No Winter for Europe

  • Thread starter Thread starter nydas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We can argue about it all day but to suggest that pumping tons of crud into the atmosphere has no effect is just silly. As with most things, the answer probably lies in the middle. There are natural cycles that cause temperature changes but we are contributing in some yet to be quantified way, unless the Angels clean the excess carbon molecules out of the atmosphere at regular intervals. (A supporting scripture would be necessary on this one).

Since we cannot survive economically without fouling the atmosphere to some extent, we will continue to rationalize our way through the problem. We are expert at that.
What kind of specific crud are we talking about?

Ya gotta have data. Subjective feelings about crud doesn’t do the job.

Carbon Dioxide, for example, is absolutely necessary for photosynthesis.

Studies of pollution show sharp declines.

I just happen to have in front of me EPA data from 1970 to 2004:

Carbon monoxide is down: -55.8%

Nitrogen oxides are down: -30.1%

Particulates are down:: -79.5%

Sulfur dioxide is down: - 51.3%

Volatile organic compounds are down: -55.5%

Lead is down: -98.6%

Some German data:

Blood levels of pentachlorophenol: down -95% since 1985

Mercury levels in Herring Gull eggs: down -59% since 1988

There are similar data for Mexico.

I’m sure you could find some “crud” levels that are higher, but in general, across the board pollution levels peaked about 30 years ago and have declined ever since.

(China may be an exception, but they’re not giving up any data.)
 
What kind of specific crud are we talking about?

Ya gotta have data. Subjective feelings about crud doesn’t do the job.

Carbon Dioxide, for example, is absolutely necessary for photosynthesis.

Studies of pollution show sharp declines.

I just happen to have in front of me EPA data from 1970 to 2004:

Carbon monoxide is down: -55.8%

Nitrogen oxides are down: -30.1%

Particulates are down:: -79.5%

Sulfur dioxide is down: - 51.3%

Volatile organic compounds are down: -55.5%

Lead is down: -98.6%

Some German data:

Blood levels of pentachlorophenol: down -95% since 1985

Mercury levels in Herring Gull eggs: down -59% since 1988

There are similar data for Mexico.

I’m sure you could find some “crud” levels that are higher, but in general, across the board pollution levels peaked about 30 years ago and have declined ever since.

(China may be an exception, but they’re not giving up any data.)
Ya gotta have data? Interesting. I just thought that millions of exhaust pipes pumping the products of combustion into the same air we breathe probably was a negative thing. What was I thinking?
 
Cities like Pittsburgh, Pa., Birmingham, Al. and Gary, In. have much cleaner air today than they did in the 1940’s. I have a friend who grew up in Pittsburgh, Pa. and he said the snow used to fall black from the sky.

Should we try not to pollute our planet? Absolutly! Should we give up our cars, factories, modern farms and comfortable homes and go back to living like peole did in say 1700? No way! Can you imagine a city the size of Chicago with horses for transportation? Talk about polution, filth and disease! I’ll take living in today’s world with all it’s problems to anyother time in history.
 
Ya gotta have data? Interesting. I just thought that millions of exhaust pipes pumping the products of combustion into the same air we breathe probably was a negative thing. What was I thinking?
Subjective thoughts about MILLIONS of exhaust pipes isn’t scientific. You need data. Thinking about exhaust pipes doesn’t do it. You need data.

Where is your data?
 
**Copyright © 2006 Earth Policy Institute **
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT:
More than 52,000 Europeans Died from Heat in Summer 2003
Janet Larsen
Following a string of high heat days and meteorologists’ warnings that this summer could be another scorcher, European public health officials and politicians are revisiting the devastating heat wave of 2003. The severely hot weather that withered crops, dried up rivers, and fueled fires that summer took a massive human toll. The full magnitude of this quiet catastrophe still remains largely an untold story, as data revealing the continent-wide scale have only slowly become available in the years since. All in all, more than 52,000 Europeans died from heat in the summer of 2003, making the heat wave one of the deadliest climate-related disasters in Western history.
When you blow smoke up me kilts like that, it tickles.😉

You may note the parts I have bolded – the first is the source. Advocacy groups have been known to make things up, you know.

Second, it’s hotter in the US than in Europe. And we do have people die from heat waves – but usually the numbers are barely in the double-digits. So is it believeable that Europe, where it is cooler, would have such huge numbers?

And in the states, we make a big thing when people die of heat. It’s all over the news. Is it believeable that such huge numbers would go unnoticed?

I suggest the author of that article is a prime nominee for the stuffed bull’s head with the winking eye.😃
 
As I said in a previous post The Earth Policy Institute has a population control agenda. In just 15 minutes I found over 100 references to how children need to be taught that population control is the only way to save the earth. They also have links for teachers on how to teach this and what specifically to say.

Can we say anti-life in the name of environmental policy?
 
news.independent.co.uk/environment/article2062484.ece
Cow ‘emissions’ more damaging to planet than CO2 from cars
By Geoffrey Lean, Environment ditor
Published: 10 December 2006

Meet the world’s top destroyer of the environment. It is not the car, or the air plane, or even George Bush: it is the cow.

A United Nations report has identified the world’s rapidly growing herds of cattle as the greatest threat to the climate, forests and wildlife. And they are blamed for a host of other environmental crimes, from acid rain to the introduction of alien species, from producing deserts to creating dead zone
the oceans, from poisoning rivers and drinking water to destroying coral reefs.
 
Subjective thoughts about MILLIONS of exhaust pipes isn’t scientific. You need data. Thinking about exhaust pipes doesn’t do it. You need data.

Where is your data?
You’re right. I stand here sans data. Uncle.
 
You may note the parts I have bolded – the first is the source. Advocacy groups have been known to make things up, you know.
Google it yourself if you don’t like my source. You won’t find a different answer.
Second, it’s hotter in the US than in Europe. And we do have people die from heat waves – but usually the numbers are barely in the double-digits. So is it believeable that Europe, where it is cooler, would have such huge numbers?
Yes. Firstly we’re not used to it, and secondly we don’t generally have air-conditioning.
And in the states, we make a big thing when people die of heat. It’s all over the news. Is it believeable that such huge numbers would go unnoticed?
It wasn’t unnoticed. It was all over the news here at the time.
I suggest the author of that article is a prime nominee for the stuffed bull’s head with the winking eye.😃
Then feel free to get googling and find a report that gives a vastly different figure.

Mike
 
Google it yourself if you don’t like my source. You won’t find a different answer.

Yes. Firstly we’re not used to it, and secondly we don’t generally have air-conditioning.

It wasn’t unnoticed. It was all over the news here at the time.

Then feel free to get googling and find a report that gives a vastly different figure.

Mike
What I keep finding all traces back to the same source. What does that tell you?😉

Now, I have no doubt that sick and elderly people died – but the same source for numers is highly suspicious.
 
Cow ‘emissions’ more damaging to planet than CO2 from cars

Geoffrey Lean, Environment Editor, The Independant
Meet the world’s top destroyer of the environment. It is not the car, or the plane,or even George Bush: it is the cow.
A United Nations report has identified the world’s rapidly growing herds of cattle as the greatest threat to the climate, forests and wildlife. And they are blamed for a host of other environmental crimes, from acid rain to the introduction of alien species, from producing deserts to creating dead zones in the oceans, from poisoning rivers and drinking water to destroying coral reefs.
The 400-page report by the Food and Agricultural Organisation, entitled Livestock’s Long Shadow, also surveys the damage done by sheep, chickens, pigs and goats. But in almost every case, the world’s 1.5 billion cattle are most to blame. Livestock are responsible for 18 per cent of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming, more than cars, planes and all other forms of transport put together.
 
This one?

eurosurveillance.org/em/v10n07/1007-224.asp

Maybe there’s only one answer because it is the correct one? 🙂

Mike
Methodology
In France, the physician fills in the death certificate and after folding the paper part containing the medical description of the cause of death to make it secret, sends it to the “mairie” (town council) . The town council sends the census information (first name, last name age address ) to the Institut National des Statistiques et Etudes Economiques (INSEE, national insititute of statistics and economics) and the health information to the physician at the Departmental (‘county’) Health Office (Direction Départementale des Affaires Sanitaires et Sociales). The departmental health office checks the cause of death and sends it to INSERM to record national statistics. This process takes several months. During the heat wave, the town councils and the departmental health offices were asked to send their respective death certificates to INSERM and INSEE daily, and to give a daily count to InVS for August and September 2003. Regular cross-checking of the three sources meant that accurate information could be obtained [1].
InVS compared the observed number of deaths from 1 to 15 August 2003 with the average rate for the years 2000, 2001 and 2002, modified by population projections for 2003 (the last census was in 1999) [2]. The INSERM study compared the number of deaths by sex and age from 1 to 20 August 2003 with the mean daily number of deaths observed during July, August and September 2000, 2001 and 2002 [1]. More recently, INSERM produced additional results based on validated mortality data between 1 August and 31 December [3]… The reference used to assess the number of deaths in France for this period was the mortality rate by sex and age observed during the period 2000-2002, modified by an estimation of the evolution of death rates and population size for the period 2000-2003.
Meteo-France (the national meteorological service) produced minimal, maximal and average 24 hour temperatures on the basis of a sample of 180 stations representative of French cities [1].
Two comments – note how the cause of death was determined, and check the bolded section in the quote above.

A good example of how the act of observation affects that which is being observed.😉
 
Absurd as it may sound, I think there is something to consider in the cow fart idea. Think about it.

How much beef do you eat per year? How many cows did that take? Given that a properly functioning modern car no longer makes enough poison to kill you in a sealed up garage (unless it is sealed enough to use up all the oxygen!), it is perhaps not absurd to wonder about the environmental effects of animal farming, manure disposal/distribution, resources required to raise the feed, etc.

I wouldn’t be surprised to see that cows make more impact today than we do. Given how much we eat versus how long they take to grow up, there are probably more cows in America than people! Given how the food supply works, they just might travel as much as we do too! Forget Kyoto, we need Cowyoto! Probably Pigyoto too…
 
Absurd as it may sound, I think there is something to consider in the cow fart idea. Think about it.

How much beef do you eat per year? How many cows did that take? Given that a properly functioning modern car no longer makes enough poison to kill you in a sealed up garage (unless it is sealed enough to use up all the oxygen!), it is perhaps not absurd to wonder about the environmental effects of animal farming, manure disposal/distribution, resources required to raise the feed, etc.

I wouldn’t be surprised to see that cows make more impact today than we do. Given how much we eat versus how long they take to grow up, there are probably more cows in America than people! Given how the food supply works, they just might travel as much as we do too! Forget Kyoto, we need Cowyoto! Probably Pigyoto too…
Two points – first of all, much of the cattle increase is in the third world – are we to destroy the economies of those African and South Americans who depend on cattle?

Secondly, not so long ago, geologically, there were huge herds of bovines covering much of the United States, the buffalo. Before that, there were even larger and more efficient producers of gas – can you imagine an Imperial Mammoth backing up to a cave and letting rip?😃
 
Let’s assume that Europe is getting warmer. What is Europe going to do about the problem? Pointing fingers at America and expecting us to fix Europe’s problem doesn’t count. Let’s say America is not going to do anything, now what does Europe do? I personally am not willing to give up my truck, air conditioned/heated home, what manufacturing jobs America has left or our agriculture so some rich guy can go ski in the Alps. As I said before we should not polute our planet anymore than we have to but I am not willing to go back to the 1700’s life style.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top