NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But I read about SO many couples here on this forum who do, specifically, use it to not get pregnant!
So many recent posts talk about how difficult it is to abstain from sex and how torturous it is on the marriage to do so…but they still abstain for a week or two every month so that the wife will not get pregnant because they don’t want any more kids…or don’t want kids yet…or whatever.
For the same reasons people use contraception!
I’ve asked this question before…isn’t that the same as not being open to life?
If you are consciously trying not to get pregnant? The mentality is the same, being that someone does NOT want to get pregnant and have a/another baby.

But many people say…no, no…it’s different.

I don’t see how different it is. It almost seems like it’s just “gaming” the system or finding a “loophole” when a couple routinely uses NFP so that they will not get pregnant.
Once again - the Church does not teach that spacing or postponing pregnancy, even indefinitely, is immoral or intrinsically evil. It is perfectly legitimate for a couple to do so. However, they must use a moral means to do so. NFP is moral. Contraception is immoral.

Say you wanted to lose weight in order to be healthier. That’s also a morally neutral goal, even a morally good goal. You have a few options: you can gorge all you want on your favorite unhealthy, fattening foods and force yourself to vomit afterwards, so you can still get the pleasure of eating without gaining weight. Or, you could abstain from the fattening foods and exercise more.

Which one is better for your body and your overall health? Obviously, it’s abstaining. It’s the same with contraception and NFP when the morally neutral goal is to avoid conception. Contraception is the attempt to get the positive benefits of sex (pleasure) but selfishly trying to avoid the natural biological consequences of sex (conception). With NFP, however, you forego the pleasure and the natural biological consequences by abstaining from the act altogether, in accordance with God’s design for our fertility cycles.
 
But I read about SO many couples here on this forum who do, specifically, use it to not get pregnant!
So many recent posts talk about how difficult it is to abstain from sex and how torturous it is on the marriage to do so…but they still abstain for a week or two every month so that the wife will not get pregnant because they don’t want any more kids…or don’t want kids yet…or whatever.
For the same reasons people use contraception!
Remember that the Church never set a rule on how many children a couple is required or allowed to have. That’s up to the couple. Even if the couple only wanted one child and used NFP to have only one child, they can do that. The way NFP works, you really have to be committed to that ideology because it is tortorous. It’s hard to follow and a great burden for many couples. Obviously, if they are torturing themselves, they have good reason to not chance an unwanted conception. Remember there are many reasons: the spirtual/mental/physical health of either parent, their capacity to care for their current family in addition to another family member, their financial situation, etc. There are many reasons. Look at the words in HV about having children: the Pope calls couples ‘generous’ when they have more children.
I’ve asked this question before…isn’t that the same as not being open to life?
No, being open to live is accepting the new life that God sends you. That means having the child and not having an abortion. You can’t dupe God. Look at all the pregnancies resulting from NFP and ABC usage. The only way one can’t get pregnant is complete abstinence.
If you are consciously trying not to get pregnant? The mentality is the same, being that someone does NOT want to get pregnant and have a/another baby.

But many people say…no, no…it’s different.

I don’t see how different it is. It almost seems like it’s just “gaming” the system or finding a “loophole” when a couple routinely uses NFP so that they will not get pregnant.
That’s because you’re not looking at the whole picture. The Church does not require couples to have child after child, year after year, until a woman’s uterus drops out with the last child. We treat our animals better than that, and the ones that don’t get their animals taken away and charges brought against them. Some couples are called to have many children and those people are doing just that. I know people with 9, 10, 13 kids and they have it all together and their homes are filled with life and joy. They’re amazing. And some are called to have just one, and they are doing just that, and they are happy and full of life too. Everyone has their reasons and it’s unfair to judge another person’s situation by your standards (not talking about YOU specifically). It’s not fair to impose burdens on another family that you would find acceptable just because you find them acceptable in your situation. (again, not just talking about YOU). Each family is reponsible for discerning what is best for their family, as HV says, without any outside interference.

If NFPers were out to “cheat”, they’d just be using ABC or getting sterilized. So give credit where credit is due. They’re not going to burden themselves with NFP if they weren’t trying to do the right thing. They are the ones dealing with the consequences of their actions, not anyone else.
 
Taking control of your fertility actually refers to a book (I haven’t read) aimed at helping women achieve pregnancy by understanding their cycles, better nutrition etc.
As a side note…I wish you would read it if you have time. I’d be interested to know what you think of it in comparison to what you learned in class. Do you think it’s possible that this book could take the place of a live teacher?

So many people can’t access a teacher. It would be great to find a resource that gives the learner more independence.
 
As a side note…I wish you would read it if you have time. I’d be interested to know what you think of it in comparison to what you learned in class. Do you think it’s possible that this book could take the place of a live teacher?

So many people can’t access a teacher. It would be great to find a resource that gives the learner more independence.
Creighton Instructors teach via skype.

fertilitycare.org/
 
As a side note…I wish you would read it if you have time. I’d be interested to know what you think of it in comparison to what you learned in class. Do you think it’s possible that this book could take the place of a live teacher?

So many people can’t access a teacher. It would be great to find a resource that gives the learner more independence.
I taught myself NFP, as a Protestant, by reading TCOYF. I just ignored the part where she recommends using condoms during the fertile period (although she does emphasize that abstinence is “safer” in terms of avoiding pregnancy).
 
As a side note…I wish you would read it if you have time. I’d be interested to know what you think of it in comparison to what you learned in class. Do you think it’s possible that this book could take the place of a live teacher?

So many people can’t access a teacher. It would be great to find a resource that gives the learner more independence.
Hi Rence…I actually learned Billings on my own, then I used their charting system, they correct you if you put in incorrect information.

I think sympto thermal can also be learned on ones own (correct me anyone if I’m wrong)
 
Taking control of your fertility actually refers to a book (I haven’t read) aimed at helping women achieve pregnancy by understanding their cycles, better nutrition etc.
the book is called Taking Charge of your Fertility and its written by Toni Weschler. Its not just about achieving pregnancy, but also avoiding conception. and yeah it
does talk about nutrition and how women in general can understand\improve their cycles.
I’m umarried (and single) but I’m thinking of getting this book so I understand my cycles. It would be beneficial now to know more about my reproductive health, and if I do get married in future, I might be more competent in understanding NFP.
 
Are you sure what is Divine will?
Is the Divine will that you are supposed to follow Church’s Magisterium without any thinking?
The same Magisterium tells us that you may choose not to have babies. So what now?
I’m not exactly sure what your comment means?

Do I always know what God’s will is? No, I don’t.

Do I think God doesn’t want people to think? No, I don’t.

My point is that I see many people who use NFP adopt the same mindset as those who use contraception- that they are in charge of their lives, not God. This is most clearly evidenced by referring to children- who are gifts from God- as “accidents” , “mistakes”, and “failures”, those terms are frequently used both by practioners of artificial contraception and NFP.

I hope that clarifies my comment and answers your questions.

Pax Christi.
 
I’m not exactly sure what your comment means?

Do I always know what God’s will is? No, I don’t.

Do I think God doesn’t want people to think? No, I don’t.

My point is that I see many people who use NFP adopt the same mindset as those who use contraception- that they are in charge of their lives, not God. This is most clearly evidenced by referring to children- who are gifts from God- as “accidents” , “mistakes”, and “failures”, those terms are frequently used both by practioners of artificial contraception and NFP.

I hope that clarifies my comment and answers your questions.

Pax Christi.
People use NFP in order not to have babies. According to Church’s teaching this is OK.
Are you saying this is still wrong because people are in charge and not God?
It seems you disagree with the Magisterium.
 
Because they love them so much that they don’t want to bring them to poverty and let them suffer.
That is the beginnings of the kind of eugenics that inspired Margaret Sanger - shudder.

Have you ever read any of her chilling writings on poverty? I think Feminists for Life have some on their website.

Give this article a read blackgenocide.org/negro.html

Sanger embraced Malthusian eugenics. Thomas Robert Malthus, a 19th century cleric and professor of political economy, believed a population time bomb threatened the existence of the human race. He viewed social problems such as poverty, deprivation and hunger as evidence of this “population crisis.”
 
Because they love them so much that they don’t want to bring them to poverty and let them suffer.
You cannot love someone who does not exist. It is impossible, IMO. So this answer, at the semantic level, is meaninglless.
So it must be something else they love so much that they don’t want them in poverty or suffering. It could be their existing family, and that is fine; financial distress can certainly be a valid reason to postpone having another child and to use NFP. But lets be honest about it. If one is going to choose to use NFP in order to not get pregnant, a serious reason is required. This implies that careful discernment must be made, which requires honesty with one self.

Note: admittedly, this is too harsh, and I know you did not intent to be dishonest. So I apologize for that. But your quick response seems very odd on a Catholic forum.
 
You cannot love someone who does not exist. It is impossible, IMO. So this answer, at the semantic level, is meaninglless.
So it must be something else they love so much that they don’t want them in poverty or suffering. It could be their existing family, and that is fine; financial distress can certainly be a valid reason to postpone having another child and to use NFP. But lets be honest about it. If one is going to choose to use NFP in order to not get pregnant, a serious reason is required. This implies that careful discernment must be made, which requires honesty with one self.

Note: admittedly, this is too harsh, and I know you did not intent to be dishonest. So I apologize for that. But your quick response seems very odd on a Catholic forum.
No harm done. I can take a punch or two. 🙂
Having said that I didn’t consider your comments harsh at all.

I understand both sides of the argument very well.
The Magisterium says be open for life and submit to God’s will. The same Magisterium says you may choose not to have babies.
There is an antagonism to a certain degree.

Married couples can choose and be happy with either or struggle to decide which way to go.
 
People use NFP in order not to have babies. According to Church’s teaching this is OK.
Are you saying this is still wrong because people are in charge and not God?
It seems you disagree with the Magisterium.
With charity, it sounds like your position is the one that disagrees with the Magisterium.

The Church has not given blanket permission to any married couple to use NFP in order to try avoiding children. It has said that for serious and grave reasons, a couple may use NFP to avoid children temporarliy, until the reasons are resolved.

If you think of a child as an accident or a mistake, that is the contraceptive mindset.

Pax Christi
 
With charity, it sounds like your position is the one that disagrees with the Magisterium.

The Church has not given blanket permission to any married couple to use NFP in order to try avoiding children. It has said that for serious and grave reasons, a couple may use NFP to avoid children temporarliy, until the reasons are resolved.

If you think of a child as an accident or a mistake, that is the contraceptive mindset.

Pax Christi
If you call it contraceptive mindset, fine that’s what it is. Nevertheless it’s approved by the Church with the right reasons and it does not have to be temporarily, could be forever.

It seems NFP can be abused only if there are no sufficient reasons. Who is going to judge that? It’s between married couple and God.
 
With charity, it sounds like your position is the one that disagrees with the Magisterium.

The Church has not given blanket permission to any married couple to use NFP in order to try avoiding children. It has said that for serious and grave reasons, a couple may use NFP to avoid children temporarliy, until the reasons are resolved.

If you think of a child as an accident or a mistake, that is the contraceptive mindset.

Pax Christi
Or forever, if the reasons are never resolved.
If you call it contraceptive mindset, fine that’s what it is. Nevertheless it’s approved by the Church with the right reasons **and it does not have to be temporarily, could be forever. **

It seems NFP can be abused only if there are no sufficient reasons. Who is going to judge that? It’s between married couple and God.
You are correct. It can be forever.

In fact, there is not an approved list, from the Church. It is between God and the couple.
 
Or forever, if the reasons are never resolved.

You are correct. It can be forever.

In fact, there is not an approved list, from the Church. It is between God and the couple.
Just like all matter of judgement are between individuals and God. So if a couple deliberately avoids children for the wrong reasons, they risk their salvation.

We’re called to bring as many souls as possible (starting with our own) to heaven. Being concerned about someone else’s spiritual wellbeing doesn’t make you judgmental…it makes you Catholic.

Pax
 
Just like all matter of judgement are between individuals and God. **So if a couple deliberately avoids children for the wrong reasons, they risk their salvation. **

We’re called to bring as many souls as possible (starting with our own) to heaven. Being concerned about someone else’s spiritual wellbeing doesn’t make you judgmental…it makes you Catholic.

Pax
Maybe or maybe not. Who knows what is wrong and what’s not in a relationship towards family planning.
Salvation should be discussed in a separate thread though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top