Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My sentiments exactly. Obama should be embarrassed by his adolescent response to not getting his way. I’ve seen five year olds who showed more maturity.

Lisa
His supporters should be embarrased as well.
 
meltzerboy are you in the straitjacket of ideology? Do you understand that the bill would not address the problems of a Sandy Hook? Do you realize that legislation would be an immediate target for the courts? What would be the point other than to pander to POTUS who thankfully is bleeding out influence?

Rep Diaz is right, we have no respect for life and this is manifested in many ways including gun violence. The turning needs to be of the mind and heart, not the choice of weapon.

Lisa
I think the turning needs to be both: mind and heart can certainly influence behavior, but the reverse is true as well. Sometimes we cannot wait for the mind and heart to change: for example, had anti-discrimination legislation waited for the mind and heart to change, it would have been a very long wait.
 
I think the turning needs to be both: mind and heart can certainly influence behavior, but the reverse is true as well. Sometimes we cannot wait for the mind and heart to change: for example, had anti-discrimination legislation waited for the mind and heart to change, it would have been a very long wait.
No disagreement there but the point is that doing “something” seemed to be the objective as if it were more important to be seen as responding than responding effectively. This law did not respond to the problem. Like most politicians, Toomey and Manchion seemed to lose sight of the objective in the quest to get a bill to the floor. When you have no target, it’s hard to get a bullseye
Lisa
 
No disagreement there but the point is that doing “something” seemed to be the objective as if it were more important to be seen as responding than responding effectively. This law did not respond to the problem. Like most politicians, Toomey and Manchion seemed to lose sight of the objective in the quest to get a bill to the floor. When you have no target, it’s hard to get a bullseye
Lisa
Agreed.

Obama wanted anything labeled “Gun Bill” passed and put on his desk for signing. It didn’t matter what it actually did. I remember years back when the “Assault Weapons Ban” was passed. A democrat congressman was being interviewed and was asked how much this bill would help fight crime. Surprisingly he admitted it would do nothing to fight crime but it would show that the government was willing to act. I guess he didn’t see how showing the government was willing to act in an ineffective and useless manner wouldn’t help either.
 
Every time one of these mass shootings happen, every time a criminal breaks the law using a gun, laws are already being broken. Would that one more law have made a difference? One more ineffective law? No. All that ‘gun control’ stuff is a joke, and just a power grab to steal individual liberty and rights from American citizens.
 
I thought the POTUS was scolding Washington, not the American people. And rightly so!
Obama showed his true colors today. How dare the senate disagree with “the one” ? By attacking not his opponents’ arguments but their motives - by saying, “those who disagree with me are operating from bad motives and petty politics” he is guaranteeing that they won’t work with him again on this issue. Which is fine with me - incidentally. Clearly, Obama is angling for a Democrat victory in the midterms - Democrat House and avoid a GOP controlled senate. But he has to be disappointed at letting a tragedy like the Newtown massacre go to waste. Rahm Emmanuel must be pretty disappointed in Obama right now.

What a president we have.

Ishii
 
Obama, in chastising the Senate is doing nothing more than following the demogog’s rule of never allowing a crisis go to waste.
Apart from that, my opposition to him and his ilk is a firm belief that any American politician who wants to amend or otherwise tamper with any part of the Bill of Rights of our Constitution, should forfeit any possibility of holding public office.
The Second Amendment, in particular, was adopted for that very reason, and the argument that armed citizens could not be successful against a modern army equiped with tanks and aircraft doe not hold water.
If there were a revolt against a tyrant who usurped the Federal Government in the US, the desertion rate of the Army and Marine Corps would be astounding! I doubt seriously if the Armed Forces as we know them today would fire on their fellow citizens.
Never forget, that just before the Civil War began, the Northern Army and Navy lost over 50% of its officers and top NCO’s to the Confederacy. Do not think it couldn’t happen again, or do you really believe that history never repeats itself.
 
Obama, in chastising the Senate is doing nothing more than following the demogog’s rule of never allowing a crisis go to waste.
Apart from that, my opposition to him and his ilk is a firm belief that any American politician who wants to amend or otherwise tamper with any part of the Bill of Rights of our Constitution, should forfeit any possibility of holding public office.
The Second Amendment, in particular, was adopted for that very reason, and the argument that armed citizens could not be successful against a modern army equiped with tanks and aircraft doe not hold water.
If there were a revolt against a tyrant who usurped the Federal Government in the US, the desertion rate of the Army and Marine Corps would be astounding! I doubt seriously if the Armed Forces as we know them today would fire on their fellow citizens.
Never forget, that just before the Civil War began, the Northern Army and Navy lost over 50% of its officers and top NCO’s to the Confederacy. Do not think it couldn’t happen again, or do you really believe that history never repeats itself.
And maybe not just against a tyrant. The City of Boston and nearby towns are “locked down”. People are locked in their homes. Kids didn’t go to school. And all because a terrorist killer is scampering about the neighborhoods and probably enough armed law enforcement personnel to conquer a small country can’t find him. One really wonders how many of the residents of those neighborhoods have kept whatever arms they had handy, or, having none, wish they did.

And how many people across the nation are going to consider how they might feel in a similar circumstance, however improbable it might be. Personally, I think “gun control” is a dead letter for now.
 
And maybe not just against a tyrant. The City of Boston and nearby towns are “locked down”. People are locked in their homes. Kids didn’t go to school. And all because a terrorist killer is scampering about the neighborhoods and probably enough armed law enforcement personnel to conquer a small country can’t find him. One really wonders how many of the residents of those neighborhoods have kept whatever arms they had handy, or, having none, wish they did.

And how many people across the nation are going to consider how they might feel in a similar circumstance, however improbable it might be. Personally, I think “gun control” is a dead letter for now.
Me too. As several posters have noted, a crisis gone to waste! If anything the Boston bombing only reinforced the realization that the police and first responders however capable and dedicated cannot be everywhere.

Further and more important, trying to infringe upon the right to keep and bear arms doesn’t play well in this country. The more power they try to grab, the more suspicious we become. The more they interfere in our lives, the more we realize we have to stop every attempt at getting more and more control over our every move.

All of the new proposals did nothing but harrass law abiding citizens. They don’t bother to prosecute those who try to buy guns illegally…they don’t care about getting the bad guys when they’ve all but said come and get me. So why do they think it’s appropriate to tell people what to do with their personal propery.

Obama showed his true self once again. A petty little tyrant having a tantrum that would two year old’s to shame. As ishii said, what a president we have!

Lisa
 
Me too. As several posters have noted, a crisis gone to waste! If anything the Boston bombing only reinforced the realization that the police and first responders however capable and dedicated cannot be everywhere.

Further and more important, trying to infringe upon the right to keep and bear arms doesn’t play well in this country. The more power they try to grab, the more suspicious we become. The more they interfere in our lives, the more we realize we have to stop every attempt at getting more and more control over our every move.

All of the new proposals did nothing but harrass law abiding citizens. They don’t bother to prosecute those who try to buy guns illegally…they don’t care about getting the bad guys when they’ve all but said come and get me. So why do they think it’s appropriate to tell people what to do with their personal propery.

Obama showed his true self once again. A petty little tyrant having a tantrum that would two year old’s to shame. As ishii said, what a president we have!

Lisa
Lisa, are you and others also not a little guilty of never letting a word uttered by Obama without being critical of him go to waste? Insofar as citizens having had guns to protect themselves from these terrorists, I can just imagine what a scene that may have been if frightened people in their homes started firing at whoever knocked on their door or was on the streets and looked suspicious. Total pandemonium.
 
Not one incident, nor any Islamic hate recorded. Well done I have to say. 😉
 
Lisa, are you and others also not a little guilty of never letting a word uttered by Obama without being critical of him go to waste? Insofar as citizens having had guns to protect themselves from these terrorists, I can just imagine what a scene that may have been if frightened people in their homes started firing at whoever knocked on their door or was on the streets and looked suspicious. Total pandemonium.
Why? Because every word he utters is calculated for political effect and driving his agenda which is at odds with our values. I was specifically referring to his response to the senate gun bill - trotting out relatives of the victims of Newtown for maximum photo-op effect. He and the gun-control folks tried to use the Newtown massacre as a springboard for reversing the public support for gun rights in this country. By failing to exploit this tragedy, he certainly let the crisis go to waste. Why, when this president is all about using crises to exploit his agenda, and when his agenda is so opposed to our values, would we cut him any slack?

Ishii
 
Why? Because every word he utters is calculated for political effect and driving his agenda which is at odds with our values. I was specifically referring to his response to the senate gun bill - trotting out relatives of the victims of Newtown for maximum photo-op effect. He and the gun-control folks tried to use the Newtown massacre as a springboard for reversing the public support for gun rights in this country. By failing to exploit this tragedy, he certainly let the crisis go to waste. Why, when this president is all about using crises to exploit his agenda, and when his agenda is so opposed to our values, would we cut him any slack?

Ishii
So many are saying that this is a crisis wasted. You don’t really think this is over do you? Polls indicate overwhelming support for improved background checks. The devil will be in the details, but I see that eventually passing.
In fact, the 45 who voted against this bill have given the President a very nice weapon to use when the next mass murder occurs.
BTW, I don’t support anything but the background check provision. Closing loophole and stricter enforcement of the present system are two things I can get behind.
 
So many are saying that this is a crisis wasted. You don’t really think this is over do you? Polls indicate overwhelming support for improved background checks. The devil will be in the details, but I see that eventually passing.
In fact, the 45 who voted against this bill have given the President a very nice weapon to use when the next mass murder occurs.
BTW, I don’t support anything but the background check provision. Closing loophole and stricter enforcement of the present system are two things I can get behind.
Hmm. Interesting take. I think the momentum for new regulations might be on the wane. That’s why I say he wasted a crisis. But as you say - there will be more.

Ishii
 
Me too. As several posters have noted, a crisis gone to waste! If anything the Boston bombing only reinforced the realization that the police and first responders however capable and dedicated cannot be everywhere.

Further and more important, trying to infringe upon the right to keep and bear arms doesn’t play well in this country. The more power they try to grab, the more suspicious we become. The more they interfere in our lives, the more we realize we have to stop every attempt at getting more and more control over our every move.

All of the new proposals did nothing but harrass law abiding citizens. They don’t bother to prosecute those who try to buy guns illegally…they don’t care about getting the bad guys when they’ve all but said come and get me. So why do they think it’s appropriate to tell people what to do with their personal propery.

Obama showed his true self once again. A petty little tyrant having a tantrum that would two year old’s to shame. As ishii said, what a president we have!

Lisa
Very well said.👍
 
I noticed that many of you have pointed out the fact that many criminals who commit crimes with guns do not obtain them through legal means and that is a good point that you have brought up. But since it is indeed the case that they obtain them via illegal means then would it not also follow that we should crack down on the black market for guns and do other things to make it far more difficult for people to obtain them illegally?
 
I noticed that many of you have pointed out the fact that many criminals who commit crimes with guns do not obtain them through legal means and that is a good point that you have brought up. But since it is indeed the case that they obtain them via illegal means then would it not also follow that we should crack down on the black market for guns and do other things to make it far more difficult for people to obtain them illegally?
Holly,

There is a black market for cocaine.

But anyone can buy cocaine.

Cocaine is smuggled into the United States from all over the world.

The crack downs only allow for selective enforcement … usually against law-abiding citizens who have not read every word of the law. It is easier to prosecute someone for a “process crime” … your registration is out of date by a couple of days, for example … by creating new categories of crime … than to actually get people who commit violent crimes.
 
I just did a Google search on Catholic teaching and gun control and I came up with a few links that I thought might be of interest to you all on where the Church stands on gun control.

Here is a sampling of statements which are from the USCCB on gun control:

nccbuscc.org/sdwp/national/criminal/gunsample.shtml

Here is a short article on handgun violence which also addresses gun control:

nccbuscc.org/sdwp/national/criminal/handguns.shtml

Here is a link from the Vatican’s news site:

news.va/en/news/usccb-on-gun-control-need-to-confront-the-culture

Now, don’t get me wrong here, I am not saying that the Magisterium teaches in favor of gun control. However, I am also not saying the opposite. From what I can tell, Catholics are free to take whatever position they wish on gun control. However, I still think it would be wise to listen to what our bishops have to say.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top