Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Holly,

There is a black market for cocaine.

But anyone can buy cocaine.

Cocaine is smuggled into the United States from all over the world.

The crack downs only allow for selective enforcement … usually against law-abiding citizens who have not read every word of the law. It is easier to prosecute someone for a “process crime” … your registration is out of date by a couple of days, for example … by creating new categories of crime … than to actually get people who commit violent crimes.
Monte, I wasn’t advocating Pharisaical enforcement of the laws. When I said crackdowns I basically mean that perhaps the government needs to work on shutting down the black market for guns. I would say the same for the black market in illegal drugs. It needs to be shut down.
 
Monte, I wasn’t advocating Pharisaical enforcement of the laws. When I said crackdowns I basically mean that perhaps the government needs to work on shutting down the black market for guns. I would say the same for the black market in illegal drugs. It needs to be shut down.
How do you shut down the black market.

Ishii
 
Monte, I wasn’t advocating Pharisaical enforcement of the laws. When I said crackdowns I basically mean that perhaps the government needs to work on shutting down the black market for guns. I would say the same for the black market in illegal drugs. It needs to be shut down.
Fast and Furious.
 
I am not an expert on that. I would have to leave that up to the experts.
Holly,

Unfortunately, the experts have failed over and over … every time they try, they fail.

They have tried over and over to shut down black markets … never been successful

Consider this: cocaine is not only illegal, but has to be imported from foreign countries. And yet … cocaine is freely available on the black market. There is a huge network of smugglers and distributors who are exceptionally successful at evading the law … which is very severe. And yet the criminals are overwhelming successful at continuing to smuggle in, distribute and supply cocaine to anyone who wants it.

The United States even had a Constitutional Amendment that prohibited alcohol … and evasion was so successful, that we ended up not only not banning alcohol, but we ended up with the creation of a huge organized crime structure that began to dominate many other forms of crime as well.

Guns are even easier to obtain that cocaine … anyone can manufacture a gun in their basement or garage. It is extremely easy. And they can also be smuggled in [as they probably are already … China actually got caught in one instance when a whole forty foot long container of machine guns was detected … but there is no telling how many other containers made it through.]

It is nice to believe that black markets can be stopped, but it is just not possible.

Think of all the other black markets that exist. Human trafficking is the biggest, along with rare animals, snakes & birds, and also Freon [believe it or not].

The easiest way to prevent gun violence such as those mass killings is to take down all those “gun free zone” signs … which are really fantasy wish list items … all they do is attract nutjobs who are searching for victims.

Those mass killers planned their attacks for two to three years and deliberately sought out places where their victims would be unprotected.

Consider this: would you put a sign in front of your house that said, “I am an unprotected victim; no guns here”? Of course not; that would be just inviting trouble. Instead you put a picture of a vicious dog and a sign that you are protected by all kinds of devices.
 
Holly,

I looked on-line and there are many different lists of things that are smuggled … illegal black market items. There is just no stopping it.

Unstoppable, no matter how hard the experts try … the illegal stuff always gets through.

In fact one guy got eight years in prison for LEGALLY importing fish. They got him on some ridiculous technicality about the size of the plastic bag that the fish was packed in or some absurd “process crime”. They can’t stop cocaine or human trafficking, so they go after legal fish.

Here is one of the lists.

VALUE in U.S. DOLLARS
Counterfeit Drugs$200 Billion
Prostitution$187.17 Billion
Counterfeit Electronics$169 Billion
Marijuana$141.80 Billion
Illegal Gambling$140 Billion
Cocaine$85 Billion
Prescription Drugs $72.5 Billion
Heroin$68 Billion
Software Piracy$63 Billion
Oil Theft$53.64 Billion
Illegal Tobacco$50 Billion
Counterfeit Foods$49 Billion
Counterfeit Auto Parts$45 Billion
Counterfeit Toys$34 Billion
Human Trafficking$32 Billion
Illegal Logging$30 Billion
Methamphetamine$28.25 Billion
Illegal Fishing$23.5 Billion
Human Smuggling$20 Billion
Wildlife Trafficking$19 Billion
Ecstasy$16.07 Billion
Music Piracy$12.5 Billion
Counterfeit Shoes$12 Billion
Counterfeit Clothing$12 Billion
Waste Dumping$11 Billion
Art Theft$10 Billion
Cable Piracy$8.5 Billion
Video Game Piracy$8.1 Billion
Counterfeit Sporting Goods$6.5 Billion
Counterfeit Pesticides$5.8 Billion
Bootlegging$4.3 Billion
Mobile Entertainment Piracy$3.4 Billion
Counterfeit Cosmetics$3.0 Billion
Movie Piracy$2.5 Billion
Metals and Minerals Smuggling$2.3 Billion
Counterfeit Aircraft Parts$2 Billion
Counterfeit Weapons$1.8 Billion
Kidnap and Ransom$1.5 Billion
International Adoptions$1.3 Billion
Fake Diplomas and Degrees$1 Billion
Arms Trafficking$1 Billion
Counterfeit Watches$1 Billion
Book Piracy$0.6 Billion ($600 Million)
Counterfeit Money$0.182 Billion ($182 Million)
Nuclear Smuggling$0.1 Billion ($100 Million)
Counterfeit IDs and Passports$0.1 Billion ($100 Million)
Organ Trafficking$0.075 Billion ($75 Million)
Counterfeit Purses$0.07 Billion ($70 Million)
Counterfeit Lighters$0.042 Billion ($42 Million)
Counterfeit Batteries$0.023 Billion ($23 Million)
 
I am not an expert on that. I would have to leave that up to the experts.
Just so you have more data.

In regulating the black market production for drugs, there are certain source materials, such as the raw drug itself that can be interdicted. We can, for example, limit the importation of poppy for heroin production
And, in general, a high degree of knowledge on chemistry is required to isolate the desired product.

In firearms, the raw materials are steel and brass. Good steel can be cheaply and easily obtained, even in your local junkyard.

The tools needed can be obtained at a decent hardware shop such as Home Depot or Lowes.

The skills needed can be obtained in any high school shop class
I, for example, made a replica Elizabethan era flintlock, machining all the parts and carving the stock.

It would have been actually easier for me to make a revolver.

In WW-II, the British designed a sub-machine gun, the Sten, that was specifically designed to be manufactured in garage shops. Again, just about anyone with access to a good hardware store could built one

Here are the plans
scribd.com/doc/2624298/sten-mk2-complete-machine-instructions

And then, we can add 3-D printing to that. That is a new technology where highly detailed 3-D object can be ‘printed’ off using polymer jets, or for advanced units, aluminum powder and lasers.

With one of these units, which can even be hobbyist build, you can print off an AR-15 or a high capacity mags in your basement overnight. Make a few extra to give to your friends.

nationalreview.com/the-feed/312458/man-creates-working-ar-15-3d-printer
forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/01/14/gunsmiths-3d-print-high-capacity-ammo-clips-to-thwart-proposed-gun-laws/

None of the firearms I mentioned above would be even traceable by Fed agencies, as they would have no serial numbers and no record of manufacture and original sale.

So what ideas would you offer to the experts to combat this?
 
Oh yea,

As you are probably aware, there are a number of jurisdictions ( municipalities, even States) that have passed laws allowing for the production of marijuana for medical purposes.

This is, of course, still in violation of Federal law, but it has the effect of removing any assistance to Federal drug officers by local law enforcement.

What would stop a municipality or even a State from doing something similar with firearms, to allow their production for ‘sporting purposes’, 3-D printed or garage manufacturing of local firearms.

That would, of course, still be in violation of Federal law, in much the same way ‘medical marijuana’ is in violation, but enforcement becomes almost impossible without the aid of local police.
 
Lisa, are you and others also not a little guilty of never letting a word uttered by Obama without being critical of him go to waste? Insofar as citizens having had guns to protect themselves from these terrorists, I can just imagine what a scene that may have been if frightened people in their homes started firing at whoever knocked on their door or was on the streets and looked suspicious. Total pandemonium.
Meltzerboy you are right as I have rarely found anything Obama says to be anything but a poltically motivated, carefully staged (props from Sandy Hook parents to doctors in fake white coats) and emotionally driven propaganda. The whole Sandy Hook exploitation was particularly disgraceful as nothing proposed would have done a THING to have prevented this tragedy…even DiFi admitted as much. A troubled young man with a mother who showed incredibly poor judgement would be difficult to legislate away!

Further irony is that after Sandy Hook a number of gun manufacturers having been demonized by Obama and CT’s governor announced plans to move their companies and jobs elsewhere. CT governor responds by begging them to stay and produce guns that can no longer be purchased by CT’s citizens but hey fine to let the rest of America shoot each other. The hypocrisy has been raised to an art form. We want the jobs and the taxes you pay but take your filthy product elsewhere…blech! You wonder why their noses don’t grow so far as to knock down the TV cameras.

The recent bill that went down had a number of hidden problems such as gun show background checks taking precedence over storefront checks. According to the industry group representing firearms manufacturers (who obviously has an agenda) the bill served to allow gun show checks to basically stop storefront checks done by the same seller. Given that gun shows and storefront sales operate simultaneously, the problems were clear to that segment of our economy…which IS substantial btw and Obama has been the best thing for gun sales since 9/11. Further although there were a number of exceptions to prevent the issue of a dad selling his son an old hunting rifle, I heard this portion of the bill read aloud and it was mind numbingly complex.

The point is what IS the point? Further that the Obama Justice Department has failed to even pretend they are following up on those who already fail background checks (some 44000 per year with only 44 prosecutions at last reporting) and that cities like Chicago with tight gun laws have among the highest in gun violence events, demonstrates that Obama isn’t the slightest bit interested in “saving the children” but in obtaining political advantage.

Lisa
 
The spineless senators who voted against reforming the crazy gun laws because they have not the guts to stand up to the NRA lobby should crawl into a corner and stay there for being the cowards they are .

DAMN THE SECOND AMENDMENT !
 
The spineless senators who voted against reforming the crazy gun laws because they have not the guts to stand up to the NRA lobby should crawl into a corner and stay there for being the cowards they are .

DAMN THE SECOND AMENDMENT !
We have limitations and restrictions to the First Amendment regarding freedom of speech and freedom of the press. What makes the Second Amendment holier than the First?
 
We have limitations and restrictions to the First Amendment regarding freedom of speech and freedom of the press. What makes the Second Amendment holier than the First?
The wording of the two amendments is completely different.

Amendment I

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Amendment II

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

AND … furthermore … guns have their OWN amendment all to themselves … guns are a totally special case … whereas religion, speech, assembly and lobbying are lumped together.

In addition, the Federalist Papers which were written to explain these Bill of Rights issues, go into huge elaborate detail to explain what is meant by them.
 
What Pat Toomey’s bipartisan work on background checks could mean for him
WASHINGTON – The Senate’s rejection of a plan to expand background checks for gun purchasers was a public policy failure but not necessarily a political one for Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey, who bucked his party to sponsor the legislation.
The first-term Republican’s attempts to bridge the policy gap endeared him to moderates and Democrats even as it alienated him from conservatives who now are angry, disappointed and pledging to hasten his ouster at re-election time in 2016.
Read more: post-gazette.com/stories/news/us/what-pat-toomeys-bipartisan-work-on-background-checks-could-mean-for-him-684390/#ixzz2R9Gv6KME
 
Perhaps Washington needs 20 more children to die. Shameful!
The majority of Senators and the vast majority of Democrats did support the expanded background checks. But the vast majority of Republicans were opposed and thus that vote fell short of the required 60 vote super majority. Just another example of the minority obstructing not only the will of the majority of the Senate but the will of the majority of the American people. Even though polls showed vast majorities of the American people in support of the background checks, Republicans may fear more drawing primary election opposition from right wing extremists and are instead willing to take their chances in a general election.

But my thought as well was how many more people who have been born into this world, innocent adults and children, need to be massacred on our streets, in movie theaters, in schools, etc. If the legislation had saved one such life, it would have been worth it. And if gun proponents are law abiding citizens of sound mind who can pass a background check, they should have nothing to fear.

Indeed I agree shameful and a sad day in America. Peace.
 
There is nothing at all wrong with that. The slippery-slope argument is not applicable to everything. As President Obama said: “This is a pretty shameful day for Washington.” And, I might add, a bad day for our country.
Agreed meltzerboy.
 
I don’t know if the legislation would have helped in the specific case of Adam Lanza, but, weak as it was, it may have helped save lives in other situations, and even if only a few lives had been saved at virtually no cost to law-abiding gun owners, it would have been worth it.
Amen
 
Apparently there is no “Big Tent” or room for compromise in either political party. To paraphrase what other posters have said about Obama, what a Congress we have!
It’s really sad. Toomey’s action is not going to swing me into his column, but he has gained a great deal of respect from me…it was a gutsy move that he must sincerely believe in, because, politically, it verges on suicide. The GOP members who are slamming him are very likely to ensure that PA will have two Democratic senators.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top