Philadelphia cardinal places 21 priests on leave following abuse allegations

  • Thread starter Thread starter Abyssinia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This makes me feel sick and very very sad!
It makes all priests look bad. I think the Devil was very active in our seminaries in the '70’s. The seminarians I talk to today are upbeat. They are saddened about this, but are confident. Their attitude is the Church has always been under attack and we have to continue our mission to uphold the true teachings of the Church.
 
Are there really record numbers of seminarians in formation, or is it that all the seminaries of the state were merged into one?

There was an article some one posted about record numbers of seminarians here in New England at St. Johns Seminary in Boston. However, it was misleading.

St John’s changed from being the exclusive seminary for the Archdioceses of Boston, to being a central seminary for all of New England.

In other words, all the other seminaries were closed because of the decline of applicants to those seminaries, so, they merely sent the few candidates they had to St. Johns in Boston, which was the real reason for the increase of seminarians there.

Jim
I live in a small archdiocese (by east coast standards) and we have 52 seminarians in formation and our single seminary has been the only one for years so we have to send some seminarians elsewhere. My parish is a suburban one, with one priest and it is far from the largest in our diaconate. We have 70 adults being received into the Church this Easter! There has got to be a renewal happening.
 
I live in a small archdiocese (by east coast standards) and we have 52 seminarians in formation and our single seminary has been the only one for years so we have to send some seminarians elsewhere. My parish is a suburban one, with one priest and it is far from the largest in our diaconate. We have 70 adults being received into the Church this Easter! There has got to be a renewal happening.
Praise God!

Jim
 
I live in a small archdiocese (by east coast standards) and we have 52 seminarians in formation and our single seminary has been the only one for years so we have to send some seminarians elsewhere. My parish is a suburban one, with one priest and it is far from the largest in our diaconate. We have 70 adults being received into the Church this Easter! There has got to be a renewal happening.
That’s awesome. We have 8 being received. That’s the highest we’ve had in my memory (St. Louis is very Catholic, so there aren’t a lot of recruits).
 
Never give up a chance to defend the priesthood! Remember Mt 5:11-12
“Blessed are ye when they shall revile you, and persecute you, and speak all that is evil against you, untruly, for my sake: Be glad and rejoice, for your reward is very great in heaven.”
 
After reading the Grand Jury report I want to puke. Even after the scathing report of the 2005 Grand Jury findings they still left accused priests in contact with kids. That archdiocese is run like a “good ole boys” club and there is obvious disrespect shown for the law and also for their own sex abuse experts at St. John Vianny Hospital who repeatedly warned them that one of the priests was violating his treatment plan.

In my archdiocese we have a record number of seminarians in formation right now. I can only hope that Christ is renewing His Church and He is working to rid it of some of these monsters.
Thank God criminal prosecutors are finally getting involved. We need more of this. Hanging would be too good for any perpetrator or their enablers found guilty.
 
Never give up a chance to defend the priesthood! Remember Mt 5:11-12
“Blessed are ye when they shall revile you, and persecute you, and speak all that is evil against you, untruly, for my sake: Be glad and rejoice, for your reward is very great in heaven.”
Uhm, did you read the report? It describes ongoing criminal activity, officially sanctioned (at least not stopped). That’s very close to an ongoing criminal enterprise.

Disgusting. How the heck can people of my generation (boomers) know this has been going on for decades and the hierarchy not know? OH, they did know because they were complicit.
 
Uhm, did you read the report? It describes ongoing criminal activity, officially sanctioned (at least not stopped). That’s very close to an ongoing criminal enterprise.

Disgusting. How the heck can people of my generation (boomers) know this has been going on for decades and the hierarchy not know? OH, they did know because they were complicit.
I think he was referring to the many good priests who are being tarnished by this great sin.
 
I’m saddened and sickened.

Cardinal Rigali has failed his community. From all accounts both the priests and laity are angry and disappointed. There is a chance that because of ongoing fraud, the statute of limitations will be voided and old cases can be brought to court… Thereby exposing the diocese to further legal and financial jeopardy. What I want to know is who will replace him and how ling before the replacement arrives? The innocent clergy and the laity of Philadelphia deserve better!
 
I’m saddened and sickened.

Cardinal Rigali has failed his community. From all accounts both the priests and laity are angry and disappointed. There is a chance that because of ongoing fraud, the statute of limitations will be voided and old cases can be brought to court… Thereby exposing the diocese to further legal and financial jeopardy. What I want to know is who will replace him and how ling before the replacement arrives? The innocent clergy and the laity of Philadelphia deserve better!
I have given up posting on CAF for Lent, but I felt the need to post since I am from the archdiocese. I have been following this since the beginning. I haven’t had the stomach to read the grand jury report, but I finally buckled down and did it and it just made me sick and angry. This has been the topic of conversation all over my area. We are angry, disgusted and are hurting deeply from this. I know when all of this first came out, so many people I knew stopped going to mass, either for a while or have never gone back. My brother, who had been away from the Church for quite a while, had started going back to mass a few years ago. He still wasn’t strong in his faith although slowly it seemed to be growing, but this new grand jury report has completely turned him off from religion. He wants none of it and has even come to a point where he believes that all religion is just made up. Perhaps it isn’t a good excuse to leave the Church, but how many other people who have been on the fence have been pushed over to the other side because of these heinous, evil acts? That archdiocese is a largely Catholic area. I didn’t even know that Catholics were not well-liked until I moved out of the area and experienced it myself, that’s how much Catholics are a very large part of the population. This has hurt us all.

People in that archdiocese have had their hearts broken, their trust betrayed and their faith shaken. I know mine has been. It is taking all of me to remind myself that these are humans corrupting the Church, not the Church corrupting the humans. But this, compounded with the hypocrisy and cruelty I have experienced from the archdiocese hierarchy towards a few whom I care for, has made it a tough year for me.

These people should have been immediately transferred over to the authorities when it was found out, instead of being transferred around to other parishes and parish schools in which these men had access to children. One of the priests was a teacher at my school when I was attending. Another priest was from my home parish and another was the pastor of my previous parish. I have friends who were abused by priests in this diocese as well. Needless-to-say, this is hitting very close to home for me. In a way, the bigger crime is the fact that these predators were continually moved around even when it was known and even when multiple complaints were made. Msrg. Lynn should be punished at the fullest extent of the law. Although the previous archbishop, Bevilaqua, is suffering from dementia, the truth needs to come out as to whether or not he was in complete compliance with Lynn in regards to allowing these priests to continue on with their duties. Archbishop Rigali should have never made the statement a few years back exonerating both A. Krol and A. Bevilaqua before making sure of doing a more thorough investigation over it. Even when that statement was made in parishes, people walked out of the mass in some churches, some priests refused to read it because they felt it was wrong and insulting to the people of the archdiocese. So, even then, it was considered wrong.

Many people are upset with the current archbishop over the way he has handled it from the beginning… including priests in various parishes. Some have even said it in so many words during their homilies this past Sunday. Our pastor was visibly angry and saddened by it. He apologized for what these men have done to shaken/question our faith, to tarnish the priesthood and to hurt the Church, herself. There are people already calling for him to resign. My heart wants him to resign as well. His actions or lack of action has created wounds and re-opened wounds. I feel so raw right now.

What’s so sad is that there are many good priests, doing their best as men and as priests, but these evil, sick, perverted criminals have hurt the whole of priesthood. I know many people who say that they now have a mistrust of priests even if they are more than likely good, normal people. How horrible is that? It hurts me to know that in the beginning, I was skeptical about it all, but so much of it has been proven to be true. It makes me angry.

I wish to God that the archdiocese would have just been transparent about all of this from the beginning, especially once it all blew up in all of our faces.

Back to my Lenten promise and will no longer post here. Thank you for allowing me to express my conscience and my hurt. And my apologies for my post being so long.
 
I have given up posting on CAF for Lent, but I felt the need to post since I am from the archdiocese. I have been following this since the beginning. I haven’t had the stomach to read the grand jury report, but I finally buckled down and did it and it just made me sick and angry. This has been the topic of conversation all over my area. We are angry, disgusted and are hurting deeply from this. I know when all of this first came out, so many people I knew stopped going to mass, either for a while or have never gone back. My brother, who had been away from the Church for quite a while, had started going back to mass a few years ago. He still wasn’t strong in his faith although slowly it seemed to be growing, but this new grand jury report has completely turned him off from religion. He wants none of it and has even come to a point where he believes that all religion is just made up. Perhaps it isn’t a good excuse to leave the Church, but how many other people who have been on the fence have been pushed over to the other side because of these heinous, evil acts? That archdiocese is a largely Catholic area. I didn’t even know that Catholics were not well-liked until I moved out of the area and experienced it myself, that’s how much Catholics are a very large part of the population. This has hurt us all.

People in that archdiocese have had their hearts broken, their trust betrayed and their faith shaken. I know mine has been. It is taking all of me to remind myself that these are humans corrupting the Church, not the Church corrupting the humans. But this, compounded with the hypocrisy and cruelty I have experienced from the archdiocese hierarchy towards a few whom I care for, has made it a tough year for me.

These people should have been immediately transferred over to the authorities when it was found out, instead of being transferred around to other parishes and parish schools in which these men had access to children. One of the priests was a teacher at my school when I was attending. Another priest was from my home parish and another was the pastor of my previous parish. I have friends who were abused by priests in this diocese as well. Needless-to-say, this is hitting very close to home for me. In a way, the bigger crime is the fact that these predators were continually moved around even when it was known and even when multiple complaints were made. Msrg. Lynn should be punished at the fullest extent of the law. Although the previous archbishop, Bevilaqua, is suffering from dementia, the truth needs to come out as to whether or not he was in complete compliance with Lynn in regards to allowing these priests to continue on with their duties. Archbishop Rigali should have never made the statement a few years back exonerating both A. Krol and A. Bevilaqua before making sure of doing a more thorough investigation over it. Even when that statement was made in parishes, people walked out of the mass in some churches, some priests refused to read it because they felt it was wrong and insulting to the people of the archdiocese. So, even then, it was considered wrong.

Many people are upset with the current archbishop over the way he has handled it from the beginning… including priests in various parishes. Some have even said it in so many words during their homilies this past Sunday. Our pastor was visibly angry and saddened by it. He apologized for what these men have done to shaken/question our faith, to tarnish the priesthood and to hurt the Church, herself. There are people already calling for him to resign. My heart wants him to resign as well. His actions or lack of action has created wounds and re-opened wounds. I feel so raw right now.

What’s so sad is that there are many good priests, doing their best as men and as priests, but these evil, sick, perverted criminals have hurt the whole of priesthood. I know many people who say that they now have a mistrust of priests even if they are more than likely good, normal people. How horrible is that? It hurts me to know that in the beginning, I was skeptical about it all, but so much of it has been proven to be true. It makes me angry.

I wish to God that the archdiocese would have just been transparent about all of this from the beginning, especially once it all blew up in all of our faces.

Back to my Lenten promise and will no longer post here. Thank you for allowing me to express my conscience and my hurt. And my apologies for my post being so long.
God bless you. I used to live in Philadelphia (Swarthmore). I feel your pain.

Cardinal Rigali was our archbishop for a long time. A lot of abuse cases surfaced after he left. Thankfully, Archbishop Burke was transparent about it and allowed these cases to be prosecuted. Archbshp Burke is still vilified around here for his conservative and uncompromising standards. Based on what was on Archbshop Burke’s plate when he got here, he had a huge mess to clean up.

May God bless all our holy men and women. Satan is hard at work on our Church.

Since your Lenten resolution is to not post here, PM me if you want to talk further.
 
I have given up posting on CAF for Lent, but I felt the need to post since I am from the archdiocese. I have been following this since the beginning. I haven’t had the stomach to read the grand jury report, but I finally buckled down and did it and it just made me sick and angry. This has been the topic of conversation all over my area. We are angry, disgusted and are hurting deeply from this. I know when all of this first came out, so many people I knew stopped going to mass, either for a while or have never gone back. My brother, who had been away from the Church for quite a while, had started going back to mass a few years ago. He still wasn’t strong in his faith although slowly it seemed to be growing, but this new grand jury report has completely turned him off from religion. He wants none of it and has even come to a point where he believes that all religion is just made up. Perhaps it isn’t a good excuse to leave the Church, but how many other people who have been on the fence have been pushed over to the other side because of these heinous, evil acts? That archdiocese is a largely Catholic area. I didn’t even know that Catholics were not well-liked until I moved out of the area and experienced it myself, that’s how much Catholics are a very large part of the population. This has hurt us all.

People in that archdiocese have had their hearts broken, their trust betrayed and their faith shaken. I know mine has been. It is taking all of me to remind myself that these are humans corrupting the Church, not the Church corrupting the humans. But this, compounded with the hypocrisy and cruelty I have experienced from the archdiocese hierarchy towards a few whom I care for, has made it a tough year for me.

These people should have been immediately transferred over to the authorities when it was found out, instead of being transferred around to other parishes and parish schools in which these men had access to children. One of the priests was a teacher at my school when I was attending. Another priest was from my home parish and another was the pastor of my previous parish. I have friends who were abused by priests in this diocese as well. Needless-to-say, this is hitting very close to home for me. In a way, the bigger crime is the fact that these predators were continually moved around even when it was known and even when multiple complaints were made. Msrg. Lynn should be punished at the fullest extent of the law. Although the previous archbishop, Bevilaqua, is suffering from dementia, the truth needs to come out as to whether or not he was in complete compliance with Lynn in regards to allowing these priests to continue on with their duties. Archbishop Rigali should have never made the statement a few years back exonerating both A. Krol and A. Bevilaqua before making sure of doing a more thorough investigation over it. Even when that statement was made in parishes, people walked out of the mass in some churches, some priests refused to read it because they felt it was wrong and insulting to the people of the archdiocese. So, even then, it was considered wrong.

Many people are upset with the current archbishop over the way he has handled it from the beginning… including priests in various parishes. Some have even said it in so many words during their homilies this past Sunday. Our pastor was visibly angry and saddened by it. He apologized for what these men have done to shaken/question our faith, to tarnish the priesthood and to hurt the Church, herself. There are people already calling for him to resign. My heart wants him to resign as well. His actions or lack of action has created wounds and re-opened wounds. I feel so raw right now.

What’s so sad is that there are many good priests, doing their best as men and as priests, but these evil, sick, perverted criminals have hurt the whole of priesthood. I know many people who say that they now have a mistrust of priests even if they are more than likely good, normal people. How horrible is that? It hurts me to know that in the beginning, I was skeptical about it all, but so much of it has been proven to be true. It makes me angry.

I wish to God that the archdiocese would have just been transparent about all of this from the beginning, especially once it all blew up in all of our faces.

Back to my Lenten promise and will no longer post here. Thank you for allowing me to express my conscience and my hurt. And my apologies for my post being so long.
I know how you feel. I am from Philly too (although I have only lived here for 7 years). Many parishioners in my church are very upset. I myself am truly horrified. The priest that left our church about 1.5 years ago is one of those put on administrative leave. He was the best priest ever and I respected him very much. Now I am all confused and I hope that the investigation will prove him innocent. On top my husband has been turning away from the church for several years and this has been the last drop. He wants to go to Unitarian church from now on. I don;t blame him. I have my doubts now too…

I think that you will tear me to pieces but still I would like to know your opinion about this. I heard some psychologists talk on the radio about these cases. They proposed that suppressed sexuality can sometimes grow into unhealthy deviations. Isn’t the time right to give priests a choice to marry if they want to? Remember that celibacy does not come from the bible, even St. Peter was married because Bible mentions his mother-in-law. First priests were also not celibate. It seems that these church sex abuse scandals are being revealed in more and more dioces all over the world. Very sad and disturbing.
P.S. I know that this is only loosely associated with the previous topic.
 
I know how you feel. I am from Philly too (although I have only lived here for 7 years). Many parishioners in my church are very upset. I myself am truly horrified. The priest that left our church about 1.5 years ago is one of those put on administrative leave. He was the best priest ever and I respected him very much. Now I am all confused and I hope that the investigation will prove him innocent. On top my husband has been turning away from the church for several years and this has been the last drop. He wants to go to Unitarian church from now on. I don;t blame him. I have my doubts now too…
No sin of man is going to separate me from the Church Jesus established on Earth.
I think that you will tear me to pieces but still I would like to know your opinion about this. I heard some psychologists talk on the radio about these cases. They proposed that suppressed sexuality can sometimes grow into unhealthy deviations. Isn’t the time right to give priests a choice to marry if they want to? Remember that celibacy does not come from the bible, even St. Peter was married because Bible mentions his mother-in-law. First priests were also not celibate. It seems that these church sex abuse scandals are being revealed in more and more dioces all over the world. Very sad and disturbing.
P.S. I know that this is only loosely associated with the previous topic.
Celibacy was actually practiced in the early Church and by some Jewish sects (Essenes) at the time of Jesus. Jesus was celibate and so was Paul. St. Paul recommends being celibate, if possible. Origen castrated himself. St John, the beloved disciple, was celibate.

The Eastern Churches still allow marriage IF you are married before becoming a priest. You cannot get married AFTER being a priest. Remarriage after the death of the wife was not allowed.

In all cases Bishops were to become celibate after becoming Bishop.

The Council of Nicea in 325 urged priests to remain celibate, if married, after ordination.

I wouldn’t believe anything about “repression” of sexual urges causing deviant sexual proclivities. All the priests I know celebrate their celibacy. 🙂
 
Truly frightening.

Communist Infiltration of Catholic Seminaries
Communist infiltration into the Catholic Church
Code:
* June 21st, 2009 9:29 pm ET
“I would recognize such a letter to be valid because it would contain my secret appellation, that is “AA-1025,” “AA” meant “Anti-Apostle.” I was therefore led to think that the number 1025 was my service number. To my great surprise, I had guessed right. Therefore I cried out, ‘1,024 priests or seminarians have entered this career before me’’” (Marie Carré, AA-1025 The Memoirs of an Anti-Apostle [Illinois: Tan Books, 1991], 14).
Bishop Fulton J. Sheen was a powerful combatant against Communist infiltration of the Catholic Church. “Bishop Fulton Sheen, auxiliary bishop of New York while giving a discourse at Saint Suzanna of Rome revealed that in 1936 the American Communists recruited some agents for infiltrating the religious communities to destroy them from within. An Appeal was made for volunteers to become priests and study in the seminaries” (André Mignot, Les Fumees de Satan, p14).
1952, he made the acquaintance of (and converted) Bella Dodd, a teacher and activist for the Communist party. After her defection, she revealed that one of her jobs, as a Communist agent was to encourage young radicals to enter Catholic seminaries. She claims that before she had left the Party in the U.S., she had encouraged almost 1,000 young radicals to infiltrate the seminaries and religious orders:
In the 1930’s, we put eleven hundred men into the priesthood in order to destroy the Church from within. The idea was for these men to be ordained, and then climb the ladder of influence and authority as Monsignors and Bishops” (vny.cuny.edu/gutter/panels/panel19.html).
Brother Joseph Natale, Founder of Most Holy Family Monastery, was present at one of Bella Dodd’s lectures in the early 1950’s. He relates:
I listened to that woman for four hours and she had my hair standing on end. Everything she said has been fulfilled to the letter. You would think she was the world’s greatest prophet, but she was no prophet. She was merely exposing the step-by-step battle plan of Communist subversion of the Catholic Church.
She explained that of all the world’s religions, the Catholic Church was the only one feared by the Communists, for it was its only effective opponent. Back then, she said: “Right now they are in the highest places in the Church.
They are working to bring about change in order that the Catholic Church would not be effective against Communism . . . that these changes would be so drastic that “you will not recognize the Catholic Church.”
The whole idea was to destroy, not the institution of the Church, but rather the Faith of the people, and even use the institution of the Church, if possible, to destroy the Faith through the promotion of a pseudo-religion — something that resembled Catholicism but was not the real thing.
The whole idea was to destroy, not the institution of the Church, but rather the Faith of the people, and even use the institution of the Church, if possible, to destroy the Faith through the promotion of a pseudo-religion — something that resembled Catholicism but was not the real thing.
This would be necessary in order to shame Church leaders into an “openness to the world”, and to a more flexible attitude toward all religions and philosophies. The Communists would then exploit this openness in order to undermine the Church.
Manning Johnson belonged to the Communist party in the 1940s and early 50s, during which time he authored the book Color, Communism and Common Sense. After leaving the Party, he testified in 1953 before the House un-American Activities Committee regarding the Communist Agenda and the Catholic Church:
Once the tactic of infiltration of religious organizations was set by the Kremlin … the Communists discovered that the destruction of religion could proceed much faster through infiltration of the (Catholic) Church by Communists operating within the Church itself. The Communist leadership in the United States realized that the infiltration tactic in this country would have to adapt itself to American conditions (Europe also had its cells) and the religious make-up peculiar to this country. In the earliest stages it was determined that with only small forces available to them, it would be necessary to concentrate Communist agents in the seminaries. The practical conclusion drawn by the Red leaders was that these institutions would make it possible for a small Communist minority to influence the ideology of future clergymen in the paths conducive to Communist purposes This policy of infiltrating seminaries was successful beyond even our communist expectations.
In January of 2007, it was announced by the Polish Roman Catholic Episcopate that it would disclose documents connecting priests and bishops with Poland’s Communist regime. One of those to be investigated was archbishop Stanislaw Wielgus, who admitted his connections with the communist security police after twenty years of spying on fellow clerics and nonconformists. In 2005, Rev. Mieczyslaw Malinski, (a close associate of John Paul II), was also discovered to have worked for the S.B. in the 1980s, along with several other priests.
One cannot help but wonder if the Catholic Church is still in a state of siege—
 
It’s not the Communists that the Church has to fear today!
The Church has nothing to fear. She has been under attack since Nero. The Church today is growing and our seminaries are overflowing with wonderfully holy men. The Church under siege undergoes a renewal, which we are experiencing today.

I think part of the problem is the “condition” that the seminaries fell into under the Communists. They became rectors of the seminaries. Most of the priests accused of these crimes were in seminary in the '60’s, '70’s, and '80’s. I think most of them have been flushed out by now.

I also think that one reason of lot of the abuse cases were “overlooked” is because of the many priests who were falsely accused in Communist countries in order to discredit the Church. In addition, psychiatrists led the Church to believe these people could be “cured.” I still find it hard to believe that a person who wants to change cannot.

I’m truly amazed at the many holy priests who came out of these seminaries in light of all they had to overcome.
 
Cardinal Rigali initially said there were no priests in active ministry “who have an admitted or established allegation of sexual abuse of a minor against them.’’"

The key part of the statement seem to be “admitted or established allegation of sexual abuse of a minor.” Assuming that none of the 21 had admitted to such wrongdoing, the question would be what Cardinal Rigali meant by “established allegation.” Apparently it meant something much more than a “credible allegation.” Whether Cardinal Rigali lied or not, it does not seem that he was willing to protect parishioners from these men, short of a legal finding of guilt – until the matter was publicized, thus embarrassing the archdiocese.

The uproar over the Cardinal’s failure to remove these priests from active ministry previously and his unwillingness to inform parishes of the identity of these priests is a self-inflicted wound. Let’s see how this affects the annual Archdiocesal Appeal.
 
No sin of man is going to separate me from the Church Jesus established on Earth.

Celibacy was actually practiced in the early Church and by some Jewish sects (Essenes) at the time of Jesus. Jesus was celibate and so was Paul. St. Paul recommends being celibate, if possible. Origen castrated himself. St John, the beloved disciple, was celibate.

The Eastern Churches still allow marriage IF you are married before becoming a priest. You cannot get married AFTER being a priest. Remarriage after the death of the wife was not allowed.

In all cases Bishops were to become celibate after becoming Bishop.

The Council of Nicea in 325 urged priests to remain celibate, if married, after ordination.

I wouldn’t believe anything about “repression” of sexual urges causing deviant sexual proclivities. All the priests I know celebrate their celibacy. 🙂
How about Peter and the other disciples? Peter was married and I assume so were many of the disciples. Jesus never said that the leaders of the church should not marry and nor did Paul. He said that it is better not to marry but because we are human beings we have sexual desires it is good to have a spouse.

Why not to open priesthood to marriage? I think that only then the seminaries would really start growing. Protestant pastors marry too. They have kids.

I believe that the reasons for celibate for priests are historical and do not come as an order from Jesus.

The purpose of the council of Nicea was unification of the church under the roman rule with respect to preserve the roman empire. Constantin himself only became a christian on his deathbed.

There might be priests that celebrate their celibacy. That is good. But why doesn’t church give a choice? To have both celibate and married seminarians. It works for protestants. I think that catholic church would be quite enriched to have married priests.

It seems to me that church just likes to preserve its structure as it is such a huge organization. Very little change and very little reform. That actually scares me. The whole scandal about the sex abuse by priests talks volumes of the politics in the church (as it turned out that the highest authorities actually knew about these problems for years and did nothing to help). Seems like an obligation to cover up the mess since the church is supposed to be holy. Why so many sex scandals associated with catholic priests all over the world? Why don’t the authorities just hand in all the accused priests to the police for investigation? If they are innocent they will be cleared. Instead church authorities prefer to wash their dirty laundry “in the house” so that the information is not released to the public.
Hopefully that will change now.

I am just really disappointed in the catholic church since these scandals have a pattern. I ask why bishops/cardinals/church administration did not/does not do much to prevent these terrible crimes? It is their job to protect parishioners and especially children in their diocese!!! I cannot even imagine this would have happened to me. Hard to send a kid to a catholic school now. Too much distrust.

 
How about Peter and the other disciples? Peter was married and I assume so were many of the disciples.** Jesus never said that the leaders of the church should not marry and nor did Paul.** He said that it is better not to marry but because we are human beings we have sexual desires it is good to have a spouse.

Why not to open priesthood to marriage? I think that only then the seminaries would really start growing. Protestant pastors marry too. They have kids.

I believe that the reasons for celibate for priests are historical and do not come as an order from Jesus.
The OP was priestly abuse. Marriage does not cure abusive sexual predators. There are many instances of nonCatholic abuse, they’re just not as high profile as Catholics, either because Catholics priests are held to a higher standard, or the media just wants to crucify Catholics. They have never been successful, nor will they ever be.
The purpose of the council of Nicea was unification of the church under the roman rule with respect to preserve the roman empire. Constantin himself only became a christian on his deathbed.

There might be priests that celebrate their celibacy. That is good. But why doesn’t church give a choice? To have both celibate and married seminarians. It works for protestants. I think that catholic church would be quite enriched to have married priests.
Obviously Catholics are not Protestants. OSAS, Sola Scriptura and Sola Fides work for protestants. They do not work for Catholics.
It seems to me that church just likes to preserve its structure as it is such a huge organization. Very little change and very little reform. That actually scares me. The whole scandal about the sex abuse by priests talks volumes of the politics in the church (as it turned out that the highest authorities actually knew about these problems for years and did nothing to help). Seems like an obligation to cover up the mess since the church is supposed to be holy. Why so many sex scandals associated with catholic priests all over the world? Why don’t the authorities just hand in all the accused priests to the police for investigation? If they are innocent they will be cleared. Instead church authorities prefer to wash their dirty laundry “in the house” so that the information is not released to the public.
Hopefully that will change now.
I am just really disappointed in the catholic church since these scandals have a pattern. I ask why bishops/cardinals/church administration did not/does not do much to prevent these terrible crimes? It is their job to protect parishioners and especially children in their diocese!!! I cannot even imagine this would have happened to me. Hard to send a kid to a catholic school now. Too much distrust.
All good questions. The married priesthood would not solve any of them.

I too am very hurt by the scandals. But now I’m starting to get really angry. Cardinal Rigali made it very personal to me. He was our archbishop for many years. He confirmed some of my nieces and nephews.

These are the people I find really hard to pray for, yet we are asked to love the unlovable.

God Bless.
 
There is a deeply disturbing history and culture in the Church of avoiding scandal at all costs and being prepared to lie to achieve this end. Surely Boston should have taught all the bishops and their administrators that this practice was likely to ‘blow up in their faces’ and deservedly so. Did they really think that they could escape Boston’s fate with so much filth under the archdiocesan carpet? Let’s hope that those who knew and did nothing are made to serve a prison sentence to give them time to consider the need to ‘tell the truth and shame the devil’, at all times.
Let’s also hope that the seminaries are being thoroughly cleansed of those responsible for the admission and ordination of sexual perverts and of the perverts themselves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top