Preaching for the Environment

  • Thread starter Thread starter fnr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Good Stewardship of our planet is an important thing. Our Patriarch, +HAH Bartholomew has taken a lead on this issue, being dubbed the “Green Patriarch”

I think a balance needs to be struck here. The Deniers and the Alarmists are both wrong. The ocean is not going to swallow up the East Coast in ten years…but to deny that all of the mess we put into the air and sea is not affecting the planet’s climate is equally ridiculous.

We don’t know for sure exactly how it will pan out, and the data is fluid. BUT---------

The Climate is changing. How much is Man contributing to it? We don’t know for sure exactly (yet), but what we are doing to the planet isn’t a good idea, and will reap negative consequences in the future. Just because the world won’t necessarily end tomorrow doesn’t mean we shouldn’t act.

I understand why the Alarmists say the stuff they do. We are a lazy and reactive society rather than proactive. We aren’t spurred to action until disaster strikes (or as the immortal Matt Hooper said “I think you’re going to ignore this particular problem, until it swims up and bites you in the ***…”) That is how we are, and the scientific community knows this and scaring us is one of the few ways to get us off our duffs. Unfortunately, it has also been “the boy who cried wolf” scenario and has given fuel to the deniers, who are not all kooks…but there are some who are tied up in the Petrol industry and have an economic interest in the status quo.
 
Good Stewardship of our planet is an important thing. Our Patriarch, +HAH Bartholomew has taken a lead on this issue, being dubbed the “Green Patriarch”

I think a balance needs to be struck here. The Deniers and the Alarmists are both wrong. The ocean is not going to swallow up the East Coast in ten years…but to deny that all of the mess we put into the air and sea is not affecting the planet’s climate is equally ridiculous.

We don’t know for sure exactly how it will pan out, and the data is fluid. BUT---------

The Climate is changing. How much is Man contributing to it? We don’t know for sure exactly (yet), but what we are doing to the planet isn’t a good idea, and will reap negative consequences in the future. Just because the world won’t necessarily end tomorrow doesn’t mean we shouldn’t act.

I understand why the Alarmists say the stuff they do. We are a lazy and reactive society rather than proactive. We aren’t spurred to action until disaster strikes (or as the immortal Matt Hooper said “I think you’re going to ignore this particular problem, until it swims up and bites you in the ***…”) That is how we are, and the scientific community knows this and scaring us is one of the few ways to get us off our duffs. Unfortunately, it has also been “the boy who cried wolf” scenario and has given fuel to the deniers, who are not all kooks…but there are some who are tied up in the Petrol industry and have an economic interest in the status quo.
Unless the rest of the world accepts the MMGW argument and ceases using fossil fuels, anything Obama imposes on the U.S. accomplishes nothing and only harms the U.S. and its people. The rest of the world seems more to be moving away from the MMGW position, not toward it.

Obama’s plan to make utility bills in the U.S. “skyrocket” artificially is like being the general who ordered the last charge “over the top” in WWI, before the armistice was to take effect officially, notwithstanding that everybody knew the war would be over in minutes.
 
Obama’s plan to make utility bills in the U.S. “skyrocket”…
Since you insist on digging up this “skyrocket” comment form the 2008 cap-and-trade debate how about including the rest of the story:

The latest version of the bill includes a number of measures to offset higher utility bills for consumers. Revenue from the permits would be passed to consumers through rebates or expanded efficiency programs, and an additional 15 percent of the revenue would go directly to low-income consumers.

politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2009/nov/16/sarah-palin/obama-said-cap-and-trade-would-increase-electricit/
 
How do they know when these people were supposed to die?
🤷
Actually, you can just look at the people exposed to low levels of air pollution and compare them to people who live in high levels of air pollution. The difference tells you how many months/years sooner a person dies. It’s just like comparing people who take vs. don’t take chemotherapy after surgery to remove an invasive cancer. Or people who have a “cancer gene” like BRCA1, compared with people who don’t.


If you want examples of air pollution studies that have these kinds of graphs, here you go:
An Association between Air Pollution and Mortality in Six U.S. Cities
Fine-Particulate Air Pollution and Life Expectancy in the United States
 
Omigosh! You mean Exxon spent $26 million debunking MMGW? :eek: No wonder it didn’t do them much good against the $100 billion this administration has spent on it.

Anyway, that was the only fact in the Coll article. The rest was just his opinion.

And Obama’s assertions in the second article have already not proved out.

So :yawn:
 
Since you insist on digging up this “skyrocket” comment form the 2008 cap-and-trade debate how about including the rest of the story:

The latest version of the bill includes a number of measures to offset higher utility bills for consumers. Revenue from the permits would be passed to consumers through rebates or expanded efficiency programs, and an additional 15 percent of the revenue would go directly to low-income consumers.

politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2009/nov/16/sarah-palin/obama-said-cap-and-trade-would-increase-electricit/
“Charge Peter to pay Paul” was not originally part of the Obama agenda, and has no chance of passing, even though I’m sure many a redistributionist would like to see it in that as well as in many other things.

What’s next? Food? Takes a tremendous amount of energy to produce it, you know. Should I pay $10 for an orange so the government can give $8 of it to some other guy so he can buy an orange for $2.00 (the government bureaucrats getting the rest)? Why not just let each of us pay the $1 the orange is really worth?

One might reasonably ask why not just not make utility rates rise artificially in the first place? That way, both Peter and Paul have reasonable rates. And Paul, by the way, already gets an energy subsidy if he’s poor enough.

Or is the real point to redistribute income? Kind of seems that way to me.
 
Actually, you can just look at the people exposed to low levels of air pollution and compare them to people who live in high levels of air pollution. The difference tells you how many months/years sooner a person dies. It’s just like comparing people who take vs. don’t take chemotherapy after surgery to remove an invasive cancer. Or people who have a “cancer gene” like BRCA1, compared with people who don’t.%between%
And in all cases there is an assumption that those that live longer should have and that there is something wrong with those that die earlier.

Reasonable perhaps, but where exactly is the scientific backing?

Any study claiming a shortness of life must by definition assume what exactly the normal lifetime should be. I would like to see the scientific basis used to determine if someone has lived the correct number of years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top