Pope shows solidarity with Migrants.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Son_of_Niall
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Has Pope Francis addressed or hinted at the crime issues Germany, France, Sweden, Austria, etc are facing due to influx of migrants?
 
This is untrue.
Thought so. It seemed so out of Character for him to say something like that. It is really tiring to see people twist the Pope’s speech like this.

For any one interested on what the Pope said (or at least this was the least biased source I could find that wasn’t a “Commentator”).

mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/pope-francis-wait-see-before-9673089
yahoo.com/news/pope-warns-against-populism-saviours-hitler-001439301.html

These articles clearly state that he has not made any kind of Judgement on Trump. So that should clear up anything for anyone else trying to state this.
 
Pope Francis called Trump Hitler. How right he is. Many of you here voted for him because you stupidly think he’s going to “save babies.”. Many of us will do everything we can to destroy every evil thing he tries to do. Did any of you see all the articles about pro-life women who participated in the Women’s March and participated in the March for Life? They carried signs that said: “Pro-Woman. Pro-Life. Anti-Trump.” Good for them. Go ahead an try to defend your dirtbag. We pro-life American patriots will do all we can to destroy anything and everything he does. By the way, did any of you find the videos of his First VVhore doing porno on-line? It’s all out there. Are you proud of her, his 58th or whatever “wife?” Let’s “save those babies.” Uh-huh, yeah, right. I’m Atheist, gay and pro-life and will forever oppose the Skank-In-Chief.
What a terrible post!
 
You have a choice, Catholic or Trumpolic.
I find this double standard funny, very interesting you didn’t say the same thing over Abortion and Clinton. And the Catechism has a very clear and succinct teaching on Abortion, much more serious than immigration.

On immigration, it is the Gospel message of Christ to help those in need, I am not against that, but I am aware that before I jump into the water to save someone from drowning, I should first assess why they are drowning to begin with, no point getting us all killed.

I hope this has helped

God Bless You

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
Agree…unfortunately this is what happens when peoples religion becomes politics…this has happened by those on the left…and the right here in the US…it’s pretty clear even by the small number of Catholics here on CAF who disrespect the Vicar of Christ by claiming they don’t have to agree with him…this site is becoming to political and anti Catholic…
We don’t have to agree with the Vatican, the USCCB or any Catholic officials on immigration policy.

That is not “disrespect”. Our first duty as Catholics is to the Truth, not to other people or their feelings.
 
I find this double standard funny, very interesting you didn’t say the same thing over Abortion and Clinton. And the Catechism has a very clear and succinct teaching on Abortion, much more serious than immigration.

On immigration, it is the Gospel message of Christ to help those in need, I am not against that, but I am aware that before I jump into the water to save someone from drowning, I should first assess why they are drowning to begin with, no point getting us all killed.

I hope this has helped

God Bless You

Thank you for reading
Josh
I have yet to find one Donald Trump supporter (including President Trump himself) who is not in favour of helping those in need.

The issue is that people are more interested in undermining the President for political purposes (mainly because they lost and were not expecting it) instead of thinking clearly and holistically.

As far as these accusations that we are somehow less Catholic or disrespecting the Pope ect. because we don’t want open borders is absurd as the official Catholic teaching is a balance between sovereign rights and humanitarian need.
 
We don’t have to agree with the Vatican, the USCCB or any Catholic officials on immigration policy.

That is not “disrespect”. Our first duty as Catholics is to the Truth, not to other people or their feelings.
I’ve been over this before.

Immigration and the rights of refugees are both moral issues.

They are not a value-free zone.
 
I’ve been over this before.

Immigration and the rights of refugees are both moral issues.

They are not a value-free zone.
The Church has made its stance very clear: balance sovereign rights and humanitarian need.
 
Pope Francis called Trump Hitler.
He didn’t. But I understand why people took he might have implied that. I think Our Holy Father was very mistaken in that comment if it was accurate, and I will continue to pray for him.
How right he is.
I don’t believe so at all.
Many of you here voted for him because you stupidly think he’s going to “save babies.”
He already is as evident by the pro-life policies he has already implemented.
Many of us will do everything we can to destroy every evil thing he tries to do.
Like?
Did any of you see all the articles about pro-life women who participated in the Women’s March and participated in the March for Life?
No, if so, very inconsistent anyway, as the Women’s March was basically for abortion. I didn’t see any abortion opposition at the Women’s March, certainly not public anyway, name one speaker who mentioned it at the Women’s March and I will concede.
They carried signs that said: “Pro-Woman. Pro-Life. Anti-Trump.” Good for them.
If they can get a speaker up there, then I will give them legitimacy, I think you will find they would not be allowed to though.
Go ahead an try to defend your dirtbag.
Ouch.
We pro-life American patriots will do all we can to destroy anything and everything he does.
That’s not very fair. I don’t think it’s right to oppose someone for opposition sake, I would recommend evaluating the positions he takes and judge it on that.
By the way, did any of you find the videos of his First VVhore doing porno on-line? It’s all out there.
Ouch. Could you imagine if someone said the same about you or your loved one?
Are you proud of her, his 58th or whatever “wife?”
He hasn’t been through 58 wives.
Let’s “save those babies.” Uh-huh, yeah, right. I’m Atheist, gay and pro-life and will forever oppose the Skank-In-Chief.
Ouch.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
It’s not 100% a matter of security vs being blown up. The current law is poorly thought of (radicals are easily everywhere, not just in these countries for starters, most attacks are not from refugees). I’m not against vetting unless that vetting (in this case, the ban) means that innocent lives are being lost. When I say I’m pro life, that extends to middle easterners as well. There are plenty of ways to reduce terrorism. If Trump think this is the best way to, he is not as intelligent as you think he is.
 
Too much virtue signalling here.

" I am with the Pope so I am better than you and I hate Trump. He is an awful person." Duh.:rolleyes:
 
Too much virtue signalling here.

" I am with the Pope so I am better than you and I hate Trump. He is an awful person." Duh.:rolleyes:
The greatest Irony for me, is that before the election, many of these people were anti-Pope and Church due to abortion policies, but when it looks like they might have an ally on immigration, they are suddenly pro-Pope, there needs to be some consistency for me to take them seriously. If they are pro-Pope and the Church now, that must mean they are also pro-life now too and oppose abortion?

Nevertheless, it doesn’t matter whether they are pro or anti, I am Catholic, so Pope Francis is my Holy Father, and I would take under advisement what he says on anything and everything, also remembering he is only infallible when it comes to matters of dogma, hopefully also making sure he is accurately reported which is a rarity these days.

God Bless You

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
The Church has made its stance very clear: balance sovereign rights and humanitarian need.
vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/corunum/documents/rc_pc_corunum_doc_25061992_refugees_en.html

**PONTIFICAL COUNCIL
FOR THE PASTORAL CARE OF MIGRANTS AND ITINERANT PEOPLE

REFUGEES: A CHALLENGE TO SOLIDARITY

PRESENTATION

1992

“A shameful wound of our time”**
"…Despite an increased awareness of interdependence among peoples and nations, some States, guided by their own ideologies and particular interests, arbitrarily determine the criteria for the application of international obligations.
On the other hand, in countries which had in the past offered a generous reception to refugees, there is now a disturbingly similar trend of political decisions aimed at reducing the number of entries and discouraging new requests for asylum. While moments of economic recession can make the imposition of certain limits on reception understandable, respect for the fundamental right of asylum can never be denied when life is seriously threatened in one’s homeland.
It is troubling to witness the reduction of resources earmarked for the solution of the refugee problem, as well as a weakening of political support for the structures purposely created for such humanitarian service.
New opportunities for progress
  1. However, numerous people within various nations are taking firm position against selfish attitudes and the adoption of policies of restrictionism, and who are committed to sensitizing public opinion in favor of the protection of the rights of all and of the value of hospitality…
The problem of refugees must be confronted at its roots, that is, at the level of the very causes of exile. **The first point of reference should not be the interests of the State, or national security but the human person, so that the need to live in community, a basic requirement of the very nature of human beings, will be safeguarded.(**7)…
A mentality of hospitality
  1. Progress in the capacity to live together within the universal human family is closely linked to the growth of a mentality of hospitality. Any person in danger who appears at a frontier has a right to protection. In order to make it easier to determine why such people have abandoned their country, as well as to adopt lasting solutions, a renewed commitment is needed to produce internationally acceptable norms for territorial asylum.(9) Such an attitude facilitates the search for common solutions and undercuts the validity of certain positions, sometimes put forward, that would limit acceptance and the granting of the right of asylum to the sole criterion of national interest.
For a more comprehensive protection of refugees
  1. Protection is not a simple concession made to the refugee: he is not an object of assistance, but rather a subject of rights and duties. Each country has the responsibility to respect the rights of refugees and assure that they are respected as much as the rights of its own citizens…
The exercise of the right to asylum proclaimed by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Art. 14, 1) should be recognized everywhere and not obstructed with deterrent and punitive measures. A person applying for asylum should not be interned unless it can be demonstrated that he or she represents a real danger, or there are compelling reasons to think that he or she will not report to the competent authorities for due examination of his or her case. Moreover, such people should be helped with access to work and to a just and rapid legal procedure…
No to forced repatriation
  1. Scrupulous respect for the principle of voluntary repatriation is a non- negotiable basis for the treatment of refugees. No person must be sent back to a country where he or she fears discriminatory action or life-threatening situations. In cases where the competent government authorities decide not to accept asylum seekers, arguing that they are not true refugees, these authorities are duty-bound to make sure that such people will be guaranteed a secure and free existence elsewhere. Recent history shows that many people were sent back against their will to a fate that was sometimes tragic; some were pushed back to sea; others were forcibly diverted towards terrains of minefields, where they perished…
No to the silence of indifference
  1. The interest in helping refugees, even when felt as a moral obligation to alleviate the sufferings of others, often clashes with the fear of an excessive growth in their numbers, and of a confrontation with other cultures: elements that can disturb established patterns of life, adopted by the receiving countries. People who were viewed with sympathy yesterday because they were still “far off” are turned away today because they are too “close” and imposing. Thus, apart from occasional spontaneous outbursts of public interest, concern for refugees tends to be delegated to certain bodies and groups specifically involved in this sector.
** The presentation of a clear, positive image of refugees is particularly necessary in those countries where their presence is exploited to intentionally distract attention from other serious domestic or foreign problems.**
Indifference constitutes a sin of omission. Solidarity helps to reverse the tendency to see the world solely from one’s own point of view. Acceptance of the global dimension of problems emphasizes the limits of every culture; it urges us towards a more sober lifestyle with a view to contributing to the common good; it makes it possible to provide an effective response to the just appeals of refugees and opens up paths of peace…"
 
From the above, some key points:

"…(1) Protection of refugees is a duty and responsibility for the Christian

Protection is not a simple concession made to the refugee: he is not an object of assistance, but rather a subject of rights and duties. Each country has the responsibility to respect the rights of refugees and assure that they are respected as much as the rights of its own citizens.

(2) The immediate needs of the refugee transcends the interests of the State and even national security in deference to the dignity of the refugee as a human person:

The problem of refugees must be confronted at its roots, that is, at the level of the very causes of exile. The first point of reference should not be the interests of the State, or national security but the human person, so that the need to live in community, a basic requirement of the very nature of human beings, will be safeguarded.…"

(3) National interest should not be the paramount concern:

*Despite an increased awareness of interdependence among peoples and nations, some States, guided by their own ideologies and particular interests, arbitrarily determine the criteria for the application of international obligations…

However, numerous people within various nations are taking firm position against selfish attitudes and the adoption of policies of restrictionism, and who are committed to sensitizing public opinion in favor of the protection of the rights of all and of the value of hospitality…

Such an attitude facilitates the search for common solutions and undercuts the validity of certain positions, sometimes put forward, that would limit acceptance and the granting of the right of asylum to the sole criterion of national interest*…"
 
Too much virtue signalling here.

" I am with the Pope so I am better than you and I hate Trump. He is an awful person." Duh.:rolleyes:
No, rather a lack of deference to the moral authority of the Holy See from some quarters and the elevation of partisan, temporal political opinions over Catholic moral truths.
 
The greatest Irony for me, is that before the election, many of these people were anti-Pope and Church due to abortion policies, but when it looks like they might have an ally on immigration, they are suddenly pro-Pope, there needs to be some consistency for me to take them seriously. If they are pro-Pope and the Church now, that must mean they are also pro-life now too and oppose abortion?

Nevertheless, it doesn’t matter whether they are pro or anti, I am Catholic, so Pope Francis is my Holy Father, and I would take under advisement what he says on anything and everything, also remembering he is only infallible when it comes to matters of dogma, hopefully also making sure he is accurately reported which is a rarity these days.

God Bless You

Thank you for reading
Josh
You are one of the few posters here who is actually sensible and charitable. God bless you.
 
For 1.6 billion dollars and 65% of my charity budget, I, too, would show solidarity with migrants. How much support would the Pope and Bishops show to immigration and resettlement if US Federal taxpayer dollars weren’t filling the coffers at Catholic Charities? Christian duty and all. Yeah, right! Try “follow the money.” This is just one of many articles.

washingtontimes.com/news/2015/sep/24/catholic-church-collects-16-billion-in-us-contract/
I don’t know the full extent of all that, and I have heard of similar reports, very, very upsetting if true, because once they are paid large sums, then they will later make demands and use those funds that one has become reliant on as leverage.

Thank you and God Bless You.

Josh
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top