No runaway trolley this time

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scowler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your meaning of ‘murder’ relies on “what can be gained” and mine on “what is being done”.
Do you know the difference between “homicide” and “murder”? Does not seem that you do.
These crazy scenario threads are useless as they don’t really prove anything.
They are not supposed to “prove” anything. They are designed to give people an opportunity to review the “boundaries” of their ethical system. It is not impossible, but next to impossible to encounter any one of them in reality. What are the chances that you are stuck in a “real life lifeboat” dilemma? Pretty much none. But the aim of these outlandish thought experiments is to “nudge” you to re-examine your ethical framework. In a thought experiment everything is “allowed”, except logically impossible scenarios. In all ethics classes the students must solve such questions and they must give reasons for their choices.

For the time being the majority of the responders conform to the horrible answer of Cardinal Newman, whose view is: “It does not matter what happens to other people and long as he stays ‘sinless’…”. He only cares about his own possible “salvation” and does not care what happens to other people. That kind of attitude is what I call true evil. His exact words are: “…for all the many millions on it to die of starvation in extremest agony, as far as temporal affliction goes…” and is continued with “but should commit one single venial sin”. Not even mortal sin! Just a simple venial sin? As opposed to the agonizing starvation of millions? And this guy became “blessed”?
What principle do you appeal to that justifies shooting the infected person?
The same as always. If there would be a way to save all those people, that would be the way to go. But when there is no such option, one must choose the solution with minimum loss of life. It is true that the infected person is “innocent”, but so are all the potential victims, too (however many they might be). Do they deserve to die? Sometimes the circumstances force you to choose between two options, none of which is “moral”. And then what?

The basic conflict is to choose between an “action” and an “inaction”. There is no difference between them.

There is another interesting result that came to light here. The universal condemnation of the “consequentialist” stance. As if the believers would not consider the consequences. 🙂 But their choice is determined by their desire to be “saved”. If God would command any atrocity - or they would believe that God demands any atrocity, they would obey. A perfect example is what was quoted from Cardinal Newman: let anything happen as long as he can “wash his hands”. Pontius Pilatus could not have done any better.
 
Do you know the difference between “homicide” and “murder”? Does not seem that you do.
I would have thought my remark: " it may be quite proper to take the life of the sick person or quite improper" would have made it clear that I do distinguish them. So, the better questions are:
  • Do you read anything put to you?
  • How do you distinguish those homicides which are murder? Let me guess - does it have something to do with consequences?
 
The universal condemnation of the “consequentialist” stance. As if the believers would not consider the consequences.
No - wrong conclusion. The “believers” consider them, but recognise they are not definitive in determining acceptable behaviour. Thus, more than consequences are considered.
 
I would have thought my remark: " it may be quite proper to take the life of the sick person or quite improper" would have made it clear that I do distinguish them. So, the better questions are:
  1. Do you read anything put to you?
  2. How do you distinguish those homicides which are murder? Let me guess - does it have something to do with consequences?
  1. Yes, I read everything. And I think about all the points.
  2. Your guess is incorrect. Murder is an intentional homicide against the law. Justified homicide is not murder, even if it is intentional or even if premeditated. Unintentional homicide is not murder. State sanctioned homicide (execution) is not murder. Killing in a war is not murder (usually). Since the law changes from place to place and from time to time, the same homicide may be murder in certain places and times, or may not be at other places or times. Life is not black and white. Of course this is one of the main reasons that our conversation is not fruitful.
No - wrong conclusion. The “believers” consider them, but recognise they are not definitive in determining acceptable behaviour. Thus, more than consequences are considered.
If that would be the case, we would be much closer in our opinion. But you are wrong. As long as you declare that certain actions are intrinsically evil, you do not consider the “why” (the reason), the outcome (the consequences) and the “how” (the method). I consider everything - not just the consequences.
 
Murder is an intentional homicide against the law.
If right/wrong is decided by the law, why is the discussion had on a Moral Theology forum rather than a Legal Ethics forum or similar?
Of course this is one of the main reasons that our conversation is not fruitful.
Yes, we speak about different things, and in a different language.
 
But you are wrong. As long as you declare that certain actions are intrinsically evil, you do not consider the “why” (the reason), the outcome (the consequences) and the “how” (the method). I consider everything - not just the consequences.
Baloney. Catholic Moral Theology can’t resolve an act as good unless all the sources of morality are good and foreseen Consequences is one of the sources. But a failing in any one font condemns the act, so if I already know the motivation is wrong, or the act is intrinsically evil, then and only then is it true that the Consequences cannot cause the act to be good.
 
If right/wrong is decided by the law, why is the discussion had on a Moral Theology forum rather than a Legal Ethics forum or similar?
This is a glaring example of the miscommunication / misunderstanding on your part. Right and wrong are NOT decided by law, however, the proper terms, like “homicide / murder” ARE decided by the law. And you keep on confusing these terms. Why is that?
Yes, we speak about different things, and in a different language.
Actually we speak about the same things. The trouble is that you use a different vocabulary, where the words you use are twisted to have a different meaning. Case in point: “murder” vs. “homicide”.
Baloney. Catholic Moral Theology can’t resolve an act as good unless all the sources of morality are good and foreseen Consequences is one of the sources. But a failing in any one font condemns the act, so if I already know the motivation is wrong, or the act is intrinsically evil, then and only then is it true that the Consequences cannot cause the act to be good.
That is the point. Which “font” is wrong? The three fonts:
  1. “what” to save people - is good.
  2. “how” the means (homicide) - is neutral.
  3. “why” is pretty obvious - one wishes to save those “innocent” would be victims.
As a matter of fact the three “fonts” must be good OR neutral. In the actual problem at hand, the intent or motivation (saving others) is undeniably good. The means: “homicide” is neutral! There is nothing evil about a “homicide”, no matter how hard you try to make it happen. The “means” would be unacceptable (or “evil”) if there would be another way to save those people. Your other problem is that you confuse the “means” with the “consequences”.
 
This is a glaring example of the miscommunication / misunderstanding on your part.
If it delights you to declare all who disagree with you wrong – feel free.
That is the point. Which “font” is wrong? The three fonts (what, how, why):
Not sure which system utilises those particular fonts - not Catholic Moral Theology. Is it Scowler’s system? 🤣

You’ll need to define the human act sufficiently before that can be answered, and then define the system of morality (or is it ethics) under which the analysis is required. And by the sound of it, you’ll need to brief us on the local law. :roll_eyes:
 
Last edited:
If there would be a way to save all those people, that would be the way to go. But when there is no such option, one must choose the solution with minimum loss of life.
That was the justification some people gave for dropping the atomic bomb on Japan. The argument they gave that it saved lives.
 
If there would be a way to save all those people, that would be the way to go. But when there is no such option, one must choose the solution with minimum loss of life. It is true that the infected person is “innocent”, but so are all the potential victims, too (however many they might be).
In this scenario, the only non-innocent person is the one attempting murder. We can only hope that the infected person prevails in the struggle landing, not a lethal blow, but a blow to the murder’s head that straightens out his twisted mind.
 
Because real life does not conform to our desires. Sometimes there is no “good” solution. You are all very funny (or pathetic) to shy away from true dilemmas, and insist on creating a get-out-of-jail card. Deal with the problem as presented, if you can.
The problem is, though, that you’ve presented a ‘dilemma’ that does have a solution: inform the person of his situation (infected with virus; certain death; certain infection of millions). Allow him to reach the moral decision to sacrifice himself for the good of humanity (“greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends”, remember?).
 
Ender: What principle do you appeal to that justifies shooting the infected person? Scowler: one must choose the solution with minimum loss of life.
I was hoping for something more generic; most of our moral decisions don’t involve the loss of life. Are you arguing in favor of the consequentialist theory?
 
I prefer to deal with real, possible dilemmas. What do I do if I see someone being bullied? What do I do if I see the government coming to lock up Jewish people? These things can and do happen. It is more helpful for me to think about my boundaries in relation to something practical.
 
There is also that promise in Scripture, we will not be tempted to sin in a way where there is no means of escape. Our faith is on the one who made that promise so we can dismiss these sorts of lose/lose scenarios and pray that in every situation we see the way!
 
If it delights you to declare all who disagree with you wrong – feel free.
It does not “delight” me at all to waste time on pointing out the difference between such simple concepts as “murder” and “homicide”.
That was the justification some people gave for dropping the atomic bomb on Japan. The argument they gave that it saved lives.
And even the Japanese accept that it was the best solution. According to the principle of honor and duty (very deeply imbedded in the Japanese culture based partially on the samurai bushido code - where the point of life is to die at the proper instance) one can never surrender. A noble fight to the death was required. The absolute horror of the bombs was needed to change this attitude.

Again, the end itself does not and cannot justify the means. However, the end and the means cannot be evaluated separately. The same end can be achieved via different means. And the same means can lead to different ends.
In this scenario, the only non-innocent person is the one attempting murder. We can only hope that the infected person prevails in the struggle landing, not a lethal blow, but a blow to the murder’s head that straightens out his twisted mind.
I hope that eventually YOU will learn the meaning of the word “murder” and you will see that it is not synonymous with “homicide”. Any hope for that?
The problem is, though, that you’ve presented a ‘dilemma’ that does have a solution: inform the person of his situation (infected with virus; certain death; certain infection of millions). Allow him to reach the moral decision to sacrifice himself for the good of humanity
This would be a good solution IF he knew about the infection (or could be notified about it) and IF he would be willing to perform the self-sacrifice. (And I am ready to differentiate between self-sacrifice and suicide just like the difference between murder and mercy killing. Are you ready to acknowledge the not-so-subtle difference? That would be awesome. 🙂 ) Unfortunately, life does not always present the best solution according to our taste… and then what?

There are two scenarios to be considered (I will simply use “you” instead of “you and/or other persons” for the sake of simplicity):
  1. Someone puts your life in danger, volitionally and/or intentionally. Even according to the church you are entitled to defend your life, even you must resort to lethal force - if there are no other options available.
  2. Someone puts your life in danger, accidentally and/or unintentionally. According to the church, are you now required to “roll over” and die? (Again, no other options available.)
Because that is the crux of the matter, without any of the frills.

Continued below…
 
Last edited:
I was hoping for something more generic; most of our moral decisions don’t involve the loss of life. Are you arguing in favor of the consequentialist theory?
I am not in favor of using labels, which can be misunderstood. My approach is to take all the factors into consideration. The factors of “intent = why”, and the “outcome = the consequences” along with the “means = how”. What do you want to achieve, why do you want to do it, and what means are you going to use? The reason I disagree with the Catholic approach is that it attempts to affix a “moral/immoral” label on these factor on their own, without regarding the whole picture. They use the “intrinsic evil” label on an act, without considering “why” and “how” the act was committed. (And, of course, it uses the label “evil” on acts which come from love and not just do not hurt anyone, but are actively beneficial for all the parties?). With such irrationality how can you expect that the other “evil” labels will be accepted?)
I prefer to deal with real, possible dilemmas.
You are not required to participate.
There is also that promise in Scripture, we will not be tempted to sin in a way where there is no means of escape.
It is not the only part of the Scripture which is incorrect.
 
I hope that eventually YOU will learn the meaning of the word “murder” and you will see that it is not synonymous with “homicide”. Any hope for that?
Listen to Sidney.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
This would be a good solution IF he knew about the infection (or could be notified about it)
So… they’re able to kill him, but not to let him know he’s infected? (This is getting more and more contrived…)
and IF he would be willing to perform the self-sacrifice.
Agreed. That is the moral choice.
(And I am ready to differentiate between self-sacrifice and suicide just like the difference between murder and mercy killing. Are you ready to acknowledge the not-so-subtle difference?
I’m not even saying that he has to kill himself – just put himself out of the way of infecting others.

If he chooses not to, then we can’t just murder him. (Unless, of course, you want to make the claim that, knowing he’s infectious, his proximity to others makes his presence a knowing attempt to infect them. Then you could talk about the morality of stopping that thread.)
 
I am not in favor of using labels, which can be misunderstood. My approach is to take all the factors into consideration. The factors of “intent = why”, and the “outcome = the consequences” along with the “means = how”. What do you want to achieve, why do you want to do it, and what means are you going to use? The reason I disagree with the Catholic approach is that it attempts to affix a “moral/immoral” label on these factor on their own, without regarding the whole picture. They use the “intrinsic evil” label on an act, without considering “why” and “how” the act was committed. (And, of course, it uses the label “evil” on acts which come from love and not just do not hurt anyone, but are actively beneficial for all the parties?). With such irrationality how can you expect that the other “evil” labels will be accepted?)
I’m still looking for the expression of principles that can be applied in determining whether or not I should commit an act. You may disagree with the principles the church has defined, but they are at least well defined, and understandable, even if difficult situations make them difficult to apply. Without a clear expression of your principles it isn’t clear they arise above “it’s OK if I think it’s OK.”
 
I’m assuming that a self-sacrifice where you stay with the infected person, keeping each other company in isolation while waiting out the both of your lives isn’t an option?

If that is not possible, then you have what is essentially the “Batman Scenario” - the reason he doesn’t kill isn’t just because his parents were murdered in front of him, but also because at some point you will need to ask yourself regarding the intentional taking of someone’s life; will it only stop at one? This concept is explored in multiple DC Comics works - such as the Justice League animated series episode(s) “A Better World” as well as the video game Injustice: Gods Among Us. In both cases Superman murders someone one, and he descends down a path which isn’t pretty.

Using that as the framework, I would answer with what some would regard as entirely too idealistic; the end never justifies the means.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top