Sean Hannity faces-off with Priest who calls him heretic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chrismasfetus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was also blocked from Sean Hannities Forum. I was given the following message:

**You have been banned for the following reason:
contempt of host

Date the ban will be lifted: Never**

All I did was express my displeasure with Sean’s treatment of Father. I did not say anything “crazy”. Also, I put up the following link in my post:

domusdei.org/2007/03/10/sean-hannity-the-heretic

I think it was the link and not anything else I said. Because the posting on Domus Dei really does tell it how it is. The Hannity Forums follow the style of his show… If he doesn’t like what you have to say you will be cut off.
Someone there named suziem called Catholics “so nasty” and “self-righteous” and then she said that Father needs to go to Confession and “shame on all of you.” 😦 She said that Father was the one that attacked Sean. This person is a former Catholic who is now Evangelical. I don’t think that is very Christian of her to behave that way. And yet her post is still there. She attacked Father Euteneuer and her post remains untouched. And yet we cannot say anything about Sean. :whacky: But they don’t care… that is Sean’s forum so of course they will protect him. :rolleyes:
 
I think we need to do some serious counter offensive with regard to Sean Hannity. If this is how he treats those who disagree with him then we should consider starting up a boycott of the advertisers of his show.
Yes this is a good idea. What I don’t like about that is how many people actually boycott advertisers of certain shows? 😦 It’s as if no one cares at all. I am going to boycott. I just hope others will do the same.
 
Arguably the MOST SERIOUS issue facing the Catholic Church is the absolute lack of knowledge by the laity of the basics of Catholicism.

A couple of years ago, Father Benedict Groeschel made this point very strongly at a seminar he gave at my home parish (Our Lady of Mount Carmel) here in Ridgewood, NJ.

The “dumbing down” of American is not confined to our secular educational system with a de-emphasis of math and science and American history. The “dumbing down” is very evident in the lack of basic knowledge of Catholic doctrine.

The famous Baltimore Catechism was thrown overboard. That was the #1 teaching tool of the Catholic Church in the U.S.

Sean Hannity is an average American with a gift of gab whose job requires no dead air time. His job also requires maintaining a certain level of “excitement” [both radio and television] to prevent viewers from changing the station. No boredom allowed for even a second. He is good at his job.

By coincidence, Sean Hannity also happens to be the average American “cradle Catholic”.

It is a miracle that Sean knows as much as he does. But he does not have a lot of “book learning”.

Witness the extreme lengths Sean went to and through during the Terry Schievo case. I apologize for spelling her name incorrectly.] Sean virtually moved his studio to Florida for a week or so. He interviewed EVERYBODY. I would even venture to say that Sean was responsible for the response, however inadequate, by the President and Congress.

When the issue of the illegal border crossings came to light, Sean again relocated his studio to the Southwest of the United States.

I did not “experience” the exchange between himself and Father Euteneur. So I have no idea what nuances took place in the instantaneous need to prevent dead air time and in the exigencies of broadcasting of keeping emotions running on high volume.

But, in my opinion, what we actually experienced was and exchange between a “typical American cradle Catholic” and a Catholic priest who is willing to be a lightning rod.

I am 64 1/2 years old and a cradle American Catholic [and I did have the benefit of the Baltimore Catechism] and I can say that arguably I have only heard the issue of contraception discussed from the pulpit on one or two occasions, at most.

People (particularly American Catholic people) have simply NOT been educated on the whys and wherefores of Catholicism. [Sarcasm: they may have been trained in coloring and making banners, but they sure don’t know much about understanding, or explaining, or defending the Faith.]

Sean merely illustrated and demonstrated for us how little we really have been educated … about how little we really know. And how far we have fallen … and how much remedial work we need to do to merely get back to where we were in the 1950’s.
 
Your post here would be good on Sean’s “Religion Forum.” I started a thread over there. Maybe you could put your links in a reply post over there? 🙂 But be careful in mentioning Sean’s name. I don’t want my thread over there to be closed the way the other thread was.
Alegre, I just finished reading through that thread - good job by you and all the others who witnessed so well there to the Catholic Faith. 👍 (I hope Sean is paying attention. :gopray: )
 
Sean merely illustrated and demonstrated for us how little we really have been educated … about how little we really know. And how far we have fallen … and how much remedial work we need to do to merely get back to where we were in the 1950’s.
well said, “young” man…👍 👍
 
Alegre, I just finished reading through that thread - good job by you and all the others who witnessed so well there to the Catholic Faith. 👍 (I hope Sean is paying attention. :gopray: )
Thanks :o All Glory to God! :gopray2:

I’m just wondering if anyone here has registered over there to post their good “arguments” along with links they gave, so that they can see all the great things out there to learn. 😦
 
All I have to say is Sean Hannity should hang his head in shame at the way he treated FR. E on his show. Shame on Him!!!😦
 
Arguably the MOST SERIOUS issue facing the Catholic Church is the absolute lack of knowledge by the laity of the basics of Catholicism.

A couple of years ago, Father Benedict Groeschel made this point very strongly at a seminar he gave at my home parish (Our Lady of Mount Carmel) here in Ridgewood, NJ.

The “dumbing down” of American is not confined to our secular educational system with a de-emphasis of math and science and American history. The “dumbing down” is very evident in the lack of basic knowledge of Catholic doctrine.

The famous Baltimore Catechism was thrown overboard. That was the #1 teaching tool of the Catholic Church in the U.S.

Sean Hannity is an average American with a gift of gab whose job requires no dead air time. His job also requires maintaining a certain level of “excitement” [both radio and television] to prevent viewers from changing the station. No boredom allowed for even a second. He is good at his job.

By coincidence, Sean Hannity also happens to be the average American “cradle Catholic”.

It is a miracle that Sean knows as much as he does. But he does not have a lot of “book learning”.

Witness the extreme lengths Sean went to and through during the Terry Schievo case. I apologize for spelling her name incorrectly.] Sean virtually moved his studio to Florida for a week or so. He interviewed EVERYBODY. I would even venture to say that Sean was responsible for the response, however inadequate, by the President and Congress.

When the issue of the illegal border crossings came to light, Sean again relocated his studio to the Southwest of the United States.

I did not “experience” the exchange between himself and Father Euteneur. So I have no idea what nuances took place in the instantaneous need to prevent dead air time and in the exigencies of broadcasting of keeping emotions running on high volume.

But, in my opinion, what we actually experienced was and exchange between a “typical American cradle Catholic” and a Catholic priest who is willing to be a lightning rod.

I am 64 1/2 years old and a cradle American Catholic [and I did have the benefit of the Baltimore Catechism] and I can say that arguably I have only heard the issue of contraception discussed from the pulpit on one or two occasions, at most.

People (particularly American Catholic people) have simply NOT been educated on the whys and wherefores of Catholicism. [Sarcasm: they may have been trained in coloring and making banners, but they sure don’t know much about understanding, or explaining, or defending the Faith.]

Sean merely illustrated and demonstrated for us how little we really have been educated … about how little we really know. And how far we have fallen … and how much remedial work we need to do to merely get back to where we were in the 1950’s.
Good thoughts. The schools miss the good sisters who taught in your day and mine. Even the years I was away from the Church, I could still recite the catechism word for word. We learned what the Church taught in those days. I often see questions from people on this forum asking questions they should know the answers to already. I don’t blame them, I blame whatever system they are in that does not educate. They are missing so much. And talk about defending the faith, my first quarter in college (we were on that system then), in English 101, the instructor had us write an essay on why we believed in God, and if we did not, why not? My paper came back with the notation that although he did not agree with me, the paper was well thought out and well phrased. I got an A. That would never have happened without twelve years of excellent Catholic education.
 
I decided to post on his (Seans) forum, in the ‘Religious’ section…yes he has a religious section.
Saul,Saul,Why do you persecute me? Acts 9:4
Sean, Sean,
Why do you persecute me? (Luk 10:16 Jesus said to his disciples, "Whoever listens to you listens to me; whoever rejects you rejects me; and whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me.)
Sean,
You claim to be a faithful Catholic, yet you publicly defend artifical birthcontrol for ‘non-catholics’(as an alternative to abortion…both are“intrinsically evil” C.C.C. 2370).
I invite you, as a fellow Catholic, to read or re-read Humanae Vitae by Pope Paul VI or Theology of the Body by Pope John Paul II or perhaps even the Catechism of the Catholic Church. These men have authority to teach the truth. Do you? Truly, you do not persume to know more then these men, do you?
You state that you went to seminary, that may be true, I don’t dispute that…just what you may have learned or rather what you misinterpreted as being Catholic teaching. I think you should apologize to Fr. Euteneuer for the disrespectful manner in how you treated an ordained priest who was trying to admonish you for your display in faithlessness. *Luk 10:16 Jesus said to his disciples(i.e. members and teachers of the Ecclesia or Church), "Whoever listens to you listens to me; whoever rejects you rejects me; and whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me *
…Luk 6:37 “Do not judge others, and God will not judge you; do not condemn others, and God will not condemn you; forgive others, and God will forgive you.”
However, Sean, we are called to make rational and moral judgements everyday as parent, children and as Christians. Be very careful as to what you condone or more accurately grant license to.
When I tried to see who responded, I couldn’t find my post. I did a search and found that I have been banned from Sean Hannity’s forum:
vBulletin Message
You have been banned for the following reason:
No reason was specified.
Date the ban will be lifted: Never
I guess Sean Hannity’s fair and balanced reporting only allows what he wants to allow.

Scott
 
Good thoughts. The schools miss the good sisters who taught in your day and mine. Even the years I was away from the Church, I could still recite the catechism word for word. We learned what the Church taught in those days. I often see questions from people on this forum asking questions they should know the answers to already. I don’t blame them, I blame whatever system they are in that does not educate. They are missing so much. And talk about defending the faith, my first quarter in college (we were on that system then), in English 101, the instructor had us write an essay on why we believed in God, and if we did not, why not? My paper came back with the notation that although he did not agree with me, the paper was well thought out and well phrased. I got an A. That would never have happened without twelve years of excellent Catholic education.
The Sisters are on their way back…

Dominican Sisters of Mary (Average Age: 24) Grown 1800% Over Last 9 Years (VIDEO)!

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=133476
 
**MAN THAT VIDEO ROCKS!!!

IT JUST CHEERED UP MY WHOLE WEEKEND!**

It just chaps my hide to hear someone who skewers hypocrits as much as Hannity does just do the liberal dance…

What a damned fool…
 
Thanks :o All Glory to God! :gopray2:

I’m just wondering if anyone here has registered over there to post their good “arguments” along with links they gave, so that they can see all the great things out there to learn. 😦
Sandy, you are a credit to your faith. I feel very sad for those in the Hannity Forum who judge you as “self-righteous”, as they are so far away from God’s Love, that they percieve it as an insult when it’s right in front of their face. How very very sad!

I registered yesterday. I hope I can be at least a little help. Don’t give up, and don’t be offended when your love is thrown back at you as some sort of trash. Christ suffered similarly. You are blessed to suffer persecution in His name!
 
First, I watched the whole show the other day and was shocked to hear that a priest would be coming on to condemn Mr. Hannity. He is a great voice for those issues that Catholics try to get across in today’s world. He has a lot of influence and compared to many other voices in today’s world, he is on the top in the mainstream media for speaking the Truth.

Second, He is not a heretic. Something must be defined as infallible and although birth control is said to be declared as such by some, others continue to say it is not. The Church has yet to clearly state whether this is an infallible dogma from what I have found and read(I may be wrong), so therefore, Mr. Hannity is being disobedient to the Church but not spreading heresy. Father Euteneuer does many great things but went about it all wrong. He should not have gone on his show and make the Church come off as it did. As I watched it, I was mad not at Sean but at the whole situation! That is a poor pastoral decision on how it was done. I also strongly disagree with Father stating he would deny him communion. For a situation like this, without clear evidence of Sean’s beliefs concerning Birth Control, I would say the priest cannot declare in the way he did, that he would deny him communion. If the Bishops do not have clear method to how they handle pro-abortion candidates, how is a priest to make such a rash decision on a public figure such as Mr. Hannity without clear concrete evidence on his true beliefs.

I think the segment hurt the image of the Church and if anything, would make people turn away from the Church.

Thirdly, I did disagree with how Mr. Hannity handled it as well. Involved the sex scandal, holding his seminary studies in such high esteem was the wrong way to interact with Father at the time. I think both handled it poorly and it hurt both sides of the issue.

I pray for both Mr. Hannity and Father Euteneuer.
 
He should not have gone on his show and make the Church come off as it did. As I watched it, I was mad not at Sean but at the whole situation! That is a poor pastoral decision on how it was done.
I understand your initial response but may I suggest you watch the video again. Sean made public statements regarding his position of ABC. Fr. E responded in a column he wrote and posted on the League website. Sean then invited him on the show. I believe that when the disagreement or dissent is public and has the potential to cause scandal, it should be addressed publicly. You yourself state that Sean reaches many people with his show. His misrepresentation of what it is to be Catholic also reached many people. I think Fr. was correct in appearing because it gave them both a chance to have, what could have been, a lively debate in public and possibly illuminate many minds. If the debate deteriorated, I blame Mr. Hannity. Father did his best to stay on topic while Sean continued to lob offensive non sequiturs at him.
For a situation like this, without clear evidence of Sean’s beliefs concerning Birth Control, I would say the priest cannot declare in the way he did, that he would deny him communion.
The clear evidence was Sean actually saying it during the interview. What other evidence could be needed? The fact that Sean was arguing his point was the evidence. In addition, Father was not the one who brought up denying Communion. That was a taunt and provocation from Sean. How else could Father have answered? I think it took great courage for Fr. E. to stand firm.
 
I think it’s totally possible that Sean wanted the priest to go on the air and say that…for ratings and such…

Honestly, hopefully watching Sean will make those Catholics who listened to Sean on Iraq and not the Pope (JPII and Pope Benedict twice).
 
Second, He is not a heretic. Something must be defined as infallible and although birth control is said to be declared as such by some, others continue to say it is not…
Who says it’s not? What’s all the arguing about then? I left the church in my early twenties because I was practicing ABC. I wasn’t even a confirmed Catholic, but I knew what the church teaches on this subject. The Catholic church is being totally beaten up over not allowing the distribution or condoms in Africa for the prevention of AIDS. So what’s the problem if no one’s said that ABC is not acceptable? Heresy is “the opinion or doctrine at variance with the orthodox or accepted doctrine, esp. of a church or religious system.” The “accepted” doctrine of the church is that ABC is not acceptable. So Sean Hannity, professing himself to be a Catholic, and also professing ABC to be acceptable is by definition a heretic.
 
sean hannity is a moron when it comes to his catholic faith’s teaching on sexuality. i hear the same arguments by people in my family. doesn’t surprise me much, being the neocon that he is.

he showed no respect to the priest. he made himself look like a total jerk.

fr. euteneuer is awesome. i like how he said he would deny him communion. if only all priests could be so prudent.

youtube.com/watch?v=f50fD5elrcg&mode=related&search=
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top