Our climate models are WRONG: Global warming has slowed

  • Thread starter Thread starter CaptFun
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The solution to that problem will need come from the free market, not the government.
So far, the free market has generated a “solution” in the form of fracking, which is a money-losing operation…
 
That’s going in tangent, but I’ve just realized something interesting.

Apparently, plants convert only 1% of incoming solar energy into biomass.

Solar cells, on the other hand, have 15% efficiency (and that’s conservative). So using solar cells to charge an electric car is going to be 15x more efficient than growing corn for bio diesel. (Meaning, solar cells will take 1/15 of the surface needed for corn to power the same number of cars). Actually, solar is probably going to be even more effective, because you have to factor in the energy loss during corn->biodiesel conversion…
I was thinking the same thing as I wandered through the thread, and it was brought to my attention years ago when I was examining the energy budget for ethanol. If I remember correctly, Brazilian sugarcane was the most efficient at the time due to genetic efficiency differences, longer growing season, and the inclusion of human vs machine processing in the production cycle.

While solar panels do have an apparent higher efficiency, I am not so certain this is a real or significant number in the long view, since solar panels cannot spit out copies of themselves. Solar PV is inexorably tied to fossil fuels because of this. An interesting view on this is in the blog “Do the Math,” in an entry titled “The Energy Trap:”

physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/10/the-energy-trap/

The author makes a compelling case for this dependence, although his political commentary is somewhat stunted in my opinion.
 
Last month, we are told, the world enjoyed “its hottest March since records began in 1880”. This year, according to “US government scientists”, already bids to outrank 2014 as “the hottest ever”. The figures from the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) were based, like all the other three official surface temperature records on which the world’s scientists and politicians rely, on data compiled from a network of weather stations by NOAA’s Global Historical Climate Network (GHCN).

But here there is a puzzle. These temperature records are not the only ones with official status. The other two, Remote Sensing Systems (RSS) and the University of Alabama (UAH), are based on a quite different method of measuring temperature data, by satellites. And these, as they have increasingly done in recent years, give a strikingly different picture. Neither shows last month as anything like the hottest March on record, any more than they showed 2014 as “the hottest year ever”.

telegraph.co.uk/comment/11561629/Top-scientists-start-to-examine-fiddled-global-warming-figures.html
 
What she does presuppose is that the amount of plants capturing this solar energy is not easily extended.
And that is also false as the density of vegetation can easily increase in any environment that can support them. What generally limits the growing is the total environment, not just one aspect such as sunlight as various species of plant can exist on less sunlight than others.

Again, the truth is that there is no pie.
The fact that most of the solar energy is “wasted” heating the oceans is of no use if you can’t turn a major portion of the Pacific into a rain forest.
No but you can put up solar power in deserts and oceans to collect the sun light as energy and any laws based on this woman’s concerns could easily be distorted so as to prevent the use of said deserts and oceans, just as the Wetlands act has been used to imprison some for building duck ponds.

Such abuse of intent by the letter of the law against the spirit behind a law is why the group hugs between scientists and government is so unsettling to many civil libertarians like me.
 
Like in the thread where people are being sentenced to death on the basis of falsified data in labs, it is no longer outside of the realm of possibility that scientists in the lucrative field of environmental studies will ensure that the results that ensure the highest level of funding for them will continue to be produced.
 
Weller,
While some countries may increase food production through deforestation, the US provides a legitimate example of what’s possible. We’ve consistently year over year increased production through technology and improved ag practices. If anything, production farm land is decreasing year over year. So we get more and more food from a decreasing piece of the solar pie.
 
Other than call Elizabeth Sawin an idiot, and claim that Science and Scientific American are infected by left wing propaganda, Alan Caruba did nothing to refute the science in her article.
She deserves to be soundly mocked for writing an article, throwing in a few percentages but completely neglecting to provide a link to the research or even the research paper title.

People here have readily refuted her conclusions as sophomoric and felonious.

As I pointed out the US has steadily grown more and more food using less and less farmland.
 
She deserves to be soundly mocked for writing an article, throwing in a few percentages but completely neglecting to provide a link to the research or even the research paper title.
Let me help you out there:

sciencemag.org/content/294/5551/2549.abstract
People here have readily refuted her conclusions as sophomoric and felonious.
Your opinion. I don’t know how you arrived at it.
As I pointed out the US has steadily grown more and more food using less and less farmland.
That does not refute any of her claims, but I am happy to hear that we are so productive.
 
Let me help you out there:

sciencemag.org/content/294/5551/2549.abstract

Your opinion. I don’t know how you arrived at it.

That does not refute any of her claims, but I am happy to hear that we are so productive.
  1. there is more sunlight reaching this Earth than is being used by any living organism, therefore this is not a limited sum or cut of the pie type of situation.
  2. Areas that grow plants can grow more plants if they get more nitrogen and added fertilization of the soil. Any gardener can tell you that.
  3. Thus there is NOTHING to suggest that if I put up a solar panel on the roof of my house that it deprives some poor plant somewhere else of sunlight.
  4. Therefore she has no case whatsoever and simple intuition would tell you that.
Scientists have gone from humble seekers of Truth, to high priests of What Must be Believed, to now Over Priced Con Artists who specialize in selling Big Brother Government Required to Save us From Ourselves.

Pathetic.
 
  1. there is more sunlight reaching this Earth than is being used by any living organism, therefore this is not a limited sum or cut of the pie type of situation.
  2. Areas that grow plants can grow more plants if they get more nitrogen and added fertilization of the soil. Any gardener can tell you that.
  3. Thus there is NOTHING to suggest that if I put up a solar panel on the roof of my house that it deprives some poor plant somewhere else of sunlight…
The article in Science said nothing about direct uses of solar energy, so I don’t know why you are citing this irrelevant fact… It was specifically and only about the fraction of photosynthesized solar energy that is directed ultimately toward human use. Even if you consider adding previously barren land to human use, that will add to both the numerator and the denominator of the fraction, thus making it even higher. The only way we could actively bring down that fraction would be to develop barren land and then leave it for other life forms to use - like that would ever happen!
 
Let me help you out there:

sciencemag.org/content/294/5551/2549.abstract

Your opinion. I don’t know how you arrived at it.

That does not refute any of her claims, but I am happy to hear that we are so productive.
]Previous global estimates of the human impact on terrestrial photosynthesis products depended heavily on extrapolation from plot-scale measurements. Here, we estimated this impact with the use of recent data, many of which were collected at global and continental scales. Monte Carlo techniques that incorporate known and estimated error in our parameters provided estimates of uncertainty. We estimate that humans appropriate 10 to 55% of terrestrial photosynthesis products. This broad range reflects uncertainty in key parameters and makes it difficult to ascertain whether we are approaching crisis levels in our use of the planet’s resources. Improved estimates will require high-resolution global measures within agricultural lands and tropical forests.

I love the gobbledygook "We estimate that humans appropriate 10 to 55% of terrestrial photosynthesis products. "

Translation We estimate that humans appropriate 10 to 55% of sunlight"

Improved estimates will require high-resolution global measures within agricultural lands and tropical forests.

Translation “I need more money”

And note how precise she is "10 to 55% of terrestrial photosynthesis products " A since deceased friend of mine who was a brilliant mathematician teaching at an Ivy League college had as a hobby writing gobbledygook articles that he submitted to scientific publications. More often than not they got published . I wonder if that is what this is?
 
I love the gobbledygook “We estimate that humans appropriate 10 to 55% of terrestrial photosynthesis products. "
Translation We estimate that humans appropriate 10 to 55% of sunlight”

Improved estimates will require high-resolution global measures within agricultural lands and tropical forests.
Translation “I need more money”

And note how precise she is "10 to 55% of terrestrial photosynthesis products " A since deceased friend of mine who was a brilliant mathematician teaching at an Ivy League college had as a hobby writing gobbledygook articles that he submitted to scientific publications. More often than not they got published . I wonder if that is what this is?
I knew there was no underlying science to discuss when I saw the 10-55% figure in the abstract. 55% is an awfully big number so their assumptions must make for an interesting read.

Since people do hike in the national parks, are they appropriating the sunlight products, etc etc.
 
You are kicking a horse which has died of old age already. The paper you are complaining about in 14 years old, and since, a much more accurate studies have been done. I have posted the link to high resolution maps of human appropriation of plant matter in #25.
 
Weller,
While some countries may increase food production through deforestation, the US provides a legitimate example of what’s possible. We’ve consistently year over year increased production through technology and improved ag practices. If anything, production farm land is decreasing year over year. So we get more and more food from a decreasing piece of the solar pie.
In rich countries, yes. In poor countries, it is just the opposite, because they cannot afford modern pie-extending methods.

http://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/do...primary-productivity/HANPP_Percentage_NPP.jpg
 
You are kicking a horse which has died of old age already. The paper you are complaining about in 14 years old, and since, a much more accurate studies have been done. I have posted the link to high resolution maps of human appropriation of plant matter in #25.
So when my mother told me to eat my vegetables she was destroying the planet?
 
So when my mother told me to eat my vegetables she was destroying the planet?
In a sense. Growing agricultural production means that natural ecosystems are being replaced with artificial ecosystems. Problem is, artificial ecosystems are much less diverse and much less robust.
 
So when my mother told me to eat my vegetables she was destroying the planet?
The underlying message is socialism and equality
  • rich people are taking more than their fair share from poor people
  • humans are taking more than their fair share from other life forms
 
In a sense. Growing agricultural production means that natural ecosystems are being replaced with artificial ecosystems. Problem is, artificial ecosystems are much less diverse and much less robust.
So we need aggressive population control?
 
So we need aggressive population control?
That would have worked 50 years ago, now it’s too late.

Human population will eventually collapse to 0.5 billion or so. The good (?) news is that it will happen by means which the Catholic Church deems morally acceptable, such as nuclear war, famine, and disease.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top