NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No… the church sees Marriage as much more than having kids. It’s a SACRAMENT. A COVENANT BOND… we don’t see it as just some legal contract that you can go sign at the clerk of court. :o

And because it is truly a SACRAMENT we have to turn to the church to define what the meaning of that Sacrament entails…
There ARE some caveats… like consummation.

*Can. 1055 §1. The matrimonial covenant, by which a man and a woman establish between themselves a partnership of the whole of life and which is ordered by its nature to the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring, has been raised by Christ the Lord to the dignity of a sacrament between the baptized.

§2. For this reason, a valid matrimonial contract cannot exist between the baptized without it being by that fact a sacrament.*

Can. 1061 §1. A valid marriage between the baptized is called ratum tantum if it has not been consummated; it is called ratum et consummatum if the spouses have performed between themselves in a human fashion a conjugal act which is suitable in itself for the procreation of offspring, to which marriage is ordered by its nature and by which the spouses become one flesh.

You can drive down to the clerk of court to get a contract signed… but it’s not valid of being called a “SACRAMENT”… THAT’S why the church gets to make the caveats… we fundamentally believe that the leaders of the church have been guided by the Holy Spirit in these teachings… :o
Who said anything about going to the courthouse or that marriage isn’t a sacrament? I didn’t. I just don’t happen to agree with the particular teaching fitting in all circumstances. But as in other things in life, we don’t have to agree with things, we just have to do them.
 
Unfortunately it is your view of marriage that “nuts.” Marriage is what it is, what God created it to be. It is not the secular definition of if two people love each other they can get married. But rather God ordained marriage for the procreation and education of children. Marriage binds the couple together as one flesh, those who cannot (permanently) engage in the marital act before the marriage cannot contract a marriage, cannot become one flesh.
Yada, yada, Nice preaching and quotes. Where does anything say the secular definiton of marriage is to just get married? Non-Catholics, even non-Christians, can’t believe in marriage and having kids? That is like saying people who aren’t Catholic can’t get married. It is almost like limiting who can be Catholics. Can’t have kids? Well, then sorry the Catholic church doesn’t want you as a married couple unless you can. I have to wonder how many people have left the church over this.

As I posted earlier, we don’t have to agree, we just have to follow it. But some of you all seem terribly offended with people like me who are in fact quite Catholic, but disagree with some teachings. Guess we’ll all know for sure when we’re dead.

I keep making the point that I believe the church teaches sex is for kids. Some here disagree because the church says sex has to be both unitive and procreative, and you can’t separate the two, etc. In the quotes you gave as well as Em_in_FL, it specifically states marriage is for having kids, or that an integral part of it is to have kids, marriage is ordered to procreation. Well, then, as someone in an earlier thread said, biology is what it is - have sex and bingo - kids. If marriage is ordered towards procreation, and you cannot get married unless you can have kids and consumate the marriage, and we cannot have sex unless we want to have kids, then yes, sex is for having kids. There is no way around all of that. Just because you all quote “unitive and procreative” doesn’t change the fact that all sexual activity for a couple must end with the man climaxing inside his wife. Biology, sex, kids, church teaching. You may not like the way I express it and can disagree with it, same as i disgree on things, but it is a fact based on church teachings and things you all present.
 
Yada, yada, Nice preaching and quotes. Where does anything say the secular definiton of marriage is to just get married? Non-Catholics, even non-Christians, can’t believe in marriage and having kids? That is like saying people who aren’t Catholic can’t get married. It is almost like limiting who can be Catholics. Can’t have kids? Well, then sorry the Catholic church doesn’t want you as a married couple unless you can. I have to wonder how many people have left the church over this.

.
Well actually since it is how God ordained marriage, lots of people believe and follow that marriage is ordered towards children and unity of the spouses (Whether or not they believe in God). I was just commenting on the fact that there is a push recently in secular thought to make marriage just about 2 people loving each other, and that makes a marriage. But that cannot be the definition of marriage for many reasons

I said nothing about not having kids. I was commenting purely on the inability to have sex, because that and not infertility prevent people from contracting a marriage, because of the very definition of marriage.

I thought, if I couched my explanation in biblical terms, you might be able to recognize that this is God’s law and not just man’s law. 🤷

I really don’t know why anyone would leave the church over this particular rule.
 
Yada, yada, Nice preaching and quotes. Where does anything say the secular definiton of marriage is to just get married? Non-Catholics, even non-Christians, can’t believe in marriage and having kids? That is like saying people who aren’t Catholic can’t get married. It is almost like limiting who can be Catholics. Can’t have kids? Well, then sorry the Catholic church doesn’t want you as a married couple unless you can. I have to wonder how many people have left the church over this.

As I posted earlier, we don’t have to agree, we just have to follow it. But some of you all seem terribly offended with people like me who are in fact quite Catholic, but disagree with some teachings. Guess we’ll all know for sure when we’re dead.

I keep making the point that I believe the church teaches sex is for kids. Some here disagree because the church says sex has to be both unitive and procreative, and you can’t separate the two, etc. In the quotes you gave as well as Em_in_FL, it specifically states marriage is for having kids, or that an integral part of it is to have kids, marriage is ordered to procreation. Well, then, as someone in an earlier thread said, biology is what it is - have sex and bingo - kids. If marriage is ordered towards procreation, and you cannot get married unless you can have kids and consumate the marriage, and we cannot have sex unless we want to have kids, then yes, sex is for having kids. There is no way around all of that. Just because you all quote “unitive and procreative” doesn’t change the fact that all sexual activity for a couple must end with the man climaxing inside his wife. Biology, sex, kids, church teaching. You may not like the way I express it and can disagree with it, same as i disgree on things, but it is a fact based on church teachings and things you all present.
I agree with you on this, but good luck convincing most here on the thread to even agree to disagree with you. Their minds are made up that all Church teaching is infallible, when in fact infallibility is defined by the proclamation of Vatican I in 1870 as when the Pope speaks Ex Cathedra. This has been done limited times; sometimes the Church says that something is infallible even if the Pope did not speak Ex Cathedra, as with female ordination. This really muddies the waters. The Vatican website lists what the Popes have declared Ex Cathedra, but you will look in vain for any listing of infallible dogmas other than those. There is nothing on the Ex Cathedra list that discusses how to have sex. Humanae Vitae was not written under Ex Cathedra. In fact, Pope Paul welcomed debate on this issue in order that we would better understand it. To me this means that the sex training listed as Church teachings should not be considered infallible.
My belief in God and the Church relies upon faith, logic and reason. When Church teaching is not logical or reasonable it raises red flags with me. But you can point out the inconsistencies all you want, but the posters here will never agree with you.
 
Well actually since it is how God ordained marriage, lots of people believe and follow that marriage is ordered towards children and unity of the spouses (Whether or not they believe in God). I was just commenting on the fact that there is a push recently in secular thought to make marriage just about 2 people loving each other, and that makes a marriage. But that cannot be the definition of marriage for many reasons

I said nothing about not having kids. I was commenting purely on the inability to have sex, because that and not infertility prevent people from contracting a marriage, because of the very definition of marriage.

I thought, if I couched my explanation in biblical terms, you might be able to recognize that this is God’s law and not just man’s law. 🤷

I really don’t know why anyone would leave the church over this particular rule.
Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if the guy can’t consumate a marriage. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?
 
It is the Church’s stance that a couple must have a JUST reason for using NFP–not a ‘most serious situation’. NFP would be very difficult to use in a sinful manner, because it calls for sacrifice and abstinence.
The term “just” is a heavy term in Christian philosophy. Having a just cause is very serious. It is not difficult to use NFP in a sinful manner. Sacrificing for and unjust cause is not beneficial. Sacrifice and abstinence is not even really pertinant to the discussion IMO.,
 
Yada, yada, Nice preaching and quotes. Where does anything say the secular definiton of marriage is to just get married? Non-Catholics, even non-Christians, can’t believe in marriage and having kids? That is like saying people who aren’t Catholic can’t get married. It is almost like limiting who can be Catholics. Can’t have kids? Well, then sorry the Catholic church doesn’t want you as a married couple unless you can. I have to wonder how many people have left the church over this.

As I posted earlier, we don’t have to agree, we just have to follow it. But some of you all seem terribly offended with people like me who are in fact quite Catholic, but disagree with some teachings. Guess we’ll all know for sure when we’re dead.

I keep making the point that I believe the church teaches sex is for kids. Some here disagree because the church says sex has to be both unitive and procreative, and you can’t separate the two, etc. In the quotes you gave as well as Em_in_FL, it specifically states marriage is for having kids, or that an integral part of it is to have kids, marriage is ordered to procreation. Well, then, as someone in an earlier thread said, biology is what it is - have sex and bingo - kids. If marriage is ordered towards procreation, ]and you cannot get married unless you can have kids and consumate the marriage, and we cannot have sex unless we want to have kids, then yes, sex is for having kids. There is no way around all of that. Just because you all quote “unitive and procreative” doesn’t change the fact that all sexual activity for a couple must end with the man climaxing inside his wife. Biology, sex, kids, church teaching. You may not like the way I express it and can disagree with it, same as i disgree on things, but it is a fact based on church teachings and things you all present.
The part of this post I bolded is wrong. You cannot get married if it cannot be consumated. You can get married if you are not able to have kids. It is a VERY important distinction.
 
Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if the guy can’t consumate a marriage. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?
Let’s take your argument and reframe it:

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if they are the same sex. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them is still married to someone else. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them is not a human being. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them wants to have three wives. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them is 14 years old. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Etc.

The question is, how do we know what God intended?

Answer: that’s why He established a Church.
 
I do not think vague terms like “contraceptive mentality” are helpful to these discussions. What does that mean? Everyone could have a slightly different definition, as we have seen on this thread. Using NFP, for just reason, is a means to have sex and but not have kids. This is a fact, and the Church says it is OK, not sinful. But since one is having sex with the intent not to have a baby, is this a “contraceptive mentality”? who knows.

And there is no need to bring such terminology into the discussion. The church works hard to use very clear and precise terms. Work with those when coming to an understanding of a Church’s teaching, not inserting your own terms and phrases and you will have better luck. And discussions will not be so acrimonious.
2368 A particular aspect of this responsibility concerns the regulation of procreation. For just reasons, spouses may wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is not motivated by selfishness but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood. Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality:
When it is a question of harmonizing married love with the responsible transmission of life, the morality of the behavior does not depend on sincere intention and evaluation of motives alone; but it must be determined by objective criteria, criteria drawn from the nature of the person and his acts criteria that respect the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love; this is possible only if the virtue of married chastity is practiced with sincerity of heart.155
This is the paragraph we care about, there is nothing about “contraceptive mentality” Quite the opposit, it points out that the morality does not depend on sincere intention and evaluation of motices alone, but by objective criteris. This is why guidance from a spiritual director, when considering the use of NFP in order to not have babies, is critical.
 
NFP is to be only used “to avoid” when one has a serious reason. There is not “most” added there. Serious reasons can be all sorts of things…not just “life or death”.

The couple makes the judgment before God with a well formed conscience. It can be also good to seek advice.

Compendium issued by Pope Benedict XVI
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for* serious reasons*; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
2370-2372

Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation.

vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html
NFP is to be only used “to avoid” when one has a serious reason. Serious reasons can be all sorts of things…for life can involve all sorts of things.

That “serious reason” need not be extreme or very serious…or grave …or life or death…

The couple makes the judgment before God with a well formed conscience. It can be also good to seek advice.
 
Let’s take your argument and reframe it:

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if they are the same sex. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

This will be fun. Nice way of twisting things, you got there. God specifically said for man and woman to be together.

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them is still married to someone else. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Ten commandments.

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them is not a human being. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Martian, dog, cat? Now you’re just being ridiculous on this one.

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them wants to have three wives. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Ten commandments, bucko.

Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if one of them is 14 years old. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?

Church never put an age on it; society has. Girls were married at 14 or so for a long time, when life expectancy was much less, and the church believes Mary was 14. This one don’t fly.

Etc.

The question is, how do we know what God intended?

Man + woman = couple according to God. Your question above is as valid as asking the couple if what is in their hearts is valid. Do you know?

Answer: that’s why He established a Church.
 
The part of this post I bolded is wrong. You cannot get married if it cannot be consumated. You can get married if you are not able to have kids. It is a VERY important distinction.
OK, but it doesn’t change the argument.
 
The part of this post I bolded is wrong. You cannot get married if it cannot be consumated. You can get married if you are not able to have kids. It is a VERY important distinction.
OK, then, as this comes up in these threads as well: so a married couple decides to live a sexless or chaste marriage, even though they could consumate the marriage, but choose not to - so the church will not let them get married? Does it invalidate a marriage because after the vows the couple decides to live that way?
 
Searching04, if you could reply outside of the quote boxes, it would make it easier to respond to your points.
This will be fun. Nice way of twisting things, you got there. God specifically said for man and woman to be together.
Plenty of same-sex attracted people who identify as Christian argue otherwise. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?
Ten commandments.
But plenty of Lutherans, Baptists, etc. who don’t believe in the concept of annulments divorce and remarry every day. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?
Martian, dog, cat? Now you’re just being ridiculous on this one.
There are devout Christians out there who no doubt sincerely believe that God blesses the love between them and their pets. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?
Ten commandments, bucko.
Mormons claim to follow Christ and many believe He has endorsed and condoned polygamy. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?
Church never put an age on it; society has. Girls were married at 14 or so for a long time, when life expectancy was much less, and the church believes Mary was 14. This one don’t fly.
So it’s A-OK with you for a 51-year-old pedophile to marry a 14 year old? Or a 10 year old? I’m sure pedophiles all over the world thank you for your support. After all, you have no right to tell them they’re wrong.
Man + woman = couple according to God.
And may gay Christians disagree with you. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong? How do you know that this is “according to God”? How can a gay couple know in their hearts, without a doubt, that they are a couple “according to God” if you say they’re not? How do we know who is right?
Your question above is as valid as asking the couple if what is in their hearts is valid. Do you know?
No, which is why I listen to the Church. That was why Jesus established a Church, so that there would be an authoritative source to answer these types of questions.
 
Searching04, if you could reply outside of the quote boxes, it would make it easier to respond to your points.

Plenty of same-sex attracted people who identify as Christian argue otherwise. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?

But plenty of Lutherans, Baptists, etc. who don’t believe in the concept of annulments divorce and remarry every day. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?

There are devout Christians out there who no doubt sincerely believe that God blesses the love between them and their pets. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?

Mormons claim to follow Christ and many believe He has endorsed and condoned polygamy. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong?

So it’s A-OK with you for a 51-year-old pedophile to marry a 14 year old? Or a 10 year old? I’m sure pedophiles all over the world thank you for your support. After all, you have no right to tell them they’re wrong.

And may gay Christians disagree with you. Who are you to tell them they’re wrong? How do you know that this is “according to God”? How can a gay couple know in their hearts, without a doubt, that they are a couple “according to God” if you say they’re not? How do we know who is right?

No, which is why I listen to the Church. That was why Jesus established a Church, so that there would be an authoritative source to answer these types of questions.
You make no sense. You say “who am I to say they are wrong?” yet I use and present the sources I’d bet you’d agree with. What are *your *answers to all of your own questions? So you’re saying following God on the above questions is wrong? Difference between all of those is I disagree that God ever intended for couples to never be married because they cannot consumate the marriage; think He was pretty clear on the the more extreme situations you came up with. So God intends for those people to remain possibly lonely and alone for life? They’re just supposed to bear that as their cross, despite believing God put a possible spouse in to their life, because they can’t have sex? Totally different than marrying martians and animals and multiple wives and pedophiles with kids and whatever else you presented. Not logical in the least, because God condones none of it.
 
You make no sense. You say “who am I to say they are wrong?” yet I use and present the sources I’d bet you’d agree with.What are *your *answers to all of your own questions? So you’re saying following God on the above questions is wrong? Difference between all of those is I disagree that God ever intended for couples to never be married because they cannot consumate the marriage; think He was pretty clear on the the more extreme situations you came up with. So God intends for those people to remain possibly lonely and alone for life? They’re just supposed to bear that as their cross, despite believing God put a possible spouse in to their life, because they can’t have sex? Totally different than marrying martians and animals and multiple wives and pedophiles with kids and whatever else you presented. Not logical in the least, because God condones none of it.
You’re missing the point, searching.

You say that it should be perfectly fine for two people to get married if one of those people cannot physically consummate the marriage. This is against Church teaching, even if society condones these marriages (just as certain segments of society, including other Christian sects, condone gay marriage, divorce, etc.).

This is what you need to ask yourself:

If the Church is right about same-sex unions, polygamy, etc. being invalid marriages, is it possible that She is also right about persons who cannot physically consummate being unable to marry?

If the Church is wrong about denying marriage to people who are physically unable to consummate, then She could just as easily be wrong about same-sex marriage, polygamy, etc.

Do you see?
 
Em_in_FL;8441781:
You can drive down to the clerk of court to get a contract signed… but it’s not valid of being called a “SACRAMENT”… THAT’S why the church gets to make the caveats… we fundamentally believe that the leaders of the church have been guided by the Holy Spirit in these teachings… :o
Who said anything about going to the courthouse or that marriage isn’t a sacrament? I didn’t. I just don’t happen to agree with the particular teaching fitting in all circumstances. But as in other things in life, we don’t have to agree with things, we just have to do them.
But - *YOU *can’t just “make up” what is and is not a SACRAMENT…

Do you not trust that the Holy Spirit has guided the church in the areas of the Sacraments??
This isn’t something we have the ability to “pick and choose” from here…
 
You’re missing the point, searching.

You say that it should be perfectly fine for two people to get married if one of those people cannot physically consummate the marriage. This is against Church teaching, even if society condones these marriages (just as certain segments of society, including other Christian sects, condone gay marriage, divorce, etc.).

This is what you need to ask yourself:

If the Church is right about same-sex unions, polygamy, etc. being invalid marriages, is it possible that She is also right about persons who cannot physically consummate being unable to marry?

If the Church is wrong about denying marriage to people who are physically unable to consummate, then She could just as easily be wrong about same-sex marriage, polygamy, etc.

Do you see?
OK, that approach makes sense, to a degree. But it is basically the church covering its holy backside to avoid the whole infallibility issue. You’re right - it would open a whole pandora’s box, though I think the church could just as easily say “this is right” and “this is wrong” concerning those issues. There is a huge, huge difference between saying God said marriage is between one man and one woman, and having to say well, oops, we need to condone gay marriage and polygomy and as another poster put it, sex with children and non-humans. But one man and one woman not being able to marry because the guy can’t have sex and produce kids? Really?

But this also makes my point why I say the church says sex is for having kids, and why the church teaches what it does on sex. It opens panora’s box as well. It condemns ABC, so it cannot condone couples having sex other than intercourse that leads to the man climaxing somewhere other than dictated (the only thing actually mandated in sex), because it would have to condone other methods as well. It is a preemptive strike to keep couples from focusing on pleasure alone and not having (enough or any) intercourse to have kids.

I disagree, obviously, but we follow it.
 
But - *YOU *can’t just “make up” what is and is not a SACRAMENT…

Where the heck anywhere in any of this did I declare marriage wasn’t a sacrament???

Do you not trust that the Holy Spirit has guided the church in the areas of the Sacraments??
This isn’t something we have the ability to “pick and choose” from here…
 
Where the heck anywhere in any of this did I declare marriage wasn’t a sacrament???
The church (guided by the Holy Spirit) has declared that consummation is required…
Can. 1061 §1. A valid marriage between the baptized is called ratum tantum if it has not been consummated; it is called ratum et consummatum if the spouses have performed between themselves in a human fashion a conjugal act which is suitable in itself for the procreation of offspring, to which marriage is ordered by its nature and by which the spouses become one flesh.
Because according to the Catholic church, a couple who believes with all their hearts that a loving God put them together, are not allowed to get married if the guy can’t consumate a marriage. Do you honestly think and believe THAT is what God intended?
🤷

Yes, I honestly believe that church has been guided by God in this teaching…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top