thrown in. Back to the above -it may be unifying, but it is because we have the freedom to have lots of sex when pregnant. Yes, you’ve said it has to be procreative, but may not result in procreation. This goes back to why I say the church is preemptive and assuming - it does not want couples only seeking the pleasure and unifying nature of sex, or we wouldn’t have enough kids, or any kids via intercourse. So it bans any activities other than intercourse, even when the wife is already pregnant, and that is only to keep couples from slipping into pleasure seeking, supposedly.

I think the overall disagreement is in whether people believe that sex must be both unitive and procreative at all times as the church dictates. I do not believe it must be, but the church says we must follow it. Yes, we can choose to follow or not. But I can tell you that when my wife and I both followed NFP and, in between phases, engaged in sex to climax without intercourse, we were closer to each other, and our overall intimacy and even spiritual life was stronger, because we were closer. It was not sex for the sake of sex - it can be and was extremely unitive, selfless, and loving - and it was for the closest physical intimacy we can have as a couple, not just for gratification. But the church does not allow couples to decide that; we are told what we can and cannot do.

You’ve said you would never go back to what you did before and NFP has brought you closer. The combination of NFP and church teachings on sex does not have that effect for everyone; it is often quite the opposite. Truly happy it worked for you.
 
Compendium issued Pope Benedict XVI
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for serious reasons; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
2370-2372

Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation.
 
Oh, well then. Let’s let individual sin (selfishness, etc.) determine moral teaching. On the same token, those pesky moral laws against homosexuality and adultery are really holding a lot of couples back from being happy, so let’s abolish those while we’re at it, too.

Do you see where that logic leads? Jesus never said that being His follower would be EASY. Sin causes all sorts of trouble and strife, especially within marriage. But that doesn’t mean the Church could or should change Her immutable moral teachings in order to conform to our level of sinfulness. We’re called to be perfect as our Father in Heaven is perfect, not to be content in our sin.
There are huge differences here and this is convenient to fall back on. Homosexuality is not a man and a woman; adultery is stepping outside of the marriage. Totally different. I don’t believe church teachings on sex are strictly “moral teachings”. It is very much because if the church said couples can have sex and the man climax outside of intercourse, then the church would have to condone other forms of ABC. That’s all it is for, I believe. Even church leaders were in disagreement at the time the pope came out with all of this; some apparently believed the wording or rules on contraception should have been changed or relaxed for couples. Pope disagreed. Here we are.
 
There are huge differences here and this is convenient to fall back on. Homosexuality is not a man and a woman; adultery is stepping outside of the marriage.
But if the Church is teaching error about contraception, how do you know She isn’t teaching error about homosexuality and adultery?
Totally different.
How so? Don’t you think couples have a right to be happy? Why should they abide by the Church’s teachings about sexuality if it makes them unhappy?
I don’t believe church teachings on sex are strictly “moral teachings”.
And what’s your basis for this assertion?
It is very much because if the church said couples can have sex and the man climax outside of intercourse, then the church would have to condone other forms of ABC.
In other words, since both methods violate the procreative aspect of the marital act, they are both condemned. Do you realize that all Christian churches taught this until 1930, when the Anglican Church caved to societal pressure (and other denominations followed suit)? Did God change His mind, or did He allow Christians to teach false doctrine for over 1,900 years?
That’s all it is for, I believe. Even church leaders were in disagreement at the time the pope came out with all of this; some apparently believed the wording or rules on contraception should have been changed or relaxed for couples. Pope disagreed. Here we are.
Yes, the Holy Spirit preserved the Church from teaching error, thank God.
 
But if the Church is teaching error about contraception, how do you know She isn’t teaching error about homosexuality and adultery?

How so? Don’t you think couples have a right to be happy? Why should they abide by the Church’s teachings about sexuality if it makes them unhappy?

And what’s your basis for this assertion?

In other words, since both methods violate the procreative aspect of the marital act, they are both condemned. Do you realize that all Christian churches taught this until 1930, when the Anglican Church caved to societal pressure (and other denominations followed suit)? Did God change His mind, or did He allow Christians to teach false doctrine for over 1,900 years?

Yes, the Holy Spirit preserved the Church from teaching error, thank God.
Do YOU think the church is teaching in error on homosexuality? Do you not see a difference between homosexual sex and heterosexual sex?

Good question - why should couples abide by church teachings on sex if it is hurting the marriage? And don’t just say “it shouldn’t be hurting the marriage”.

I don’t believe it is just “moral teachings” because the pieces are not logical.

Where in that last 1900 years, or before the 1930s - shoot, where in the times of the Apostles and after for a few hundred years or so - did anything say what the church now says on sex?

Darn it, I wish these things would give all of the post I’m responding to!
 
Do YOU think the church is teaching in error on homosexuality? Do you not see a difference between homosexual sex and heterosexual sex?
Of course I do, because I obey the Church. But there are plenty of “Catholics” and Christians who believe the Church teaches error in that regard.
Good question - why should couples abide by church teachings on sex if it is hurting the marriage? And don’t just say “it shouldn’t be hurting the marriage”.
Exactly! In the same vein, it logically follows that couples shouldn’t abide by Church teachings if those teachings make them unhappy in any way, shape, or form. That, then, means that homosexual relationships, adultery, pre-marital sex, infertility treatments, etc. are all A-OK. And why stop there? If it’d make me happy to be rich, I should be able to morally rob a bank so I can be happy, right?

(Note: I don’t believe the above, but that is what YOU’RE advocating when you claim that couples shouldn’t abide by any Church teachings that make them unhappy.)

To seriously answer your question, it’s not NFP that’s troubling the marriage, it’s the underlying sin involved. For example - if the marriage is troubled because the man wants the capability to have sex 24/7/365, then he’s committing the sins of selfishness and lust, treating his wife as an object for pleasure and rejecting part of her (her fertility). Do you think that’s a good thing?
I don’t believe it is just “moral teachings” because the pieces are not logical.
It’s eminently logical. Your comments clearly show that you simply don’t understand the teachings.
Where in that last 1900 years, or before the 1930s - shoot, where in the times of the Apostles and after for a few hundred years or so - did anything say what the church now says on sex?
The Church has had the exact same teachings on sex for the past 2,000 years. See this article, which discusses Church teaching regarding periodic continence in the 19th century: rtforum.org/lt/lt103.html
 
Of course I do, because I obey the Church. But there are plenty of “Catholics” and Christians who believe the Church teaches error in that regard.

Exactly! In the same vein, it logically follows that couples shouldn’t abide by Church teachings if those teachings make them unhappy in any way, shape, or form. That, then, means that homosexual relationships, adultery, pre-marital sex, infertility treatments, etc. are all A-OK. And why stop there? If it’d make me happy to be rich, I should be able to morally rob a bank so I can be happy, right?

(Note: I don’t believe the above, but that is what YOU’RE advocating when you claim that couples shouldn’t abide by any Church teachings that make them unhappy.)

I advocate none of the above, but you’re making a good leap. It is these kinds of incorrect analogies and jumping to these types of examples that make some of us sit back and go “What the heck are you talking about?” and queston whether you actually believe all of this or are just following along. And it may well not matter whether you believe it. But having sex with our God-given spouse in a heterosexual, monogamous marriage is equivalent to robbing a bank because I disagree with church teachings? C’mon!

To seriously answer your question, it’s not NFP that’s troubling the marriage, it’s the underlying sin involved. For example - if the marriage is troubled because the man wants the capability to have sex 24/7/365, then he’s committing the sins of selfishness and lust, treating his wife as an object for pleasure and rejecting part of her (her fertility). Do you think that’s a good thing?

I’m guessing you’ll apply that to women with a high sex drive, too? And no, not in the least is it always lust and sin and selfishness and objectifying a spouse because one or the other or both wishes to have lots of sex. I don’t buy the rejecting her fertility thing.

It’s eminently logical. Your comments clearly show that you simply don’t understand the teachings.

No, it’s not. I understand exactly. I just don’t agree with church teachings, nor how it is all presented to us in how and why the church came to those decisions and teachings.

The Church has had the exact same teachings on sex for the past 2,000 years. See this article, which discusses Church teaching regarding periodic continence in the 19th century: rtforum.org/lt/lt103.html
From the article:

Taking into account the whole spectrum of biblical and Church teaching in this area, I personally think that we need to bring back the word “grave” into the discourse about family planning. That is, we should be teaching that the temporal or worldly problems to be anticipated by another pregnancy and birth (mainly of health or poverty) need to be really grave in character before a married couple is entitled to conclude that they have a “just reason” for them to use NFP. (I said “bring back” above, because, as I shall show in this article, that key adjective, “grave”, has in fact been used by the Magisterium in this context, in certain decisions that have been generally forgotten, but by no means repudiated.)

The majority of the article focuses on why NFP is allowed, the difference between two factions on NFP, and says what the church says now - don’t use contraceptive means. This guy actually says the church needs to stress “grave” reasons before a couple is ENTITLED to conclude they have reason to not have another child. So couples are not supposed to think and decide for themselves - they have to be ENTITLED to do so by the church??? He goes further and stresses couples should be taught that a large family is a blessing and a sign of parents’ generosity.

Don’t show me this and then tell me that church teachings do not dictate that sex isn’t for having kids. It is exactly for having kids. I will also point out that this explicitly states that whatever pope it was never declared that purposely trying to avoid pregnancy via NFP is sinful. There are posts in this thread that say NFP can be sinful if used contraceptively. Obviously not acording to this guy’s quotes.
 
Of course I do, because I obey the Church. But there are plenty of “Catholics” and Christians who believe the Church teaches error in that regard.

Exactly! In the same vein, it logically follows that couples shouldn’t abide by Church teachings if those teachings make them unhappy in any way, shape, or form. That, then, means that homosexual relationships, adultery, pre-marital sex, infertility treatments, etc. are all A-OK. And why stop there? If it’d make me happy to be rich, I should be able to morally rob a bank so I can be happy, right?

(Note: I don’t believe the above, but that is what YOU’RE advocating when you claim that couples shouldn’t abide by any Church teachings that make them unhappy.)

To seriously answer your question, it’s not NFP that’s troubling the marriage, it’s the underlying sin involved. For example - if the marriage is troubled because the man wants the capability to have sex 24/7/365, then he’s committing the sins of selfishness and lust, treating his wife as an object for pleasure and rejecting part of her (her fertility). Do you think that’s a good thing?

It’s eminently logical. Your comments clearly show that you simply don’t understand the teachings.

The Church has had the exact same teachings on sex for the past 2,000 years. See this article, which discusses Church teaching regarding periodic continence in the 19th century: rtforum.org/lt/lt103.html
PS - Earliest this article quoted was around 1854 - what were teachings before that, seriously?
 
I advocate none of the above, but you’re making a good leap. It is these kinds of incorrect analogies and jumping to these types of examples that make some of us sit back and go “What the heck are you talking about?” and queston whether you actually believe all of this or are just following along. And it may well not matter whether you believe it. But having sex with our God-given spouse in a heterosexual, monogamous marriage is equivalent to robbing a bank because I disagree with church teachings? C’mon!
I never said they were equivalent. I said that the same logic can be used to justify other sins. Don’t you see the distinction?

“If X makes me happy, I should be able to do X.” X can stand for having extra-marital sex, having contraceptive sex, robbing a bank. See?
I’m guessing you’ll apply that to women with a high sex drive, too? And no, not in the least is it always lust and sin and selfishness and objectifying a spouse because one or the other or both wishes to have lots of sex. I don’t buy the rejecting her fertility thing.
But that’s exactly what contraception DOES. It communicates, “I want your body, but not your fertility. That part of you is bad and I want it excluded from our sex life.”

Here’s the thing about high sex drives - no one has ever died from having to abstain from sex. What if a woman had a medical condition that precluded sex? For example, pelvic rest during a threatened miscarriage, or during the immediate postpartum period when sex could potentially introduce infection. Or if a husband was undergoing treatment for testicular cancer and had to abstain from sex for a period of time. Would you expect a spouse to abstain during these times, despite his/her high sex drive? If not, then why is it such a stretch to expect a couple with serious reasons to abstain from sex for the purposes of spacing pregnancies?
No, it’s not. I understand exactly. I just don’t agree with church teachings, nor how it is all presented to us in how and why the church came to those decisions and teachings.
And every comment you makes displays a fundamental ignorance of the purpose of sex in marriage, the purpose of morality, the two complementary characteristics of sex, and the logical conclusions of tossing out moral teachings if they don’t make us happy.
From the article:

Taking into account the whole spectrum of biblical and Church teaching in this area, I personally think that we need to bring back the word “grave” into the discourse about family planning. That is, we should be teaching that the temporal or worldly problems to be anticipated by another pregnancy and birth (mainly of health or poverty) need to be really grave in character before a married couple is entitled to conclude that they have a “just reason” for them to use NFP. (I said “bring back” above, because, as I shall show in this article, that key adjective, “grave”, has in fact been used by the Magisterium in this context, in certain decisions that have been generally forgotten, but by no means repudiated.)

The majority of the article focuses on why NFP is allowed, the difference between two factions on NFP, and says what the church says now - don’t use contraceptive means. This guy actually says the church needs to stress “grave” reasons before a couple is ENTITLED to conclude they have reason to not have another child. So couples are not supposed to think and decide for themselves - they have to be ENTITLED to do so by the church??? He goes further and stresses couples should be taught that a large family is a blessing and a sign of parents’ generosity.

Don’t show me this and then tell me that church teachings do not dictate that sex isn’t for having kids. It is exactly for having kids.
re: your first paragraph - you’re quoting the opinion of the priest, not official Church teaching. My point in linking that article was to show that the Church has consistently taught the same sexual moral teachings for 2,000 years, which you originally disputed. Do you concede the point?

However, he has a point in that couples do need to inform their consciences according to the Church in this area. Essentially, he says that couples need to follow Christ in all things, especially when planning their families. We are not entitled to follow our consciences if those consciences are not in conformity with objective morality; that is, the teaching of the Church that Christ established. Otherwise, we could commit any sin under the sun and justify it by saying, “I’m just following my conscience.” (Many Christians already do this; for example, see “Catholics for a Free Choice.” They justify their support of abortion with the “we’re following our consciences!” argument.)

Here’s what you don’t seem to get: sex makes babies. Biologically, the purpose of sex is procreation. We can’t and shouldn’t divorce sex from procreation, biologically or morally. Sex is also for bonding, and that purpose *also *can’t be divorced from sex. They must BOTH be present. You can’t have sex for bonding while precluding babies, nor should you have sex only for procreation (especially if one partner is unwilling!).

I will say AGAIN: if the Church actually taught that sex was only for procreation, then procreation without the direct intention to conceive a child would be considered sinful. Since the Church does NOT teach the latter, then logically we can conclude that the Church does not teach that each and every sex act must be with the intent to conceive.
I will also point out that this explicitly states that whatever pope it was never declared that purposely trying to avoid pregnancy via NFP is sinful. There are posts in this thread that say NFP can be sinful if used contraceptively. Obviously not acording to this guy’s quotes
At last, we agree.
 
I never said they were equivalent. I said that the same logic can be used to justify other sins. Don’t you see the distinction?

“If X makes me happy, I should be able to do X.” X can stand for having extra-marital sex, having contraceptive sex, robbing a bank. See?

But that’s exactly what contraception DOES. It communicates, “I want your body, but not your fertility. That part of you is bad and I want it excluded from our sex life.”

That is what the church teaches; does not mean that it is the case at all times.

Here’s the thing about high sex drives - no one has ever died from having to abstain from sex. What if a woman had a medical condition that precluded sex? For example, pelvic rest during a threatened miscarriage, or during the immediate postpartum period when sex could potentially introduce infection. Or if a husband was undergoing treatment for testicular cancer and had to abstain from sex for a period of time. Would you expect a spouse to abstain during these times, despite his/her high sex drive? If not, then why is it such a stretch to expect a couple with serious reasons to abstain from sex for the purposes of spacing pregnancies?

Because it is not all the same.

And every comment you makes displays a fundamental ignorance of the purpose of sex in marriage, the purpose of morality, the two complementary characteristics of sex, and the logical conclusions of tossing out moral teachings if they don’t make us happy.

And you just don’t get it either - just because I disagree on something doesn’t mean I can’t figure it out. And who the heck are you to tell me I don’t understand the purpose of morality? Or that I’m tossing out teachings because they don’t make me happy? Who is ignorant of what? We disagree, period. But you don’t like it.

re: your first paragraph - you’re quoting the opinion of the priest, not official Church teaching. My point in linking that article was to show that the Church has consistently taught the same sexual moral teachings for 2,000 years, which you originally disputed. Do you concede the point?

Didn’t dispute it, I asked where it is, and the article covers a few hundred years, not 2000. Questions still stands, so no, I don’t concede it - I’m actually curious.

However, he has a point in that couples do need to inform their consciences according to the Church in this area. Essentially, he says that couples need to follow Christ in all things, especially when planning their families. We are not entitled to follow our consciences if those consciences are not in conformity with objective morality; that is, the teaching of the Church that Christ established. Otherwise, we could commit any sin under the sun and justify it by saying, “I’m just following my conscience.” (Many Christians already do this; for example, see “Catholics for a Free Choice.” They justify their support of abortion with the “we’re following our consciences!” argument.)

He wasn’t talking entitled to conscience - he was talking entitled to make a decision. Huge difference. And again, you assume that couples will automatically apply such decision making to all things and throw morality to the wind. In deciding not to do that, couples do indeed exercise morality.

Here’s what you don’t seem to get: sex makes babies. Biologically, the purpose of sex is procreation. We can’t and shouldn’t divorce sex from procreation, biologically or morally. Sex is also for bonding, and that purpose *also *can’t be divorced from sex. They must BOTH be present. You can’t have sex for bonding while precluding babies, nor should you have sex only for procreation (especially if one partner is unwilling!).

And THAT is the disagreement, that sex must be both. Nothing else. Well, part of it. Yep, sex is for making babies. You JUST AGREED WITH ME !

The point I keep trying to make - and with which you obviously disagree - is that sex can indeed be for bonding without babies; it is just that the church says no. If we are not allowed to have sex without having intercourse, which is dictated by the church, then the church is saying that sex is for making babies. It also says it has to be unitive. The difference is you think it has to both; I do not. But because of the exact fact that the church tells us it has to be both or not at all, then sex is for making babies - as you mentioned above. If you can’t have one without the other, there is no divorcing that sex is for making babies.

I will say AGAIN: if the Church actually taught that sex was only for procreation, then procreation without the direct intention to conceive a child would be considered sinful. Since the Church does NOT teach the latter, then logically we can conclude that the Church does not teach that each and every sex act must be with the intent to conceive.

And again, I never said that the church said sex is only for making babies; I said that because the church prohibits sex without leaving open the chance for a baby, that it does indeed teach that sex *is for having *babies. If not, it would allow for other things. As for your last sentence, that once again makes my point - the intent may not have to be to have a child, but the act must be open to it; by its very nature, as is so often pointed out, sex=biology=babies (in most cases). By church dictate, unless we want a baby or to have the chance of a baby, we are not to have sex. So sex is for having babies.

At last, we agree.
 
Searching - I think I’m slowly (have I mentioned I’m a little slow? :p) starting to understand your perspective…
You’re okay with… or rather, don’t understand the church’s teachings on… particular aspects of marital sexual intimacy… such as mutual masturbation or finishing outside of intercourse. I understand that many find this confusing… if both partners are in agreement, then how can it be “offensive”??.. they *feel *“united”.

I don’t think anything that is written or that anyone has said is going to just pop out an *convince *you of these truths… but we (as the Catholic faithful) are called to still TRUST that the Holy Spirit has guided the church in these teachings, even when they don’t make sense.
Out-rightly saying, “I don’t agree with this” will only continue to harden your heart and bring more and more bitterness.
There’s a LOT of people that have a hard time with SEVERAL teachings… this *one *has just got *you *tangled and twisted up and, to be honest, Satan is messing with you really good. :o

I’m going to (maybe in vain) post another document that I found some interesting wording in…
vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19751229_persona-humana_en.html
Scroll down to section IX… which speaks on masturbation (which is, in many ways, an aspect of your struggle - yours just happens to fall under more of a “mutual” masturbation category)… and it discusses how this truly IS a very challenging aspect for many to understand and believe.

This is the part I’ll quote:
Whatever the force of certain arguments of a biological and philosophical nature, which have sometimes been used by theologians, in fact both the Magisterium of the Church - in the course of a constant tradition - and the moral sense of the faithful have declared without hesitation that masturbation is an intrinsically and seriously disordered act.[19] The main reason is that, whatever the motive for acting this way, the deliberate use of the sexual faculty outside normal conjugal relations essentially contradicts the finality of the faculty. For it lacks the sexual relationship called for by the moral order, namely the relationship which realizes “the full sense of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love.”[20] All deliberate exercise of sexuality must be reserved to this regular relationship. Even if it cannot be proved that Scripture condemns this sin by name, the tradition of the Church has rightly understood it to be condemned in the New Testament when the latter speaks of “impurity,” “unchasteness” and other vices contrary to chastity and continence.
So, it’s something that has been a constant tradition in the teachings of the faith.
Maybe just take some time to deliberately pray over these ideas and ask God to help you understand…
… rather than condemning the teaching as something we’ll just have to agree to disagree on… :o

Prayers… and peace.
 
Searching - I think I’m slowly (have I mentioned I’m a little slow? :p) starting to understand your perspective…
You’re okay with… or rather, don’t understand the church’s teachings on… particular aspects of marital sexual intimacy… such as mutual masturbation or finishing outside of intercourse. I understand that many find this confusing… if both partners are in agreement, then how can it be “offensive”??.. they *feel *“united”.

Bingo. Especially when intercourse is not an option for extended periods and NFP goes on forever. Yes, that goes to deciding on the reasons, but in our case, it has been for years. Yes, when we did those other things, then yes, we felt incredibly close and intimate and united. Never felt otherwise, or used, or objectified, or wrong.

I don’t think anything that is written or that anyone has said is going to just pop out an *convince *you of these truths… but we (as the Catholic faithful) are called to still TRUST that the Holy Spirit has guided the church in these teachings, even when they don’t make sense.
Out-rightly saying, “I don’t agree with this” will only continue to harden your heart and bring more and more bitterness.
There’s a LOT of people that have a hard time with SEVERAL teachings… this *one *has just got *you *tangled and twisted up and, to be honest, Satan is messing with you really good. :o

Agreed on that.

I’m going to (maybe in vain) post another document that I found some interesting wording in…
vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19751229_persona-humana_en.html
Scroll down to section IX… which speaks on masturbation (which is, in many ways, an aspect of your struggle - yours just happens to fall under more of a “mutual” masturbation category)… and it discusses how this truly IS a very challenging aspect for many to understand and believe.

This is the part I’ll quote:

So, it’s something that has been a constant tradition in the teachings of the faith.
Maybe just take some time to deliberately pray over these ideas and ask God to help you understand…
… rather than condemning the teaching as something we’ll just have to agree to disagree on… :o

Prayers… and peace.
Sincerely appreciate your response and approach and the quote above. No, I cannot wrap my brain around it, but just have to keep following it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top