please explain TULIP and then Catholic disagreements

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cr8ton
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m not familar with that word. Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.
The wword obfuscate means to obscure, to confuse.

The CCC teaches , We are to love and serve God in this life so as to be happy with him forever in the next. Carlan
 
I answered your question, now be Christ-like and answer my question. Here’s my question again.
I answered your question the first time, there was no real substantial difference when you asked the second time.

By the way, Christ didn’t answer every question that was asked of Him, so when you say be “Christ-like” (rhetoric though it is), I did just that. 😉

Side note: Who was it that was quoting people, only to change what was in their actual post and answer a completely different question? (You have done this AT LEAST twice in the last 24 hours.) Who was it who ignores an entire post but gives a misdirecting comment about that person’s signature? You. I have observed you dodging/obfuscating what is being asked of you in about half of your posts to some degree or another, so let’s not get hypocritical here. Sound good?
 
I’m not familar with that word. Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.
For your edification, and to re-answer your question: Yes, (as my first answer to you would prove obvious)…*six one way, half-dozen another.
*
 
I answered your question the first time, there was no real substantial difference when you asked the second time.

By the way, Christ didn’t answer every question that was asked of Him, so when you say be “Christ-like” (rhetoric though it is), I did just that. 😉

Side note: Who was it that was quoting people, only to change what was in their actual post and answer a completely different question? (You have done this AT LEAST twice in the last 24 hours.) Who was it who ignores an entire post but gives a misdirecting comment about that person’s signature? You. I have observed you dodging/obfuscating what is being asked of you in about half of your posts to some degree or another, so let’s not get hypocritical here. Sound good?
Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.

Please simply post a yes or a no for the record.
 
Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.

Please simply post a yes or a no for the record.
For your edification, and to re-answer your question: Yes, (as my first answer to you would prove obvious)…*six one way, half-dozen another.
*
Okay, I found your answer… and thank you. Therefore, Protestants and Catholics have the same primary purpose to glorify god and enjoy Him forever. Let’s wait to see if other Catholics disagree with this conclusion.

While we wait, would you agree that God saves sinners for His good pleasure and His own glory… to the praise of His glorious grace (Ephesians 1 and 2)?
 
To answer your [off topic] question, a Catholic’s “chief aim” in life would be to know, love and serve God and to be happy with him in the world to come.

2nd Adam, are you familiar with the term obfuscation?
For your edification, and to re-answer your question: Yes, (as my first answer to you would prove obvious)…*six one way, half-dozen another.
*
Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.

Please simply post a yes or a no for the record.
For the 3rd time, yes.

(I love being forced to answer the same question multiple times by a person who dodges questions themselves. Ironically hypocritical, IMO.)
 
Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.

Please simply post a yes or a no for the record.
For your edification, and to re-answer your question: Yes, (as my first answer to you would prove obvious)…six one way, half-dozen another.
Um . . . I think that’s a yes? Or do you want him to answer only yes or no so that he is unable to clarify his position?
 
Okay, I found your answer… and thank you. Therefore, Protestants and Catholic have the same primary purpose to glorify god and enjoy Him forever. Let’s wait to see if other Catholics disagree with this conclusion.
No need to wait, that is the teaching of the Faith. Proceed.
 
Um . . . I think that’s a yes? Or do you want him to answer only yes or no so that he is unable to clarify his position?
Is that a yes for you too? I want to get a majority response from Catholic Christians. I think EENS came from a Calvinstic background; therefore, I want to know what most Catholics believe in regards to man’s chief aim in life. Let’s remember to be patient with each other since there is a delay between our posted answers.
 
Is that a yes for you too? I want to get a majority response from Catholic Christian. I think
Please just move forward, the answer to this question should be obvious to any Christian who would take part in such a discussion. Do you really think you are going to get a disagreement here?
 
Is that a yes for you too? I want to get a majority response from Catholic Christians. I think EENS came from a Calvinstic background; therefore, I want to know what most Catholics believe in regards to man’s chief aim in life. Let’s remember to be patient with each other since there is a delay between our posted answers.
Yes.
 
Please just move forward, the answer to this question should be obvious to any Christian who would take part in such a discussion. Do you really think you are going to get a disagreement here?
I don’t really know what most Catholics would say in regards to man’s chief aim in life. I’m going to sit on this question for a few hours. Heck, many Protestants would not come up with our shared answer. 😉

Dear Catholic siblings,

What is man’s primary purpose, or what is man’s chief aim in life?
 
You’re answer doesn’t really count since you were raised with sound doctrine known as Calvinism. Why don’t you ask Scott Hahn what is man’s primary purpose? 🙂
Honestly, coming from a Calvinist background before my conversion to Catholicism, I think the best argument against Calvinism is the Church, or more specifically the authority of the Catholic Church. But I guess that is a thread in and of itself.
 
You’re answer doesn’t really count since you were raised with sound doctrine known as Calvinism. Why don’t you ask Scott Hahn what is man’s primary purpose? 🙂
Of course I count, as I answered for the Church, not myself alone. This is Catholic teaching, not my opinion, and it is the teaching of EVERY Christian denomination worth a lick.

Edit: I wasn’t raised Calvinist, I merely was Calvinist directly before becoming Catholic. Before that I was just your typical wishy-washy, everyday Christian. 😉
 
Do you agree with the Westminster Catechism of:

WESTMINSTER LARGER CATECHISM

Q. 1. What is the chief and highest end of man?

A. Man’s chief and highest end is to glorify God, and fully to enjoy him forever.
Originally Posted by 2nd Adam
Is that a yes for you too? I want to get a majority response from Catholic Christians. I think EENS came from a Calvinstic background; therefore, I want to know what most Catholics believe in regards to man’s chief aim in life. Let’s remember to be patient with each other since there is a delay between our posted answers.
You agree with the centrality and driven force of Calvinism. 😉
 
I don’t really know what most Catholics would say in regards to man’s chief aim in life. I’m going to sit on this question for a few hours. Heck, many Protestants would not come up with our shared answer. 😉

Dear Catholic siblings,

What is man’s primary purpose, or what is man’s chief aim in life?
When you post things like this, you are saying that a “consensus” from any number of people could have any bearing on the clear, true teaching of the Church. There is no need to know what “most Catholcis would say”, but only what The Church itself would say. I understand that you believe that there is an elect within the Church, but the Church itself does not believe that. You don’t have to accept the belief of the Church, but in order to have a productive discussion you do have to accept the reality that the Church officially has a teaching different than yours, and that this teaching is clear, concise, and out there for all to see. It’s almost as if you’re having a discussion with yourself and we’re just all standing here watching it.
 
Can everyone answer this question with a yes or a no before we continue with TULIP?
I say yes! and I think LOVE is a huge part of glorifying God… I mean after all, loving God is the first and greatest commandment. =]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top