No runaway trolley this time

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scowler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your wording implies something very strange. It seems that one is allowed to grab a gun, close one’s eyes and hope that the bullet will stop the attacker, but it is not allowed to aim to shoot to kill.
No. That’s not what I’m attempting to imply.

It’s not “squint, point, shoot”. Rather, it’s “shoot with intent to save one’s life”, not “shoot with intent to kill”, that’s morally licit.

So, in this case, the situation you’re contriving doesn’t allow for a reasonable alternative, which would give you the chance to communicate with the person (and let him make a morally licit choice).
Any and all instructors will tell you that if must shoot, shoot to kill and never to “maim”.
Clearly, these are instructors in firearms use, not instructors in Catholic moral theology. 😉
I see no moral problem. If you also see no problem, then we have an agreement.
The problem I see is that the example is contrived to an extent that it’s unusable. 🤷‍♂️
I am reluctant to repeat the pointed phraseology of the problem, but here it is: “Are you required to roll over and just die, if there is no ill intent on the part of the other person?”
And I would respond, “you’re required to try and find a way to save your life and not kill the other.” It seems that this is possible in this scenario (but that you want to artificially constrain the problem in order to ask a question you’re dying to ask). 😉
 
Let me rephrase the question: what part of Aquinas’ comment do you reject?
The quote is fine. You are in the wrong section of the Summa. This is not a case of self-defense.
Am I prohibited from responding to threats that I perceive to be lethal?
No, you certain may and ought to respond as you have a duty to preserve your own life. But you may not murder the person.

How do you morally categorize this person? Simply breathing is an un-willed act and, as such, is absent any moral content. If you claim self-defense then you must project onto him an unjust will without any evidence.
The prenatal infant, however, is destroyed by the action taken to defend the mother. The virus carrier is destroyed by the action taken to defend me. The distinction here is less than obvious.
Restate this post in the active voice and I think you’ll have your answer.
 
It’s not “squint, point, shoot”. Rather, it’s “shoot with intent to save one’s life”, not “shoot with intent to kill”, that’s morally licit.

So, in this case, the situation you’re contriving doesn’t allow for a reasonable alternative, which would give you the chance to communicate with the person (and let him make a morally licit choice).
Unfortunately life does not give a “dayum” about our preferences. I expressly stipulated the far-out, maybe improbable, but still logically possible scenario, where all your evasive options are ruled out. And it is done on purpose, to “force” you to example the boundaries of your ethical system. The intent here is to defend one’s life as surely and as certainly as one can - which happens to be to “shoot to kill”.
Clearly, these are instructors in firearms use, not instructors in Catholic moral theology.
Indeed, since the instructor of firearms is rational, while the “moral” theology is irrational. When using a gun, one must be as certain as possible that the threat is eliminated. It is a well-known fact that many times the gun will be taken away from the hesitating user, and will be used against him.
The problem I see is that the example is contrived to an extent that it’s unusable.
Nonsense. In a hypothetical thought experiment the only excluded scenario is which is logically impossible. And there is nothing impossible about the scenario where the only defense against an accidental, unwanted exposure to deadly harm is also a deadly defense. And that is what you try to avoid.
 
Is it time to introduce the lifeboat story, where you discuss who is entitled to throw whom overboard? I always liked that one.
If you wish to examine it in a new thread, go ahead. But this one deals with a different problem.

For those who need a quick summary, here we deal with a scenario, where one specific person’s mere existence presents a deathly danger (due to the infection) to others. I am careful to avoid the word “deathly threat”, since he does not explicitly threaten anyone. He is innocent of any wrongdoing or malice. If he would know about the danger, he would be willing to avoid contact with others, so as not to infect them. This possibility is ruled out. The possibility of a “deus ex machina” is also ruled out. The basic problem is this: “how far can you go in defending yourself (and/or others) against an unintended but deadly danger”?

There is a good reason for not allowing cheap escapes from this problem. True moral dilemmas are supposed to go for the “jugular”, to force people to confront the boundaries or frontiers of their ethical system. Of course this is the reason that most or the responders try to “wiggle out”, and complain that there is no easy solution. By their desperate attempts to avoid the problem they prove that their ethical system has very serious problems in it, which they are unwilling to face. Unfortunately in real life “guano happens” and frequently there is no easy way out.

Yet, there is a simple solution. There is no real difference between being intentionally and/or accidentally exposed to some deadly danger. A deadly danger is a deadly danger, and one should be “allowed” to use any necessary steps to avoid it.
 
Unfortunately life does not give a “dayum” about our preferences.
Fortunately, God does. 😉
I expressly stipulated the far-out, maybe improbable, but still logically possible scenario, where all your evasive options are ruled out.
“Logically possible”? No. “Realistically implausible”? Yes. 🤷‍♂️
And it is done on purpose, to “force” you to example the boundaries of your ethical system.
Yeah, I get it. And my response is that your ‘dilemma’ doesn’t approach those boundaries. Try again. 😉
The intent here is to defend one’s life as surely and as certainly as one can - which happens to be to “shoot to kill”.
Cool. If you’re asking whether “shoot to kill” is moral, the answer is easy: No.
Indeed, since the instructor of firearms is rational, while the “moral” theology is irrational.
LOL!

OK… now I know where you’re coming from. Catholic theology is “irrational”. Thanks for playing… please come again. :roll_eyes:
And there is nothing impossible about the scenario where the only defense against an accidental, unwanted exposure to deadly harm is also a deadly defense.
Yet, you haven’t provided an example of this scenario. That’s the only thing we’re railing about. So… try again. Maybe you’ll do better next time. 🤷‍♂️
 
The quote is fine. You are in the wrong section of the Summa. This is not a case of self-defense.
True, this is not a case of self defense, but the principles are the same because they are both cases of double effect. The act of throwing the switch is not intended to kill the one any more than killing in self defense is directed at killing the attacker. The intent is to save lives (one’s own or the four on the track). “since one’s intention is to save … life, is not unlawful.”
No, you certain may and ought to respond as you have a duty to preserve your own life. But you may not murder the person.
True again, but I may kill him as a result of my attempt to stop him. Murder goes to intent, and as long as my intent is self preservation my action is valid.
If you claim self-defense then you must project onto him an unjust will without any evidence.
I have granted that his threat is entirely unintended, that doesn’t make the threat any less lethal. You said above I have a right to defend my own life, does that right not extend to unintended threats?
 
True, this is not a case of self defense, but the principles are the same because they are both cases of double effect. The act of throwing the switch is not intended to kill the one any more than killing in self defense is directed at killing the attacker. The intent is to save lives (one’s own or the four on the track). “since one’s intention is to save … life, is not unlawful.”
There are three fonts to be examined and all must be good to determine a moral act. Intent is just one font and I agree, the intent is good. The other two, not so much.

The object – direct killing of an innocent person – is precisely the definition of murder, an intrinsically evil act. Game over, so to speak.
True again, but I may kill him as a result of my attempt to stop him. Murder goes to intent, and as long as my intent is self preservation my action is valid.
Stop him from what, being? One may with proper authority use force to confine him but not the violence to kill him. The docs who went to Africa to contain Ebola took masks, gloves and gowns, not guns.

With proper authority, one may quarantine one with infectious diseases but not murder him. If the person resists lawful quarantine (and becomes an unjust aggressor) then force including, if necessary, lethal force may be permitted.
I have granted that his threat is entirely unintended, that doesn’t make the threat any less lethal. You said above I have a right to defend my own life, does that right not extend to unintended threats?
If the threat is unintended then we presume the person is non-violent.

His being is an unintended physical threat as the existence of earthquakes and hurricanes are unintended physical threats (but only to our temporal lives). So add one more physical threat to your list.

If, as materialist and atheists believe, our temporal life is the greatest good then we would order our acts to that end and, perhaps justify killing this person. But Catholics believe God is the greatest good and we order our acts to His will which is “Thou shalt not murder.”
 
Fortunately, God does.
But we live here and now, where God does not always provide a desired outcome. Not always? More like never.
And my response is that your ‘dilemma’ doesn’t approach those boundaries.
It is an empty response. Why not provide a solution, which would be “moral” - within the stipulated boundaries. The “excuse” that those constrains can NEVER happen, because there is ALWAYS a “deus ex machina”, a Godly intervention, which allow you to escape the dilemma - unfortunately does not exist.
Yet, you haven’t provided an example of this scenario.
An example is not necessary. The only thing that matters is that it is possible to be exposed to a deadly situation, without anyone intending it. The mere existence of an infected person poses a danger to the life others. This is not a theoretical scenario, it happened over and over again. HIV, Ebola and others.

You need to show that in this case it is ALWAYS possible to have a “good” solution. But, since you are stubborn, let’s create a possible scenario. Your group of explorers encounters a new deadly virus. Everyone is infected, but one of you happens to have a natural immunity. He still carries the virus and passes it on to others. However this is only discovered when the group is already heading home. He is too far away to be reached by a communication method (no cell-phone towers), but not too far to be stopped by a gunshot. (A Lee Enfield has a long range). Your only option to stop him is to shoot.

This is a possible scenario when someone’s mere existence poses a deadly “threat” to others. And you deny the option to save everyone else, just because he is “innocent”. The self-defense principle does not apply because the lack of malice?
His being is an unintended physical threat as the existence of earthquakes and hurricanes are unintended physical threats (but only to our temporal lives). So add one more physical threat to your list.
Unfortunately, we have no defense to thwart an earthquake or a hurricane. But we can defend against an unintentional exposure to a deadly disease. If the only defense is to kill the virus carrier, then that is allowed. And that is the way the cookie crumbles. Case closed.
“Thou shalt not murder.”
If only your would understand the difference between “homicide” and “murder”… 🙂
 
But we live here and now, where God does not always provide a desired outcome. Not always? More like never.
Wait – you talked about “caring”, not “doing my personal bidding”. God does the former, but doesn’t promise the latter. (Well, unless you believe in the perversion of the Gospel message known as the “Prosperity Gospel”, which Joel Osteen will happily take your money in order to hear him tell you that yes, God will give you whatever desired outcome you want, as long as you want it enough… :roll_eyes: )
And my response is that your ‘dilemma’ doesn’t approach those boundaries.
It is an empty response.
No, it’s an honest response. Your scenario doesn’t work in the way you want it to.
Why not provide a solution, which would be “moral” - within the stipulated boundaries.
You’re the one who thinks the boundaries of the Catholic moral system need pushed. So, go ahead… push them! (I’ll keep being honest and telling you the ways in which your examples fail, if they do.)
The “excuse” that those constrains can NEVER happen, because there is ALWAYS a “deus ex machina”, a Godly intervention, which allow you to escape the dilemma
No, that’s not the case at all. We’re not proposing a deus ex machina, nor have any (IIRC) been proposed in this thread.
Yet, you haven’t provided an example of this scenario.
An example is not necessary. The only thing that matters is that it is possible to be exposed to a deadly situation, without anyone intending it.
Fair enough. But then you make the leap of logic to call it “roll over and die” territory. I’ve shown that, in the scenario you propose, that isn’t necessary.
The mere existence of an infected person poses a danger to the life others. This is not a theoretical scenario, it happened over and over again. HIV, Ebola and others.
And yet, we didn’t see armed militia in the streets, taking potshots at the infected victims. Umm… doesn’t that clue you in that your example doesn’t work, because it is neither a necessary nor moral response? 🤔
You need to show that in this case it is ALWAYS possible to have a “good” solution.
No. But (and here’s a classical part of Catholic moral theology, so get ready:) if all you have are immoral choices, you cannot choose one of them simply because it’s the ‘least evil’.
 
40.png
Scowler:
But, since you are stubborn
I prefer “persistent”, thank you very much! 🤣
Your group of explorers encounters a new deadly virus. Everyone is infected, but one of you happens to have a natural immunity. He still carries the virus and passes it on to others. However this is only discovered when the group is already heading home. He is too far away to be reached by a communication method (no cell-phone towers), but not too far to be stopped by a gunshot. (A Lee Enfield has a long range). Your only option to stop him is to shoot.
sigh. In all charity, you’re not very good at this. 😉
ok:
  • the explorers discover the new virus, but the rest of civilization – who are unable to communicate with the explorers – knows that the virus exists and is being carried by the survivor?
  • the survivor knows that everyone else has died from an unknown cause, and yet, nevertheless, is making his way back to civilization, knowing that he may be carrying this virus right smack into society?
So, here’s the thing: this example, too, fails… on two counts: you were trying to create a victim unaware of his plight (so that he’d be innocent when he approaches civilization), but this victim both knows and still approaches society. (Strike one). And, society (who, so that you can get around the claim that they can’t warn the victim of his infection) can’t possibly have been made aware that the survivor is a carrier, but yet, wants to shoot him on sight. (Strike two.) (And you say that we Catholics are irrational? (Strike three. You’re out.))
“Thou shalt not murder.”
If only your would understand the difference between “homicide” and “murder”… 🙂
Actually, we’re kinda hoping you would eventually understand it yourself. So far, no luck. 🤷‍♂️
 
The mere existence of an infected person poses a danger to the life others. This is not a theoretical scenario, it happened over and over again. HIV, Ebola and others.
I’d suggest reading some first person accounts of highly infections diseases, “The Hot Zone” comes to mind. The established scientific protocol is to isolate an infectious person and to treat them with the best medical care available at that time and place. In the developing world sometimes the best is a mat on the ground and sips of cold water, in other places it is the isolation ward of a cutting edge medical facility.

Taking them out and killing them is a good plot device in movies, but, in real life it does not work that way. People are by nature compassionate creatures.
 
Unfortunately, we have no defense to thwart an earthquake or a hurricane. But we can defend against an unintentional exposure to a deadly disease.
This sub-category of “Apologetics” is “Moral Theology” so the issue is not can we but may we.
If only your would understand the difference between “homicide” and “murder” …
If I catch this virus and you show up to “defend” yourself then I may kill you. That would be a homicide. If you kill me then that would be murder. Get it?
 
If I catch this virus and you show up to “defend” yourself then I may kill you. That would be a homicide. If you kill me then that would be murder. Get it?
Scowler must reject murder as we define it, because to do otherwise would be to acknowledge an intrinsically evil. For him, such cannot exist. Thus, he demotes ‘murder’ to a mere (and arbitrary) legal matter - a homicide contrary to law.
 
But (and here’s a classical part of Catholic moral theology, so get ready:) if all you have are immoral choices, you cannot choose one of them simply because it’s the ‘least evil’.
Except one of the choices is to do nothing. Inaction is also a choice. You simply cannot avoid making a choice. So what will you choose? The “greater evil”? Or simply make a random selection? Or do nothing? Can you point me to some official declaration of catholic morality, which tells you that “if all you have are immoral choices, you cannot choose one of them simply because it’s the ‘least evil’”.

I heard that not all “sins” are equal. Some are more “evil” than others. And from your words it seems that even if “acting” leads to a “lesser” evil, you must stay inactive and cause a much greater “evil” to prevail… Very strange, indeed.
 
Except one of the choices is to do nothing. Inaction is also a choice. You simply cannot avoid making a choice.
Yes. Correct.
So what will you choose? The “greater evil”? Or simply make a random selection? Or do nothing?
If there is no morally licit act, then one cannot simply choose one of the evil options.
Can you point me to some official declaration of catholic morality, which tells you that “if all you have are immoral choices, you cannot choose one of them simply because it’s the ‘least evil’”.
Sure. Here’s a direct quotation from the Catechism of the Catholic Church (paragraph 1753):
A good intention (for example, that of helping one’s neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just. The end does not justify the means. Thus the condemnation of an innocent person cannot be justified as a legitimate means of saving the nation.
Please note that your whole series of attempts at constructing a scenario fit nicely into the last sentence I’ve quoted: “the condemnation of an innocent person cannot be justified as a legitimate means of saving the nation.”
I heard that not all “sins” are equal. Some are more “evil” than others.
Yes. And we are called to avoid all of them, not just the “more naughty” ones.
And from your words it seems that even if “acting” leads to a “lesser” evil, you must stay inactive and cause a much greater “evil” to prevail
The greater evil is not of your making. You cannot commit evil so that good may come of it. From the Letter of St Paul to the Romans (ch3, v8):
And why not say—as we are accused and as some claim we say—that we should do evil that good may come of it? Their penalty is what they deserve.
40.png
Scowler:
… Very strange, indeed.
Only strange if you believe in utilitarianism as a moral guide (which the Catholic Church does not).
 
Last edited:
If there is no morally licit act, then one cannot simply choose one of the evil options.
So what do you choose then?
Yes. And we are called to avoid all of them, not just the “more naughty” ones.
Excellent. How do you choose among the options if all of them are “sinful”? And some of them are more “sinful” than others?
The greater evil is not of your making.
And is that an excuse? I wonder… is Pontius Pilatus one of your saints? Let’s just wash our hands…
 
And is that an excuse? I wonder… is Pontius Pilatus one of your saints? Let’s just wash our hands…
One may not sin - do evil - in order to improve outcomes, unless one subscribes to proportionalism/consequentialism. I don’t presume to know his situation well enough to pontificate on exactly what he should have done, but is it your assertion that no matter what Pilate did, he would have acted immorally? I don’t think so.

Your assertion that one is morally culpable for every bad outcome not stopped is not one Catholics accept. God does draw the line at what we may do, regardless of the situation. As a practical matter, such situations are rarely faced, and mostly only in “not real good” dilemmas.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top