C
Contarini
Guest
Well, she’s sixteen, which in the U.S. isn’t old enough to leave and get married, but obviously that’s cultural and not a matter of natural law. (I think in the original story she was fifteen, in fact.) However, the idea that when you’re old enough to “leave and get married” you don’t have to obey your parents is also a cultural idea of the modern West.I think the issue most hyper Catholics have is the nudity/modesty issues and the fact she’s disobeying her father.
Well I can kinda understand the first point the second is totally lost on me.
If she is old enough to leave and get married then she’s old enough to make her own choices.
I would put it a bit differently: the key disturbing moment for me is when Sebastian starts telling her to stay and obey her father and give up her love for the prince and then adds, “and be miserable all your life.”
This is vicious nonsense, and tells girls that their adolescent crushes are the most important things in the universe and if they miss their “one true love” they will be miserable for the rest of their lives.
This is what folks ought to be upset about.
Edwin