Scientists are growing organs from aborted babies

  • Thread starter Thread starter epower
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For decades, it has seemed to me that the acceptance of abortion on demand would lead to ghoulish practices.

This reminds me of nothing so much as the “Dracula” story. How anybody brings themselves to utilize the organs of murdered children is beyond me. Might as well eat them or use their skin to make lampshades as well.
 
I understand pointing out that it’s a repercussion, but in this translation you have changed killing a baby to a dubious procedure. Why?
My definition of 'baby" differs from yours. I view “baby” as a synonym for infant, not fetus. There are important biological and physiological differences between the two which are not bridged by a semantic catchall like “baby”.

Let’s go back to the parasitic/vestigal twin example I posted earlier. Say you have a set of twins. Let’s compare them at six weeks after fertilization, and six weeks after birth.

At six weeks in the womb, a twin is capable of biologically absorbing his counterpart, and coming to term (usually) without any lingering effects. The tissue that was the second twin now resides in the first. Sometimes it’s hidden. Sometime it manifests as extra limbs, or–most horrifically–a severe deformity.

Compare with a pair of infant twins six weeks out of the womb. Try as you might, it’s biologically impossible for one infant–a baby–to absorb another infant.

Biological differences like so are why I don’t use the word “baby” to refer to fetuses.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ephesians4 View Post
I understand pointing out that it’s a repercussion, but in this translation you have changed killing a baby to a dubious procedure. Why

My definition of 'baby" differs from yours. I view “baby” as a synonym for infant, not fetus. There are important biological and physiological differences between the two which are not bridged by a semantic catchall like “baby”.

Let’s go back to the parasitic/vestigal twin example I posted earlier. Say you have a set of twins. Let’s compare them at six weeks after fertilization, and six weeks after birth.

At six weeks in the womb, a twin is capable of biologically absorbing his counterpart, and coming to term (usually) without any lingering effects. The tissue that was the second twin now resides in the first. Sometimes it’s hidden. Sometime it manifests as extra limbs, or–most horrifically–a severe deformity.

Compare with a pair of infant twins six weeks out of the womb. Try as you might, it’s biologically impossible for one infant–a baby–to absorb another infant.

Biological differences like so are why I don’t use the word “baby” to refer to fetuses.
The original question was asking why you used the word “dubious”. Dubious implies some argument that an action MIGHT be licit or moral, but might not. Are you unsure if the killing of the baby/fetus is wrong or not?
 
I should note that anyone who’s had a rubella vaccine has benefited from practices like this.
You are correct. Sickening in this day and age with our technology, that we can’t take the time to come up with an acceptable alternative. There are ethical alternatives for some vaccines though. It’s also a sad fact that medicine benefited from Nazi experimentation on Jews. It isn’t something to be triumphalistic about.
 
The original question was asking why you used the word “dubious”. Dubious implies some argument that an action MIGHT be licit or moral, but might not. Are you unsure if the killing of the baby/fetus is wrong or not?
That’s not what was asked; the question was why I referred to “killing of a baby” as a dubious procedure. The question is unanswerable, because I do not accept its semantic premise: the merger of the definitions of baby and fetus.

Killing of a baby–which I define as an infant–is, of course, wrong.

Killing of a fetus could go either way, depending on the circumstances and its development.
 
My definition of 'baby" differs from yours. I view “baby” as a synonym for infant, not fetus. There are important biological and physiological differences between the two which are not bridged by a semantic catchall like “baby”.

Let’s go back to the parasitic/vestigal twin example I posted earlier. Say you have a set of twins. Let’s compare them at six weeks after fertilization, and six weeks after birth.

At six weeks in the womb, a twin is capable of biologically absorbing his counterpart, and coming to term (usually) without any lingering effects. The tissue that was the second twin now resides in the first. Sometimes it’s hidden. Sometime it manifests as extra limbs, or–most horrifically–a severe deformity.

Compare with a pair of infant twins six weeks out of the womb. Try as you might, it’s biologically impossible for one infant–a baby–to absorb another infant.

Biological differences like so are why I don’t use the word “baby” to refer to fetuses.
Fetus and infant refer to stages of human development according to biological science. You may want to consider instead how the term fetus has been transformed into a dehumanizing euphemism rather than argue the semantic use of the word baby let alone on your own terms as if they should apply to who you seek to argue with.
 
Fetus and infant refer to stages of human development according to biological science. You may want to consider instead how the term fetus has been transformed into a dehumanizing euphemism rather than argue the semantic use of the word baby let alone on your own terms as if they should apply to who you seek to argue with.
One, in the absence of a strict definition for “baby”, I don’t see how my terms are any less valid than those of anyone else.

Two, this is an emotionally charged issue, and, like all such issues, emotion tends trumps logic. It leads to rash accusations and bad thinking. The flipside of the use of fetus as a “dehumanizing euphemism” is the use of “baby” as an *anthropomorphizing *euphanism. If I’m going to be accused of supporting the “killing of babies”, then I feel it imperative to figure out what that entails.
 
A functioning brain, a functioning heart, these babies often perhaps always have this.

Already, enough Doctors, let alone Pro-Choicers have called them “babies” in the womb; to come up with the semantics argument between fetus and baby now.
 
A functioning brain, a functioning heart, these babies often perhaps always have this.

Already, enough Doctors, let alone Pro-Choicers have called them “babies” in the womb; to come up with the semantics argument between fetus and baby now.
There may be much less difference than people think. I know people will find this incredible, but I remember being born. I remember right before it too. Now, admittedly, my mother had diabetes and I was “overmature” somewhat. Apparently that’s not uncommon with diabetic mothers. But still. If that’s possible at all (and I’m not the only person who remembers such things) then there’s not a whole lot of difference between a “partial birth abortion” baby and a baby that has been born.
 
There may be much less difference than people think. I know people will find this incredible, but I remember being born. I remember right before it too. Now, admittedly, my mother had diabetes and I was “overmature” somewhat. Apparently that’s not uncommon with diabetic mothers. But still. If that’s possible at all (and I’m not the only person who remembers such things) then there’s not a whole lot of difference between a “partial birth abortion” baby and a baby that has been born.
My brother’s FIL also remembers being born. He says that there were a lot of people talking but he couldn’t understand them because he hadn’t learned the language yet.
 
My brother’s FIL also remembers being born. He says that there were a lot of people talking but he couldn’t understand them because he hadn’t learned the language yet.
No, you don’t remember words. Just sights and other sense impressions. Also, no small amount of anxiety. The memory of it was very vivid and, was scary to me until I was maybe two or three years old.
 
That’s not what was asked; the question was why I referred to “killing of a baby” as a dubious procedure. The question is unanswerable, because I do not accept its semantic premise: the merger of the definitions of baby and fetus.

Killing of a baby–which I define as an infant–is, of course, wrong.

Killing of a fetus could go either way, depending on the circumstances and its development.
What circumstances warrant intentionally killing an innocent human being?
 
What circumstances warrant intentionally killing an innocent human being?
Almost none, of course.

Although, as our definitions of “human” in re: embryo development undoubtedly differ, I imagine any qualifications I might be able to offer would be futile.
 
Almost none, of course.

Although, as our definitions of “human” in re: embryo development undoubtedly differ, I imagine any qualifications I might be able to offer would be futile.
So you refuse to answer my question and give the circumstances when it is okay to intentionally kill an innocent human being?
 
My definition of 'baby" differs from yours.
Ah, you were making two points, then. I see now.
I view “baby” as a synonym for infant, not fetus. There are important biological and physiological differences between the two which are not bridged by a semantic catchall like “baby”.
You can call the status of a person’s humanity a semantic catchall if you wish, but all lines people draw on this matter, even those enshrined in law or formed as medical opinion are value judgments about the different facts available, and as such are subjective.

The reason that is important, is that whether anyone views the human being killed as a human being or not, does not change things for the victim.
 
This is a bit misleading. Nobody is roping women in, impregnating them, and forcing them to have abortions in order to drive the fetal tissue trade. It’s merely the aftereffect of a dubious (yet legal) procedure.
So was making lampshades out of the skin of Jews killed in the death camps . It was merely the aftereffect of a dubious (yet legal) procedure
 
Almost none, of course.

Although, as our definitions of “human” in re: embryo development undoubtedly differ, I imagine any qualifications I might be able to offer would be futile.
History is replete with instances where changing the definition of human was used to justify the killing of millions .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top