NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it is really not much different, not the way this is being discussed. And there we are again - skipping sex during the fetile times without “sufficient reason”. Whose “sufficient reason”? The logic, or lack thereof, in all of this still goes back to couples should be having more kids, because to only have sex during infertile times to lessen the chances of pregnancy is not correct and is sinful and is selfish. Looking for what God wants? Terribly hard to know that, but having more kids “just because” or getting pregnant and then hoping God will send cash (is that testing God or trusting Him, seriously?) isn’t the answer either.
There are 3 main criteria for just/serious/grave reasons outlined by the Church: economic, social, and medical (includes psychological). They don’t have to be life and death, but they shouldn’t be trivial. The Church doesn’t have a list, because just reasons would vary for every couple. That is financially burdensome for you might not be fore me, the medical risk might be worth it to you and not for me. These are prudential judgements made by the spouse in conversation with GOD through prayer. Sometimes a spiritual director (ie a holy priest) should be contacted, if there is division within the couples decision or if there is confusion about the justness of their reasons.

Try these links (the 2nd one is really good! Simcha is one of my fav bloggers!)
ewtn.com/expert/answers/nfp_serious_motives.htm
simchafisher.wordpress.com/2011/03/23/why-doesnt-the-church-just-make-a-list/
 
So using NFP is sinful, not using is sinful, and using it incorrectly may be sinful.

Yikes! No wonder so many Catholics seem neurotic! :D:D:D
 
Is it not the Catholic Church’s teaching that,

1.NFP is only to be used in the most serious of situations.

If true, why is this not preached more?
For example, I have watched many good programs on EWTN and read many articles and discussions on the internet about NFP, but this fact is almost always left out of the discussion. Yet it is so vital to the spiritual well being of the couple practicing NFP.

Am I mistaken, is this not a teachings of the Church.
Thank you all.
My understanding is that it is a teaching of the Church… NFP should only be used for a sufficient reason. Not just because the couple doesn’t want children.
 
My understanding is that it is a teaching of the Church… NFP should only be used for a sufficient reason. Not just because the couple doesn’t want children.
This is copied directly from Humanae Vitae; it clearly states that the couple does not want children; it also does not define acceptable reasons, leaving that to the couple. Pope Paul is comparing NFP against ABC. The reasons in each case are the same; what is unacceptable to the Church is the means and ways; artificial birth control is considered inherently morally wrong.
That is a subject for another thread. What is at question here is the intent of people using Natural Family Planning (NFP): According to Pope Paul, who after all wrote Humane Vitae and should know what he meant, is that in each case the intent of the couple was the same; No Children.

B]. **It cannot be denied that in each case the married couple, for acceptable reasons, are both perfectly clear in their intention to avoid children and wish to make sure that none will result. /**B]
 
There are 3 main criteria for just/serious/grave reasons outlined by the Church: economic, social, and medical (includes psychological). They don’t have to be life and death, but they shouldn’t be trivial. The Church doesn’t have a list, because just reasons would vary for every couple. That is financially burdensome for you might not be fore me, the medical risk might be worth it to you and not for me. These are prudential judgements made by the spouse in conversation with GOD through prayer. Sometimes a spiritual director (ie a holy priest) should be contacted, if there is division within the couples decision or if there is confusion about the justness of their reasons.

Try these links (the 2nd one is really good! Simcha is one of my fav bloggers!)
ewtn.com/expert/answers/nfp_serious_motives.htm
simchafisher.wordpress.com/2011/03/23/why-doesnt-the-church-just-make-a-list/
This part of the first link you posted I think is particularly interesting:
NFP is the study and knowledge of the bodily powers through which we bodily express conjugal love. NFP, therefore, reveals the dignity of both spouses to one another. In revealing this awesome dignity, it fosters love as well as a deep and abiding respect in each spouse for himself or herself and for the other. It also builds an unbelievable longing to share the infinite goods of human life with others, i.e., with children. NFP then builds a respect for human life. With this respect in place through the use of NFP, any decision by a couple to try to achieve a pregnancy or to avoid will be made for a good reason. It is not that serious reasons are not necessary—they are. But, a couple practicing NFP after taking the classes and knowing the method, practicing their faith attending Church and receiving the sacraments, with an active prayer life, and conscientious about the religious education of their children, will, if they decide to avoid a pregnancy, have serious reasons. This is what was meant by saying that virtue results from using NFP. It should also be noted that NFP couples generally discuss whether or not to try to achieve a pregnancy every single month. This re-examination also builds a respect for life.
Which I think is basically the same as what manualman said so articulately a few posts back!
 
This is copied directly from Humanae Vitae; it clearly states that the couple does not want children; it also does not define acceptable reasons, leaving that to the couple. Pope Paul is comparing NFP against ABC.

B]. It cannot be denied that in each case the married couple, for acceptable reasons, are both perfectly clear in their intention to avoid children and wish to make sure that none will result.
But the couple must have a just (acceptable) reason. The reason may NOT just be, we don’t want children end of story. It could be: we can’t afford the bigger car we need (to fit car seats/be safe) to have another child right now, I have a health condition that makes a pregnancy unwise, I live in a country where I would be forced to abort another child, I am severely/clinically depressed and so on. Not trivial-- but just reasons.
 
This is copied directly from Humanae Vitae; it clearly states that the couple does not want children; it also does not define acceptable reasons, leaving that to the couple. Pope Paul is comparing NFP against ABC. The reasons in each case are the same; what is unacceptable to the Church is the means and ways; artificial birth control is considered inherently morally wrong.
That is a subject for another thread. What is at question here is the intent of people using Natural Family Planning (NFP): According to Pope Paul, who after all wrote Humane Vitae and should know what he meant, is that in each case the intent of the couple was the same; No Children.

B]. **It cannot be denied that in each case the married couple, for acceptable reasons, are both perfectly clear in their intention to avoid children and wish to make sure that none will result. /**B]
but the couple must have a “just reason” for not wanting children… not just “we don’t feel like having kids right now”. There should be an important reason, otherwise the intention is similar to contraception (though the method is not).

“In deciding whether or not to have a child, [spouses] must not be motivated by selfishness or carelessness, but by a prudent, conscious generosity that weighs the possibilities and circumstances, and especially gives priority to the welfare of the unborn child. Therefore, when there is a reason not to procreate, this choice is permissible and may even be necessary. However, there remains the duty of carrying it out with criteria and methods that respect the total truth of the marital act in its unitive and procreative dimension, as wisely regulated by nature itself in its biological rhythms. One can comply with them and use them to advantage, but they cannot be ‘violated’ by artificial interference.”[1]
(Pope John Paul II).

ewtn.com/library/PROLIFE/zjustcause.HTM

ewtn.com/library/PROLIFE/zpostpreg.HTM
 
But the couple must have a just (acceptable) reason. The reason may NOT just be, we don’t want children end of story. It could be: we can’t afford the bigger car we need (to fit car seats/be safe) to have another child right now, I have a health condition that makes a pregnancy unwise, I live in a country where I would be forced to abort another child, I am severely/clinically depressed and so on. Not trivial-- but just reasons.
I get what you are saying but who decides what is just and what is trivial? How does someone really know?
 
I get what you are saying but who decides what is just and what is trivial? How does someone really know?
The couplel decides through prayer and discernment and the guidance of a holy priest or spiritual director, if needed. It should fall within the categories listed above: economic, social or medical.
 
The couplel decides through prayer and discernment and the guidance of a holy priest or spiritual director, if needed. It should fall within the categories listed above: economic, social or medical.
My understanding is that the guidance of a priest is ALWAYS needed, in order for NFP to be ethical and in accordance with Church teaching.

This part is often forgotte, along with having just reasons.

Pax
 
In my opinion, anytime you use NFP, you have a contraceptive mentality.

*Contraceptive: tending or serving to prevent conception or impregnation. (dictionary.com) *

The only difference as I see it is:
  • you’re not using something artificial like a drug or barrier
  • since you’re not using a drug or barrier, it feels like anything can happen so it is more natural
But please don’t tell me that painstakingly taking your temperature every morning, checking mucus or whatever method is used, and then not having sex during fertile days, is not done in attempt to not have children for that period of time.
 
No… sex is not “only” for having children. The two aspects are NOT separable… they are completely intertwined… inseparable.
Your second paragraph sorta indicates that you may still not understand this. There is no “for the sake of intimacy”… union and procreation are one. Separating the two is the definition of the “contraceptive mentality”.
Just have to disagree on it. Because based on what you say here, I would bet then that the majority couples using NFP are sinning. If in fact that using NFP and having sex at the infertile times to lessen the chances of having a child is a sin, then yep, sex is for having kids. Makes no sense other wise. Yeah, the church teaches unitive and procreative at all times. But it seems that you are saying that the difference lies in whether the couple is thinking, “Gee, I hope we don’t get pregnant” or "It’s OK if we do."
Well, can’t they be thinking: “I hope we don’t get pregnant BUT it’s OK if we do?” That’s basically how I feel about it. I thought that was what it all comes down to. If you have a reason to avoid pregnancy that is very severe and totally urgent, the alternative is total abstinence. Like manualman said, what seems like a good reason to avoid sometimes fades away “in the moment.” A really urgent reason, I imagine, would not.

What it comes down to, I think, is that some people get caught up in the “I really really really don’t want to get pregnant, but I don’t want to abstain. It’s not fair. I deserve intimacy with my spouse.” And although it sounds harsh, the basic answer is that the world is not always fair. I have a girlfriend who had to have an emergency hysterectomy after her second child was born. She was hemorrhaging and she would have died without the operation. She was 28. So now she and her hubby have had the privilege of sex whenever they wanted for many, many years. No worries, no problem. So, although sometimes I think “Wow, how easy and carefree that must be,” I try not to think “It’s not FAIR! She can have sex whenever and I have to abstain at times!!”
 
This part of the first link you posted I think is particularly interesting:

Which I think is basically the same as what manualman said so articulately a few posts back!
Copied from post #26:

NFP is the study and knowledge of the bodily powers through which we bodily express conjugal love. NFP, therefore, reveals the dignity of both spouses to one another. In revealing this awesome dignity, it fosters love as well as a deep and abiding respect in each spouse for himself or herself and for the other. It also builds an unbelievable longing to share the infinite goods of human life with others, i.e., with children. NFP then builds a respect for human life.

This may be the goal of NFP; it is not an absolute. It is why couples struggle with it. Some couples get to this point, some do not. I respect human life and it has nothing whatosever to do with NFP, and NFP has done nothing to increase that or make me see something differently.

With this respect in place through the use of NFP, any decision by a couple to try to achieve a pregnancy or to avoid will be made for a good reason. It is not that serious reasons are not necessary—they are. But, a couple practicing NFP after taking the classes and knowing the method, practicing their faith attending Church and receiving the sacraments, with an active prayer life, and conscientious about the religious education of their children, will, if they decide to avoid a pregnancy, have serious reasons. This is what was meant by saying that virtue results from using NFP.

Again, a goal, not an absolute, not a guarantee, not the same for all. This is a good example of how NFP is presented as all peaches and cream when it is not, when taken as a whole with church teachings on sex.

It should also be noted that NFP couples generally discuss whether or not to try to achieve a pregnancy every single month. This re-examination also builds a respect for life.
 
I get what you are saying but who decides what is just and what is trivial? How does someone really know?
And why is simply saying I don’t want to have children, or any more children, trivial?
 
but the couple must have a “just reason” for not wanting children… not just “we don’t feel like having kids right now”. There should be an important reason, otherwise the intention is similar to contraception (though the method is not).

This is a perfect example of what I mean when I say the church expects couples to keep having kids (if this and other presentations/posts are in fact church teaching), and that sex is for having kids. If a couple has the money, means, house, health, everything to provide for a child and do not wish to have one at that time for some other reason, this and other posts say they are wrong and sinning, and therefore should go ahead and have kids. If there is no “just reason” to not have children, then that dictates the couple must have more children.

“In deciding whether or not to have a child, [spouses] must not be motivated by selfishness or carelessness, but by a prudent, conscious generosity that weighs the possibilities and circumstances, and especially gives priority to the welfare of the unborn child. Therefore, when there is a reason not to procreate, this choice is permissible and may even be necessary. However, there remains the duty of carrying it out with criteria and methods that respect the total truth of the marital act in its unitive and procreative dimension, as wisely regulated by nature itself in its biological rhythms. One can comply with them and use them to advantage, but they cannot be ‘violated’ by artificial interference.”[1]
(Pope John Paul II).

ewtn.com/library/PROLIFE/zjustcause.HTM

ewtn.com/library/PROLIFE/zpostpreg.HTM
 
And why is simply saying I don’t want to have children, or any more children, trivial?
Not trivial, but apparently considered a sin, by what I’m reading through all of this.
 
Not trivial, but apparently considered a sin, by what I’m reading through all of this.
Your forgetting something my friend. From what I’m getting on this thread, everything is sinful. My goodness, I’m glad I’m a bachelor so I don’t have to worry about this! Yikes!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top