NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You CAN get married if you can’t have kids. You can’t get married if you can’t perform the act BEFORE marriage and it’s known.

Priests are people, too. We act like they couldn’t have a clue about relationships. Guess what, they can. We act like it’s not GOD speaking through them (esp during confession). Guess what, it is. They are given special graces to handle these questions and problems.
Ditto. Its kind of like if I had heart problems, I wouldn’t be against having a cardiologist that has never had a heart attack operate on my heart, as long as he has the right credentials/education. The same with a dentist, in fact maybe I would think twice before letting a dentist that has had lots of cavities treat mine if I had any.
 
Regarding the misconception that guidance from a priest or spiritual director is REQUIRED for couples to use NFP to avoid pregnancy - that is not the teaching of the Church:
Parents should regard as their proper mission the task of transmitting human life and educating those to whom it has been transmitted. They should realize that they are thereby cooperators with the love of God the Creator, and are, so to speak, the interpreters of that love. Thus they will fulfil their task with human and Christian responsibility, and, with docile reverence toward God, will make decisions by common counsel and effort. Let them thoughtfully take into account both their own welfare and that of their children, those already born and those which the future may bring. For this accounting they need to reckon with both the material and the spiritual conditions of the times as well as of their state in life. Finally, they should consult the interests of the family group, of temporal society, and of the Church herself. **The parents themselves and no one else should ultimately make this judgment in the sight of God. **But in their manner of acting, spouses should be aware that they cannot proceed arbitrarily, but must always be governed according to a conscience dutifully conformed to the divine law itself, and should be submissive toward the Church’s teaching office, which authentically interprets that law in the light of the Gospel. That divine law reveals and protects the integral meaning of conjugal love, and impels it toward a truly human fulfillment. Thus, trusting in divine Providence and refining the spirit of sacrifice, (1 Cor. 7:5) married Christians glorify the Creator and strive toward fulfillment in Christ when with a generous human and Christian sense of responsibility they acquit themselves of the duty to procreate. Among the couples who fulfil their God-given task in this way, those merit special mention who with a gallant heart and with wise and common deliberation, undertake to bring up suitably even a relatively large family. (Pius XII, Address Tra le visite, Jan. 20, 1958: AAS 50 (1958), P. 91)
Marriage to be sure is not instituted solely for procreation; rather, its very nature as an unbreakable compact between persons, and the welfare of the children, both demand that the mutual love of the spouses be embodied in a rightly ordered manner, that it grow and ripen. Therefore, marriage persists as a whole manner and communion of life, and maintains its value and indissolubility, even when despite the often intense desire of the couple, offspring are lacking.
Gaudium et Spes, Pope Paul VI

Basically, it’s a good idea – an extremely good idea – to get guidance from an orthodox priest or spiritual director while forming one’s conscience in this area, but it’s not required.

Also, this article – NFP: Licit or Illicit? – pretty much answers every single objection raised thus far. An excerpt:
I have heard or read more times than I can remember that since ABC and NFP have the same “end goal” in mind, (avoiding pregnancy) either both are valid or both are invalid. This argument is put forth by those who reject the Church’s teaching against ABC as well as those who reject NFP along with ABC. The problem with that line of thinking, in my opinion, is that it confuses the issue. ** The problem with it is that it assumes that seeking to avoid pregnancy is always evil in all circumstances. If that were true, then I would have to agree that no matter how you violate that, it is evil. But avoiding pregnancy for a good (sufficient/grave/serious) reason is not evil. ** The problem enters with the how. It comes down to the meaning and purpose of sex and to the natural law regarding human sexuality.
 
What !!?

Source?
2296 Organ transplants are in conformity with the moral law if the physical and psychological dangers and risks incurred by the donor are proportionate to the good sought for the recipient. Donation of organs after death is a noble and meritorious act and is to be encouraged as a manifestation of generous solidarity. It is not morally acceptable if the donor or those who legitimately speak for him have not given their explicit consent.
It is furthermore morally inadmissible directly to bring about the disabling mutilation or death of a human being, even in order to delay the death of other persons.
The key words in there are “donation of organs after death”. A heart transplant only works, because the heart comes from a living person. The act of removing the heart is the immediate cause of death. In other words it’s murder. Or in the words of the CC- “bring about the disabling mutilation or death of a human being”.

Listen to this. The priest speaking references Church documents that makes this clear.

AudioSancto.org/auweb/20050807-Brain-Dead-Dead-Means-the-Soul-Has-Left-the-Body.mp3

If you’d like to discuss further in another thread, so as not to derail this one, I’d be happy to.

Pax and God Bless.
 
The key words in there are “donation of organs after death”. A heart transplant only works, because the heart comes from a living person. The act of removing the heart is the immediate cause of death. In other words it’s murder. Or in the words of the CC- “bring about the disabling mutilation or death of a human being”.

Listen to this. The priest speaking references Church documents that makes this clear.

AudioSancto.org/auweb/20050807-Brain-Dead-Dead-Means-the-Soul-Has-Left-the-Body.mp3

If you’d like to discuss further in another thread, so as not to derail this one, I’d be happy to.

Pax and God Bless.
Um, that’s not true. In the slightest. See here.

This is a good article from the National Catholic Bioethics Center.
 
Is it not the Catholic Church’s teaching that,

1.NFP is only to be used in the most serious of situations.

If true, why is this not preached more?
For example, I have watched many good programs on EWTN and read many articles and discussions on the internet about NFP, but this fact is almost always left out of the discussion. Yet it is so vital to the spiritual well being of the couple practicing NFP.

Am I mistaken, is this not a teachings of the Church.
Thank you all.
NFP is to be only used “to avoid” when one has a serious reason. There is not “most” added there. Serious reasons can be all sorts of things…not just “life or death”.

The couple makes the judgment before God with a well formed conscience. It can be also good to seek advice.

Compendium issued by Pope Benedict XVI
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for* serious reasons*; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
2370-2372

Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html
 
Priests are people, too. We act like they couldn’t have a clue about relationships. Guess what, they can. We act like it’s not GOD speaking through them (esp during confession). Guess what, it is. They are given special graces to handle these questions and problems.
Furthermore, priests probably experience more marriages than most people do. If you are married, you know your marriage pretty well - you know its flaws and its strengths. You might know something about your friends’ marriages, but some people are pretty private about that stuff.

But priests give relationship counseling to TONS of people. Inside and outside of the confessional, so they probably hear and learn much much more about relationships than the average married couple.

No, they aren’t in them, so they don’t have the dynamic of that, but they do know a lot about them given their close experience. It’s similar to a psychiatrist not being the one who needs the counseling, but since they counsel so many other people they know what it’s like.
 
And emotional (unless it is included under social).

I had a miscarriage a little bit ago, and the thought of getting pregnant scares me. I need time to emotionally recover. So my husband and I are using NFP. It might be a sin, but a man (or woman) doesn’t have to die to go to Hell. I went through Hell and back with our miscarriage, and I’m not prepared to go through it right away.
Not sinful at all!
I did attend a lecture on canon law and found out that a paraplegic could not get married by the Church unless he could perform the “marital act” in the proper way. He would have to get some treatments and take some special medicine to insure he could perform the act . Otherwise he cannot marry for companionship or love. What nonsense.

In theory everything is wonderful and makes perfect sense, everyday reality is a whole different thing, like someone said, no wonder people become neurotic just thinking about these things.
I follow the Church teachings but yes I cant find the sense in this deal of paraplegics not getting married, I find it so sad 😦
Only if it’s abused. I feel using it to avoid children because they are inconvenient for the couple at a given time is abuse and is sinful. If it’s for valid medical reasons then I don’t see a problem with it.
in many cases when children are seen as “inconvenient” its likely to be a result of another problem. Can the mother deal with another child? if not then yes having a child would be inconvenient for her, so sin at all.
Furthermore, priests probably experience more marriages than most people do. If you are married, you know your marriage pretty well - you know its flaws and its strengths. You might know something about your friends’ marriages, but some people are pretty private about that stuff.

But priests give relationship counseling to TONS of people. Inside and outside of the confessional, so they probably hear and learn much much more about relationships than the average married couple.

No, they aren’t in them, so they don’t have the dynamic of that, but they do know a lot about them given their close experience. It’s similar to a psychiatrist not being the one who needs the counseling, but since they counsel so many other people they know what it’s like.
You have a good point. I never thought of that.
 
You CAN get married if you can’t have kids. You can’t get married if you can’t perform the act BEFORE marriage and it’s known.

Don’t think I understand this - ?

Priests are people, too. We act like they couldn’t have a clue about relationships. Guess what, they can. We act like it’s not GOD speaking through them (esp during confession). Guess what, it is. They are given special graces to handle these questions and problems.
 
And emotional (unless it is included under social).

I had a miscarriage a little bit ago, and the thought of getting pregnant scares me. I need time to emotionally recover. So my husband and I are using NFP. It might be a sin, but a man (or woman) doesn’t have to die to go to Hell. I went through Hell and back with our miscarriage, and I’m not prepared to go through it right away.
I cannot for the life of me see this as even remotely sinful.

I’m so sorry for you. Your in my prayers.
 
The teaching is that if a paralysed man wants to get married he must be able to consummate the marriage, meaning he has to be able to have sexual intercourse with his wife. This would apply to all who are impotent.

On the other hand if one is able to have sexual relations with their spouse but would be unable to conceive (e.g. A woman who has had her ovaries removed), they are allowed to marry.
The issue here is the ability to consummate not the ability to conceive.
 
Mine too. 😦 She needs to allow her heart and body to heal. Miscarriages are devastating, physically an emotionally. Hugs for CountrySinger.
Being a dude, I can’t relate. But I’m sure it’s heartbreaking.

Countrysinger-If anyone said that using NFP is sinful after a miscarriage, ignore them. In fact, they are deeply misguided at best, and downright mean at worst.
 
Originally Posted by Jennifer J View Post
You CAN get married if you can’t have kids. You can’t get married if you can’t perform the act BEFORE marriage and it’s known.
Why? Being able to complete the marital act is part of the definition of Marriage. (In order of contract a marriage). As someone said earlier Marriage, sex and children, are all the same topic, we cannot separate them. And the Church cannot change the obligations of marriage from fidelity and fecundity to companionship and non-conjugal love.
 
NFP is to be only used “to avoid” when one has a serious reason. There is not “most” added there. Serious reasons can be all sorts of things…not just “life or death”.

The couple makes the judgment before God with a well formed conscience. It can be also good to seek advice.

Compendium issued by Pope Benedict XVI
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for* serious reasons*; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
2370-2372

Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html
 
Why?

Because of the way it is phrased.

Being able to complete the marital act is part of the definition of Marriage. (In order of contract a marriage). As someone said earlier Marriage, sex and children, are all the same topic, we cannot separate them. And the Church cannot change the obligations of marriage from fidelity and fecundity to companionship and non-conjugal love.
 
The teaching is that if a paralysed man wants to get married he must be able to consummate the marriage, meaning he has to be able to have sexual intercourse with his wife. This would apply to all who are impotent.

And this is so wrong. If two people honestly believe that God gave them to each other to be husband and wife forever, the Catholic church is the only church on the planet that will tell them no they can’t, just because they can’t have kids? Totally nuts (for any church to say) and not at all what a loving God intended. But once again this is testament to the fact that the church sees sex as only for having kids, wrapped up into the “unitve and procreative” thing.

On the other hand if one is able to have sexual relations with their spouse but would be unable to conceive (e.g. A woman who has had her ovaries removed), they are allowed to marry.
The issue here is the ability to consummate not the ability to conceive.
 
Furthermore, priests probably experience more marriages than most people do. If you are married, you know your marriage pretty well - you know its flaws and its strengths. You might know something about your friends’ marriages, but some people are pretty private about that stuff.
So it would make sense if you are unsure if your reason is just. But many of us do not have questions.

No where does the Church say
Dan Daly:
My understanding is that the guidance of a priest is ALWAYS needed, in order for NFP to be ethical and in accordance with Church teaching.
 
And this is so wrong. If two people honestly believe that God gave them to each other to be husband and wife forever, the Catholic church is the only church on the planet that will tell them no they can’t, just because they can’t have kids? Totally nuts (for any church to say) and not at all what a loving God intended. But once again this is testament to the fact that the church sees sex as only for having kids, wrapped up into the “unitve and procreative” thing.
Unfortunately it is your view of marriage that “nuts.” Marriage is what it is, what God created it to be. It is not the secular definition of if two people love each other they can get married. But rather God ordained marriage for the procreation and education of children. Marriage binds the couple together as one flesh, those who cannot (permanently) engage in the marital act before the marriage cannot contract a marriage, cannot become one flesh.
 
And this is so wrong. If two people honestly believe that God gave them to each other to be husband and wife forever, the Catholic church is the only church on the planet that will tell them no they can’t, just because they can’t have kids? Totally nuts (for any church to say) and not at all what a loving God intended. But once again this is testament to the fact that the church sees sex as only for having kids, wrapped up into the “unitve and procreative” thing.
No… the church sees Marriage as much more than having kids. It’s a SACRAMENT. A COVENANT BOND… we don’t see it as just some legal contract that you can go sign at the clerk of court. :o

And because it is truly a SACRAMENT we have to turn to the church to define what the meaning of that Sacrament entails…
There ARE some caveats… like consummation.

*Can. 1055 §1. The matrimonial covenant, by which a man and a woman establish between themselves a partnership of the whole of life and which is ordered by its nature to the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring, has been raised by Christ the Lord to the dignity of a sacrament between the baptized.

§2. For this reason, a valid matrimonial contract cannot exist between the baptized without it being by that fact a sacrament.*

Can. 1061 §1. A valid marriage between the baptized is called ratum tantum if it has not been consummated; it is called ratum et consummatum if the spouses have performed between themselves in a human fashion a conjugal act which is suitable in itself for the procreation of offspring, to which marriage is ordered by its nature and by which the spouses become one flesh.

You can drive down to the clerk of court to get a contract signed… but it’s not valid of being called a “SACRAMENT”… THAT’S why the church gets to make the caveats… we fundamentally believe that the leaders of the church have been guided by the Holy Spirit in these teachings… :o
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top