Oklahoma Execution Botched

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sooner87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Another difference is that the person who was executed was an actual living person, as opposed to a microscopic-sized embryo that is only visible via specialized medical instruments.
Airplanes carrying Bombs could see human beings on earth as being no bigger than ants.

Parallel? Maybe, maybe not.
 
The methods have come a long way, but are they effective? I reason that they aren’t…
I would imagine that currently-living average citizens are safer from crime, despite the allegedly “ineffective” penal systems, than they were under the far more severe societal rubrics of Aquinian times.

ICXC NIKA.
 
Actually, something like Penal Islands might be proper for serious cases.

Just being in jail, gaol, imprisoned in ways is inhumane. Somewhere you have to draw the line.

Now, I don’t know if I’d want to go that far but I’ve heard people say, if you want to discourage crime, put the gallows out in the village square like in days of old and let people see it. That is scary. Still, it seems every death penalty case I have seen has involved extreme depravity.
If there are going to be executions, by all means let’s do that.

If seeing a live human being transformed into a “dangling heap of clothes” as Dickens put it, is not a deterrent to crime, then deterrence just doesn’t exist.

And it would be no more cruel to the dangling human being than our squeamish modern capital-punishment rubrics are.

ICXC NIKA.
 
Another difference is that the person who was executed was an actual living person, as opposed to a microscopic-sized embryo that is only visible via specialized medical instruments.
The argument that some people are not real people has been used before, sometimes saying that some people are subhuman, sometimes that some are just three-fifths a person. You stand with a notorious crowd.
 
The argument that some people are not real people has been used before, sometimes saying that some people are subhuman, sometimes that some are just three-fifths a person. You stand with a notorious crowd.
I was stating a physiological and scientific fact. What do you have against science?
 
If there are going to be executions, by all means let’s do that.

If seeing a live human being transformed into a “dangling heap of clothes” as Dickens put it, is not a deterrent to crime, then deterrence just doesn’t exist.

And it would be no more cruel to the dangling human being than our squeamish modern capital-punishment rubrics are.

ICXC NIKA.
The continuing need for the death penalty, thru Roman crucifixions, to the hangings of Dicken’s time, to today’s I-will-experiment-with-every-drug-I-don’t-have-until-you’re-dead approach speaks against the death penalty as being a deterrent. Unless I’ve missed something, the states/countries without the DP aren’t overrun with crime compared to those which retain it as a “deterrent”.
 
I was stating a physiological and scientific fact. What do you have against science?
Fact hmm? Is a lentil microscopic-sized? Lentil as in pea? I think not. Pint-sized human or full grown criminal, ALL life belongs to God alone and we had better think long and hard before we interfere with its continuation.
 
The continuing need for the death penalty, thru Roman crucifixions, to the hangings of Dicken’s time, to today’s I-will-experiment-with-every-drug-I-don’t-have-until-you’re-dead approach speaks against the death penalty as being a deterrent. Unless I’ve missed something, the states/countries without the DP aren’t overrun with crime compared to those which retain it as a “deterrent”.
That’s an interesting observation and if we look at Europe, that may well be so. I have no idea how the murder rate is in Saudi Arabia which is famous for their death penalty.

One thing we know, absolute mayhem has been pervasive in parts of Mexico for the past six years and they have no death penalty and gun control as well. Without going into the tangent of the fact that Americans help fuel this war through buying drugs, I can’t help but think if they had a government that could really crack down on crime, we’d see a decline. As it is, the situation is out-of-control.
 
I was stating a physiological and scientific fact. What do you have against science?
I have nothing against science. I too was stating fact. Even Dr. Seuss is more accurate than your post though. Even he knew that “a person’s a person no matter how small.”

Yes, there is a size difference. No, this is not significant, unless you think children and midgets are of less value than adults and tall people.
 
That’s an interesting observation and if we look at Europe, that may well be so. I have no idea how the murder rate is in Saudi Arabia which is famous for their death penalty.

One thing we know, absolute mayhem has been pervasive in parts of Mexico for the past six years and they have no death penalty and gun control as well. Without going into the tangent of the fact that Americans help fuel this war through buying drugs, I can’t help but think if they had a government that could really crack down on crime, we’d see a decline. As it is, the situation is out-of-control.
It’s hard for me to see the death penalty as a solution to Mexico’s drug violence problem when merely by getting involved in the drug trade, participants are risking their lives. Death’s already part of their calculations when they decide to sign up with the drug lords so how would fear of death keep them on the straight and narrow?

I used to hear a similar argument during the “war on terror”: threatening with deadly weapons, the very extremists who had already vowed to die for their cause, was somehow supposed to solve terrorism…go figure.
 
I have nothing against science. I too was stating fact. Even Dr. Seuss is more accurate than your post though. Even he knew that “a person’s a person no matter how small.”

Yes, there is a size difference. No, this is not significant, unless you think children and midgets are of less value than adults and tall people.
That is an oversimplification.

It’s not that one is smaller than the other; it’s a moving, breathing full-bodied human being, versus a clump of cells so deeply hidden within someone else’s body as to seem part of her body.

Yes, both are human and their life should be protected, but most people sympathize more with the fully-embodied human life than with the embryonic phase. To an extent, seeing is believing.

ICXC NIKA.
 
It’s hard for me to see the death penalty as a solution to Mexico’s drug violence problem when merely by getting involved in the drug trade, participants are risking their lives. Death’s already part of their calculations when they decide to sign up with the drug lords so how would fear of death keep them on the straight and narrow?

I used to hear a similar argument during the “war on terror”: threatening with deadly weapons, the very extremists who had already vowed to die for their cause, was somehow supposed to solve terrorism…go figure.
Maybe so, maybe it would not see a decline in the killings however, in this case, the original point addressed per post #68
“Unless I’ve missed something, the states/countries without the DP aren’t overrun with crime compared to those which retain it as a “deterrent”.”
Mexico and in fact, Venezuela who do not have the death penalty either both have a lot of crime.

By the way, if Mexico earnestly wanted to thwart the cartels which would mean ridding the government itself of corruption and really did crack down, I’m sure the violence could be greatly lowered. I stand by my original statement except adding in corruption which seems to be a big part of the problem as well.
 
Another difference is that the person who was executed was an actual living person, as opposed to a microscopic-sized embryo that is only visible via specialized medical instruments.
Truth, beauty and goodness take up no space at all. Are you claiming they are valueless?

Neither are courage, love, loyalty, justice, hope, talent, wisdom, or dignity visible to the naked eye, nor even to “specialized medical instruments.”

What is your point, again?

The more obtrusive in your field of view the more to be valued? :rolleyes:
 
Are you saying things were better that way?
I’m just stating facts.

In times past, a vicious murderer like this would’ve simply been shot on the spot. Nowadays, we spend a fortune (hundreds of thousands to millions) trying a case like this and housing such people until their execution (if ever). Then we argue about how long his execution took. Or we can argue about sticking him in a small cell for the rest of his life void of any pleasures (i.e., mental torture).

I assume you support the latter?
 
I live within sight of Mexico.

They have not had a death penalty in more than two generations, yet the current violent conditions there date back less than a decade.

So it would not seem that the lack of executions foments violent crime.

ICXC NIKA.
 
That is an oversimplification.
If you go back to the first post, size was the issue, not movement or shape, though similar arguments could be made for each of those issues as well. (quadriplegics are less human? Disable and injured that look less human lose humanity based on looks?)

I do think it is very simple and logic cannot favor pro-abortion arguments, unless we want to open up really scary stuff.
 
I live within sight of Mexico.

They have not had a death penalty in more than two generations, yet the current violent conditions there date back less than a decade.

So it would not seem that the lack of executions foments violent crime.

ICXC NIKA.
Did someone say it did?

Please look up the original post quoted #68:
“Unless I’ve missed something, the states/countries without the DP aren’t overrun with crime compared to those which retain it as a “deterrent”.”
Now, if you are saying that Mexico is not overrun with crime compared to those which retain it as a “deterrent”, I disagree with you.
 
Juarez and Tijuana have both lowered their crime greatly with a stronger law and order apparatus, thus, enforcing the law does work. But this is off-topic now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top