Rubio Endorses Romney

  • Thread starter Thread starter ishii
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I move on my friend because after we each have pointed out things to each other, and if we still disagree, instead of going around in circles, I move on. Usually I just let you have the last word. Someone has to inititate moving on though in such cases. 🤷 Peace.
Who do you think would be the best running mate for Romney? How about Chris Christie? Would America elect another Bush- even as veep?

Ishii
 
Who do you think would be the best running mate for Romney? How about Chris Christie? Would America elect another Bush- even as veep?

Ishii
Well from the extensive list Abyssinia provided a page or so back:

I immediately rule out Rubio. Romney says his VP will be ready from day one to step into the Presidency if needed. With Rubio being a senator for just over 16 mos that would eliminate him from any consideration I’d give him. I actually find it a bit strange for Republicans to be touting him after they complained Obama didn’t have enough experience and Obama had been in the Senate longer. Both were in state legislatures beforehand but Obama also had the real life experiences in his days as a community organizer working with Catholic parishes in Chicago on things like jobs and tutoring programs, as well as being a scholar and teacher of the Constitution.

Portman is too conservative for me. I’d have to see though if there is any indication he might help Romney carry Ohio.

They’re all actually too conservative for me. But Jindal I also don’t believe is ready for prime time. I still have in my head the one time he gave a GOP response, perhaps it was to the SOTU, I don’t recall. But his presentation was a disaster by all accounts I remember hearing at the time.

Paul Ryan absolutely not. He’s already the poster boy for a budget ending Medicare as we know it and tax policy favoring the rich.

That takes care of tier one of that list.

Christie’s overbearing personality, while I know is loved in Tea Party and other Republican circles, I don’t think plays well to the general public. I think he would be a disaster.

Jeb? No I don’t believe America is ready for another Bush even as VP.

Pawlenty seems like a pretty nice guy at least in demeanor vs lets say a Christie.

McDonnell perhaps might help with VA. I’d think though he would have his problems with everyone. With some for supporting the controversial provision forcing women to undergo ultrasounds. And I’m amazed conservatives are still supporting him after he flipped flopped on it. 🤷 And in any case I think the VA Senate race may have a bigger impact on VA than VP.

I’m not going to go thru the entire list. I also don’t know enough about some of the others. But Huckabee plays a mean bass guitar on FOX and seems like a decent fellow. Again I disagree with him on a lot of issues.

Rand Paul? Hardly. He’s only been in the Senate as long as Marco and the guy is way too connected to the Tea Party to appeal to the mainstream especially considering how unpopular the Tea Party has become since their glory days of 2010 when they took over the House.

Condi I’m not sure would have the same “Bush drag” on Romney as Jeb would. But still that could be a problem.

I can eliminate some but it’s really hard for me to pick a “best” among your party’s options, Ishii. I definitely think Romney has his work cut out for him in choosing someone.

I know they’re Northeasterners too but what about Susan Collins or Olympia Snowe? They might help appeal to some moderates including moderate, independent minded women. And other than with conservative women like many here, Romney by all accounts otherwise is facing such a huge gender gap among women, as well with other groups. But on second thought Sarah didn’t do much good for the GOP the last time around. Though it would be unfair to compare her with Collins or Snowe in appeal to independents and even some Democrats.
 
Thanks for your comments - my comments in blue.
Well from the extensive list Abyssinia provided a page or so back:

I immediately rule out Rubio. Romney says his VP will be ready from day one to step into the Presidency if needed. With Rubio being a senator for just over 16 mos that would eliminate him from any consideration I’d give him. I actually find it a bit strange for Republicans to be touting him after they complained Obama didn’t have enough experience and Obama had been in the Senate longer. Both were in state legislatures beforehand but Obama also had the real life experiences in his days as a community organizer working with Catholic parishes in Chicago on things like jobs and tutoring programs, as well as being a scholar and teacher of the Constitution.

I don’t think 1 year more in the senate made Obama more qualified than Rubio to be president. (and not even vice president). Furthermore, Rubio was Speaker of the Florida State House for two years - a position that is often a springboard to the governorship. That shows leadership experience of the kind Obama never displayed as a politician and still hasn’t. So let’s dispense of the whole “Rubio is not experienced” idea. Perhaps the real issue is not experience but ideology? Maybe Rubio is too conservative for you?

Portman is too conservative for me. I’d have to see though if there is any indication he might help Romney carry Ohio.

Don’t know much about Portman either. I think if the GOP has to “introduce” the vice president to America (i.e. he/she is relatively unknown) then the GOP will be at a disadvantage.
They’re all actually too conservative for me. But Jindal I also don’t believe is ready for prime time. I still have in my head the one time he gave a GOP response, perhaps it was to the SOTU, I don’t recall. But his presentation was a disaster by all accounts I remember hearing at the time.

He’s a successful governor and I think he’d be qualified to be president. He did flub the GOP response a couple of years ago, but he is one of the rising stars of the GOP - and he would be difficult for the Democrat/Obama billion dollar campaign to smear as an “out of touch rich white guy.” Not sure if he’d make geological sense as Louisiana is probably in the GOP column already.
Paul Ryan absolutely not. He’s already the poster boy for a budget ending Medicare as we know it and tax policy favoring the rich.

I think he’d run circles around the party hack Biden and articulate the principles of fiscal responsibility. He’s an expert at the budget and my guess is he’d be a great candidate to highlight the fact that Obama has not submitted a serious budget. My guess is if America was faced with a scaled down version of Medicare or no medicare - due to insolvency and no $$ (overspending by Obama) - they’d pick the scaled down version.

Christie’s overbearing personality, while I know is loved in Tea Party and other Republican circles, I don’t think plays well to the general public. I think he would be a disaster.

Hard to say - he might put New Jersey into play. If Obama has to defend New Jersey, then he would be in big trouble. I agree that he might be a loose cannon among the more moderate folks. Hard to say if his style would play among the larger (non-GOP) voters who are not necessarily conservative or GOP but are open to someone other than Obama.

Jeb? No I don’t believe America is ready for another Bush even as VP.

Me neither. Agreed.

Pawlenty seems like a pretty nice guy at least in demeanor vs lets say a Christie.

Yes, but somewhat boring. It would be a solid ticket with Romney/Pawlenty.

McDonnell perhaps might help with VA. I’d think though he would have his problems with everyone. With some for supporting the controversial provision forcing women to undergo ultrasounds. And I’m amazed conservatives are still supporting him after he flipped flopped on it. 🤷 And in any case I think the VA Senate race may have a bigger impact on VA than VP.

I think you may be overplaying the ultrasound flap - I don’t think the whole “GOP war on women” campaign will fly. McDonnell, if popular in Virginia will help keep it in play - if so, Obama has his work cut out for him.

I’m not going to go thru the entire list. I also don’t know enough about some of the others. But Huckabee plays a mean bass guitar on FOX and seems like a decent fellow. Again I disagree with him on a lot of issues.

Seems decent enough, but I’m not sure he’d be the best candidate.
Condi I’m not sure would have the same “Bush drag” on Romney as Jeb would. But still that could be a problem.

She’s pro-choice, and that won’t fly for the vice president nomination in 2012.

I can eliminate some but it’s really hard for me to pick a “best” among your party’s options, Ishii. I definitely think Romney has his work cut out for him in choosing someone.

I think he has a lot of great choices: Ryan, Rubio, Pawlenty, McDonnell, among others. Jeb Bush, even though he has an unfortunate last name, is qualified to be president and speaks Spanish fluently, and is very popular in Florida.

I know they’re Northeasterners too but what about Susan Collins or Olympia Snowe? They might help appeal to some moderates including moderate, independent minded women.
I see where you’re going, but I don’t think another northeastern moderate/liberal will help a moderate Massachussetts governor (Romney) energize the conservative base of the GOP - doesnt make political sense at all.
Ishii
 
I reject your premises and assumptions, HailStarofSea. You are saying that any “person of color” who doesn’t buy into the whole liberal victimhood ideology is “self-interested” ? I think your post here is quite telling - you can’t fathom the possibility that minority members of the GOP (and conservatives in general) might just have a different view of what the solutions to some of the societal problems are! The liberal victim ideology says minorities problems are because of racism and oppression, and women’s problems are because of sexism and if someone isn’t blaming the problems of minorities on racism, then they are “self-interested”
You are reframing the debate to a subject that you feel strongly about and misrepresenting people’s positions in the process. The negative impact of racism and sexism isn’t just the “liberal victim ideology.” It was also what earned St. Katherine Drexel her sainthood, and His Holiness Pope John Paul wrote about racism as late as 2001, and His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI said ““one of humanity’s greatest challenges today is to end racism” in 2008. There are several orders formed related to these destructive social sins such as the Josephites, and the Church has a ministry related to addressing these issues.

The bishops’ statement says, “We are painfully aware that sexism, defined as ‘unjust discrimination based on sex,’ is still present in some members of the Church. We reject sexism and pledge renewed efforts to guard against it.”
. In addition to that ideology being wrong, I find that ideology to be the very thing that limits minorities ability improve their lives based on personal responsibility, self reliance, and hard work. Instead, minorities are told:
It must be very nice of you to have more knowledge on what limits minorities and women more than they know themselves as well as more knowledge than the Church, its bishops, its Popes, its saints, and even Marian locutions.
I see that you seem to have an inability to accept that conservatives, far from wanting to hurt minorities and women, just have different ideas on how to help them. Why do you insist on imputing bad motives to those with whom you disagree? It stifles debate, you know, and is basically a form of ad hominem argument - used by people who don’t have a very strong argument to begin with. Wouldn’t it be better to have a discussion on what policies work and what doesn’t, and hash that out, instead of tired ad hominems? You should read some Thomas Sowell.
The problems of racism and sexism cannot be completely solved through policies, but also need direct confrontation with individuals. The first step to solving a problem is admitting it exists and agreeing on what it is, which means challenging those who seek to say that the problem is unimportant or imaginary and challenging those who seek to impute immoral character to those who seek to solve those problems. No, the opposite; people who seek to end these social evils should be commended. 👍

Have read Thomas Sowell and am not sure how any of his points support your points. But in the interest of a discussion on tokenism, you forgot to tell me to also read Walter Williams. 😃 Neither Sowell nor Williams are conservatives anyways; they are libertarians.

We shouldn’t need to “debate” something that should already be accepted as truth. If you want to say that all of minority and female problems are because they are irresponsible, not hard working, and not self reliant then you should not be surprised that anyone is offended by these insults. As for policies, the most important issues are abortion and poverty, which are related to the issues for minorities and women but not exactly the same.
 
Thanks for your comments - my comments in blue.

Rubio was Speaker of the Florida State House for two years - a position that is often a springboard to the governorship. That shows leadership experience of the kind Obama never displayed as a politician

My guess is if America was faced with a scaled down version of Medicare or no medicare - due to insolvency and no $$ (overspending by Obama) - they’d pick the scaled down version.

I see where you’re going, but I don’t think another northeastern moderate/liberal will help a moderate Massachussetts governor (Romney) energize the conservative base of the GOP - doesnt make political sense at all.
Ishii
And thank you Ishii for your comments. I’ll just touch further on a few.

I still don’t think even with Rubio having been a state house speaker that it makes him as qualified as Obama. True Obama wasn’t speaker but he too served in a state legislature. And Obama’s experience with people in the real world when for instance he worked with those Catholic parishes in service to the community, far trumps in my view Rubio’s experience as a politician who was a speaker in a state legislature. But we will have to agree to disagree on Mr. Rubio.

Ishii, no one is talking “no Medicare” other than the Republicans who want to end it as we know it.

And if Republicans would even just agree to end the Bush tax cuts for the wealthiest and raise taxes on the highest incomes, some additional revenue would be better than nothing as we work on a deficit reduction plan. But of course we learned during a Republican debate that not a single Republican candidate was willing to raise his hand in support of a deficit reduction plan with even a ratio of cuts to revenue increases of a whopping 10:1. That is just astonishing to many Americans.

I was just trying to find you a VP candidate who might have broader appeal to a cross section of the American electorate. I know neither of the Maine senators have a shot at the GOP VP nomination. But I thought the conservative base whose motto is anyone but Barack Obama, will now be in Romney’s corner. So why do you need a more conservative VP nominee who might turn off enough of the moderate vote? 🤷
 
And thank you Ishii for your comments. I’ll just touch further on a few.

I still don’t think even with Rubio having been a state house speaker that it makes him as qualified as Obama. True Obama wasn’t speaker but he too served in a state legislature. And Obama’s experience with people in the real world when for instance he worked with those Catholic parishes in service to the community, far trumps in my view Rubio’s experience as a politician who was a speaker in a state legislature. But we will have to agree to disagree on Mr. Rubio.:
So a “community organizer” makes one more qualified to be president and work with congress to solve problems than a speaker of a state house? Are you serious Cmatt?
Ishii, no one is talking “no Medicare” other than the Republicans who want to end it as we know it. :
No, it is the policies of Obama and the Democrats that will end Medicare as we know it. The deficit spending of Obama/Democrats will bankrupt our safety net. Therefore, Obama policies will end Medicare as we know it, as well as other programs. As the great Margaret Thatcher said, the problem with socialism is you eventually run out of other people’s money. Cmatt, would you run up a huge balance on ten credit cards and leave the debt to your children? I would hope not, but that is in effect what we’re doing when we continue to borrow, borrow, borrow to fund more and more domestic spending programs - Obama care, etc. Such a policy is immoral, imo. And soaking the rich won’t solve our fiscal problems - the “buffet tax” would not reduce the deficit much. Spending needs to be cut - including defense spending - conservative senator Tom Coburn has proposed spending cuts that include a trillion dollar cut in defense spending. Hard choices - but if you think we can go on spending like drunken sailors then you’re living in a fantasy world.
And if Republicans would even just agree to end the Bush tax cuts for the wealthiest and raise taxes on the highest incomes, some additional revenue would be better than nothing as we work on a deficit reduction plan.:
Taxing the wealthy would do very little to reduce the deficit, Cmatt. But taxing the rich does satisfy those who envy the rich, and want to score political points based on that envy.
But of course we learned during a Republican debate that not a single Republican candidate was willing to raise his hand in support of a deficit reduction plan with even a ratio of cuts to revenue increases of a whopping 10:1. That is just astonishing to many Americans. :
Loopholes need to be cut - I agree. But I would regard the GOP efforts as much more serious than the non-budget of Obama. What kind of budget have the Democrats/Obama proposed Cmatt?
I was just trying to find you a VP candidate who might have broader appeal to a cross section of the American electorate. I know neither of the Maine senators have a shot at the GOP VP nomination. But I thought the conservative base whose motto is anyone but Barack Obama, will now be in Romney’s corner. So why do you need a more conservative VP nominee who might turn off enough of the moderate vote? 🤷
How nice of you to want to pick an effective GOP VP candidate! Neither Collins nor Olympia Snowe make any political sense at all, unless one wants to weaken GOP chances. Romney is a moderate governor from the northeast. He would be better served by picking a more conservative running mate. This was true of Bush in '88 and the opposite in '80 when the conservative picked the moderate George Bush. I don’t think Romney needs a home run like McCain did in '08. He just needs a solid VP pick, and there are many to choose from. Obama is not as popular as in '08 now that people know what he is about, and as the economy continues its lackluster performance under Obama’s tenure, and as it gets harder and harder for Obama to successfully blame others for his own lack of leadeship and lackluster performance.

Ishii
 
You are reframing the debate to a subject that you feel strongly about and misrepresenting people’s positions in the process.
No, I was responding to your implicit premise that any minority who doesn’t buy into the ideology of endless victimhood and who doesn’t buy into the tired, failed liberal ideology is “not caring about the plight of minorities.” Such a view - yours it seems - is unfair, insulting and ad hominem.
The negative impact of racism and sexism isn’t just the “liberal victim ideology.” It was also what earned St. Katherine Drexel her sainthood,
I think there is a huge difference between the America that St. Katherine Drexel lived in 90 years ago and the America now. So why do you act like nothing has changed? Does segregation still exist?
The bishops’ statement says, “We are painfully aware that sexism, defined as ‘unjust discrimination based on sex,’ is still present in some members of the Church. We reject sexism and pledge renewed efforts to guard against it.”
I would like to see that statement - do you have a link to it?
It must be very nice of you to have more knowledge on what limits minorities and women more than they know themselves as well as more knowledge than the Church, its bishops, its Popes, its saints, and even Marian locutions.
Getting back to America in 2012 - I think the bigger problem among minorities is the ideology which promotes a lack of self-responsibility. It tells people " you are not responsible for you actions. You can blame racism for all of your problems." HailstarofSea, the biggest problems facing minorities is a lack of personal responsibility. It is what causes the highest out of wedlock birthrates, drug use, high school drop out rates, etc. Those are problems which are not a function of racism, but rather a lack of personal responsibility. Racism exists, but it is not what is holding back so many minorities from being successful and rising above poverty and despair.
The problems of racism and sexism cannot be completely solved through policies, but also need direct confrontation with individuals. The first step to solving a problem is admitting it exists and agreeing on what it is, which means challenging those who seek to say that the problem is unimportant or imaginary and challenging those who seek to impute immoral character to those who seek to solve those problems. No, the opposite; people who seek to end these social evils should be commended. 👍
Again, the problem is more the victim mentality and the lack of focus on personal responsibility. Everyone will have setbacks. Racism and sexism exist. But they are notn what’s holding back minorities and women. What holds them back is the ideology which says, “its not your fault you are not successful - you can blame all your problems on racism.” How convenient. Its nice to have a scapegoat for one’s failures, but ultimately those who want to improve their lot in life in these times need to look toward the values of hard work, education, and faith. Unfortunately, the victim hood ideology prevails among so many minorites that it holds them back- along with destructive socialistic welfare polices which undermined the family structure and failed education policies which allow minorities to keep failing.
Have read Thomas Sowell and am not sure how any of his points support your points. But in the interest of a discussion on tokenism, you forgot to tell me to also read Walter Williams. 😃 Neither Sowell nor Williams are conservatives anyways; they are libertarians.
I forgot - you should read Walter Williams, too. Both subscribe to the view that lack of personal responsiblity is a greater problem among todays minorities who struggle to be successful, than is racism. You should also read “Losing Ground” by Charles Murray.
We shouldn’t need to “debate” something that should already be accepted as truth.
So sorry if I don’t except your version of the truth!
If you want to say that all of minority and female problems are because they are irresponsible, not hard working, and not self reliant then you should not be surprised that anyone is offended by these insults. As for policies, the most important issues are abortion and poverty, which are related to the issues for minorities and women but not exactly the same.
Well, you lost me on that last point- perhaps you could re-phrase it more coherently. I didn’t say that ALL minority problems are due to irresponsibility. Rather, it is the liberal victimhood mentality which holds back minority progress more than racism.
 
No, I was responding to your implicit premise that any minority who doesn’t buy into the ideology of endless victimhood and who doesn’t buy into the tired, failed liberal ideology is “not caring about the plight of minorities.” Such a view - yours it seems - is unfair, insulting and ad hominem.
Its fair if I don’t respond to strawmen and just respond to actual replies to my actual statements. 🙂
I think there is a huge difference between the America that St. Katherine Drexel lived in 90 years ago and the America now. So why do you act like nothing has changed? Does segregation still exist?
Sure, there’s a difference but equality isn’t even close to being achieved. Yes, segregation still exists. Excuse me if I think that second class status is still a bad thing even if it isn’t at the level of slavery. 🤷 Slavery and colonization aren’t normal states of nature. They were evil and unique aberrations. Why don’t you ask Pope Benedict why he still said racism needs to be overcome in 2008 instead of acting as if I am the only person who acknowledges this is still an important problem?

Its a little hard to respond to you when you persist in exaggeration of the statements that you believe in and minimization of the statements that you don’t. Here is a key example. Drexel died in 1955 and was canonized in 2000, hardly 90 years ago. 🤷
I would like to see that statement - do you have a link to it?
old.usccb.org/laity/bonds.shtml
Racism and sexism exist. But they are notn what’s holding back minorities and women.
Here is where I as well as the bishops, Pope, saints, and every GOP presidential candidate disagrees with you. You can talk about all those other factors all you want, but you are 100% wrong on this point. The existence of those other factors does not mean that racism and sexism do not ALSO hold people back. And for some, it is the MAJOR factor.

So sorry if I don’t think libertarian thinking is to be admired where people take the point of view that it is immoral to try and fix “cosmic injustices” as Thomas Sowell does. And that’s why all the people that you have mentioned are libertarians and really unrepresentative of the majority of conservatives on most issues.

We see the obvious discrepancy between Sowell’s statements and the Catholic Church: “Judicial nominees should not be chosen by the President to reverse Roe v. Wade or rejected by the Senate if they don’t pledge to uphold it.” humanevents.com/article.php?id=8041 Hmm, thought the major and ONLY real reason to vote GOP was to pick the right judicial nominees to end Roe v. Wade. So should we also adopt the laissez-faire libertarian philosophy on abortion, obviously not. It would be sinful. Then why should we adopt it in any other area of life? It is not a philosophy with a great track record of solving any social evils.🤷
So sorry if I don’t except your version of the truth!
Not just my version, also that of the bishops, the Pope, and the saints.
Well, you lost me on that last point- perhaps you could re-phrase it more coherently. I didn’t say that ALL minority problems are due to irresponsibility. Rather, it is the liberal victimhood mentality which holds back minority progress more than racism.
Yes, you did. You just wrote it above where you said that racism and sexism do not hold minorities back. How convenient for you to have an excuse not to care about these unimportant issues, since they don’t affect anyone and don’t matter anyways. 🤷 We can ignore all of science as well as the consistent teaching of the Church. And you wonder why I accuse people of acting in self-interest instead of genuine concern when their self-serving statements have no basis in reality? 🤷 And you don’t bother to supply any factual evidence behind your statements either so I guess we should all bow to your superior opinion that was rejected by the bishops, Popes, saints, science, as well as the people directly affected.
 
I was just trying to find you a VP candidate who might have broader appeal to a cross section of the American electorate. I know neither of the Maine senators have a shot at the GOP VP nomination. But I thought the conservative base whose motto is anyone but Barack Obama, will now be in Romney’s corner. So why do you need a more conservative VP nominee who might turn off enough of the moderate vote? 🤷
😛 Since ishii loves Thomas Sowell so much, maybe he should listen to him regarding the need to “energize” the base.

Thomas Sowell on Coalition politics
On the contrary, it is a betrayal of your cause to make it more likely that the enemies of that cause will be elected because you consider it more important to force the coalition to have symbolic statements that make you feel good than to actually advance another step toward your ultimate goal.
jewishworldreview.com/cols/sowell030600.asp
 
**Rubio’s New Position On Being VP: No Comment **
Florida Sen. March Rubio signaled in an interview with CNN’s Candy Crowley that aired Sunday morning that he is taking a new approach to commenting on speculation about whether he’ll be Mitt Romney’s VP pick: He will no longer discuss it.
“Up to now, it’s all been theoretical,” Rubio explained, but now the party has a nominee who has begun the process of finding a running mate. “Moving forward, we’re gonna let his process play itself out,” Rubio said.
Does Rubio hold by his position that he would turn down the spot if selected? “I’m not gonna even discuss the process anymore. I’m gonna be respectful of the process he’s put in place,” Rubio said. “The last thing he needs are those of us in the peanut gallery to be saying what we would or would not do.”
livewire.talkingpointsmemo.com/entries/rubios-new-position-on-being-vp-no-comment
 
If its okay, may I address you as HSS?
Code:
 Its fair if I don't respond to strawmen and just respond to actual replies to my actual statements.  :)
Well, I was responding to this statement by you:
Code:
The women or "persons of color" that the GOP nominates do not seem to be interested in helping all people who are oppressed, they seem to be primarily self-interested.  Their advancement seems to be coupled with policies that help only themselves.  In fact, some think they are likely to be worse than the rest of the GOP since they have to "prove" to the rest of the GOP that they can be just as tough on minorities and women as the rest of the GOP.
Such a statement is a blatant ad hominem - rather than address the legitimate arguments put forth by conservative people who happen to be black or minorities, you question their motives and focus on their color/race. That is the classic liberal ad hominem approach and I called you on it.
Sure, there’s a difference but equality isn’t even close to being achieved. Yes, segregation still exists. Excuse me if I think that second class status is still a bad thing even if it isn’t at the level of slavery. 🤷 Slavery and colonization aren’t normal states of nature. They were evil and unique aberrations. Why don’t you ask Pope Benedict why he still said racism needs to be overcome in 2008 instead of acting as if I am the only person who acknowledges this is still an important problem?
Where does segregation still exist? Racism does need to be overcome. But does that mean racism is the main or even among the top reasons why minorities fail to get ahead or succeed? I would argue no, and you have not demonstrated that Pope Benedict is agreeing with your victimhood philosophy with his statement about racism needing to be overcome. We disagree, HSS. Why is it so hard for you to merely argue based on facts, rather than engage in ad hominems - question motives, etc. ?
Its a little hard to respond to you when you persist in exaggeration of the statements that you believe in and minimization of the statements that you don’t. Here is a key example. Drexel died in 1955 and was canonized in 2000, hardly 90 years ago. 🤷
St Katherine Drexel did her work during a time of blatant racism -cross burnings, Klu Klux Klan activity, Jim Crow laws. If you’re going to tell me that the conditions in St Katherine Drexel’s time are even remotely similar to now then I think you’ll have a hard time being taken seriously. And she did most of her work before falling into ill health in the late 30’s - which is about 80 years ago or so - you’re splitting hairs.

Let me clarify and apologize if I wasn’t consistent and clear: I believe that racial discrimination exists and does make it harder for some to get ahead. There. However, I think what hinders many minorities more - in inner cities, for example - is a breakdown of the value of personal responsibility. What is the out of wedlock birthrate in the inner cities among minorities? Wouldn’t you say that a major obstacle to minorities in inner cities from being successful is that they suffer from all the problems associated with being born out of wedlock - no father figure/single mothers, etc.? Its a huge problem - would you blame that on racism? Not all problems, nor the most pressing problems are a function of racism, HSS. I think to focus primarily on racism as the biggest problem is to ignore the larger problems that affect society - that is my basic point.
Here is where I as well as the bishops, Pope, saints, and every GOP presidential candidate disagrees with you. You can talk about all those other factors all you want, but you are 100% wrong on this point. The existence of those other factors does not mean that racism and sexism do not ALSO hold people back. And for some, it is the MAJOR factor.
Racism and sexism do hold some people back. However, there are other factors that are far worse than any racism or sexism. Those should be the focus.
We see the obvious discrepancy between Sowell’s statements and the Catholic Church: “Judicial nominees should not be chosen by the President to reverse Roe v. Wade or rejected by the Senate if they don’t pledge to uphold it.” humanevents.com/article.php?id=8041 Hmm, thought the major and ONLY real reason to vote GOP was to pick the right judicial nominees to end Roe v. Wade. So should we also adopt the laissez-faire libertarian philosophy on abortion, obviously not. It would be sinful. Then why should we adopt it in any other area of life? It is not a philosophy with a great track record of solving any social evils.🤷
Who cares if Thomas Sowell is not a “conservative” but is more libertarian? Why focus on labels instead of speaking to the arguments themselves? You indeed have a penchant for ad hominems, and it stifles debate. Furthermore, justices that Sowell would approve of would be strick contructionists who would therefore strike down Roe V Wade - so your argument that Sowell and the Church are somehow at odds is false - nice try.
Not just my version, also that of the bishops, the Pope, and the saints.
How convenient. I see you don’t need to provide arguments - just claim that all the saints, the Pope and bishops agree with your “racism is why minorities fail” philosophy of victimhood. Perhaps you could bolster your case by claiming that all the apostles, the doctors of the Church, Augustine and Aquinas agree with your philosophy as well - maybe throw in Mother Theresa?

Ishii
 
So a “community organizer” makes one more qualified to be president and work with congress to solve problems than a speaker of a state house? Are you serious Cmatt?

No, it is the policies of Obama and the Democrats that will end Medicare as we know it. The deficit spending of Obama/Democrats will bankrupt our safety net. Therefore, Obama policies will end Medicare as we know it, as well as other programs. As the great Margaret Thatcher said, the problem with socialism is you eventually run out of other people’s money. Cmatt, would you run up a huge balance on ten credit cards and leave the debt to your children? I would hope not, but that is in effect what we’re doing when we continue to borrow, borrow, borrow to fund more and more domestic spending programs - Obama care, etc. Such a policy is immoral, imo. And soaking the rich won’t solve our fiscal problems - the “buffet tax” would not reduce the deficit much. Spending needs to be cut - including defense spending - conservative senator Tom Coburn has proposed spending cuts that include a trillion dollar cut in defense spending. Hard choices - but if you think we can go on spending like drunken sailors then you’re living in a fantasy world.

Taxing the wealthy would do very little to reduce the deficit, Cmatt. But taxing the rich does satisfy those who envy the rich, and want to score political points based on that envy.

What kind of budget have the Democrats/Obama proposed Cmatt?

How nice of you to want to pick an effective GOP VP candidate! Neither Collins nor Olympia Snowe make any political sense at all, unless one wants to weaken GOP chances. Romney is a moderate governor from the northeast. He would be better served by picking a more conservative running mate. This was true of Bush in '88 and the opposite in '80 when the conservative picked the moderate George Bush. I don’t think Romney needs a home run like McCain did in '08. He just needs a solid VP pick, and there are many to choose from. Obama is not as popular as in '08 now that people know what he is about, and as the economy continues its lackluster performance under Obama’s tenure, and as it gets harder and harder for Obama to successfully blame others for his own lack of leadeship and lackluster performance.

Ishii
Yes Ishii, I am being very serious as I believe real world experiences with people out in the community and working in their behalf alongside those Catholic parishes he worked with, as well as for instance knowing what it is like to be raised by a single mom who needed food stamps for a period of time, far outweighs the experience to be POTUS of all the people than does being speaker of a conservative state legislature in Tallahassee. Or for that matter outweighs the experience of someone heading Bain Capital as in the case of your presumptive nominee for the top of the ticket. Obama I believe had a better mix of experience. And working with Congress has to be a 2-way street Ishii. Something the Tea Party - Republican controlled House has been unwilling to do.

Ishii, though childless, not that it’s any of your business, but no I’m not carrying a balance, huge or otherwise at the moment. But neither do I compare a household budget with government’s. We simply have a fundamental difference in the role of government and in our political philosophies. And of course in many households people do borrow and carry debt, be it a mortgage, car loans and so forth. 🤷

Ishii, no one is saying “soaking the rich” will solve the entire deficit. But it wouldn’t hurt to have more revenue coming in from those most able to afford it.

I am extremely tired of conservatives playing the “envy” card. It doesn’t fly with me. It is not envy or class warfare but merely a matter of greater fairness rather than subjecting the poor and middle class to balancng the budget on their backs without expecting the wealthiest to greater sacrifice as well.

Democrat Obama’s budget can be found here:

whitehouse.gov/omb/budget

Ishii, under President Obama the economic trends are heading in the right direction. Ronald Reagan used the same pitch to win his reelection bid when one year earlier, the unemployment rate under Reagan stood at 8.8%, higher than it is today.

articles.businessinsider.com/2012-01-23/politics/30485008_1_unemployment-rate-obama-election-day

Chris Matthews stated this wk if it remains closer to 8% Obama wins. Goes up to 9 Romney wins. Whether or not we agree with Matthews assessment, I hope and trust you are not hoping it rises to 9 in the next 6 mos, Ishii. Peace.
 
Hello Cmatt - just a few comments…
Code:
Yes Ishii, I am being very serious as I believe real world experiences with people out in the community and working in their behalf alongside those Catholic parishes he worked with, as well as for instance knowing what it is like to be raised by a single mom who needed food stamps for a period of time, far outweighs the experience to be POTUS of all the people than does being speaker of a conservative state legislature in Tallahassee.  Or for that matter outweighs the experience of someone heading Bain Capital as in the case of your presumptive nominee for the top of the ticket.  Obama I believe had a better mix of experience.  And working with Congress has to be a 2-way street Ishii.  Something the Tea Party - Republican controlled House has been unwilling to do.
You may think community organizing trumps being the speaker of a state legislature for valid executive experience but in reality being speaker would prepare one for working with congress and I think you’d be hard pressed to find many to agree with you on this. You may argue that a community organizer who has seen what poor folks go through migh be more empathetic to the plight of the poor, but as far as hands on experience that relates to the actual job of president, I think being speaker would be much more relavent - given the duties of the president.
Ishii, though childless, not that it’s any of your business, but no I’m not carrying a balance, huge or otherwise at the moment. But neither do I compare a household budget with government’s. We simply have a fundamental difference in the role of government and in our political philosophies. And of course in many households people do borrow and carry debt, be it a mortgage, car loans and so forth. 🤷
That’s good Cmatt, that you don’t have any credit card balances. But what I’m talking about is the deficit which has grown under Obama more than under Bush and yet, Obama still proposes more spending increases! Its like the person in deep credit card debt who keep getting more and more loans - eventually the debt will catch up to us. Either we make the tough decisions now - and protect the safety net for those who really need it, or we risk going the Obama route and getting into a fiscal crisis that prevents us from even funding the safety net. I think to keep spending at the current level is reckless and immoral in that it endangers the safety net which the truly poor rely on.
Ishii, no one is saying “soaking the rich” will solve the entire deficit. But it wouldn’t hurt to have more revenue coming in from those most able to afford it.

I am extremely tired of conservatives playing the “envy” card. It doesn’t fly with me. It is not envy or class warfare but merely a matter of greater fairness rather than subjecting the poor and middle class to balancng the budget on their backs without expecting the wealthiest to greater sacrifice as well.
Cmatt, the Buffet tax is a gimmick designed to appeal to class envy. The campaign strategy of Obama is indeed based on envy - sorry you are tired of it. It is also a strategy of division - between working mothers and stay at home mothers, against women and men - (“GOP war on women”) and even races. Obama is all about division. Sad to see well-intentioned liberals such as yourself ignore this.

I
shii, under President Obama the economic trends are heading in the right direction. Ronald Reagan used the same pitch to win his reelection bid when one year earlier, the unemployment rate under Reagan stood at 8.8%, higher than it is today.
Cmatt - the unemployment under Reagan went from a high of 10.8%during the recession to 7.2% just before the election in 1984. That was a decline of 3.6%! Reagan was indeed justified on running on the record of economic recovery from the recession and America agreed and re-elected him in a landslide. Obama on the other hand has presided over an umenmployment rate that went from a high of 10% to 8.2% now. That is a tepid recovery (if a recovery at all) and one that is very dubious as a record to run on for re-election. Chris Matthews the partisan Democrat Obama lover may predict the election based on the unemployment rate, but my guess is that he is not the most objective observer out there. I think there is a real sense that this recovery is tepid and weak and that Obama’s policies and lack of leadership is party responsible for that. Romney has a big opportunity here if he plays his cards right.

articles.businessinsider.com/2012-01-23/politics/30485008_1_unemployment-rate-obama-election-day
Chris Matthews stated this wk if it remains closer to 8% Obama wins. Goes up to 9 Romney wins. Whether or not we agree with Matthews assessment, I hope and trust you are not hoping it rises to 9 in the next 6 mos, Ishii. Peace.
No, Cmatt, I don’t wish that people will remain out of work so Obama loses - thanks for questioning that 🤷 However, I do expect the Democrats and Obama (and the mainstream media) to play up any new stat as a silver lining and evidence of “happy days are here again.” The reality is (and I know you don’t agree) that Obama does not deserve to be re-elected. He has failed. We shall see if the rest of America agrees or disagrees.

Peace.
 
IWell, I was responding to this statement by you:
View Post
The women or “persons of color” that the GOP nominates do not seem to be interested in helping all people who are oppressed, they seem to be primarily self-interested. Their advancement seems to be coupled with policies that help only themselves. In fact, some think they are likely to be worse than the rest of the GOP since they have to “prove” to the rest of the GOP that they can be just as tough on minorities and women as the rest of the GOP.
Well, I was responding to this question by you.
View Post
Is there a double standard in which if the Democats nominate a woman or “person of color” its okay, but if the GOP does it, its " tokenism" ?
You asked why there seems to be a “double standard.” This is why. If you don’t like it, tough. Truth hurts. This is not an ad hominem as I am not declining to debate any specific policies or legitimate arguments put forth by conservative people just answering an apparently “gotcha” question. 🤷
I would argue no, and you have not demonstrated that Pope Benedict is agreeing with your victimhood philosophy with his statement about racism needing to be overcome. We disagree,
I do not see any way in which Pope Benedict is in disagreement with my philosophy, and you haven’t pointed out any way. Care to do so? 😛 In fact, I think the Popes, particularly Pope John Paul II on the feast day of St. Martin of Porres express some of my views better and more strongly than I have ever seen them expressed elsewhere. 🙂

Denial of real racism or real sexism, especially by those who benefit from it, is generally done for negative motives. It is a hateful action (when not done out of genuine ignorance) and is a harmful problem in and of itself whether done out of ignorance or not. You repeatedly denied the impact of racism and the moral worth of challenging racism **until held to the carpet in multiple posts about how the Church consistently disagreed with your statements and people have received sainthood for challenging this evil. At that point, you “clarified” your position. **While I appreciate your “clarification” and apology and hope that we are making progress, it is up to you to stop making offensive statements if you don’t want your motives questioned.
St Katherine Drexel’s time are even remotely similar to now then I think you’ll have a hard time being taken seriously. And she did most of her work before falling into ill health in the late 30’s - which is about 80 years ago or so - you’re splitting hairs.
Sorry, her order still exists and is kicking in 2012 because the need for it is still exsts. The mission hasn’t changed, and did not die when she died. Not splitting hairs, just pointing out your repeated attempts to exaggerate or minimize out of accord with the facts. Your statement about “90” years ago doesn’t seem to refer to anything. I’m not sure what point your trying to make here: are you really saying that the need to address deeply rooted racial injustice ended in St. Katherine Drexel’s late 30’s?
Who cares if Thomas Sowell is not a “conservative” but is more libertarian? Why focus on labels instead of speaking to the arguments themselves? You indeed have a penchant for ad hominems, and it stifles debate. Furthermore, justices that Sowell would approve of would be strick contructionists who would therefore strike down Roe V Wade - so your argument that Sowell and the Church are somehow at odds is false - nice try.
I pointed out the general criticism of libertariansim in the sentence that you conveniently omitted.

You can’t see the difference between Sowell’s statement:
What is even more dangerous than this political fixation on abortion is the underlying notion that judicial nominees are to be confirmed or voted down on the basis of how they might rule on particular policy issues
and the church’s teaching that we should rule with the issue of abortion held foremost in mind. The church is the #1 driver of this so-called “political fixation.” If you can’t see the obvious conflict between Sowell’s argument and the church’s teaching, there’s no hope then for this discussion.

As for refuting his arguments, to refute an argument, it has to exist first and be placed in this thread for discussion. As I said before, I do not see how his points support your points. But now that you are clarifying, it is hard to know what your points are.
 
How convenient. I see you don’t need to provide arguments - just claim that all the saints, the Pope and bishops agree with your “racism is why minorities fail” philosophy of victimhood. Perhaps you could bolster your case by claiming that all the apostles, the doctors of the Church, Augustine and Aquinas agree with your philosophy as well - maybe throw in Mother Theresa?
No, because Augustine and Aquinas didn’t say anything on racism. It didn’t really exist in their time and was definitely not a major social issue. Since this is a Catholic forum, it would be good for you not to be sarcastic about church teaching. 🙂

You already apologized and clarified, so obviously you are realizing that a lot of your statements are out of line - not because you respect my arguments but because you respect the Church.

Here below is the Church’s position on affirmative action. So you are simply wrong to say that the Democrat’s support of affirmative action or quotas is by definition “pandering.” it isn’t.

**THE CHURCH AND RACISM: An Introductory Update
Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace

Contribution to World Conference against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance**
Positive discrimination as a means of counteracting racism and forms of discrimination
  1. Regarding “good practices to promote” and more especially what is called “positive discrimination” or “affirmative distinctions”, it is well known that the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, of 21 December 1965, envisages in Article 1 §4 the possibility of adopting special measures "for the sole purpose of securing adequate advancement of certain racial or ethnic groups or individuals requiring such protection as may be necessary in order to ensure such groups or individuals equal enjoyment or exercise of human rights … " (the Holy See ratified this Convention in 1969; see CR, Part IV, n. 30. See also the Holy See’s Report to CERD, n. 4 k: “So far as the International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination is concerned, the Holy See takes special pleasure in reiterating its support of the Convention as the Catholic Church considers it its duty to preach the equal dignity of all human beings, created by God in His image”). On this basis of “affirmative action”, various countries have adopted legislation providing special protection notably for indigenous peoples and minorities. These voluntary measures are intended to ensure effective recognition of the equality of all, for example by facilitating access to bank loans for a particular category of the population. There are different systems of applying such measures: the many more or less obligatory provisions for affirmative action, the system of quotas imposing a fixed percentage of one or other group of people (in public employment, schools, universities, elections …), etc.
  1. The choice of this kind of policy remains controversial. There is a real risk that such measures will crystallize differences rather than foster social cohesion, that in the area of employment or political life, for example, there will be recruitment or election of individuals on the basis of their ethnic group rather than their competence, and finally that freedom of choice will be compromised. Those, who support these voluntary policies reply that it is not enough to recognize equality—it has to be created. And in fact it cannot be denied that the weight of historical, social and cultural precedents requires at times positive action by States.
The Catholic Church is always keen to defend the reality of the concrete person, situated in history (cf. John Paul II Encyclical Letter Redemptor hominis [4 March 1979], n. 13), and she calls for effective respect for human rights. These policies are legitimate to the extent that they respect the prudent reserve of Article 1, § 4 of the 1965 Convention, which provides that these measures of positive discrimination must be temporary, that they ought not have the effect of maintaining different rights for different groups, and that they must not be kept in force once their objectives have been achieved.
 
back peddle 😃
Pointed out a few posts back that it was pretty obvious that he was angling for the VP when he wrote a book conveniently timed to be released around the next presidential election. :rolleyes:

Its best to ignore people’s words when their actions contradict. 🙂
 
I do not see any way in which Pope Benedict is in disagreement with my philosophy, and you haven’t pointed out any way. Care to do so? 😛 .
It is not my burden to prove how Pope Benedict disagrees w/ your victim of racism philosophy - it is your duty to show how Pope Benedict agrees with your victim ideology. You have not made the case at all.
Denial of real racism or real sexism, especially by those who benefit from it, is generally done for negative motives. It is a hateful action (when not done out of genuine ignorance) and is a harmful problem in and of itself whether done out of ignorance or not. .
Perhaps you should lobby to make denial of racism and sexism a hate crime punishable by imprisonment or sentence to re-education camps. You could head the sentencing committee.
You repeatedly denied the impact of racism and the moral worth of challenging racism **until held to the carpet in multiple posts about how the Church consistently disagreed with your statements and people have received sainthood for challenging this evil. At that point, you “clarified” your position. **While I appreciate your “clarification” and apology and hope that we are making progress, it is up to you to stop making offensive statements if you don’t want your motives questioned. .
HSS, your concern about racism and its effect on our society is way out of proportion to the reality. The biggest problem is lack of personal responsibility. I think it is offensive on your part to impute bad motives or ignorance on my part just because I disagree with your victim ideology. I am not hateful nor harmful. Crying “racism!” is an excuse for failure. The biggest problem is a failure of responsibility. I notice you did not respond at all to my points about the societal ills brought about by social welfare programs that helped create a culture of dead-bead Dads in inner cities and out of wedlock births. Since you apparently can’t bring yourself to read Thomas Sowell, I recommend Charles Murray.
Sorry, her order still exists and is kicking in 2012 because the need for it is still exsts. The mission hasn’t changed, and did not die when she died. Not splitting hairs, just pointing out your repeated attempts to exaggerate or minimize out of accord with the facts. Your statement about “90” years ago doesn’t seem to refer to anything. I’m not sure what point your trying to make here: are you really saying that the need to address deeply rooted racial injustice ended in St. Katherine Drexel’s late 30’s? .
So racism in America is the same as in Drexel’s time? No improvements at all? Still cross-burnings, Jim Crow laws, and segregation? Are you in a time warp? FYI: this is 2012, not 1950.

Ishii
 
Marco Rubio was asked on Hannity about VP and he said he is not going to answer questions about that anymore and let the VP team that Mitt has set up to do their work. I think the chances of him being VP are slim, but why isn’t he denying it anymore? 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top