S
Scowler
Guest
Do you know the difference between “homicide” and “murder”? Does not seem that you do.Your meaning of ‘murder’ relies on “what can be gained” and mine on “what is being done”.
They are not supposed to “prove” anything. They are designed to give people an opportunity to review the “boundaries” of their ethical system. It is not impossible, but next to impossible to encounter any one of them in reality. What are the chances that you are stuck in a “real life lifeboat” dilemma? Pretty much none. But the aim of these outlandish thought experiments is to “nudge” you to re-examine your ethical framework. In a thought experiment everything is “allowed”, except logically impossible scenarios. In all ethics classes the students must solve such questions and they must give reasons for their choices.These crazy scenario threads are useless as they don’t really prove anything.
For the time being the majority of the responders conform to the horrible answer of Cardinal Newman, whose view is: “It does not matter what happens to other people and long as he stays ‘sinless’…”. He only cares about his own possible “salvation” and does not care what happens to other people. That kind of attitude is what I call true evil. His exact words are: “…for all the many millions on it to die of starvation in extremest agony, as far as temporal affliction goes…” and is continued with “but should commit one single venial sin”. Not even mortal sin! Just a simple venial sin? As opposed to the agonizing starvation of millions? And this guy became “blessed”?
The same as always. If there would be a way to save all those people, that would be the way to go. But when there is no such option, one must choose the solution with minimum loss of life. It is true that the infected person is “innocent”, but so are all the potential victims, too (however many they might be). Do they deserve to die? Sometimes the circumstances force you to choose between two options, none of which is “moral”. And then what?What principle do you appeal to that justifies shooting the infected person?
The basic conflict is to choose between an “action” and an “inaction”. There is no difference between them.
There is another interesting result that came to light here. The universal condemnation of the “consequentialist” stance. As if the believers would not consider the consequences.