Question for thought: What moves a newly-married spouse from a loving and intimate moment during their honeymoon to the point where he/she takes “every dream, hope, fear and confidence” … and uses “them against you to mock, threaten, manipulate and use in court to make you seem unbalanced?”
Who knows? Maybe the same thing that ruined both of his engagements before me, or led the two women he was engaged to after he left me to walk away? The same thing that caused him to kick his mother out on the street when she was old after she took care of his home and the visiting kids for 10 years?
The same thing that caused him to file divorce against me twice? To go to Retrouvaille to keep me in an abusive marriage, but never go to follow up meetings or do the dialoging?
The same thing to make him hit me and spit in my face?
Gee? Was it me? Because I haven’t tortured myself long enough over what I might have done over the years to take my one and only and turn him against me so that he hates me? Or maybe it wasn’t me. Maybe it “turned bad” when I told him he could no longer treat me like excrement. Maybe taking the blows, not answering in anger, letting him have his way, crying, begging, pleading for his soul to God, praying for him, being meek, being nice, being assertive… maybe all of that just didn’t work because some people are just mean. And I didn’t leave. HE filed and walked out and left. TWICE! (Meaning, I let him back in when others wouldn’t have. But I was trying to do God’s will, and that, looking back, was a HUGE mistake!) But maybe after I stop shaking at your insinuation that it was all my fault that he turned nasty and hated me… maybe I can get something done for the rest of the day. Because apparently if we only all tried harder 100 percent of marriages could be saved. Maybe I just was a quitter after 10 years of abuse. Now I’m watching him steer my children away from the faith. It’s all my fault for not being stronger. Thanks.
GoBison, you’re right… Catholics here giving advice to leave a spouse might sound scandalous. But sometimes only hearing part of a story …it all is so familiar. And sometimes it’s the charitable thing to do to tell someone they have to think of themselves. Maybe if someone had told me years ago that I was not bound to stay with a man who threatened my health, my safety and my sanity that it was okay to go, maybe I’d be in a much better place now. And maybe my kids would be too.
But I’m weak,. I drove him to it. I failed at everything. You’re right. He did tell me it was all my fault he had to leave. On that you two agree, Happy. Because I didn’t put him first. Whatever that meant. I followed him all over the world, had no friends but him, had no job, stayed at home with the kids and handled everything for him. I still am working to figure how I could have put him first more. Maybe I didn’t support his need to spend all the money on sports cars and I was intolerant when he’d come in at 2 a.m. Maybe if I hadn’t questioned who he was with. It’s my fault.
Thanks, Happy Again. Just sign me Heartbroken and Self Doubting Again. (I will say MY expectations of marriage were not met either. But I didn’t walk away from him. Even when he threatened to kill me.) He chose to try to kick me out on the street. Maybe I made a bad decision in not begging him to keep me on any of his terms possible. Quite frankly, he had vowed to crucify me and destroy me. So I still had a tiny bit of self preservation left. I have pictures one of my kids drew of him throwing things and hitting me in front of her. In the picture she is hiding under a table. I am a weak sinful person for not choosing unselfishness and staying to make that man whole, right? Quite frankly, I didn’t want my children to think that was what marriage was. But if they do, someday they won’t be disappointed and their expectations of marriage just may be met! Will you then say they have no reason to leave?
I say you spread false hope because not everyone gets a happy ending in life. And while Retrouvaille worked for you, it’s because there was still a shred of decency in your husband and he was willing to work with you. Yet I get a sense from your posts on the subject that we ALL could have that outcome if we would just try harder. It takes TWO to make a marriage. Some of us were married all alone.