Well from the extensive list Abyssinia provided a page or so back:
I immediately rule out Rubio. Romney says his VP will be ready from day one to step into the Presidency if needed. With Rubio being a senator for just over 16 mos that would eliminate him from any consideration Iâd give him. I actually find it a bit strange for Republicans to be touting him after they complained Obama didnât have enough experience and Obama had been in the Senate longer. Both were in state legislatures beforehand but Obama also had the real life experiences in his days as a community organizer working with Catholic parishes in Chicago on things like jobs and tutoring programs, as well as being a scholar and teacher of the Constitution.
I donât think 1 year more in the senate made Obama more qualified than Rubio to be president. (and not even vice president). Furthermore, Rubio was Speaker of the Florida State House for two years - a position that is often a springboard to the governorship. That shows leadership experience of the kind Obama never displayed as a politician and still hasnât. So letâs dispense of the whole âRubio is not experiencedâ idea. Perhaps the real issue is not experience but ideology? Maybe Rubio is too conservative for you?
Portman is too conservative for me. Iâd have to see though if there is any indication he might help Romney carry Ohio.
Donât know much about Portman either. I think if the GOP has to âintroduceâ the vice president to America (i.e. he/she is relatively unknown) then the GOP will be at a disadvantage.
Theyâre all actually too conservative for me. But Jindal I also donât believe is ready for prime time. I still have in my head the one time he gave a GOP response, perhaps it was to the SOTU, I donât recall. But his presentation was a disaster by all accounts I remember hearing at the time.
Heâs a successful governor and I think heâd be qualified to be president. He did flub the GOP response a couple of years ago, but he is one of the rising stars of the GOP - and he would be difficult for the Democrat/Obama billion dollar campaign to smear as an âout of touch rich white guy.â Not sure if heâd make geological sense as Louisiana is probably in the GOP column already.
Paul Ryan absolutely not. Heâs already the poster boy for a budget ending Medicare as we know it and tax policy favoring the rich.
I think heâd run circles around the party hack Biden and articulate the principles of fiscal responsibility. Heâs an expert at the budget and my guess is heâd be a great candidate to highlight the fact that Obama has not submitted a serious budget. My guess is if America was faced with a scaled down version of Medicare or no medicare - due to insolvency and no $$ (overspending by Obama) - theyâd pick the scaled down version.
Christieâs overbearing personality, while I know is loved in Tea Party and other Republican circles, I donât think plays well to the general public. I think he would be a disaster.
Hard to say - he might put New Jersey into play. If Obama has to defend New Jersey, then he would be in big trouble. I agree that he might be a loose cannon among the more moderate folks. Hard to say if his style would play among the larger (non-GOP) voters who are not necessarily conservative or GOP but are open to someone other than Obama.
Jeb? No I donât believe America is ready for another Bush even as VP.
Me neither. Agreed.
Pawlenty seems like a pretty nice guy at least in demeanor vs lets say a Christie.
Yes, but somewhat boring. It would be a solid ticket with Romney/Pawlenty.
McDonnell perhaps might help with VA. Iâd think though he would have his problems with everyone. With some for supporting the controversial provision forcing women to undergo ultrasounds. And Iâm amazed conservatives are still supporting him after he flipped flopped on it.

And in any case I think the VA Senate race may have a bigger impact on VA than VP.
I think you may be overplaying the ultrasound flap - I donât think the whole âGOP war on womenâ campaign will fly. McDonnell, if popular in Virginia will help keep it in play - if so, Obama has his work cut out for him.
Iâm not going to go thru the entire list. I also donât know enough about some of the others. But Huckabee plays a mean bass guitar on FOX and seems like a decent fellow. Again I disagree with him on a lot of issues.
Seems decent enough, but Iâm not sure heâd be the best candidate.
Condi Iâm not sure would have the same âBush dragâ on Romney as Jeb would. But still that could be a problem.
Sheâs pro-choice, and that wonât fly for the vice president nomination in 2012.
I can eliminate some but itâs really hard for me to pick a âbestâ among your partyâs options, Ishii. I definitely think Romney has his work cut out for him in choosing someone.
I think he has a lot of great choices: Ryan, Rubio, Pawlenty, McDonnell, among others. Jeb Bush, even though he has an unfortunate last name, is qualified to be president and speaks Spanish fluently, and is very popular in Florida.
I know theyâre Northeasterners too but what about Susan Collins or Olympia Snowe? They might help appeal to some moderates including moderate, independent minded women.