Preventive Double Mascectomies

  • Thread starter Thread starter SubjectVerb
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am pretty sure that the position of the church on this is that it is mutilation of a healthy organ so I think it would be considered a sin.
My moral theology professor, by no means a liberal, said otherwise when we discussed the issue of preventative mastectomies in the case of the gene in question.
 
yes that is true, but the procedure also mutilated a healthy organ. Another example of mutilation of a healthy organ is sex reassignment surgery. Mastectomies made under sex reassignment fall into the sin of mutilation of a healthy organ. Another example is that guy I don’t.remember in which state who wanted to look like a snake and had surgery to split his tongue and turn it into a snake tongue. That is mutilation of a healthy organ. What I don’t know is in her case there would be an exception because she is doing it as preventive medicine not for reassignment or to look like something else.
It is preventative medicine, it is not birth control, gender reassignment, or cosmetic, and anything trying to tie it to those procedures is ludicrous.

We not only have a right, but we have a duty to protect our bodies., I do not see anything sinful about this at all.

The only thing about this story that I think is sinful is for people to judge someone and declare them a sinner for having a valid preventative medical procedure.
 
I am sorry, but this has nothing to do with Hollywood, and attitudes like this are harmful to women. I work with many breast cancer patients, there most certainly is an increased familial risk, and a big one at that, in certain types of breast cancer, and these types can be very aggressive and spread rapidly. Also silicone implants are no longer done–saline implants are used, also there are other types of plastic surgeries using abdominal fat and the woman’s own tissue.

She may be a Hollywood star, but she is a human being, and deserves more respect than what you are giving her. The threat of cancer is very high and she, like anyone else has a difficult and potentially life preserving decision to make. She would benefit more from your prayers than your criticism.
Well stated and I totally agree! This is a personal and family decision and should not be treated as though she had an abortion (which, for some, is also a personal decision).
 
I have no clue what I would do if I was told I had an 87% chance of having breast cancer. I can sit here and say I would do this or that, but I honestly don’t know what I would do. I don’t think no one knows what they would do. I hope that I will never have to face that decision. We should keep her in our prayers, as this had to be a very difficult time for her.
 
The BRACA gene increases the odds of contracting breast cancer by 87% and ovarian cancer by 50%.

That is huge.

Not to mention…her mother died from breast cancer.
Her mother actually died from ovarian cancer. Does anyone have thoughts on removing ovaries as a preventive measure? Can you justify removing breasts as a preventive measure but not ovaries?
 
Her mother actually died from ovarian cancer. Does anyone have thoughts on removing ovaries as a preventive measure? Can you justify removing breasts as a preventive measure but not ovaries?
Removing the ovaries could come under the heading of birth control, removing the breasts do not. :gopray:🙂
 
Removing the ovaries could come under the heading of birth control, removing the breasts do not. :gopray:🙂
But wouldn’t the intent be a preventive medical procedure? The Church distinguishes intent in medical situations. For example, an abortion for an abortion’s sake is always wrong; however, an indirect abortion resulting from the removal of a cancerous womb is okay because it is meant to save the mother’s life from cancer. The death of the baby is an unintended consequence.
 
yes that is true, but the procedure also mutilated a healthy organ. Another example of mutilation of a healthy organ is sex reassignment surgery. Mastectomies made under sex reassignment fall into the sin of mutilation of a healthy organ. Another example is that guy I don’t.remember in which state who wanted to look like a snake and had surgery to split his tongue and turn it into a snake tongue. That is mutilation of a healthy organ. What I don’t know is in her case there would be an exception because she is doing it as preventive medicine not for reassignment or to look like something else.
What about bariatric surgery? (surgical treatment for morbid obesity, and its associated conditions such as diabetes, etc). I think in most instances they cut part of the stomach, or divide it and reconnect it to the intestines…would this be also considered a sin since it’s mutilating a healthy organ? And yet it is considered a treatment option in cases of extreme obesity…
 
I never thought I would say this, but I think Ms. Jolie is right on this. I would do the exact same thing in her situation. She has a large family to raise. Breasts are by no means necessary for life or even creating life and I DO believe in breastfeeding–I have been breast feeding for 17 of the last 20 years! That being said, babies can be bottled fed and still be perfectly fine.

I will continue to pray for her family and their conversion. It would be wonderful for our nation if that occurred.
 
Removing the ovaries could come under the heading of birth control, removing the breasts do not. :gopray:🙂
I think from a moral standpoint, a lot of it has to do with the reason behind it. If it is a preventative measure for a medical reason, I do not think there would be a problem with it. If it is done for the purposes of birth control, then I would think there would be a problem. I am not sure on this one, and I do not think it is as clear cut as the mastectomy question.
 
CCC
Respect for bodily integrity
2297 … Except when performed for strictly therapeutic medical reasons, directly intended amputations, mutilations, and sterilizations performed on innocent persons are against the moral law.
this might help.

some of the responses on this thread are unbelievably harsh.
 
CCC

this might help.

some of the responses on this thread are unbelievably harsh.
So it would seem to me that mastectomies and even removal of the ovaries when used only as a medical procedure and not as a form of birth control are moral.
 
I think that must have been a hard decision, to remove such a identifying part of your body/gender, even with reconstruction.

The national catholic bioethics center
To sum up then, even though a woman with multiple risk factors can never categorically prove that she will develop cancer in the future, she may nevertheless arrive at prudential certitude that she will develop the disease after carefully assessing the various risk factors. Insofar as she achieves that prudential certitude within herself, she not only may, but ought to consider seriously the possibility of undergoing risk-reduction surgery.
ncbcenter.org/page.aspx?pid=1101
 
So it would seem to me that mastectomies and even removal of the ovaries when used only as a medical procedure and not as a form of birth control are moral.
between the CCC and the national catholic bioethics center statement, so it does seem.
 
I think that must have been a hard decision, to remove such a identifying part of your body/gender, even with reconstruction.

The national catholic bioethics center

ncbcenter.org/page.aspx?pid=1101
Ahhh…it’s nice to be Catholic: we have tons of people studying hard moral questions. Thank you for the link.

I think Fr. Pacholczyk’s answer walks a good middle ground and gives the topic a fair answer.
 
And just for the record I don’t know if there are any exception to the mutilation of a healthy organ, that is why I say that I think. If anyone has more knowledge on this sin and its details it would be great for them to chime in.
Circumcision is removal of a healthy organ. I’ve never heard of any Church teaching of any kind against it 🤷

Tubal ligation is wrong not, AFAIK, because it is mutilation particularly, but because it is usually done for contraceptive purposes.
 
Ahhh…it’s nice to be Catholic: we have tons of people studying hard moral questions. Thank you for the link.

I think Fr. Pacholczyk’s answer walks a good middle ground and gives the topic a fair answer.
Exactly. Surgery as a preventative measure to hugely increase one’s odds of survival is a very different issue to surgery for vanity or for contraception.

Heck, a woman is allowed to remove her Fallopian tube or cancerous uterus with a baby growing inside it in order to save her life. If she is morally permitted to indirectly kill her unborn child for this purpose, then at least sometimes she may well be permitted to remove a healthy but risk-laden lump of inanimate tissue for the same reason.

Doctors remove benign and thus essentially harmless skin growths all the time - because they might be or become cancerous in future.
 
Circumcision is removal of a healthy organ. I’ve never heard of any Church teaching of any kind against it 🤷

Tubal ligation is wrong not, AFAIK, because it is mutilation particularly, but because it is usually done for contraceptive purposes.
Lily, circumcision is NOT removal of an organ, healthy or otherwise! But I understand what you’re saying.
 
Exactly. Surgery as a preventative measure to hugely increase one’s odds of survival is a very different issue to surgery for vanity or for contraception.

Heck, a woman is allowed to remove her Fallopian tube or cancerous uterus with a baby growing inside it in order to save her life. If she is morally permitted to indirectly kill her unborn child for this purpose, then at least sometimes she may well be permitted to remove a healthy but risk-laden lump of inanimate tissue for the same reason.

Doctors remove benign and thus essentially harmless skin growths all the time - because they might be or become cancerous in future.
Look at liposuction. People do that all the time and it removes healthy fat cells for aesthetic reasons. I don’t think the Church has come out against cosmetic surgery has it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top