S
SaintPatrick333
Guest
Kindly go to scripturecatholic(dot)com and look up sola scriptura. It will provide countless scriptural evidence that tears that heresy apart.Ahs said,
The Bible is Truth and does not contradict itself, yet those relying on SS still come to opposing views which are both fully based on Scripture alone. This is an excellent reason to dismiss SS…no one can be certain that the opposing view is wrong because BOTH views are based on someone’s understanding of scripture.
Ahs, since you have agreed that the bible is truth and does not contradict itself, it must then follow that any doctrine, dogma or tradition of the church must by necessity not contradict the Bible in order to also be true. Anything that contradicts truth cannot be true.
That is why a basic rule of Bible interpretation is: “To understand doctrine, bring all the scriptures together on the subject you wish to know; then let every word have its proper influence; and if you can form your theory without a contradiction, you cannot be in error.” If you find your doctrine contradicting any scripture it should be regarded as erroneous and dismissed.
When you read Matt 5:19 where Jesus says no one should break the least of the commandments or teach others to do so, that should be clear enough for any reasonable man to understand. Add to that Psm 111:8, where the commandments are said to stand fast forever and ever , and you have indisputable evidence that changing or removing a commandment of God is forbidden by God. There are many other verses attesting to the immutability of the commandments, as well
You may argue for a doctrine that allows tradition to violate scripture , but then what you are really saying is that tradition is allowed to contradict truth and therefore does not have to be true.
Ahs said "…no one can be certain that the opposing view is wrong because BOTH views are based on someone’s understanding of what Scripture is really saying. How does SS resolve this issue?
Be careful in your analysis here, for what you are really saying is that no one can be sure of what is really true. But Jesus said if you did His will you would know the truth. (John 7:17 and 8:31-31) Many people want to know the truth without doing His will, and say they love Him without keeping His commandments (John 14:15).Paul says the scriptures can make you wise unto salvation (2Tim 3:15) and Jesus says you will err in not knowing the scriptures (Matt 22:29) These are powerful verses given validity to sola scriptura and that the Lord has made provision for us to know the truth.
If the doctrines of the Catholic church do not violate scripture , why would you be so adamant in your dislike for SS? If your doctrines are pure, SS would be a powerful argument for your beliefs. The only people who would object to SS would be those who cannot validate their doctrines or traditions through the inspired word of God. Sola scriptura is the great truth detector for it compares all doctrine to the Bible, and you have already agreed that the Bible is truth.
When you say “no one can be certain” then you are contradicting Christ’s statements saying we are to know the truth : John 8:32 “And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.”
Phineas said: Knowing the truth depends on your sincerity and depth of study.
Ahs then asked: Says who? Does the Bible say this? Or is this just an opinion? Using SS, please demonstrate this for me.
Sincerity Jerm 29:13 And ye shall seek me, and find [me], when ye shall search for me with all your heart.
Depth of Study 2 Tim 2:15 Study to show thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.
Remember, SS is not against tradition in general, but rather against tradition that contradicts the scriptures, for anything that contradicts the truth is a lie…
and :hug3: win you over.