Oklahoma Execution Botched

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sooner87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Murderers, IMHO, have to be treated differently from others. People that have already shown that they will willfully take the lives of others, and in some cases for no reason (such as the baby rapist/murderer was execution was delayed as a result of this “botched” execution) are an imminent threat to others lives. You can’t just forgive and forget. And there are no good choices. ** Some have suggested a life sentence in isolation. This is effectively torture, and is that the right thing to do?**
Even after the AP finally gets around to telling us why Lockett was on Death Row, they (and most other media sources I’ve seen) are really soft-selling Lockett’s criminal record. Here’s his rap sheet. Felonies, armed robberies, a few counts of witness intimidation, four counts of kidnapping, four counts of first-degree rape.
humanevents.com/2014/04/30/botched-execution-takes-40-minutes-to-kill-despicable-murderer-in-oklahoma/

Really looks like Lockett who was executed should not have been allowed back on the streets from prison.
 
I’m aware of that. The victim’s family can discuss that with their attorneys.
As a Catholic, it’s not as simple as leaving the issue up to attorneys. By virtue of the CCC, all Catholics should know this.
The victims of those rightly convicted of capital punishment were deprived of that same opportunity BECAUSE they were murdered. Yet, those awaiting execution are given months and years to “turn to Christ.” Your argument gets stood on its head.
No, it doesn’t. If you’re in favor of the death penalty for the sake of vengeance (which is what seems obvious from your comments), you’re not in favor of the Church’s view of the death penalty. I’m not really interested in defending Her position on the issue, since She really needs no defense, but I’ll simply note that the Church believes in the dignity of the human person. And as I said before, all people have dignity inherently. There is no human being who can be assumed lost. Only God can determine that.
 
The debate between supporters and opponents of the death penalty will stretch on and on, no doubt, but there is a clearer issues to be addressed in this case:

What methods may be used to humanely put a person to death?
Is it necessary to seek out humane methods, or will any method do?
To what lengths is it moral to go in the quest to put certain criminals to death?
What are the moral alternatives if most of the providers of accepted DP methods decide to stop providing? (e.g drug manufacturers, medical/pharmacy professionals etc)

I think the latter question indicates the direction in which the DP debate will eventually be decided. Even pharmacies which make up the drugs are scared off by the negative publicity. I have seen some posters here blaming European laws regarding import of lethal inject drugs, but really, doesn’t every country have the choice of participating or refusing to participate in the application of the DP?
 
The debate between supporters and opponents of the death penalty will stretch on and on, no doubt, but there is a clearer issues to be addressed in this case:

What methods may be used to humanely put a person to death?
Is it necessary to seek out humane methods, or will any method do?
To what lengths is it moral to go in the quest to put certain criminals to death?
What are the moral alternatives if most of the providers of accepted DP methods decide to stop providing? (e.g drug manufacturers, medical/pharmacy professionals etc)

I think the latter question indicates the direction in which the DP debate will eventually be decided. Even pharmacies which make up the drugs are scared off by the negative publicity. I have seen some posters here blaming European laws regarding import of lethal inject drugs, but really, doesn’t every country have the choice of participating or refusing to participate in the application of the DP?
It has been reported that some European chemical users have held back and that has been told of in this thread, not sure if posters have “blamed” the makers.

What can be considered is something like no possibility of parole, cell sizes that are extremely small and solitary confinement. Even cells 4 feet high, 4 feet wide.
 
I’ll pray for his soul, and for an end to capital punishment in the United States. It is immoral and unnecessary. Whatever this man did, and I believe what he did was reprehensible and evil, his life belonged to God - not to the state.
This is one of the best, most concise summaries of why I am against Capital Punishment I have ever read. Thank You
 
As a Catholic, it’s not as simple as leaving the issue up to attorneys. By virtue of the CCC, all Catholics should know this.

No, it doesn’t. If you’re in favor of the death penalty for the sake of vengeance (which is what seems obvious from your comments), you’re not in favor of the Church’s view of the death penalty. I’m not really interested in defending Her position on the issue, since She really needs no defense, but I’ll simply note that the Church believes in the dignity of the human person. And as I said before, all people have dignity inherently. There is no human being who can be assumed lost. Only God can determine that.
If I understand and accept your position, then I would have to accept that all justice is merely vengeance. Is it vengeance to seek recompense for injury or damage done to others? Taking someone’s money ought to be compensated for, but taking their life means nothing?

In actuality, I am NOT in favour of the death penalty and never have been. I have made that point in other threads on capital punishment.

What I have not been convinced by are arguments that oppose capital punishment for weaker reasons than those which exist for it.

The issue is one of expression - expressing compelling reasons to oppose capital punishment that do not come across as essentially an expression of distaste. I.e., “I personally find capital punishment repugnant, therefore it ought not be used.” Sometimes, that distaste masquerades as “mercy” or compassion.

On the other hand, there is a deep seated distrust and lack of love for others, resulting from the state of original sin, that makes us prone to anger and hatred. Sometimes, the faults and trespasses of others and ourselves are scapegoated onto those who commit the worst of deeds as hatred and vengeance. We do have to be morally astute to recognize when this is happening, also.

Human dignity translates to moral dignity - I would resist the urge to enhance the human dignity of those who commit wrong at the expense of the moral dignity of those wronged. Otherwise, there is a tendency to view evil as good and good as evil, or at least confuse the two.

The human person, as an intact human individual, is absolutely worthy of dignity, but at what point of degeneracy is that dignity lost? Are you claiming never? No matter what a person does or makes of themselves, dignity is never lost?

Evil changes human beings into lesser beings - that is the phenomenon of perversion. Redemption means changing degenerated beings into whole beings again. We are powerless to do that to ourselves, hence grace. Yet, God does not act against individuals who determinably choose to be evil. He allows them the dignity of choice. A dignity that means they will bear the burden of their choices, including separation from God.

I am not clear that claiming human dignity can never be surrendered is completely reconcilable with doctrines of the Church. On the other hand, I am not clear that we can ever be in a position to know enough about another human being to make a call about when the humanity of any individual is or has been irretrievably lost, which is why capital punishment is a live issue. It is not settled for me definitively, which is why I tend to the side of being opposed to it, but not so rigorously that I cannot see the reasons for it. I suspect this is why the Church has not definitively ruled it out.

I would suggest you not jump to conclusions about other posters merely because they raise contentious - to your liking - points.
 
As a Catholic, it’s not as simple as leaving the issue up to attorneys. By virtue of the CCC, all Catholics should know this.
You are free to insert yourself into the situation if you so choose. Call the family, call the attorneys, etc. If you don’t, then you are doing the same exact thing as me: leaving the situation up to the family, attorneys, and the legal system.
No, it doesn’t. If you’re in favor of the death penalty for the sake of vengeance (which is what seems obvious from your comments), you’re not in favor of the Church’s view of the death penalty.
Though this was not directed at me, I am not in favor of revenge or vengeance. I am in favor of protecting the innocent. The majority of the population not only can’t protect themselves, but take actions detrimental to their safety.
 
If I understand and accept your position, then I would have to accept that all justice is merely vengeance.
It’s not “put criminals to death or set them free.” Justice can also be found via imprisonment.
What I have not been convinced by are arguments that oppose capital punishment for weaker reasons than those which exist for it.
Oh, dear. Here are three excellent reasons to abandon the death penalty: 1) wrongful executions, 2) the application of the death penalty unfairly along racial lines, and 3) the failure of the death penalty to act as a deterrent to criminals. I don’t know what kinds of conversations you’ve been having here but I haven’t heard one claim in favor of widespread use of the death penalty (aka more than what the Church permits) that’s reasonable and logically acceptable.
The issue is one of expression - expressing compelling reasons to oppose capital punishment that do not come across as essentially an expression of distaste. I.e., “I personally find capital punishment repugnant, therefore it ought not be used.” Sometimes, that distaste masquerades as “mercy” or compassion.
Well, rest easy. As noted above, it’s a bit more complex than that.
Human dignity translates to moral dignity - I would resist the urge to enhance the human dignity of those who commit wrong at the expense of the moral dignity of those wronged. Otherwise, there is a tendency to view evil as good and good as evil, or at least confuse the two.
The human dignity of the criminal isn’t being “enhanced.” It’s being noted.
The human person, as an intact human individual, is absolutely worthy of dignity, but at what point of degeneracy is that dignity lost? Are you claiming never? No matter what a person does or makes of themselves, dignity is never lost?
See this: vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a5.htm
I would suggest you not jump to conclusions about other posters merely because they raise contentious - to your liking - points.
:ehh:
I am in favor of protecting the innocent. The majority of the population not only can’t protect themselves, but take actions detrimental to their safety.
The Church limits the use of the death penalty to those instances when imprisonment will not safeguard the community. And as It notes, “Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself - the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity ‘are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.’” You’re claiming that the Church’s assessment of modern imprisonment is incorrect?
 
The Church limits the use of the death penalty to those instances when imprisonment will not safeguard the community. And as It notes, “Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself - the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity ‘are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.’” You’re claiming that the Church’s assessment of modern imprisonment is incorrect?
Are you claiming that modern imprisonment is 100% foolproof? Does the Church claim that, and if so, cite the source.
 
Do murderers escape prison and murder again?

The answer is of course yes.
 
Didn’t this man shoot a 19 year old woman and bury her alive imagine how she felt as she slowly suffocated he even confesses that he heard her screaming and crying sorry I’m going Old Testament and saying
Exodus 21:12-14 12"Anyone who strikes a man and kills him shall surely be put to death. 13 However, if he not do it intentionally, but God lets it happen, he is to flee to a place I will designate. 14 But if a man schemes and kills another man deliberately, take him away from my altar and put him to death.

Here’s a video of his confession and some details of his crime

I know as catholics we should be against capital punishment but imagine if this girl was your child he buried alive would you feel sympathy for him he suffered maybe 30 minutes of a heart attack this girl suffered much more. Even his own mother shouldn’t feel sympathy she should feel immense shame for what her son did
God forgive me for being uncharitable and not having sympathy
 
Oh, dear. Here are three excellent reasons to abandon the death penalty: 1) wrongful executions, 2) the application of the death penalty unfairly along racial lines, and 3) the failure of the death penalty to act as a deterrent to criminals. I don’t know what kinds of conversations you’ve been having here but I haven’t heard one claim in favor of widespread use of the death penalty (aka more than what the Church permits) that’s reasonable and logically acceptable.
None of these are actual arguments against imposition of the death penalty in cases such as Lockett’s.
  1. Improve due process so that certainty exists before imposition of capital punishment.
  2. Change the judicial system so that unfairness is eliminated.
  3. Deterrence is not the main reason for imposition of the death penalty. Neither is the penalty without deterrent value.
Like I said the arguments opposing the death penalty are weak.
Well, rest easy. As noted above, it’s a bit more complex than that.
It isn’t complex for the reasons you have noted.
The human dignity of the criminal isn’t being “enhanced.” It’s being noted.
Imposition of a just penalty does not, in itself, reduce human dignity. The humanity of the person committing the act was reduced by their own action - they acted inhumanly towards another person.

If I am fined for speeding, I do not unjustly suffer an indignity. I am justly penalized for a wrong done. The question is whether capital punishment is an appropriate and just consequence for the commission of a heinous act.

Are you claiming that a sentence of capital punishment in Lockett’s case was unjust and did not fit the crime?
The Church limits the use of the death penalty to those instances when imprisonment will not safeguard the community. And as It notes, “Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself - the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity ‘are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.’” You’re claiming that the Church’s assessment of modern imprisonment is incorrect?
This is the Church’s considered judgement on the issue, it is not the final word. It isn’t incorrect. It is a compelling argument, but it isn’t a doctrine of the Church. There exist compelling arguments on the other side of the issue and the Church does recognize those, as well.
 
The crime was committed in 2000.
He was on death row for 13 years, almost as long as the young girl was old that he killed.
He knew his sentence; his wasn’t surprise death.
I have heard the arguments, against the death penalty, so as to give the person time to repent.
He had time.
I have heard arguments, and the Church’s teaching, about life imprisonment for those who are not a threat to society.
He remained defiant and had to be tased in the end.
He refused to see his lawyer or anyone.
Society also includes our prison guards and other prisoners. Was he a threat to them?
Also, I am hoping the Church will further speak about what to do when it isn’t financially feasible to keep people for life - further upping of taxes to cover costs.

I am hoping and praying in those last moments he did turn to Christ and ask for mercy and forgiveness. That is my prayer.
I don’t see that doing away with the death penalty will help in reforming criminals. Some do not want to spend their life in prison. Some go on to criminal activities behind bar - and what do they have to loose?

If I include the prison guards and other prisoners as part of our society, it is hard for me to believe in this case he wasn’t further threat to them. It was just a matter of time as he had already been making weapons from objects he had.

I am focusing on praying for the family and his soul.

If we do away with the death penalty, would that mean that the guards would treat max security inmates differently - shoot to kill - in self-defense?
 
If I include the prison guards and other prisoners as part of our society, it is hard for me to believe in this case he wasn’t further threat to them. It was just a matter of time as he had already been making weapons from objects he had.
It just so happens one of my very best martial arts buddies is a former prison guard. Let’s just say being in those high security prisons isn’t exactly those most fun nor safest place to be. Criminals in for life don’t give a damn about anyone’s safety, and if they kill someone else it doesn’t matter since it doesn’t change their effective sentence.
 
It just so happens one of my very best martial arts buddies is a former prison guard. Let’s just say being in those high security prisons isn’t exactly those most fun nor safest place to be. Criminals in for life don’t give a damn about anyone’s safety, and if they kill someone else it doesn’t matter since it doesn’t change their effective sentence.
Yes.
I do worry about our prison guards who are in a position like that and the effect it has on them. I view it similarly as those going to war in that some are not sure if this will be there last day or not because of who they are dealing with. Doing away with the death penalty, would they treat the max security prisoners differently? It seems like they might.

If, already in our law/procedures, there is in place a means to appeal, and the person doesn’t want that - remains a threat - then what?
We can not force someone to repent and reform their life.
We can offer and keep offering. Offering prayers on their behalf and looking at other areas that don’t help (children out of wedlock-daddy figure missing) is a way to help in some.

Also, justice is not the same as vengeance.
What he did was unlawful, murder. What he was sentenced to was not a murder but justice carried out for his crimes.

Those are questions that I would like answered, looked in to, before I would vote/push to have the death penalty removed.
 
It just so happens one of my very best martial arts buddies is a former prison guard. Let’s just say being in those high security prisons isn’t exactly those most fun nor safest place to be. Criminals in for life don’t give a damn about anyone’s safety, and if they kill someone else it doesn’t matter since it doesn’t change their effective sentence.
This is actually a good argument against life without parole sentences.

Basically, if there’s no chance of ever getting out, unless the person experiences a religious conversion, there will be little to no incentive to behave well. However, if let’s say the maximum sentence is 20 to 30 years (which is common in Europe), but with the added clause that release has to be authorized by a team of mental health professionals, criminologists and so on, with decisions being made every five years, there is incentive. Basically, if the prisoner has been rehabilitated, with no criminal behavior of any kind within prison walls and no other sign of being in danger of repeating their crime when they get out, he or she will be released when they’re served their minimum time. If not, they’ll have to wait another five years, then five more and so on.

In reality, this sort of sentence works. I have never heard of murder within prison walls where I live. Not once. It could of course have happened, but if so, it is extremely rare. Our prisons are also criticized for being “hotel like” (which is a gross overstatement, but oh well) and we spend a lot of money on education in prison. Most Americans would see it as being “soft on crime”. But nevertheless, we have some of the world’s best statistics on rehabilitation - the repeat rate is especially low for murder. Prisoners who recommit murder upon release are virtually unheard of - I haven’t heard about one, single case of that in my life, either.

To an outsider (and to many insiders too, is my impression9, the American system seems to perpetuate crime. Okay, the prisoners (death penalty or not, I think long prison sentences are also being handed down far too often “over there”) may get their “just punishment”, but they’re basically just being groomed for further crime. In the majority of death sentence cases, the prisoner seems to have been in and out of prison for years before finally doing something that warrants the death sentence. Often, it starts in their early teens, with multiple prison stays that just make everything worse.

So yes, in most news reports about someone being executed in the States, I have sympathy for the prisoner. Their life often seems to have been laid out before them since before even reaching adulthood, with few (if any) other options. They are, more often than not, victims. Does that mean they aren’t responsible for their deeds? Absolutely not, there’s always a choice. But it does mean we should be careful with our judgement; I think most of us could have ended up the same way, in different circumstances.

Does that mean I don’t feel sorry for their victims? Obviously not. But I refuse to let the rhetoric about sympathy for the victim prevent me from seeing the prisoner as a human being, or looking for better options to solve crime. It is a false dichotomy; sympathy for one doesn’t exclude sympathy for the other.

Americans should decide whether they want to reduce crime, or stick to 19th-century principles of “justice”. As of now, the policies do nothing but perpetuate crime, on a societal as well as individual level. Changing this would not only reduce the amount of crime, but the amount of crime victims - which I’d think is a better form of sympathy than simply demanding the perpetrator hung, drawn and quartered…
 
This is actually a good argument against life without parole sentences.

Basically, if there’s no chance of ever getting out, unless the person experiences a religious conversion, there will be little to no incentive to behave well. However, if let’s say the maximum sentence is 20 to 30 years (which is common in Europe), but with the added clause that release has to be authorized by a team of mental health professionals, criminologists and so on, with decisions being made every five years, there is incentive. Basically, if the prisoner has been rehabilitated, with no criminal behavior of any kind within prison walls and no other sign of being in danger of repeating their crime when they get out, he or she will be released when they’re served their minimum time. If not, they’ll have to wait another five years, then five more and so on.

In reality, this sort of sentence works. I have never heard of murder within prison walls where I live. Not once. It could of course have happened, but if so, it is extremely rare. Our prisons are also criticized for being “hotel like” (which is a gross overstatement, but oh well) and we spend a lot of money on education in prison. Most Americans would see it as being “soft on crime”. But nevertheless, we have some of the world’s best statistics on rehabilitation - the repeat rate is especially low for murder. Prisoners who recommit murder upon release are virtually unheard of - I haven’t heard about one, single case of that in my life, either.

To an outsider (and to many insiders too, is my impression9, the American system seems to perpetuate crime. Okay, the prisoners (death penalty or not, I think long prison sentences are also being handed down far too often “over there”) may get their “just punishment”, but they’re basically just being groomed for further crime. In the majority of death sentence cases, the prisoner seems to have been in and out of prison for years before finally doing something that warrants the death sentence. Often, it starts in their early teens, with multiple prison stays that just make everything worse.

So yes, in most news reports about someone being executed in the States, I have sympathy for the prisoner. Their life often seems to have been laid out before them since before even reaching adulthood, with few (if any) other options. They are, more often than not, victims. Does that mean they aren’t responsible for their deeds? Absolutely not, there’s always a choice. But it does mean we should be careful with our judgement; I think most of us could have ended up the same way, in different circumstances.

Does that mean I don’t feel sorry for their victims? Obviously not. But I refuse to let the rhetoric about sympathy for the victim prevent me from seeing the prisoner as a human being, or looking for better options to solve crime. It is a false dichotomy; sympathy for one doesn’t exclude sympathy for the other.

Americans should decide whether they want to reduce crime, or stick to 19th-century principles of “justice”. As of now, the policies do nothing but perpetuate crime, on a societal as well as individual level. Changing this would not only reduce the amount of crime, but the amount of crime victims - which I’d think is a better form of sympathy than simply demanding the perpetrator hung, drawn and quartered…
Correct me if I am wrong, but in the UK, hasn’t it been shown that police are not recording all crimes and also giving out a LOT of warning before an arrest (50 in some cases)?

I am all for looking at better ways of doing this. But I would like accurate information and if in fact what we consider criminals are being caught/something done.
 
And I believe this is a related question.

What makes America different than virtually all developed countries in the world who have done away with Capital Punishment.

What is it about America which, regarding Capital Punishment, in the same catagory as China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, North Korea etc etc.?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top