Oklahoma Execution Botched

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sooner87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And in the times past you are citing it is just as likely that someone with nothing to do with the crime but happened to be in the area would be strung up on the nearest tree with no due process whatsoever. So yes, I do think we are better off with our current system.
I’m not referring to the innocent, but rather the guilty. We can all bring in the opposite POV to attempt to dismiss the other point of view.

Example: How many people were unjustly imprisoned for decades? Does that mean we should dismiss the system of imprisonment?
 
I’m not referring to the innocent, but rather the guilty. We can all bring in the opposite POV to attempt to dismiss the other point of view.

Example: How many people were unjustly imprisoned for decades? Does that mean we should dismiss the system of imprisonment?
A person that is falsly imprisoned can be let free and even receive some financial compensation. That’s a small consolation but if they are dead, there is no bringing them back. That (death) will sometimes happen natually and it is a tragedy that they died while falsy imprisioned (I’m sure we can all agree with that). If we put them to death unnaturally it is still a tragedy but it’s even worse because they didn’t have to die and would be set free if they were allowed to live.

This is only one reason to oppose the death penalty.
 
The only time an execution is “botched” is when the crook suffers less than the victim.

That is all.
Then what would remain to differentiate the executioners from the executed other than the power of the State? This is not about the criminals or how vicious they are, this is about the rest of society and how viciously we can act and still claim to be law-abiding.
 
Maybe so, maybe it would not see a decline in the killings however, in this case, the original point addressed per post #68

Mexico and in fact, Venezuela who do not have the death penalty either both have a lot of crime.

By the way, if Mexico earnestly wanted to thwart the cartels which would mean ridding the government itself of corruption and really did crack down, I’m sure the violence could be greatly lowered. I stand by my original statement except adding in corruption which seems to be a big part of the problem as well.
For you argument to hold water, it needs to examine capital crimes in places with the DP versus those without it. General statements about crime do not apply, because the DP (theoretically at least) would only act as a deterrent for crimes which carry that penalty. A few statistics might not hurt either.
 
Death Penalty is usually for the most heinous acts, multiple murders, etc.

I empathize with what you say but I also recognize that feeling this way seems a bit like wanting revenge. An eye for an eye. Maybe, I’m undecided about that.
Is it wanting revenge, or wanting justice?
 
I’m not referring to the innocent, but rather the guilty. We can all bring in the opposite POV to attempt to dismiss the other point of view.

Example: How many people were unjustly imprisoned for decades? Does that mean we should dismiss the system of imprisonment?
We can free people that are found to have been wrongly imprisoned. We cannot bring people back to life that were wrongly executed.
 
For you argument to hold water, it needs to examine capital crimes in places with the DP versus those without it. General statements about crime do not apply, because the DP (theoretically at least) would only act as a deterrent for crimes which carry that penalty. A few statistics might not hurt either.
Post #66: forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=11949769&postcount=66
** Unless I’ve missed something, the states/countries without the DP aren’t overrun with crime compared to those which retain it as a “deterrent”. **
You first made this generalized statement on crimes.

Also, since crime statistics seem to largely be available for more developed countries, it is hard to draw comparisons however we have this: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate

Mexico and Venezuela in fact do have a higher “intentional homicide rate” than the USA and both abolished the death penalty.

However, as the article points out, it is difficult to get a cohesive definition of “intentional homicide rate” and it is difficult to get crime stats out of some countries.

Note too, I know Japan and South Korea still have the death penalty as well, in the case of Japan, rarely used but on the books nonetheless. We can look for statistics but I’d wager Japan has a relatively low crime rate.
 
The death penalty = penance.

There are too many murderes, baby rapers, child abusers, and necrophiliacs that are stuffing the prisons. Lest anyone thinks that having such inmates go to prison and be accepting of what is happening to them has another thing coming.
 
We can free people that are found to have been wrongly imprisoned. We cannot bring people back to life that were wrongly executed.
We cannot bring back the victims of murderers either. To often the victim is forgotten. For example, because this murdered lived a few minuted longer than he reputedly should have, the death sentence of a baby-rapist/murder was not carried out.

I am no “pro-death,” but certain people are so violent and such a danger to society that society in some cases feels that it is appropriate to put them to death. In the past, this was common sense. Today, we keep them alive, just put them aside, and hope they don’t get out and kill/rape others.
 
We can free people that are found to have been wrongly imprisoned. We cannot bring people back to life that were wrongly executed.
You also cannot give someone back the time you took from them by wrongful imprisonment. By this logic, we should punish no one.
 
The death penalty = penance.

There are too many murderes, baby rapers, child abusers, and necrophiliacs that are stuffing the prisons. Lest anyone thinks that having such inmates go to prison and be accepting of what is happening to them has another thing coming.
You start off claiming that the “death penalty = penance” (you can’t actually force someone to repent their sins, the correct term would be punishment) and then switch to too many prisoners “stuffing the prisons.” You also list a serious of crimes based on emotional reaction versus crimes that have been found to need the death penalty as a punishment (the oddest one being necrophiliacs). The “kitchen sink” approach doesn’t really provide good support for your argument.
 
You also cannot give someone back the time you took from them by wrongful imprisonment. By this logic, we should punish no one.
Your above would only be correct if lost time (the time an innocent person is unjustly imprisoned) were of equal value to life itself; and if ability to reverse the miscarriage of justice is the same for both.
 
You also cannot give someone back the time you took from them by wrongful imprisonment. By this logic, we should punish no one.
There are few if any on Death Row in America who are not guilty. We have had one prison guard murdered in a local prison last year by a proven killer. Years back, a local 17yo was stuck in a cell with a murderous kook, NIcholas Karabin, who killed at random with the plan to ultimately kill his wife. Since Karabin was kept alive in the slammer, the young man left in a body bag, “convicted” in a “fun” kangaroo court by “Judge” Karabin behind bars. 😦 Rob
 
You start off claiming that the “death penalty = penance” (you can’t actually force someone to repent their sins, the correct term would be punishment) and then switch to too many prisoners “stuffing the prisons.” You also list a serious of crimes based on emotional reaction versus crimes that have been found to need the death penalty as a punishment (the oddest one being necrophiliacs). The “kitchen sink” approach doesn’t really provide good support for your argument.
  • It’s not an argument, it’s the truth.
  • Even if the religious equation is taken out of it, prisons were/still called the penitentiary. It comes from Latin “paenitentia” that means penance because there is a belief that if one is senteneced to a penitentiary, they might actually feel sorry and use the punishment as a form of penance.
  • Emotional reaction? Murder does not merit emotional reaction? The rape of an infant? Maniacs who dig up corpses or make their own, to commit necrophilia are curable?
  • If kitchen sink doesn’t work then employ the “empty wastebasket” by all means. Release them all and see if they recommit.
 
There are few if any on Death Row in America who are not guilty. We have had one prison guard murdered in a local prison last year by a proven killer. Years back, a local 17yo was stuck in a cell with a murderous kook, NIcholas Karabin, who killed at random with the plan to ultimately kill his wife. Since Karabin was kept alive in the slammer, the young man left in a body bag, “convicted” in a “fun” kangaroo court by “Judge” Karabin behind bars. 😦 Rob
Few is not the same as zero, and given the severity of the punishment it needs to be zero.
 
  • It’s not an argument, it’s the truth.
  • Even if the religious equation is taken out of it, prisons were/still called the penitentiary. It comes from Latin “paenitentia” that means penance because there is a belief that if one is senteneced to a penitentiary, they might actually feel sorry and use the punishment as a form of penance.
  • Emotional reaction? Murder does not merit emotional reaction? The rape of an infant? Maniacs who dig up corpses or make their own, to commit necrophilia are curable?
  • If kitchen sink doesn’t work then employ the “empty wastebasket” by all means. Release them all and see if they recommit.
Yes, because the only logic alternative to executing prisoners is to of course release them all.:rolleyes:
 
  • Emotional reaction? Murder does not merit emotional reaction? .
I understand the visceral reaction we have when confronted with these heinous crimes. However, one’s position on this topic does not in anyway diminish the empathy one has for the victim’s and their loved ones.
 
Your above would only be correct if lost time (the time an innocent person is unjustly imprisoned) were of equal value to life itself; and if ability to reverse the miscarriage of justice is the same for both.
No, life is of much greater value. However, the logic remains intact because the argument being used was not that life is of value, but that it cannot be replaced when taken. In this one thing, that neither can be returned once taken, life and time are the same. Neither can be returned once taken. I think this is why this argument does not work well for anyone who is not already against the death penalty.

We should strive to always be sure of the guilty of anyone that is being incarcerated for life, or for a significant length of time.
 
No, life is of much greater value. However, the logic remains intact because the argument being used was not that life is of value, but that it cannot be replaced when taken. In this one thing, that neither can be returned once taken, life and time are the same. Neither can be returned once taken. I think this is why this argument does not work well for anyone who is not already against the death penalty.

We should strive to always be sure of the guilty of anyone that is being incarcerated for life, or for a significant length of time.
I stand corrected. Placing the emphasis on the ability to get back what was taken instead of what was taken creates a poor argument.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top