G
Gorgias
Guest
No. That’s not what I’m attempting to imply.Your wording implies something very strange. It seems that one is allowed to grab a gun, close one’s eyes and hope that the bullet will stop the attacker, but it is not allowed to aim to shoot to kill.
It’s not “squint, point, shoot”. Rather, it’s “shoot with intent to save one’s life”, not “shoot with intent to kill”, that’s morally licit.
So, in this case, the situation you’re contriving doesn’t allow for a reasonable alternative, which would give you the chance to communicate with the person (and let him make a morally licit choice).
Clearly, these are instructors in firearms use, not instructors in Catholic moral theology.Any and all instructors will tell you that if must shoot, shoot to kill and never to “maim”.
The problem I see is that the example is contrived to an extent that it’s unusable.I see no moral problem. If you also see no problem, then we have an agreement.
And I would respond, “you’re required to try and find a way to save your life and not kill the other.” It seems that this is possible in this scenario (but that you want to artificially constrain the problem in order to ask a question you’re dying to ask).I am reluctant to repeat the pointed phraseology of the problem, but here it is: “Are you required to roll over and just die, if there is no ill intent on the part of the other person?”