NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There’s an interesting and relevant article in the latest issue of Latin Mass Magazine, which points out that indeed NFP is only to be used for spacing children for GRAVE reasons.

“Serious” is a bad translation from the Latin to English.

Pax and God bless.
Well the term used in the recent documents of the Church is “serious reasons”.

The various editions of the Compendium issued by Pope Benedict XVI:

The English word is serious

the French edition is sérieux

The German ernsthaften

Italian seri

All translate as: Serious.

Here are some other examples of more recent documents:

From the Encyclical of Pope John Paul II Evangelium Vitae

This happens when the family is generously open to new lives, and when couples maintain an attitude of openness and service to life, even if, for serious reasons and in respect for the moral law, they choose to avoid a new birth for the time being or indefinitely.

(the term in Latin is: seriis…serious)

From the Compendium of Social Doctrine of the Catholic Church
  1. The family contributes to the social good in an eminent fashion through responsible motherhood and fatherhood, the spouses’ special participation in God’s work of creation[519]. The weight of this responsibility must not be used as a justification for being selfishly closed but must guide the decisions of the spouses in a generous acceptance of life. “In relation to physical, economic, psychological and social conditions, responsible parenthood is exercised both in the duly pondered and generous decision to have a large family, and in the decision, made for serious reasons and in respect of the moral law, to avoid for a time or even indeterminately a new birth”[520]. The motivations that should guide the couple in exercising responsible motherhood and fatherhood originate in the full recognition of their duties towards God, towards themselves, towards the family and towards society in a proper hierarchy of values.
From a vatican guide for confessors:

The witness of couples who for years have lived in harmony with the plan of the Creator, and who, for proportionately serious reasons, licitly use the methods rightly called “natural,” confirms that it is possible for spouses to live the demands of chastity and of married life with common accord and full self-giving.

(of course serious does not only = life or death stuff…there can be various serious reasons…life has lots of variations)
 
Well, I’m glad I could clear up the misunderstanding for you. Hopefully Church doctrine now makes more sense.
Church doctrine always made sense, the writings of the saints and theologians do not.

You keep trying to conflate the two, despite the fact that you stated on the previous page that St. Augustine and other saints are not infallible, that they are not the Magisterium and that their writings represent their private opinions.

You can’t have it both ways. Either the saints and theologians are infallible and their writings are the Magisterium, or they are their own personal opinions. Which is it? Make up your mind.
 
Church doctrine always made sense, the writings of the saints and theologians do not.
And yet Church doctrine is based, in part, on the writings of those saints and theologians. Funny how that works.
You keep trying to conflate the two, despite the fact that you stated on the previous page that St. Augustine and other saints are not infallible, that they are not the Magisterium and that their writings represent their private opinions.
You can’t have it both ways. Either the saints and theologians are infallible and their writings are the Magisterium, or they are their own personal opinions. Which is it? Make up your mind.
I never said that the writings of the saints and theologians are the Magesterium. You need to improve your reading comprehension. This is what I said; please pay attention to the bolded portion:
Also remember that St. Augustine’s views don’t represent infallible Church teaching – they represent the teaching of one man. A great man, a saint, a doctor of the Church, but still a man. He’s not infallible, and his writings represent his private opinion, not the infallible teaching of the Magisterium.
That’s why Jesus established a Church and created the Papacy + Magesterium, so they could glean what was good and true from such writings and discard what was in error, and thus promulgate authentic teaching, inspired by the Holy Spirit, to the faithful.
 
Church doctrine always made sense, the writings of the saints and theologians do not.

You keep trying to conflate the two, despite the fact that you stated on the previous page that St. Augustine and other saints are not infallible, that they are not the Magisterium and that their writings represent their private opinions.

You can’t have it both ways. Either the saints and theologians are infallible and their writings are the Magisterium, or they are their own personal opinions. Which is it? Make up your mind.
The Theologians and the Saints all had/have their opinions. Those opinions mostly represent the teachings of the Church, and at times the Church proclaimed their opinions to be one with Church teaching, but sometimes there are errors.

I think in the case of Augustine, his opinions were uniform with the Church in regards to sexuality, but we have a tendency to misunderstand what he meant in his writings. Therefore, we look to other Church Fathers and to the Church Doctrine itself to better understand. As you can see by the quotes I posted in Post # 237, it is not evident that Augustine or any other Church Father/Theologian viewed sex as a necessary evil, but saw merit in the marital act. If one is going to study the writings of Augustine, or any of the early Church Fathers for that matter, it is wise to also take a look at the history and contemplate what was taking place in that time period and to know what he was wrtining in defense…what sins were prevelant at that time.
 
And yet Church doctrine is based, in part, on the writings of those saints and theologians. Funny how that works.
That doesn’t make them the same thing.
I never said that the writings of the saints and theologians are the Magesterium. You need to improve your reading comprehension. This is what I said; please pay attention to the bolded portion:
So do you! I keep saying “I have problems with X” and you respond by saying “You have problems with Y.” It’s very frustrating when people don’t listen!

If the saints and theologians are not the infallible magisterium, then having a problem with the saints and theologians is not the same thing as having a problem with the infallible magisterium.

I don’t have a problem with the Catechism or Casti Connubi or Humane Vitae or anything like that.
 
That doesn’t make them the same thing.
I never said they were. But don’t you see how illogical it is to say that “100% of saints and theologians taught and believed X; however, the Church, who in part bases Her doctrine on these same beliefs and teachings, taught Y”?
If the saints and theologians are not the infallible magisterium, then having a problem with the saints and theologians is not the same thing as having a problem with the infallible magisterium.

I don’t have a problem with the Catechism or Casti Connubi or Humane Vitae or anything like that.
Actually, earlier in this thread you claimed that the Church *changed *Her teaching on sex and marriage after the year 1900. That claim undermines Church authority by implying that She makes up doctrine willy-nilly based on the societal conventions of the day, just like many Protestants do.
 
I have no problem wtith the Immaculate Conception. I believe in the Immaculate Conception. But I guess you disagree with Bl. John Henry Newman on the development of Christian doctrine. He felt that Christian doctrine developed over time, and I guess you do not.
Maybe we have a failure to communicate, what do I mean by change

Doctrine does develop, it does not transform into something else.

Take two pictures, a baby the day he is born and the same person at 85 years old. The baby has developed, grown, and has in a way changed yet is still the same person, he has not transformed into a different person.

Does that make sense?
 
Maybe we have a failure to communicate, what do I mean by change

Doctrine does develop, it does not transform into something else.

Take two pictures, a baby the day he is born and the same person at 85 years old. The baby has developed, grown, and has in a way changed yet is still the same person, he has not transformed into a different person.

Does that make sense?
Depending on what it is, doctrines can indeed change (national defense, for example - from isolationist to pre-emptive intervention). But that will go back to each person’s interpretation of what is doctrine - never ending circle…
 
Is it not the Catholic Church’s teaching that,

1.NFP is only to be used in the most serious of situations.

If true, why is this not preached more?
For example, I have watched many good programs on EWTN and read many articles and discussions on the internet about NFP, but this fact is almost always left out of the discussion. Yet it is so vital to the spiritual well being of the couple practicing NFP.

Am I mistaken, is this not a teachings of the Church.
Thank you all.
First off, using it for the most serious circumstances is oversimplifying the moral situation. It is rather an issue of balancing the need for unity with the need to space and limit family size to be able to adequately provide for the family.

I believe the issue is not addressed because understanding Catholic doctrine takes more teaching then the time given to give a homily. Moreover, the homily is supposed to be reserved for connecting and explaining the readings of the mass for that liturgical day. If the homily is frequently irrelevent to the readings, the priest isn’t doing his job, and the laity tend to just scratch their heads about the readings. Meanwhile Catholic education tends to be done in CCD (which frankly is a crash course in Catholic that is limited by the students’ age when taking the classes) or by Catholic schools which often have lost their Catholic identity. This leaves exposure to the teachings to the one brief day or couple of days for marriage prep. The Church then is too busy trying to convince couples to reject everything they’ve been told about fertility in school (that the woman can ovulate any time of the cycle and is equally fertile any day of the year) to “Just believe us and ignore the fact that couples who practice NFP have large families, because this study here says the method effectiveness is 99%.”

Unforunately the Church is relying on a couple’s commitment to follow the letter of the law and seeing the larger families as evidence that NFP naturally leads a couple to be more open to children. Unforunately they are not paying attention to the couples who try NFP, find it too hard, resort to contraceptive and then try to convince those open to using NFP that it doesn’t work. Moreover they are ignoring the fact that couples with the contraceptive mentality that use NFP tend to overall promote the faulty message that sexual pleasure is a necessary evil. Even if they do not say this in words, their continued rejection of fertility turns into a rejection of pleasure. NFP in their minds is moral because sexual pleasure can only be morally rationally through sexual intercourse. When the reality is that the Church documents all speak highly of the value of the begetting of children and of the beauty of sexual pleasure in marriage.

The only thins the Holy Spirit protects are the keys to salvation. The Holy Spirit does not protect the Church from people who want to treat evangalization as a Public Relation campaign or to promote it through the methods used to promote commercialism.
 
I read this excellent article today (written by a priest, for* Crisis Magazine*) and it reminded me of this thread:

NFP: the Myth of the Contraceptive Mentality
Thank you for posting the article. It was interesting to read. I would respectfully disagree with some of the Father’s conclusions, but it is good to see a Priest putting thought into the issue and seeking to address it.

I believe a contraceptive mentality most definitely can drive use of NFP.

Adultery is not looking at someone. Or is it? Our Lord tells us that He who looks at someone with lust, has indeed committed adultery. Did Our Lord misspeak? Should he have said they had been “selfish” or “sinful” but not adulterous? I do not believe so. Likewise, although NFP may be very different than artificial contraception, just as looking at someone is very different than having sex with them, the status of the heart and mind can unite the two acts.

For example, I have heard many times, I believe even in this thread if I recall correctly, that NFP allows a couple to “take control of their fertility”. In many cases, I believe the idea presented in the comment is the same as the idea that drives contraception- that the Divine will must be made secondary to the human will of the couple.

Pax Christi
 
Thank you for posting the article. It was interesting to read. I would respectfully disagree with some of the Father’s conclusions, but it is good to see a Priest putting thought into the issue and seeking to address it.

I believe a contraceptive mentality most definitely can drive use of NFP.

Adultery is not looking at someone. Or is it? Our Lord tells us that He who looks at someone with lust, has indeed committed adultery. Did Our Lord misspeak? Should he have said they had been “selfish” or “sinful” but not adulterous? I do not believe so. Likewise, although NFP may be very different than artificial contraception, just as looking at someone is very different than having sex with them, the status of the heart and mind can unite the two acts.

For example, I have heard many times, I believe even in this thread if I recall correctly, that NFP allows a couple to “take control of their fertility”. In many cases, I believe the idea presented in the comment is the same as the idea that drives contraception- that the Divine will must be made secondary to the human will of the couple.

Pax Christi
Taking control of your fertility actually refers to a book (I haven’t read) aimed at helping women achieve pregnancy by understanding their cycles, better nutrition etc.
 
People use contraceptives so they don’t have to abstain, fertilty is no longer a “problem” and to thwart the natural design of a woman.
 
I don’t see how different it is. It almost seems like it’s just “gaming” the system or finding a “loophole” when a couple routinely uses NFP so that they will not get pregnant.
If that is all it is, then why worry about it? The Church gives a method that is exactly like contraception to plan our family. Isn’t that wonderful? Sure the reasoning may not make perfect sense to you, but why look a gift horse in the mouth?

I think that the fact that NFP is so hateful to the spirit of people who support contraception is some small evidence that they do sense that it is different.
 
Thank you for posting the article. It was interesting to read. I would respectfully disagree with some of the Father’s conclusions, but it is good to see a Priest putting thought into the issue and seeking to address it.

I believe a contraceptive mentality most definitely can drive use of NFP.

Adultery is not looking at someone. Or is it? Our Lord tells us that He who looks at someone with lust, has indeed committed adultery. Did Our Lord misspeak? Should he have said they had been “selfish” or “sinful” but not adulterous? I do not believe so. Likewise, although NFP may be very different than artificial contraception, just as looking at someone is very different than having sex with them, the status of the heart and mind can unite the two acts.

For example, I have heard many times, I believe even in this thread if I recall correctly, that NFP allows a couple to “take control of their fertility”. In many cases, I believe the idea presented in the comment is the same as the idea that drives contraception- that the Divine will must be made secondary to the human will of the couple.

Pax Christi
Are you sure what is Divine will?
Is the Divine will that you are supposed to follow Church’s Magisterium without any thinking?
The same Magisterium tells us that you may choose not to have babies. So what now?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top