Well, let’s take the part about jumping off the cliff. Take a clip from “My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic” second episode of the first season:
youtube.com/watch?v=eqfkgVvHIX0. It does include a pony (Applejack) telling another pony (Twilight Sparkle) to do just that - jump off a cliff. Now, do you agree that it all ended well and, given the circumstances, that was the right and rational thing to do…? If so, do you think that it would become any less rational if Applejack was replaced with God…?