W
whosebob
Guest
JMJ + OBT
Check it out:Freedom for the Traditional Latin Mass
YES!!!
In the Hearts of Jesus and Mary.
IC XC NIKA
If you happen to visit (as I do, to keep myself informed and not because I agree with them) real traditional sites such as traditio.com, they are not going to return to the fold even if there is a “universal indult,” which there is not going to be in the first place. In the words of Shakespeare, from King Lear, “Never, never, never, never, never.” Too many bishops would not touch the TLM with a ten foot pole or allow their priests to.This may be too good to be true but in the distance I do hear the sounds of 100,000 bagpipers in beautiful unison marching home…
How long Lord? May our traditional brethren never feel like lepers again. Ostende nobis, Domine, misericordiam tuam.
whosebob said:Check it out:
JMJ + OBT
Freedom for the Traditional Latin Mass
YES!!!
I hope this is true!
Keep us posted!
Our Bishop rocks.
It could also turn out that it could bring some more reverence to the knew liturgy. Having the old liturgy there to scrutinize the knew one could cause it to get better.As much as I love the Tridentine Mass, I think it would be a disaster to bring it back.
Vatican II clearly calls for Gregorian chant in the Mass and assumes that the Mass will be continued to be said in Latin. Sadly, few Masses are said in Latin and few use Gregorian chant.
If the Tridentine Mass is reintroduced in full vigor, I don’t think we will ever see the Novus Ordo Mass offered as the Council Fathers intended it to be offered – in Latin and with Gregorian chant. Catholics will just go to the Tridentine Mass if they want a Latin Mass and Gregorian chant.
A move such as described here, allowing the priest to decide which Mass to celebrate, will cause much confusion and destruction within the Church as, I hate to say this and I know it will be deined, those laity who prefer the old Mass are a minority with in the Church.
It should be up to the bishop who is the pastor of his diocese to decide when and where the old Mass will be offered.
Also, while many priests may wish to do this not all know how as the semianries only teach the current Mass.
I still do not believe that Pope Benedict will stomp on the feet of the bishops in such a way.
A move such as described here, allowing the priest to decide which Mass to celebrate, will cause much confusion and destruction within the Church as, I hate to say this and I know it will be deined, those laity who prefer the old Mass are a minority with in the Church.
Gottle of Geer said:## After all the disruption and anguish of changing from the older Mass, more disruption and anguish in changing back again is exactly what is not needed.
Why can’t the two Masses co-exist in peace, instead of being reasons for cat-fights ?
IMO, there needs to be mutual forebearance - but ther can be no rejection of Vatican II.
The real puzzle, if the excommunications in 1988 are to be overturned, is why they were imposed on the first place. If they are not valid now, why should they be treated as having been valid then ? I wish Abp. Lefebvre could have been alive to see this (I’d rather see him canonised than JP2). ##