Ron Paul: I Would Not Have Ordered Bin Laden Raid

  • Thread starter Thread starter JMJSHJ
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Many people feel that way about Bush. If they can come for him, what’s to stop them from coming after any other American they don’t like?
Code:
Some individuals may believe that, but the idea that President Bush's goal was the murder of innocent civilians is absurd in my opinion.  I find comparison of him and Bin Laden grotesque.

There is nothing at all to stop them except of course the U.S. Armed Forces and local law enforcement.  But were there terrorists operating in the U.S. whose goal was to murder Spaniards, I have no doubt the U.S. would do everything to help the Spaniards bring them to justice.  I do not think the same can be said in regards to Pakistan.
 
Some individuals may believe that, but the idea that President Bush’s goal was the murder of innocent civilians is absurd in my opinion. I find comparison of him and Bin Laden grotesque.
Code:
There is nothing at all to stop them except of course the U.S. Armed Forces and local law enforcement.  But were there terrorists operating in the U.S. whose goal was to murder Spaniards, I have no doubt the U.S. would do everything to help the Spaniards bring them to justice.  I do not think the same can be said in regards to Pakistan.
Regardless of what you think. If we as a sovereign nation expect others to recognize our sovereignty, we must do the same in return. Regardless of what kind of third world dump it is.
 
Regardless of what you think. If we as a sovereign nation expect others to recognize our sovereignty, we must do the same in return. Regardless of what kind of third world dump it is.
I disagree. If we as a sovereign nation are harboring terrorists, then the rest of the world has every right to react appropriately.
 
I disagree. If we as a sovereign nation are harboring terrorists, then the rest of the world has every right to react appropriately.
Then they declare war on you if you are knowingly aiding terrorists.

There was no evidence they were helping Bin Laden hide in their country.
 
I’m not sure that’s true. If I said that every third person on Earth was an alien in disguise would you say that’s plausible?
Has it been proven patently false? I mean we can assume that it is false based on public records, etc…
 
Then they declare war on you if you are knowingly aiding terrorists.

There was no evidence they were helping Bin Laden hide in their country.
No evidence that we know of but since Obama had ordered the raid without advising Pakistan, I can’t see him doing it without overwhelming evidence.
 
Then they declare war on you if you are knowingly aiding terrorists.

There was no evidence they were helping Bin Laden hide in their country.
I disagree with your assessment of the Pakistanis.

Declaration of war is not necessary when defending ourselves against terrorists harbored on foreign soil. You might want to check out this article by Col. Charles J. Dunlap, Jr. (USAF):

duke.edu/~pfeaver/dunlapterrorism.pdf
 
The fact Obama decided on the course of action he did, does not in of itself, make it legitimate or lend credence to its legitimacy.
Code:
  	 		 	 	 No evidence that we know of but since Obama had ordered the raid  without advising Pakistan, I can't see him doing it without overwhelming  evidence.
 
No evidence that we know of but since Obama had ordered the raid without advising Pakistan, I can’t see him doing it without overwhelming evidence.
He had plenty of evidence that Bin Laden was there. He had no evidence that Pakistan government was aiding him in hiding from us.
 
And that is the heart of this, if Ron Paul is that naive, then he is so unfit for Presidency.
It brings up a good point. As Christians, where should we put the greater emphasis, what you are calling naivete, or a lack of moral ethics. If a police officer has to act ethically and risk failure or be successfully unethical, which would you prefer?
 
It brings up a good point. As Christians, where should we put the greater emphasis, what you are calling naivete, or a lack of moral ethics. If a police officer has to act ethically and risk failure or be successfully unethical, which would you prefer?
I prefer my elected leaders to ensure that the means are as licit and moral as the ends.
 
So, if Obama did it, it must be wrong? :confused:
If Obama did it, it must be right?:confused:

His administration couldn’t even handle the press release on OBL death, what makes you think he could correctly handle the actual raid without botching it in some (or most) respects.
 
If Obama did it, it must be right?:confused:

His administration couldn’t even handle the press release on OBL death, what makes you think he could correctly handle the actual raid without botching it in some (or most) respects.
I’m not saying that at all. I would have supported this action against Bin Laden regardless of whether it was ordered by Bush or Obama.

The raid was a success in my book.
 
I’m not saying that at all. I would have supported this action against Bin Laden regardless of whether it was ordered by Bush or Obama.
So again, you have no problem with an American President sending in a hit team to assassinate a political enemy in a foreign country without notifying them? What if Israel sent a team of Mossad here to snuff a radical Islamic cleric (and American citizen) that was raising money for the PLO without notifying our government?
 
So again, you have no problem with an American President sending in a hit team to assassinate a political enemy in a foreign country without notifying them? What if Israel sent a team of Mossad here to snuff a radical Islamic cleric (and American citizen) that was raising money for the PLO without notifying our government?
The difference is that I believe that Pakistan is harboring terrorists, while the U.S. would not do the same.
 
The difference is that I believe that Pakistan is harboring terrorists, while the U.S. would not do the same.
From your perspective. Not ever country out there thinks like we do. There are a great many people who think Bush is the equivalent of bin Laden. So, you’d be okay with Iran sending a hit squad over to his ranch in Texas and “attempting to arrest him, at which point he grabbed Laura as a human shield and attempted to return fire on the team”?
 
Obama’s decision to kill Obama resonated well with the vast majority of the American public, even those who otherwise would not give him the time of day.
With that im mind, Ron Pual has got his followers, but he is not in tune with where the people are at on mnay issues, including this one.

Nations have been served notice long ago what America was going to do when it came to the pursuit of these kinds of terrorists.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top