It just so happens one of my very best martial arts buddies is a former prison guard. Let’s just say being in those high security prisons isn’t exactly those most fun nor safest place to be. Criminals in for life don’t give a damn about anyone’s safety, and if they kill someone else it doesn’t matter since it doesn’t change their effective sentence.
This is actually a good argument against life without parole sentences.
Basically, if there’s no chance of ever getting out, unless the person experiences a religious conversion, there will be little to no incentive to behave well. However, if let’s say the maximum sentence is 20 to 30 years (which is common in Europe), but with the added clause that release has to be authorized by a team of mental health professionals, criminologists and so on, with decisions being made every five years, there is incentive. Basically, if the prisoner has been rehabilitated, with no criminal behavior of any kind within prison walls and no other sign of being in danger of repeating their crime when they get out, he or she will be released when they’re served their minimum time. If not, they’ll have to wait another five years, then five more and so on.
In reality, this sort of sentence works. I have
never heard of murder within prison walls where I live. Not once. It could of course have happened, but if so, it is
extremely rare. Our prisons are also criticized for being “hotel like” (which is a gross overstatement, but oh well) and we spend a lot of money on education in prison. Most Americans would see it as being “soft on crime”. But nevertheless, we have some of the world’s best statistics on rehabilitation - the repeat rate is especially low for murder. Prisoners who recommit murder upon release are virtually unheard of - I haven’t heard about one, single case of that in my life, either.
To an outsider (and to many insiders too, is my impression9, the American system seems to perpetuate crime. Okay, the prisoners (death penalty or not, I think long prison sentences are also being handed down far too often “over there”) may get their “just punishment”, but they’re basically just being groomed for further crime. In the majority of death sentence cases, the prisoner seems to have been in and out of prison for years before finally doing something that warrants the death sentence. Often, it starts in their early teens, with multiple prison stays that just make everything worse.
So yes, in most news reports about someone being executed in the States, I have sympathy for the prisoner. Their life often seems to have been laid out before them since before even reaching adulthood, with few (if any) other options. They are, more often than not, victims. Does that mean they aren’t responsible for their deeds? Absolutely not, there’s always a choice. But it does mean we should be careful with our judgement; I think most of us could have ended up the same way, in different circumstances.
Does that mean I don’t feel sorry for their victims? Obviously not. But I refuse to let the rhetoric about sympathy for the victim prevent me from seeing the prisoner as a human being, or looking for better options to solve crime. It is a false dichotomy; sympathy for one doesn’t exclude sympathy for the other.
Americans should decide whether they want to reduce crime, or stick to 19th-century principles of “justice”. As of now, the policies do nothing but perpetuate crime, on a societal as well as individual level. Changing this would not only reduce the amount of crime, but the amount of crime victims - which I’d think is a better form of sympathy than simply demanding the perpetrator hung, drawn and quartered…