Preventive Double Mascectomies

  • Thread starter Thread starter SubjectVerb
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Taken from:

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/10.1111/(ISSN)1399-0004

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1399-0004.2010.01604.x/full
Breast cancer after prophylactic mastectomy?
“You have breast cancer” are the last words any woman wants to hear. But women facing hereditary breast and ovarian cancer risk who opt for prophylactic mastectomies hope never to hear these words. Avoiding breast cancer is why these women take dramatic action to reduce risk. So when a new study comes out that may indicate that residual breast cancer risk is higher than previously thought, alarm bells start sounding in the high-risk community. The journal Clinical Genetics did publish such a study recently. This study, entitled Breast cancer after bilateral risk-reducing mastectomy is based on research out of Denmark involving 307 BRCA-positive women, 96 of whom chose to have prophylactic bilateral mastectomies to reduce their risk.
On one level, the study’s finding are concerning. Three of the 96 women developed breast cancer 2 years, 5 years, and 7 years after prophylactic mastectomy respectively. All of these women were BRCA1 positive and all of the cancers were triple negative. These numbers led the researchers to alarming conclusion that the breast cancer risk after preventive mastectomy for BRCA-positive women is roughly 10 percent, almost the same level of risk as the average risk women.
And I will shut up!
 
I am pretty sure that the position of the church on this is that it is mutilation of a healthy organ so I think it would be considered a sin. I know one of the reasons wihy Tubal litigation is sinful is because is considered mutilation of a healthy organ so I think the same applies to the preventive mastectomy. Now I totally understand her fears but there are no guarantees in life. The only person who I know that got this procedure done died exactly one year after of a heart attack. On the other my great grandfather was diagnosed with bone cancer and decided he didn’t want to get any treatment at all. He ended up dying at 95 years old after spending 25 years (and he did quite good during those years) with a cancer that was never treated. So only God knows.
No, tubal ligation is sinful because it is sterilization, not because the tubes are healthy organs. This is a totally different scenario. The double mastectomy is for prevention of a fatal disease, not for prevention of pregnancy, and not for the purpose of mutilation. The two cannot be compared.
 
I think from a moral standpoint, a lot of it has to do with the reason behind it. If it is a preventative measure for a medical reason, I do not think there would be a problem with it. If it is done for the purposes of birth control, then I would think there would be a problem. I am not sure on this one, and I do not think it is as clear cut as the mastectomy question.
In these types of breast cancer like Mrs. Jolie has, ovaries are often removed to prevent the spread of the cancer, as the estrogen secreted by the ovaries causes the cancer to grow. This is not birth control–it is a medical treatment intended to save a life.

There is a wealth of literature available online about breast cancer. I suggest people start reading it. Every woman needs to be informed about this, as every woman is a potential victim of it. And men better become aware of it too–they need to understand the risks their wives and women friends face–there is no excuse for ignorance or misinformation about this disease. It is in the news all the time and resources are plentiful.

And BTW, men are at risk, too, and apparently the disease has a higher mortality rate in them:
eldoradospringsmo.com/pages/?p=16130

With the rate of obesity in this country, I wouldn’t be surprised to see an increase in the rate of breast cancer in men. Every man I have taken care of for breast cancer surgery has been obese, but I don’t know if that is the norm.
 
I have. I don’t chime in much but this is something I researched before, and this is the page I bookmarked.

fisheaters.com/circumcision.html
Not good enough - the passages from scripture refer purely to circumcision for religious reasons, and the idea that circumcision procures some kind of spiritual benefit.

The neighbouring peoples of the Jews did not circumcise, apart from the Egyptians - as seen in Macabbeees when, in order to fit in with the ruling non-Jewish culture, Jewish men would hide the unique sign of their Jewishness - their circumcision.

AFAIK it was not done, as Christians do it today, either for aesthetics or hygiene. Egyptians, as with Jews, performed it for religious reasons. Indeed, most of the surrounding cultures such as the Greeks considered it aesthetically unpleasing.

If you are saying we cannot alter our bodies for aesthetic reasons, consider laser surgery to correct the eyesight (purely to avoid the inconvenience of glasses).

Consider children having their ears pinned back when they stick out too much - I for one think Prince Charles’ life could have been vastly improved if he had had such a procedure.

Think of braces for teeth - I had to have several healthy teeth removed when I had mine - done mostly for the sake of aesthetics.
 
I am sorry, but this has nothing to do with Hollywood, and attitudes like this are harmful to women. I work with many breast cancer patients, there most certainly is an increased familial risk, and a big one at that, in certain types of breast cancer, and these types can be very aggressive and spread rapidly. Also silicone implants are no longer done–saline implants are used, also there are other types of plastic surgeries using abdominal fat and the woman’s own tissue.

She may be a Hollywood star, but she is a human being, and deserves more respect than what you are giving her. The threat of cancer is very high and she, like anyone else has a difficult and potentially life preserving decision to make. She would benefit more from your prayers than your criticism.
Well said.👍👍
 
Angelina Jolie announced that she had a preventative double mascectomy because of results from genetic testing that said she had a gene that increased her risk of breast cancer. Amputating your breasts because of a risk of breast cancer but no diagnosis doesn’t sit easy with me. It seems seems like harming the integrity of your body unnecessarily, and with today’s medicine, close monitoring of your breasts by doctors should help catch cancer early.

Does the Catholic Church have a direct teaching on removing body parts for preventive reasons? Jolie also said that she has an increased risk of ovarian cancer (her mother died of it). What if she had her ovaries removed for preventive reasons? Would the Church not allow this because of procreative reasons?

Here’s the link to her op ed: nytimes.com/2013/05/14/opinion/my-medical-choice.html?_r=0"

P.S. If this belongs in the “In the News” forum, I apologize. The story gave rise to my general moral questions.
It appears the Prophylactic mastectomy is an option…

cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/Risk/BRCA
Prophylactic Surgery—This type of surgery involves removing as much of the “at-risk” tissue as possible in order to reduce the chance of developing cancer. Bilateral prophylactic mastectomy (removal of healthy breasts) and prophylactic salpingo-oophorectomy (removal of healthy fallopian tubes and ovaries) do not, however, offer a guarantee against developing cancer. Because not all at-risk tissue can be removed by these procedures, some women have developed breast cancer, ovarian cancer, or primary peritoneal carcinomatosis (a type of cancer similar to ovarian cancer) even after prophylactic surgery. In addition, some evidence suggests that the amount of protection salpingo-oophorectomy provides against the development of breast and ovarian cancer may differ between carriers of BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations (17).
17.Kauff ND, Domchek SM, Friebel TM, et al. Risk-reducing salpingo-oophorectomy for the prevention of BRCA1- and BRCA2-associated breast and gynecologic cancer: A multicenter, prospective study. Journal of Clinical Oncology 2008; 26(8):1331–1337.
However not the only option as there appear to be a few. The entire discussion should be understood in light of surgery as an option for managing a risk for cancer…
11.What are the options for a person who has a positive test result?
Several options are available for managing cancer risk in individuals who have a harmful BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation. However, high-quality data on the effectiveness of these options are limited.
 
The BRACA gene increases the odds of contracting breast cancer by 87% and ovarian cancer by 50%.

That is huge.

Not to mention…her mother died from breast cancer.

I don’t think we should judge her actions in this regard. She isn’t doing it for selfish reasons. Her mother fought the disease for a decade and passed away at the age of 56…she is reported to say she did it so she would be around for her children.

I have a problem with people nitpicking about her life. Pray for her and her children. Pray for her conversion as well.
I heard this story too and I could care less about that Hollywood bunch. They mean nothing to me. I don’t even know who many of them are. I don’t think the OP was being “nitpicky” about a person personally. Just using her as an example about the church’s position on preventative actions.
 
I am a BRCA1 mutant breast cancer survivor. I was diagnosed at age 28 while 20 weeks pregnant. My mother was diagnosed at the age of 48. Her mother was diagnosed at age 53 and died at age 58. Her mother was diagnosed at 42 and died 2 weeks later. Her mother was diagnosed in her forties and died shortly thereafter. I was also 20 weeks pregnant with my daughter at the time of my diagnosis. At this moment, we have 3 breast cancer survivors in our family including her. When my mom reaches her 59th birthday, she will be the oldest woman in her maternal line for as long as we know.

Both my mother & I had the “worst” type of BRCA1 breast cancer – triple negative – it is assumed the other generations of women had the same mutation, but the triple negative aspect cannot be predicted as of yet. Although there is a lot of research into BRCA1 mutant breast cancer, there are few good options for those cancers that are also triple negative. Current research shows that only 40% of triple negative BRCA1 mutant breast cancers actually respond to chemotherapy. Bilateral mastectomies reduce the risk for primary tumors or reccurances from up to 87% to less than 5% for most women. On the contrary, mammograms, breast MRIs, breast ultrasounds, or other breast cancer screening tests only find breast cancer after it has already created a tumor – the smallest typically detected is the size of a pencil eraser. Since this genetic mutation also significantly increases the risk of ovarian cancer, this is another concern. A prophylactic oophorectomy reduces the risk for primary tumors from up to 50% to less than 5%. Ovarian cancer is typically detected at a point where approximately 50% die within 5 years of diagnosis. Birth control is often considered a preventative measure against ovarian cancer, but increases BRCA1 mutant carriers’ breast cancer risk and does not significantly prevent ovarian cancer either.

So, while it is relatively easy for someone who has never faced such a diagnosis (the genetic test diagnostic tool), to presume the “drastic” action of removing presumably ‘healthy’ body parts (breasts and/or ovaries) is unnecessary, that is untrue. In reality, when you hear that dreaded diagnosis, the only thought in your mind is doing something about it, unless you choose to give up and just let it kill you. If, like Angelina, you watched a close relative die from this beast, you investigate your options, weigh the risks, pray for guidance, consult moral theologians, and make the best decision for you. Neither of these surgeries are fun. They are life altering, not because you lose your femininity, but because you gain scars, anxiety, and sometimes long-lasting complications. You may never look at yourself the same again (I haven’t) Yet, many women are choosing to have these “drastic” surgeries, not because they’re afraid of death, but because they have so much to live for: young children, ministries, vocations, etc. We don’t wake up one morning and decide to “mutilate” ourselves for no reason. To assume so is to slap the face of all of us who have LIVED this diagnosis and disease and/or witnessed the extraordinary agony of death caused by this monster. As a very holy priest told my mother, “your moral obligation is to fight this disease and live for those who need you. God put you on this earth to bring these people to Heaven, and He put these doctors in your path to ensure you can do so.” Very few, if any moral theologians condemn those of us who’ve had these surgeries for these reasons. In fact several holy priests, including a few trained in biology/science, guided me, as a single woman, toward NFP and were supportive of my decision to have an oophorectomy. Just as with NFP, critics automatically assume anyone using medical science in relation to their fertility has a “contraceptive mindset”. This is very sad and offensive to those of us who are simply trying to live our vocation the best way we can. It can also be the sin of rash judgement to condemn those of us place between a rock and a hard place with this disease. I have yet to hear a reasonable alternative to these “drastic” surgeries from a critic of this practice. Changes in diet, pregnancies, and breast feeding may reduce the risk by a few percentage points, but not significantly. Chemical prevention (by use of hormonal contraceptives) is not only ineffective and increases risk for breast cancer, but is also morally problematic.

I pray that no one who rashly judges women like my mother, Angelina Joli, and myself ever face the same type of diagnosis we did. If they do, I hope they are not met with the same criticism and condemnation we have been. Perhaps one day God will gift science with the knowledge of cancer prevention. Until then, throwing stones at those doing the best they can should be avoided.
 
I am a BRCA1 mutant breast cancer survivor. I was diagnosed at age 28 while 20 weeks pregnant. My mother was diagnosed at the age of 48. Her mother was diagnosed at age 53 and died at age 58. Her mother was diagnosed at 42 and died 2 weeks later. Her mother was diagnosed in her forties and died shortly thereafter. I was also 20 weeks pregnant with my daughter at the time of my diagnosis. At this moment, we have 3 breast cancer survivors in our family including her. When my mom reaches her 59th birthday, she will be the oldest woman in her maternal line for as long as we know.

Both my mother & I had the “worst” type of BRCA1 breast cancer – triple negative – it is assumed the other generations of women had the same mutation, but the triple negative aspect cannot be predicted as of yet. Although there is a lot of research into BRCA1 mutant breast cancer, there are few good options for those cancers that are also triple negative. Current research shows that only 40% of triple negative BRCA1 mutant breast cancers actually respond to chemotherapy. Bilateral mastectomies reduce the risk for primary tumors or reccurances from up to 87% to less than 5% for most women. On the contrary, mammograms, breast MRIs, breast ultrasounds, or other breast cancer screening tests only find breast cancer after it has already created a tumor – the smallest typically detected is the size of a pencil eraser. Since this genetic mutation also significantly increases the risk of ovarian cancer, this is another concern. A prophylactic oophorectomy reduces the risk for primary tumors from up to 50% to less than 5%. Ovarian cancer is typically detected at a point where approximately 50% die within 5 years of diagnosis. Birth control is often considered a preventative measure against ovarian cancer, but increases BRCA1 mutant carriers’ breast cancer risk and does not significantly prevent ovarian cancer either.

So, while it is relatively easy for someone who has never faced such a diagnosis (the genetic test diagnostic tool), to presume the “drastic” action of removing presumably ‘healthy’ body parts (breasts and/or ovaries) is unnecessary, that is untrue. In reality, when you hear that dreaded diagnosis, the only thought in your mind is doing something about it, unless you choose to give up and just let it kill you. If, like Angelina, you watched a close relative die from this beast, you investigate your options, weigh the risks, pray for guidance, consult moral theologians, and make the best decision for you. Neither of these surgeries are fun. They are life altering, not because you lose your femininity, but because you gain scars, anxiety, and sometimes long-lasting complications. You may never look at yourself the same again (I haven’t) Yet, many women are choosing to have these “drastic” surgeries, not because they’re afraid of death, but because they have so much to live for: young children, ministries, vocations, etc. We don’t wake up one morning and decide to “mutilate” ourselves for no reason. To assume so is to slap the face of all of us who have LIVED this diagnosis and disease and/or witnessed the extraordinary agony of death caused by this monster. As a very holy priest told my mother, “your moral obligation is to fight this disease and live for those who need you. God put you on this earth to bring these people to Heaven, and He put these doctors in your path to ensure you can do so.” Very few, if any moral theologians condemn those of us who’ve had these surgeries for these reasons. In fact several holy priests, including a few trained in biology/science, guided me, as a single woman, toward NFP and were supportive of my decision to have an oophorectomy. Just as with NFP, critics automatically assume anyone using medical science in relation to their fertility has a “contraceptive mindset”. This is very sad and offensive to those of us who are simply trying to live our vocation the best way we can. It can also be the sin of rash judgement to condemn those of us place between a rock and a hard place with this disease. I have yet to hear a reasonable alternative to these “drastic” surgeries from a critic of this practice. Changes in diet, pregnancies, and breast feeding may reduce the risk by a few percentage points, but not significantly. Chemical prevention (by use of hormonal contraceptives) is not only ineffective and increases risk for breast cancer, but is also morally problematic.

I pray that no one who rashly judges women like my mother, Angelina Joli, and myself ever face the same type of diagnosis we did. If they do, I hope they are not met with the same criticism and condemnation we have been. Perhaps one day God will gift science with the knowledge of cancer prevention. Until then, throwing stones at those doing the best they can should be avoided.
I think your story tells it the way it should be told, by someone who is living with the disease and has family who suffered from it. No one should judge you or any other woman for doing what they need to do to survive and fulfill their life’s work. Thank you for telling your story. I hope and pray for your courage to continue fighting and for your eventual recovery and renewed health.
 
👍
I am a BRCA1 mutant breast cancer survivor. I was diagnosed at age 28 while 20 weeks pregnant. My mother was diagnosed at the age of 48. Her mother was diagnosed at age 53 and died at age 58. Her mother was diagnosed at 42 and died 2 weeks later. Her mother was diagnosed in her forties and died shortly thereafter. I was also 20 weeks pregnant with my daughter at the time of my diagnosis. At this moment, we have 3 breast cancer survivors in our family including her. When my mom reaches her 59th birthday, she will be the oldest woman in her maternal line for as long as we know.

Both my mother & I had the “worst” type of BRCA1 breast cancer – triple negative – it is assumed the other generations of women had the same mutation, but the triple negative aspect cannot be predicted as of yet. Although there is a lot of research into BRCA1 mutant breast cancer, there are few good options for those cancers that are also triple negative. Current research shows that only 40% of triple negative BRCA1 mutant breast cancers actually respond to chemotherapy. Bilateral mastectomies reduce the risk for primary tumors or reccurances from up to 87% to less than 5% for most women. On the contrary, mammograms, breast MRIs, breast ultrasounds, or other breast cancer screening tests only find breast cancer after it has already created a tumor – the smallest typically detected is the size of a pencil eraser. Since this genetic mutation also significantly increases the risk of ovarian cancer, this is another concern. A prophylactic oophorectomy reduces the risk for primary tumors from up to 50% to less than 5%. Ovarian cancer is typically detected at a point where approximately 50% die within 5 years of diagnosis. Birth control is often considered a preventative measure against ovarian cancer, but increases BRCA1 mutant carriers’ breast cancer risk and does not significantly prevent ovarian cancer either.

So, while it is relatively easy for someone who has never faced such a diagnosis (the genetic test diagnostic tool), to presume the “drastic” action of removing presumably ‘healthy’ body parts (breasts and/or ovaries) is unnecessary, that is untrue. In reality, when you hear that dreaded diagnosis, the only thought in your mind is doing something about it, unless you choose to give up and just let it kill you. If, like Angelina, you watched a close relative die from this beast, you investigate your options, weigh the risks, pray for guidance, consult moral theologians, and make the best decision for you. Neither of these surgeries are fun. They are life altering, not because you lose your femininity, but because you gain scars, anxiety, and sometimes long-lasting complications. You may never look at yourself the same again (I haven’t) Yet, many women are choosing to have these “drastic” surgeries, not because they’re afraid of death, but because they have so much to live for: young children, ministries, vocations, etc. We don’t wake up one morning and decide to “mutilate” ourselves for no reason. To assume so is to slap the face of all of us who have LIVED this diagnosis and disease and/or witnessed the extraordinary agony of death caused by this monster. As a very holy priest told my mother, “your moral obligation is to fight this disease and live for those who need you. God put you on this earth to bring these people to Heaven, and He put these doctors in your path to ensure you can do so.” Very few, if any moral theologians condemn those of us who’ve had these surgeries for these reasons. In fact several holy priests, including a few trained in biology/science, guided me, as a single woman, toward NFP and were supportive of my decision to have an oophorectomy. Just as with NFP, critics automatically assume anyone using medical science in relation to their fertility has a “contraceptive mindset”. This is very sad and offensive to those of us who are simply trying to live our vocation the best way we can. It can also be the sin of rash judgement to condemn those of us place between a rock and a hard place with this disease. I have yet to hear a reasonable alternative to these “drastic” surgeries from a critic of this practice. Changes in diet, pregnancies, and breast feeding may reduce the risk by a few percentage points, but not significantly. Chemical prevention (by use of hormonal contraceptives) is not only ineffective and increases risk for breast cancer, but is also morally problematic.

I pray that no one who rashly judges women like my mother, Angelina Joli, and myself ever face the same type of diagnosis we did. If they do, I hope they are not met with the same criticism and condemnation we have been. Perhaps one day God will gift science with the knowledge of cancer prevention. Until then, throwing stones at those doing the best they can should be avoided.
👍👍👍

God bless you. Thank you for sharing.
 
I am a BRCA1 mutant breast cancer survivor. I was diagnosed at age 28 while 20 weeks pregnant. My mother was diagnosed at the age of 48. Her mother was diagnosed at age 53 and died at age 58. Her mother was diagnosed at 42 and died 2 weeks later. Her mother was diagnosed in her forties and died shortly thereafter. I was also 20 weeks pregnant with my daughter at the time of my diagnosis. At this moment, we have 3 breast cancer survivors in our family including her. When my mom reaches her 59th birthday, she will be the oldest woman in her maternal line for as long as we know.

Both my mother & I had the “worst” type of BRCA1 breast cancer – triple negative – it is assumed the other generations of women had the same mutation, but the triple negative aspect cannot be predicted as of yet. Although there is a lot of research into BRCA1 mutant breast cancer, there are few good options for those cancers that are also triple negative. Current research shows that only 40% of triple negative BRCA1 mutant breast cancers actually respond to chemotherapy. Bilateral mastectomies reduce the risk for primary tumors or reccurances from up to 87% to less than 5% for most women. On the contrary, mammograms, breast MRIs, breast ultrasounds, or other breast cancer screening tests only find breast cancer after it has already created a tumor – the smallest typically detected is the size of a pencil eraser. Since this genetic mutation also significantly increases the risk of ovarian cancer, this is another concern. A prophylactic oophorectomy reduces the risk for primary tumors from up to 50% to less than 5%. Ovarian cancer is typically detected at a point where approximately 50% die within 5 years of diagnosis. Birth control is often considered a preventative measure against ovarian cancer, but increases BRCA1 mutant carriers’ breast cancer risk and does not significantly prevent ovarian cancer either.

So, while it is relatively easy for someone who has never faced such a diagnosis (the genetic test diagnostic tool), to presume the “drastic” action of removing presumably ‘healthy’ body parts (breasts and/or ovaries) is unnecessary, that is untrue. In reality, when you hear that dreaded diagnosis, the only thought in your mind is doing something about it, unless you choose to give up and just let it kill you. If, like Angelina, you watched a close relative die from this beast, you investigate your options, weigh the risks, pray for guidance, consult moral theologians, and make the best decision for you. Neither of these surgeries are fun. They are life altering, not because you lose your femininity, but because you gain scars, anxiety, and sometimes long-lasting complications. You may never look at yourself the same again (I haven’t) Yet, many women are choosing to have these “drastic” surgeries, not because they’re afraid of death, but because they have so much to live for: young children, ministries, vocations, etc. We don’t wake up one morning and decide to “mutilate” ourselves for no reason. To assume so is to slap the face of all of us who have LIVED this diagnosis and disease and/or witnessed the extraordinary agony of death caused by this monster. As a very holy priest told my mother, “your moral obligation is to fight this disease and live for those who need you. God put you on this earth to bring these people to Heaven, and He put these doctors in your path to ensure you can do so.” Very few, if any moral theologians condemn those of us who’ve had these surgeries for these reasons. In fact several holy priests, including a few trained in biology/science, guided me, as a single woman, toward NFP and were supportive of my decision to have an oophorectomy. Just as with NFP, critics automatically assume anyone using medical science in relation to their fertility has a “contraceptive mindset”. This is very sad and offensive to those of us who are simply trying to live our vocation the best way we can. It can also be the sin of rash judgement to condemn those of us place between a rock and a hard place with this disease. I have yet to hear a reasonable alternative to these “drastic” surgeries from a critic of this practice. Changes in diet, pregnancies, and breast feeding may reduce the risk by a few percentage points, but not significantly. Chemical prevention (by use of hormonal contraceptives) is not only ineffective and increases risk for breast cancer, but is also morally problematic.

I pray that no one who rashly judges women like my mother, Angelina Joli, and myself ever face the same type of diagnosis we did. If they do, I hope they are not met with the same criticism and condemnation we have been. Perhaps one day God will gift science with the knowledge of cancer prevention. Until then, throwing stones at those doing the best they can should be avoided.
My prayers for all of you.
 
I think your story tells it the way it should be told, by someone who is living with the disease and has family who suffered from it. No one should judge you or any other woman for doing what they need to do to survive and fulfill their life’s work. Thank you for telling your story. I hope and pray for your courage to continue fighting and for your eventual recovery and renewed health.
Well said.
 
I am a BRCA1 mutant breast cancer survivor. I was diagnosed at age 28 while 20 weeks pregnant. My mother was diagnosed at the age of 48. Her mother was diagnosed at age 53 and died at age 58. Her mother was diagnosed at 42 and died 2 weeks later. Her mother was diagnosed in her forties and died shortly thereafter. I was also 20 weeks pregnant with my daughter at the time of my diagnosis. At this moment, we have 3 breast cancer survivors in our family including her. When my mom reaches her 59th birthday, she will be the oldest woman in her maternal line for as long as we know.

Both my mother & I had the “worst” type of BRCA1 breast cancer – triple negative – it is assumed the other generations of women had the same mutation, but the triple negative aspect cannot be predicted as of yet. Although there is a lot of research into BRCA1 mutant breast cancer, there are few good options for those cancers that are also triple negative. Current research shows that only 40% of triple negative BRCA1 mutant breast cancers actually respond to chemotherapy. Bilateral mastectomies reduce the risk for primary tumors or reccurances from up to 87% to less than 5% for most women. On the contrary, mammograms, breast MRIs, breast ultrasounds, or other breast cancer screening tests only find breast cancer after it has already created a tumor – the smallest typically detected is the size of a pencil eraser. Since this genetic mutation also significantly increases the risk of ovarian cancer, this is another concern. A prophylactic oophorectomy reduces the risk for primary tumors from up to 50% to less than 5%. Ovarian cancer is typically detected at a point where approximately 50% die within 5 years of diagnosis. Birth control is often considered a preventative measure against ovarian cancer, but increases BRCA1 mutant carriers’ breast cancer risk and does not significantly prevent ovarian cancer either.

So, while it is relatively easy for someone who has never faced such a diagnosis (the genetic test diagnostic tool), to presume the “drastic” action of removing presumably ‘healthy’ body parts (breasts and/or ovaries) is unnecessary, that is untrue. In reality, when you hear that dreaded diagnosis, the only thought in your mind is doing something about it, unless you choose to give up and just let it kill you. If, like Angelina, you watched a close relative die from this beast, you investigate your options, weigh the risks, pray for guidance, consult moral theologians, and make the best decision for you. Neither of these surgeries are fun. They are life altering, not because you lose your femininity, but because you gain scars, anxiety, and sometimes long-lasting complications. You may never look at yourself the same again (I haven’t) Yet, many women are choosing to have these “drastic” surgeries, not because they’re afraid of death, but because they have so much to live for: young children, ministries, vocations, etc. We don’t wake up one morning and decide to “mutilate” ourselves for no reason. To assume so is to slap the face of all of us who have LIVED this diagnosis and disease and/or witnessed the extraordinary agony of death caused by this monster. As a very holy priest told my mother, “your moral obligation is to fight this disease and live for those who need you. God put you on this earth to bring these people to Heaven, and He put these doctors in your path to ensure you can do so.” Very few, if any moral theologians condemn those of us who’ve had these surgeries for these reasons. In fact several holy priests, including a few trained in biology/science, guided me, as a single woman, toward NFP and were supportive of my decision to have an oophorectomy. Just as with NFP, critics automatically assume anyone using medical science in relation to their fertility has a “contraceptive mindset”. This is very sad and offensive to those of us who are simply trying to live our vocation the best way we can. It can also be the sin of rash judgement to condemn those of us place between a rock and a hard place with this disease. I have yet to hear a reasonable alternative to these “drastic” surgeries from a critic of this practice. Changes in diet, pregnancies, and breast feeding may reduce the risk by a few percentage points, but not significantly. Chemical prevention (by use of hormonal contraceptives) is not only ineffective and increases risk for breast cancer, but is also morally problematic.

I pray that no one who rashly judges women like my mother, Angelina Joli, and myself ever face the same type of diagnosis we did. If they do, I hope they are not met with the same criticism and condemnation we have been. Perhaps one day God will gift science with the knowledge of cancer prevention. Until then, throwing stones at those doing the best they can should be avoided.
No one should judge. My mother had breast Cancer although she was a survivor of mastectomy. She died of a stroke and never had reconstruction.

The conversation would be much different if it was discovered that there was a similar and parallel genetic link and test for

Cancer of the Testicles or Cancer of other male appendages…
 
I haven’t read this entire thread, so excuse me if someone mentioned this already, but it looks as though she’s planning to have her ovaries removed as well…
nydailynews.com/entertainment/gossip/angelina-jolie-planning-remove-ovaries-report-article-1.1344591

Peace, Mark
see post 47…
Prophylactic Surgery—This type of surgery involves removing as much of the “at-risk” tissue as possible in order to reduce the chance of developing cancer. Bilateral prophylactic mastectomy (removal of healthy breasts) and prophylactic salpingo-oophorectomy (**removal of healthy fallopian tubes and ovaries) **do not, however, offer a guarantee against developing cancer. Because not all at-risk tissue can be removed by these procedures, some women have developed breast cancer, ovarian cancer, or primary peritoneal carcinomatosis (a type of cancer similar to ovarian cancer) even after prophylactic surgery. In addition, some evidence suggests that the amount of protection salpingo-oophorectomy provides against the development of breast and ovarian cancer may differ between carriers of BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations (17).
 
I haven’t read this entire thread, so excuse me if someone mentioned this already, but it looks as though she’s planning to have her ovaries removed as well…
nydailynews.com/entertainment/gossip/angelina-jolie-planning-remove-ovaries-report-article-1.1344591

Peace, Mark
It DOESN’T matter! In fact, ovarian cancer is much much much more deadly since more than 75% of ovarian cancers are caught beyond the 50% 5 year survival rate. With her genes, she has up to a 40% chance of getting ovarian cancer. She’s not doing it to contracept, she’s doing it to LIVE!! At 37, she’s beyond or moving beyond reproductive age. I’m not certain, but haven’t she and Brad had trouble conceiving - isn’t that why they adopted so many children?

I gave my story above. I had my oophorectomy at age 30. It was probably THE hardest decision of my life, yet it was also one I knew was for the BEST for my family. I wanted more children. I fought very hard to carry my daughter to term (she was the one I was pregnant with at diagnosis). I fought hard for all the babies I lost (2 before my son & 2 before my daughter) – I almost died during my last miscarriage. I suffered for years with endometriosis and polycystic ovaries, refusing hormonal birth control as a cure, for 10 years before my breast cancer diagnosis. Even when I almost died during my oophorectomy (as a complication of my severe endometriosis and another genetic issue - MFTHR). Yet, even when I woke 2 days after my surgery when they were giving me yet another unit of blood through my jugular-central line, I knew I had made the right decision. Even sitting here almost 4 years since my initial diagnosis, after 8 surgeries, losing my job bc of my health, and suffering life-long complications and scars, I know I’d rather be here where I can smell my 3 and 5 year old’s soft skin and glory in their warmth as we snuggle than dead. Statistically speaking, that was my other ‘option’. With the exception of my mother, 4 generations prior to me have died after their diagnosis. Two very quickly afterwards and the other after a 5 year BATTLE. Thankfully their children were already out of the house and set up as adults. Since my cancer struck me so early, I still have 2 little people that I would DIE for in my home. It causes me tremendous pain when so-called experts condemn Joli for making the same decision I did, although lucky for her, she beat the cancer before it struck her. Any of us with these prophylactic surgeries as risk-reducing surgeries know that we can still get cancer, but our chances go from 87% and 40% to less than 5% for both.

There is no reason for anyone to criticize either of these decision based on ethics or morality. As Catholics we should strive to give people the benefit of the doubt. Knowing how high her risk is based on her genetic mutation, she has ethical and moral reasons to take this prophylactic approach! Lets try that?
 
It DOESN’T matter! In fact, ovarian cancer is much much much more deadly since more than 75% of ovarian cancers are caught beyond the 50% 5 year survival rate. With her genes, she has up to a 40% chance of getting ovarian cancer. She’s not doing it to contracept, she’s doing it to LIVE!! At 37, she’s beyond or moving beyond reproductive age. I’m not certain, but haven’t she and Brad had trouble conceiving - isn’t that why they adopted so many children?

I gave my story above. I had my oophorectomy at age 30. It was probably THE hardest decision of my life, yet it was also one I knew was for the BEST for my family. I wanted more children. I fought very hard to carry my daughter to term (she was the one I was pregnant with at diagnosis). I fought hard for all the babies I lost (2 before my son & 2 before my daughter) – I almost died during my last miscarriage. I suffered for years with endometriosis and polycystic ovaries, refusing hormonal birth control as a cure, for 10 years before my breast cancer diagnosis. Even when I almost died during my oophorectomy (as a complication of my severe endometriosis and another genetic issue - MFTHR). Yet, even when I woke 2 days after my surgery when they were giving me yet another unit of blood through my jugular-central line, I knew I had made the right decision. Even sitting here almost 4 years since my initial diagnosis, after 8 surgeries, losing my job bc of my health, and suffering life-long complications and scars, I know I’d rather be here where I can smell my 3 and 5 year old’s soft skin and glory in their warmth as we snuggle than dead. Statistically speaking, that was my other ‘option’. With the exception of my mother, 4 generations prior to me have died after their diagnosis. Two very quickly afterwards and the other after a 5 year BATTLE. Thankfully their children were already out of the house and set up as adults. Since my cancer struck me so early, I still have 2 little people that I would DIE for in my home. It causes me tremendous pain when so-called experts condemn Joli for making the same decision I did, although lucky for her, she beat the cancer before it struck her. Any of us with these prophylactic surgeries as risk-reducing surgeries know that we can still get cancer, but our chances go from 87% and 40% to less than 5% for both.

There is no reason for anyone to criticize either of these decision based on ethics or morality. As Catholics we should strive to give people the benefit of the doubt. Knowing how high her risk is based on her genetic mutation, she has ethical and moral reasons to take this prophylactic approach! Lets try that?
Umm, I don’t recall my criticism :confused:…but, maybe it’s just me. 🤷

Peace, Mark
 
Umm, I don’t recall my criticism :confused:…but, maybe it’s just me. 🤷

Peace, Mark
If you’re in my shoes, the questioning of a decision I’ve made for the same reason Angelina has, IS criticism. If its wrong for her, it is being judged as wrong for me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top