Our climate models are WRONG: Global warming has slowed

  • Thread starter Thread starter CaptFun
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, but you don’t call someone an idiot just because you haven’t grasped her proof.
What proof? Something like that should be able to be calculated mathematically. So where is it? Looks to me like she’s struggling for an idea for some kind of grant.
 
The criticism of Elizabeth Sawian’s article was based on a gross misstatement of her claim, probably intentional. And what you have stated here is that same misunderstanding. So in answer to your question, no, you do not understand her article correctly.
Her premise sounds absurd to me, but if I am misinformed, please enlighten me.

I have no desire or incentive to cling to false concepts.

There are enough fools in this world without using imagination to gin up even more.

IF you can explain what she means please do so.
 
Her premise sounds absurd to me, but if I am misinformed, please enlighten me.

I have no desire or incentive to cling to false concepts.

There are enough fools in this world without using imagination to gin up even more.

IF you can explain what she means please do so.
The idea of man-made climate change is so overblown.

I’m an environmental scientist, and I can tell you that this whole issue is loaded with corruption and scandal all over from academia to the offices of certain politicians. It’s nothing more than an agenda-driven scheme by those who are selfish and want to make a name for themselves.

The reality is that most all the models are wrong.

In fact, a lot of the “solutions” proposed to fight “global warming” are actually unsustainable and making the environment worse off.
 
Her premise sounds absurd to me, but if I am misinformed, please enlighten me.
With pleasure. Here is an image which you can find in a high school biology textbook:

http://images.tutorvista.com/content/ecosystem/ecosystem-energy-flow.jpeg

So, all she’s saying is that 32% of all solar (name removed by moderator)ut into plants is now diverted into feeding humans, i.e. it goes into growing our crops, or grass we use for feeding our livestock. So the rest of the ecosystem must live on the remaing 68%. The implication is that is that if human population incrased 3x, we would basically starve the rest of the (land) ecosystem out of existence, because all plant production would be going into feeding humans, i.e. nothing would be left for wild animals. You can make the same point looking at the amount of planet’s land surface dedicated to farming (currently about 50%), or counting the mass of wild plants and wild animals, versus crops, livestock, and humans. (See explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1338:_Land_Mammals )

W.r.t. the conservative commentary on this… To quote a classic, “You cannot expect someone to understand X, if their job depends on not understanding X in the first place”.
 
W.r.t. the conservative commentary on this… To quote a classic, “You cannot expect someone to understand X, if their job depends on not understanding X in the first place”.
Does that mean all of these politicians and lawyers in places like DC, London, at Western Unis and in the UN who have no experience in research or coursework in advanced thermodynamics have no ground to stand on when they say that we will all be dead and extinct if we don’t go back to the stone age while they hop around on first-class flights and private jets? 😛
 
Does that mean all of these politicians and lawyers in places like DC, London, at Western Unis and in the UN who have no experience in research or coursework in advanced thermodynamics have no ground to stand on when they say that we will all be dead and extinct if we don’t go back to the stone age while they hop around on first-class flights and private jets? 😛
Yes, because it looks like resource depletion will destroy modern civilization before AGW does. The topic of resource depletion is truly anathema in political circles… Probably because there is no group lobbying for it… cassandralegacy.blogspot.com/2014/11/brussels-passing-message-about-resource.html
 
…
So, all she’s saying is that 32% of all solar (name removed by moderator)ut into plants is now diverted into feeding humans, i.e. it goes into growing our crops, or grass we use for feeding our livestock. So the rest of the ecosystem must live on the remaing 68%. The implication is that is that if human population incrased 3x, we would basically starve the rest of the (land) ecosystem out of existence, because all plant production would be going into feeding humans, i.e. nothing would be left for wild animals. You can make the same point looking at the amount of planet’s land surface dedicated to farming (currently about 50%), or counting the mass of wild plants and wild animals, versus crops, livestock, and humans. …
Back in the 1970s, there was an idea going around that at the current rate of human population growth, by year “x” [where “x” is in the future] the mass of people will exceed the mass of the earth. Conclusion: three will be a massive die-off [through some calamity, war famine, etc.] of the human population before “x”. Of course the key is “at the current rate.”
 
That nice little graphic excluded that we are losing the majority of solar energy as heat before the first stage. Through irrigation and better farm practices, we continually capture more of this excluded solar energy into the first stage of the graphic.
With pleasure. Here is an image which you can find in a high school biology textbook:

http://images.tutorvista.com/content/ecosystem/ecosystem-energy-flow.jpeg

So, all she’s saying is that 32% of all solar (name removed by moderator)ut into plants is now diverted into feeding humans, i.e. it goes into growing our crops, or grass we use for feeding our livestock. So the rest of the ecosystem must live on the remaing 68%. The implication is that is that if human population incrased 3x, we would basically starve the rest of the (land) ecosystem out of existence, because all plant production would be going into feeding humans, i.e. nothing would be left for wild animals. You can make the same point looking at the amount of planet’s land surface dedicated to farming (currently about 50%), or counting the mass of wild plants and wild animals, versus crops, livestock, and humans. (See explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1338:_Land_Mammals )

W.r.t. the conservative commentary on this… To quote a classic, “You cannot expect someone to understand X, if their job depends on not understanding X in the first place”.
 
With pleasure. Here is an image which you can find in a high school biology textbook:

http://images.tutorvista.com/content/ecosystem/ecosystem-energy-flow.jpeg

So, all she’s saying is that 32% of all solar (name removed by moderator)ut into plants is now diverted into feeding humans, i.e. it goes into growing our crops, or grass we use for feeding our livestock. So the rest of the ecosystem must live on the remaing 68%. The implication is that is that if human population incrased 3x, we would basically starve the rest of the (land) ecosystem out of existence, because all plant production would be going into feeding humans, i.e. nothing would be left for wild animals. You can make the same point looking at the amount of planet’s land surface dedicated to farming (currently about 50%), or counting the mass of wild plants and wild animals, versus crops, livestock, and humans. (See explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1338:_Land_Mammals )

W.r.t. the conservative commentary on this… To quote a classic, “You cannot expect someone to understand X, if their job depends on not understanding X in the first place”.
But all this presupposes that all the solar energy is being used and we have in effect a static pie model, where if anyone or anything gets more than their share then someone or something else loses their old share which is poppycock.

Most solar energy is simply wasted warming ocean water and bare sand and rock.

There is plenty to spare.

So I guess I didn’t misunderstand her at all, thank you.
 
That nice little graphic excluded that we are losing the majority of solar energy as heat before the first stage. Through irrigation and better farm practices, we continually capture more of this excluded solar energy into the first stage of the graphic.
That would make the percentage of plant energy used by humans even larger than the 32% claimed by Sawian. Her point was not that humans are going to run out of this plant energy source. It was that humans are consuming a disproportionate percentage of what is available, leaving less for life forms that are not immediately part of the supply chain for humans. Followed to its logical conclusion, the advancement you hope for would eventually leave only life forms that are of current economic value to humans. Even if we discount the obligation we have to preserve biodiversity for its own sake, ignoring life forms that do not currently add to the bottom line of Walmart or McDonalds is bad for humans in the long run. For example, recent findings about the medical applications of snake venom would have been impossible if we had made all venomous snakes go extinct. Preserving biodiversity is a hedge against future needs that we have not yet imagined.
 
But all this presupposes that all the solar energy is being used and we have in effect a static pie model, where if anyone or anything gets more than their share then someone or something else loses their old share which is poppycock.

Most solar energy is simply wasted warming ocean water and bare sand and rock.

There is plenty to spare.

So I guess I didn’t misunderstand her at all, thank you.
Sawian’s article has never been about a limited amount of solar energy. The title in the criticism article was misleading to imply that it was. What she does presuppose is that the amount of plants capturing this solar energy is not easily extended. The fact that most of the solar energy is “wasted” heating the oceans is of no use if you can’t turn a major portion of the Pacific into a rain forest.
 
Ah! Rain! I’m watching it softly fall on the nearby hillside (and the blacktop of my parking area). I can almost see the vegetation getting greener. I can smell the air getting “cleaner”.

For the moment my part of California is not part of the globe. 😉

It’s not so warm (or cold really).

I’m happy for the rain.

But I have a feeling that if it continues for a bit … it may ruin the day of those whose present windmill to joust with is the “California Drought”.

nationalreview.com/article/417396/global-warming-guacamole-kevin-d-williamson

^ Thanks FollowChrist for posting these insightful and entertaining articles on the subject in post 9. I repost it to save other readers from having to scroll back. Thereby practicing digital conservation.

😃 - " … savin’ th’ planet - one keystroke at a time!"
 
Top scientists start to examine fiddled global warming figures

My cue for those pieces was the evidence multiplying from across the world that something very odd has been going on with those official surface temperature records, all of which ultimately rely on data compiled by NOAA’s GHCN. Careful analysts have come up with hundreds of examples of how the original data recorded by 3,000-odd weather stations has been “adjusted”, to exaggerate the degree to which the Earth has actually been warming. Figures from earlier decades have repeatedly been adjusted downwards and more recent data adjusted upwards, to show the Earth having warmed much more dramatically than the original data justified.

So strong is the evidence that all this calls for proper investigation that my articles have now brought a heavyweight response. The Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) has enlisted an international team of five distinguished scientists to carry out a full inquiry into just how far these manipulations of the data may have distorted our picture of what is really happening to global temperatures.

The panel is chaired by Terence Kealey, until recently vice-chancellor of the University of Buckingham. His team, all respected experts in their field with many peer-reviewed papers to their name, includes Dr Peter Chylek, a physicist from the National Los Alamos Laboratory; Richard McNider, an emeritus professor who founded the Atmospheric Sciences Programme at the University of Alabama; Professor Roman Mureika from Canada, an expert in identifying errors in statistical methodology; Professor Roger Pielke Sr, a noted climatologist from the University of Colorado, and Professor William van Wijngaarden, a physicist whose many papers on climatology have included studies in the use of “homogenisation” in data records.

telegraph.co.uk/comment/11561629/Top-scientists-start-to-examine-fiddled-global-warming-figures.html
 
If global warming has slowed then perhaps it is because changes that are being made are actually working which would be a very good thing.
 
Top scientists start to examine fiddled global warming figures

My cue for those pieces was the evidence multiplying from across the world that something very odd has been going on with those official surface temperature records, all of which ultimately rely on data compiled by NOAA’s GHCN. Careful analysts have come up with hundreds of examples of how the original data recorded by 3,000-odd weather stations has been “adjusted”, to exaggerate the degree to which the Earth has actually been warming. Figures from earlier decades have repeatedly been adjusted downwards and more recent data adjusted upwards, to show the Earth having warmed much more dramatically than the original data justified.

So strong is the evidence that all this calls for proper investigation that my articles have now brought a heavyweight response. The Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) has enlisted an international team of five distinguished scientists to carry out a full inquiry into just how far these manipulations of the data may have distorted our picture of what is really happening to global temperatures.

The panel is chaired by Terence Kealey, until recently vice-chancellor of the University of Buckingham. His team, all respected experts in their field with many peer-reviewed papers to their name, includes Dr Peter Chylek, a physicist from the National Los Alamos Laboratory; Richard McNider, an emeritus professor who founded the Atmospheric Sciences Programme at the University of Alabama; Professor Roman Mureika from Canada, an expert in identifying errors in statistical methodology; Professor Roger Pielke Sr, a noted climatologist from the University of Colorado, and Professor William van Wijngaarden, a physicist whose many papers on climatology have included studies in the use of “homogenisation” in data records.

telegraph.co.uk/comment/11561629/Top-scientists-start-to-examine-fiddled-global-warming-figures.html
There are those that would have you believe that surface temperature measurements have been adjusted to favor a specific outcome. But the truth is that the temperature measurements have been adjusted to make them more reliable by counteracting known corrupting effects, such as a monitoring station moving from a hill top to a city, or a sensor that is found to be out of calibration. The criteria for these adjustments have been made public. There is nothing “secret” about them. The reasons for these adjustments are above-board. But due to the constant bombardment by those who want a different outcome (i.e. the Heartland Institute and the like), they are re-evaluating these adjustments. I would hold off judgement until that inquiry you mentioned is done.
 
But all this presupposes that all the solar energy is being used and we have in effect a static pie model, where if anyone or anything gets more than their share then someone or something else loses their old share which is poppycock.
I would like to remind you two basic facts:

(a) land surface of the planet is finite
(b) the land currently used for farming was originally biologically active, (i.e. either forest or grassland), not desert

Therefore, yes, the “finite pie model” definitely applies.

Extending the pie requires either converting deserts into arable land/forest, or adding extra capture surface by going up (vertical farming). Problem is, both options are considerably more expensive than simply burning another patch of forest, as clearly demonstrated in the Amazon. So arguing that the pie is extensible in principle does not really invalidate her argument.
 
That’s going in tangent, but I’ve just realized something interesting.

Apparently, plants convert only 1% of incoming solar energy into biomass.

Solar cells, on the other hand, have 15% efficiency (and that’s conservative). So using solar cells to charge an electric car is going to be 15x more efficient than growing corn for bio diesel. (Meaning, solar cells will take 1/15 of the surface needed for corn to power the same number of cars). Actually, solar is probably going to be even more effective, because you have to factor in the energy loss during corn->biodiesel conversion…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top