Oklahoma Execution Botched

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sooner87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
As recent as 2010, a Utah prisoner selected the firing squad as method of execution. The problem is something can go wrong with any form of execution, I’m sure some people have survived hanging.
They have, but not since the modern process involving “drop charts” and neck measurements was instituted in the mid 1800s. This kills instantly by spinal shock.
Also, this topic was covered in another thread, it seems some companies, mainly European may well not be selling the chemicals that make this form of execution happen.
Correct. But again, here in TX they got around such a limitation. No more than an inconvenience to the state.
I don’t know if they can choose method of execution in Oklahoma and whether they have more than one form.
OK allows for use of firing squads in the sole circumstance of lethal injection being ruled out.

Hopefully, they and the other states will give up trying to fine-tune this horror script and just let everybody breathe.

ICXC NIKA
 
Life Imprisonment for those found guilty of murder and other acts punished by the death penalty but make sure there is no possibility of parole and that the prisoners are given minimal living quarters.
I agree with this.
 
Life Imprisonment for those found guilty of murder and other acts punished by the death penalty but make sure there is no possibility of parole and that the prisoners are given minimal living quarters.
No TV, internet, etc, is all that I will add.
 
They have, but not since the modern process involving “drop charts” and neck measurements was instituted in the mid 1800s. This kills instantly by spinal shock.
Unless the calculation was wrong and the rope too short, in which case it would just be like an extra painful short drop hanging.

Or too long, in which case it would kill instantly indeed, but be grisly to watch.

However I do agree, hanging is more reliable and probably less painful than lethal injection. In addition, if hanging is botched, it is generally visible. With lethal injection (especially the triple-drug version), if let’s say the dose of sedative was not high enough, and it weans off after the muscle relaxant sets in but before death is induced, the prisoner might wake up in horrible pain, panic (not being able to breathe, not being able to move), and go through minutes of complete horror until the heart stops. There is good reason to believe this to have happened, but there is no way for the prisoner to signal, or for the pathologist to tell it from autopsy. This is why lethal injection in no way can be seen as humane, except perhaps for the bystanders.

I’m against the death penalty in time of peace on principle, but if the US is to keep executing people, at least they should switch to a method which is quick, less painful and less medicalized than the current circus. Hanging, decapitation, shooting or even the electric chair would be better and more humane alternatives. The only option I see as worse than lethal injection is gas, since that is almost certain to induce panic and a terrible, almost uncontrollable struggle in the victim.
 
Someone else probably quoted the CCC, but here you go:

CCC 2267: "Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself - the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity “are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.”

State sponsored killing is not something I agree with as it exists in the US, for several reasons. The main reasons are the lack of equity and possible mistakes.
  1. Let’s take two towns: one rich, one poor. Two identical horrific crimes are done in each town. However, town A is rich and can afford the expense of convicting their criminal so their DA asks and receives a death penalty verdict from the jury. Town B is poor and cannot afford the expense of the death penalty so they do not ask for it. The inequity is troublesome.
  2. Let’s say the same crime occurs in two towns that are equally wealthy. However, the criminals are not: one is rich and can afford the best attorneys. The other is poor and must rely on the overworked public defender. Which one receives the death penalty and who do you think escapes from it? Again, the potential for inequity is troublesome for me.
  3. Mistakes have occurred. We know this. We killed people for crimes they did not commit. It’s bad enough to take away their freedom, but at least that can be returned. A life cannot.
All this doesn’t include the moral issues regarding how to kill someone. Hanging was bad, the chair was bad, firing squad was awful, and now, we can’t come up with a good concoction to inject into a convicted criminal. Even putting animals down doesn’t always go smoothly and we have much more experience in that field. We should really just give it up.

We do not have the ability to correct for any of these, so our government shouldn’t be in the business of killing, imho.
 
Please let me add, so there is no assumption of hypocrisy, the government should not be in the business of killing anyone: either the unborn or the criminals.
 
We should really just give it up.
Agreed. But the reason I still would “applaud” (wrong word, since the only thing I would truly applaud is abolition, but oh well) a reversal to execution methods other than lethal injection, is that the injection, on top of being inhumane, dulls those watching into believing it’s humane. And therefore, in addition to potentially torturing the prisoner without anyone ever knowing, it lessens the chance of the penalty being abolished.
 
Life Imprisonment for those found guilty of murder and other acts punished by the death penalty but make sure there is no possibility of parole and that the prisoners are given minimal living quarters.
It’s perhaps interesting to note that worldwide, there is a good deal of debate about the punishment of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole as an inhumane practice.
 
Please let me add, so there is no assumption of hypocrisy, the government should not be in the business of killing anyone: either the unborn or the criminals.
The difference between the two is that the unborn are guilty of no crime or transgression. Capital punishment, unlike abortion, can be used justly and morally in certain situations.
 
No TV, internet, etc, is all that I will add.
I agree with this as well.

Those convicted of particularly heinous murder should, in general, simply be housed until their life has come to an end.

I actually don’t mind the duration and vocational training that is given in prisons but I do believe that there isn’t need of so many TV’s, radios, and other luxuries.
 
I oppose the death penalty in all cases. However this guy beat a young woman, shot her twice in the face and buried her alive. I have a hard time working up a lot of sympathy for him.
 
The difference between the two is that the unborn are guilty of no crime or transgression. Capital punishment, unlike abortion, can be used justly and morally in certain situations.
Prisoners on death row have been exonerated before they were executed in the US. God only knows how many times the state has murdered innocent people using the death penalty.
 
Prisoners on death row have been exonerated before they were executed. God only knows how many innocent people have been murdered by the state.
I’m well aware of that and that is one of the reasons I oppose the use of capital punishment. That being said, the use of capital punishment can be moral. Abortion is never moral. Comparing the victims of abortion to criminals facing capital punishment ignores the morality of both issues (abortion and capital punishment).
 
The difference between the two is that the unborn are guilty of no crime or transgression. Capital punishment, unlike abortion, can be used justly and morally in certain situations.
There is certainly a difference between the unborn versus a criminal (except for the aforementioned wrongly accused) but my point was that the government should not be in the business of killing. It’s wrong, regardless of whom they intend to kill. If we can get the government entirely out of the business of killing, we’ll stand taller as a nation.
 
It’s perhaps interesting to note that worldwide, there is a good deal of debate about the punishment of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole as an inhumane practice.
I actually agree that no possibility of parole whatsoever is inhumane and even highly problematic theologically - it denies even the slightest possibility of rehabilitation. I think I remember seeing a theologian pointing out once that it’s easier to defend the death penalty than to defend life without parole.

Obviously I don’t think individuals who would get such a verdict should be let out on the street as a matter of routine, but there should be some way to let them submit themselves to evaluation after a set minimum of years, and then be released if found to no longer be a danger to society.
 
There is certainly a difference between the unborn versus a criminal (except for the aforementioned wrongly accused) but my point was that the government should not be in the business of killing. It’s wrong, regardless of whom they intend to kill. If we can get the government entirely out of the business of killing, we’ll stand taller as a nation.
Well I agree with that.
 
I oppose the death penalty in all cases. However this guy beat a young woman, shot her twice in the face and buried her alive. I have a hard time working up a lot of sympathy for him.
Yeah, that’s pretty foul.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top