NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, then, as this comes up in these threads as well: so a married couple decides to live a sexless or chaste marriage, even though they could consumate the marriage, but choose not to - so the church will not let them get married? Does it invalidate a marriage because after the vows the couple decides to live that way?
First question: no: As long as they are able to comsummate the marriage they may get married even if they decide ahead of time to live a sexless marriage. But the terminology of this being a chaste marriage is way off base. It is, but you are implying the definition of a chaste marriage is a sexless marriage. This is so far off base, it calls into question how much you have really tried to understand Catholic Church teaching on these subjects.

Second question: no, deciding to live in a sexless marriage after the vows does not invalidate the marriage.

These are very basic points. You really need to do a little research, before you get so got up emotionally in the arguments. If you disagree with the Church on its teachings, you at the minum have a moral responsibility to come to a understanding of those teachings.
 
OK, that approach makes sense, to a degree. But it is basically the church covering its holy backside to avoid the whole infallibility issue. You’re right - it would open a whole pandora’s box, though I think the church could just as easily say “this is right” and “this is wrong” concerning those issues. There is a huge, huge difference between saying God said marriage is between one man and one woman, and having to say well, oops, we need to condone gay marriage and polygomy and as another poster put it, sex with children and non-humans. But one man and one woman not being able to marry because the guy can’t have sex and produce kids? Really?
What you don’t understand is that all these teachings derive from the same definition of marriage, as defined by the Church. All of them.

Listen, I volunteer with my parish’s marriage preparation program, and we teach couples that there are “Five F’s” in marriage: Freely, Fully, Faithfully, Fruitfully, and Forever. Each “F” corresponds to a key principle of Catholic theology regarding marriage.

Freely - a marriage cannot be contracted if one party doesn’t consent, isn’t capable of consenting, or lacks the ability to fully consent.

Fully - a couple must be able to physically consummate their marriage. They must be able to become one flesh** at the time they marry**, even if one/both of the spouses loses that capability afterwards.

Faithfully - a couple must remain faithful and monogamous to one another in thought, word, and deed.

Fruitfully - a couple must be open to life and children. They must always retain the **capability **of procreation with every marriage act (i.e., they must be open to new life) even if they do not have the ability due to physical problems (e.g., infertility).

Forever - a valid marriage bond cannot be dissolved by civil or ecclesiastical law. When two people contract a valid marriage, that bond can only be dissolved by death.

ALL FIVE of these conditions must be present for EVERY SINGLE MARRIAGE. Contracepting couples violate “fruitfully.” Quadriplegic couples violate “fully.”
But this also makes my point why I say the church says sex is for having kids, and why the church teaches what it does on sex.
This is not what the Church teaches regarding sex. From Humane Vitae:
The reason is that the fundamental nature of the marriage act, while uniting husband and wife in the closest intimacy, also renders them capable of generating new life—and this as a result of laws written into the actual nature of man and of woman. And if each of these essential qualities, the unitive and the procreative, is preserved, the use of marriage fully retains its sense of true mutual love and its ordination to the supreme responsibility of parenthood to which man is called. We believe that our contemporaries are particularly capable of seeing that this teaching is in harmony with human reason.
Sex has to be UNITIVE and PROCREATIVE. That does not mean that each act of sex must result in conception, only that the man and woman cannot deliberately place any artificial barriers (drugs, latex, etc.) designed to prevent conception at any point before, during, or after the marriage act.
It opens panora’s box as well. It condemns ABC, so it cannot condone couples having sex other than intercourse that leads to the man climaxing somewhere other than dictated (the only thing actually mandated in sex), because it would have to condone other methods as well. It is a preemptive strike to keep couples from focusing on pleasure alone and not having (enough or any) intercourse to have kids.
I disagree, obviously, but we follow it.
Good, I’m glad you’re following Church teaching even if you don’t understand it. I really encourage you to read Contraception: Why Not? by Dr. Janet Smith. It may help you understand Church teaching in this regard better – you seem to have quite a few misconceptions.
 
I agree with you on this, but good luck convincing most here on the thread to even agree to disagree with you. Their minds are made up that all Church teaching is infallible, when in fact infallibility is defined by the proclamation of Vatican I in 1870 as when the Pope speaks Ex Cathedra. This has been done limited times; sometimes the Church says that something is infallible even if the Pope did not speak Ex Cathedra, as with female ordination. This really muddies the waters. The Vatican website lists what the Popes have declared Ex Cathedra, but you will look in vain for any listing of infallible dogmas other than those. There is nothing on the Ex Cathedra list that discusses how to have sex. Humanae Vitae was not written under Ex Cathedra. In fact, Pope Paul welcomed debate on this issue in order that we would better understand it. To me this means that the sex training listed as Church teachings should not be considered infallible.
My belief in God and the Church relies upon faith, logic and reason. When Church teaching is not logical or reasonable it raises red flags with me. But you can point out the inconsistencies all you want, but the posters here will never agree with you.
The ordinary teaching magesterium is infallible. Which means no Pope has to declare the definition of the Trinity is for it to be an infallible teaching. It is a continuous and unchanging teaching of the Church. The same goes for contraception or the teaching on marriage…unchanging and continuous, and therefore infallible by nature.
 
The ordinary teaching magesterium is infallible. Which means no Pope has to declare the definition of the Trinity is for it to be an infallible teaching. It is a continuous and unchanging teaching of the Church. The same goes for contraception or the teaching on marriage…unchanging and continuous, and therefore infallible by nature.
Previous Popes have felt it necessary to declare the unique character of Jesus, the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption of Mary, amongst some others. The ordinary teaching magesterium is based on the Pope and Bishops being in agreement. Since 1968 it has been almost a litmus test for a bishop candidate to explicitly state his conviction in Humanae Vitae in order to become a bishop, so it is not hard to understand why today bishops in general support this. It was not that way in 1968 when Humanae Vitae was published, nor in 1980 when 75% of the papal birth control commission wanted to remove the inherent immorality of artificial birth control from Church teachings.
 
First question: no: As long as they are able to comsummate the marriage they may get married even if they decide ahead of time to live a sexless marriage. But the terminology of this being a chaste marriage is way off base. It is, but you are implying the definition of a chaste marriage is a sexless marriage. This is so far off base, it calls into question how much you have really tried to understand Catholic Church teaching on these subjects.

Second question: no, deciding to live in a sexless marriage after the vows does not invalidate the marriage.

These are very basic points. You really need to do a little research, before you get so got up emotionally in the arguments. If you disagree with the Church on its teachings, you at the minum have a moral responsibility to come to a understanding of those teachings.
Chaste, sexless - I understand just fine, thank you. Don’t be so presumptive or naive or whatever - you know what the heck we are talking about in the threads… Don’t play semantics.
 
Chaste, sexless - I understand just fine, thank you. Don’t be so presumptive or naive or whatever - you know what the heck we are talking about in the threads… Don’t play semantics.
Chaste and sexless do not mean the same thing. That is what she is saying. They are not synonyms. Two people in a chaste marriage have sex.
 
What you don’t understand is that all these teachings derive from the same definition of marriage, as defined by the Church. All of them.

Listen, I volunteer with my parish’s marriage preparation program, and we teach couples that there are “Five F’s” in marriage: Freely, Fully, Faithfully, Fruitfully, and Forever. Each “F” corresponds to a key principle of Catholic theology regarding marriage.

Freely - a marriage cannot be contracted if one party doesn’t consent, isn’t capable of consenting, or lacks the ability to fully consent.

Fully - a couple must be able to physically consummate their marriage. They must be able to become one flesh** at the time they marry**, even if one/both of the spouses loses that capability afterwards.

Faithfully - a couple must remain faithful and monogamous to one another in thought, word, and deed.

Fruitfully - a couple must be open to life and children. They must always retain the **capability **of procreation with every marriage act (i.e., they must be open to new life) even if they do not have the ability due to physical problems (e.g., infertility).

Forever - a valid marriage bond cannot be dissolved by civil or ecclesiastical law. When two people contract a valid marriage, that bond can only be dissolved by death.

ALL FIVE of these conditions must be present for EVERY SINGLE MARRIAGE. Contracepting couples violate “fruitfully.” Quadriplegic couples violate “fully.”

This is not what the Church teaches regarding sex. From Humane Vitae:

Sex has to be UNITIVE and PROCREATIVE. That does not mean that each act of sex must result in conception, only that the man and woman cannot deliberately place any artificial barriers (drugs, latex, etc.) designed to prevent conception at any point before, during, or after the marriage act.

Good, I’m glad you’re following Church teaching even if you don’t understand it. I really encourage you to read Contraception: Why Not? by Dr. Janet Smith. It may help you understand Church teaching in this regard better – you seem to have quite a few misconceptions.
I understand just fine and have no misconceptions; I just don’t agree on some things. And to me, and others as well in one respect or another, it is a matter of words and how those words are put together. You all fall back onto “unitive and procreative”. Fine. I disagree it has to be both. And the dictates of church teachings do indeed mean that sex is for having kids. How else do you want to describe it and why do you not want to acknowledge that? Procreative, procreation, conception, open to life - the church says couples cannot have sex unless the man climaxes via intercourse and without ABC. That means sex is for having kids. What else then? Supposed to be both unitive and procreative? OK, but that does not mean sex is not for having kids, because we are prohibited from having sex otherwise. If sex is not for having kids, then why? It can’t be unitive because it has to be procreative, too.
 
I understand just fine and have no misconceptions; I just don’t agree on some things. And to me, and others as well in one respect or another, it is a matter of words and how those words are put together. You all fall back onto “unitive and procreative”. Fine. I disagree it has to be both. And the dictates of church teachings do indeed mean that sex is for having kids. How else do you want to describe it and why do you not want to acknowledge that? Procreative, procreation, conception, open to life - the church says couples cannot have sex unless the man climaxes via intercourse and without ABC. That means sex is for having kids. What else then? Supposed to be both unitive and procreative? OK, but that does not mean sex is not for having kids, because we are prohibited from having sex otherwise. If sex is not for having kids, then why? It can’t be unitive because it has to be procreative, too.
No… MARRIAGE (as in, the Sacrament) is “ordered to” having kids… and since sex is a natural part of marriage, sex within marriage has to be “ordered to” having kids…
 
Chaste, sexless - I understand just fine, thank you. Don’t be so presumptive or naive or whatever - you know what the heck we are talking about in the threads… Don’t play semantics.
Well, your post which I quoted showed that you did not understand this just fine. The equating of a chaste marriage with a sexless marriage is truly absurd. Pointing it out is not playing semantics. Being precise with choice of words and definitions is not playing semantics, it is being respectful to the other party.

As to not knowing what the heck you are talking about, I admit to some truth in that. I find many of the points people have made on this thread confusing and hard to understand, at times contradictory. In post 89, I showed the paragraphs from the catechism which apply directly to this thread. My humble suggestion is that those paragraphs be the focus of the discussion. There is a lot there to grasp and understand.

Good day and God Bless
 
No… MARRIAGE (as in, the Sacrament) is “ordered to” having kids… and since sex is a natural part of marriage, sex within marriage has to be “ordered to” having kids…
I give up. We’re playing word games. Sex being “ordered” towards having kids is no different than sex is for having kids. Have sex, you’re going to have kids, eventually or really quick, if couples follow church rules. Just because NFP says have sex during infertile times to lessen the chance of pregnancy doesn’t mean it is any less “ordered” to having kids. Sex = kids. Biology, as someone put it.
 
Well, your post which I quoted showed that you did not understand this just fine. The equating of a chaste marriage with a sexless marriage is truly absurd. Pointing it out is not playing semantics. Being precise with choice of words and definitions is not playing semantics, it is being respectful to the other party.

As to not knowing what the heck you are talking about, I admit to some truth in that. I find many of the points people have made on this thread confusing and hard to understand, at times contradictory. In post 89, I showed the paragraphs from the catechism which apply directly to this thread. My humble suggestion is that those paragraphs be the focus of the discussion. There is a lot there to grasp and understand.

Good day and God Bless
Well, on that part, I can agree. There is alot in a small paragraph to grasp.
 
I give up. We’re playing word games. Sex being “ordered” towards having kids is no different than sex is for having kids.
Yes, it is different. If the Church taught that sex was for having kids, then Her teaching would be, “Each and every sex act MUST be with the sole intent of conceiving a child.” If the Church actually taught what you thought it did, then it would be immoral to have sex during a woman’s infertile period.
Have sex, you’re going to have kids, eventually or really quick, if couples follow church rules.
Even post-menopausal couples? Wow! What about a woman who had to have a hysterectomy for medical reasons? Are you telling me that following Church teaching will magically make her able to conceive?
Just because NFP says have sex during infertile times to lessen the chance of pregnancy doesn’t mean it is any less “ordered” to having kids. Sex = kids. Biology, as someone put it.
Exactly, and that’s why it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies. But using contraception violates this “order” toward procreation.
 
It can’t be unitive because it has to be procreative, too.
Just to clarify, are you trying to say that it can’t be both at the same time? Because the church teaches that you need both, marital relations are both unitive and ordered towards procreation. They are inseparable and we are not to separate them.
 
an impotent couple wants to get married and obviously they will have to live their marital life like celibate people. Why would the Church oppose this? they are not sinning in anyway if they are living like siblings (the way divorced couples must live with their new spouses). It’s not like as if they are committing sexual sins in any way.
 
an impotent couple wants to get married and obviously they will have to live their marital life like celibate people. Why would the Church oppose this? they are not sinning in anyway if they are living like siblings (the way divorced couples must live with their new spouses). It’s not like as if they are committing sexual sins in any way.
No one said they were sinning. We said they were unable to contract a valid marriage. There is a difference. Yes, people can enter “Josephite” marriages (Intending not to consummate the marriage), however, those marriages can be absolved by the pope, and from my understanding one spouse can ask for the marital debt, if they want and they will then have a regular marriage.

In a union where one spouse is impotent from the start, the marital debt cannot be given, regardless of the other spouses wishes or change of heart/mind. Thus it is not allowed. (If the tribunal has determined that the impotency is of a permanent nature).
 
No one said they were sinning. We said they were unable to contract a valid marriage. There is a difference. Yes, people can enter “Josephite” marriages (Intending not to consummate the marriage), however, those marriages can be absolved by the pope, and from my understanding one spouse can ask for the marital debt, if they want and they will then have a regular marriage.

In a union where one spouse is impotent from the start, the marital debt cannot be given, regardless of the other spouses wishes or change of heart/mind. Thus it is not allowed. (If the tribunal has determined that the impotency is of a permanent nature).
So impotent couples can validly have a Josephite marriage? :confused:
 
I give up. We’re playing word games. Sex being “ordered” towards having kids is no different than sex is for having kids. Have sex, you’re going to have kids, eventually or really quick, if couples follow church rules. Just because NFP says have sex during infertile times to lessen the chance of pregnancy doesn’t mean it is any less “ordered” to having kids. Sex = kids. Biology, as someone put it.
Sadly that is not always the case. As evidence you can look at the many married couples, who have sex, and want children, but for reasons known only to God have not been blessed with any.

Following the laws of the Church does not automatically create children.

Pax and God Bless.
 
Exactly, and that’s why it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies. But using contraception violates this “order” toward procreation.
That should be “it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies…if you are using NFP correctly and for the right reasons”

NFP can be just as immoral as contraception, if it is misused. That’s the whole point of discussion in this thread I believe.

I’d argue that in most cases, NFP is used immorally, as every NFP class I’ve been to spends 90%+ of the time talking about how to do it, and not why or why not to do it. My personal opinion is that most practioners view it as “Catholic contraception”, and I fail to see the reason for instructing every soon-to-be married Catholic couple in the method before they are even married. If they later encounter serious reasons not to desire children, they can abstain, seek guidance, and then be instructed in NFP if it is appropriate.

The message put out by the pre-Cana NFP classes is that Catholics have two choices:

Contraception (forbidden)
NFP (what you should do- according to the classes)

That’s a false choice. It leaves off:
-Abstaining from relations entirely if you have serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.
-Simply living your life, having relations, and trusting to the divine providence of God.

Both of those are entirely valid Catholic views. Both are dismissed by the “Catholic Contraception NFP crowd”.

Pax and God bless.
 
That should be “it’s not immoral to use NFP to space pregnancies…if you are using NFP correctly and for the right reasons”

NFP can be just as immoral as contraception, if it is misused. That’s the whole point of discussion in this thread I believe.

I’d argue that in most cases, NFP is used immorally, as every NFP class I’ve been to spends 90%+ of the time talking about how to do it, and not why or why not to do it. My personal opinion is that most practioners view it as “Catholic contraception”, and I fail to see the reason for instructing every soon-to-be married Catholic couple in the method before they are even married. If they later encounter serious reasons not to desire children, they can abstain, seek guidance, and then be instructed in NFP if it is appropriate.

The message put out by the pre-Cana NFP classes is that Catholics have two choices:

Contraception (forbidden)
NFP (what you should do- according to the classes)

That’s a false choice. It leaves off:
-Abstaining from relations entirely if you have serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.
-Simply living your life, having relations, and trusting to the divine providence of God.

Both of those are entirely valid Catholic views. Both are dismissed by the “Catholic Contraception NFP crowd”.

Pax and God bless.
so you’re pretty much against NFP?
Unless one has major serious reasons to avoid then abstinence would be more licit but NFP could still be taught?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top