Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, of course. Women should be locked up because they are just as dangerous as guns or, as you say, liable to be raped. It’s for their own safety as well as the public good. And household utensils (i.e. knives) should also be locked up because they may be stolen. Apples and oranges are both fruits; therefore apples ARE oranges.
So some constitutional rights are less equal than others?

Given the fact that over 20% of women are sexually assualted in their lifetime the proposal that they be kept safe should be considered.
 
So some constitutional rights are less equal than others?

Given the fact that over 20% of women are sexually assualted in their lifetime the proposal that they be kept safe should be considered.
So you’re saying that one’s right to display a weapon in one’s car, rather than hiding it from the view of possible criminals, is just as inalienable as one’s right not to be limited in freedom as a woman, even though one may become the target of rape. The same principle of freedom applies to people who carry guns as to women. And thus guns and women are equivalent means by which criminals commit crimes. I just want to make sure I understand your argument.
 
I think there is a slippery slope possibility in either direction with regard to both too much gun control and too little gun control.
How about EFFECTIVE gun control?

Again would you, whom I think of as a thoughtful person, please address the many facts posted regarding our current laws, that they are not being enforced, that the proposals would not have stopped any of the mass shooters, that “gun free zones” seem to be more of an attraction than a deterrent, that concealed carry laws have allowed responsible citizens to deal with or stop crime? What about the mental health issue? I believe you are a professional in mental health/psychiatry aren’t you? What about the explosion in use of psychtropic drugs to treat disturbed young men? What about DiFi’s admission that her proposals wouldn’t have stopped the Newtown Shooter?

The other element in the room is the profile of the victims. Apparently killing young people weekly in gang banger shootings doesn’t even warrent a comment. The shooters and the victims tend to be poor and members of minority groups. However should some upper class cute white kids get killed by another upper class white kid, it’s pull out all the stops to restrict gun ownership. Oddly our black President, a former resident of Chicago, can’t be bothered to address gun violence in his own city directed toward (and by) people of his own minority status. Go figure:shrug:

I just bet that 99.99% of Americans are for gun control if it means guns are not available to criminals or violent mental illness patients. I bet 99.99% of Americans are for background checks that would prevent criminals and the violent mentally ill persons from obtaining guns.

So of COURSE one can be a gun owner and for “gun control.” Let’s not reiterate the obvious but consider what would have stopped the mass shooters, knowing that we cannot prevent every single such crime but can only take reasonable measures to prevent lunatics and violent loners (the profile of such shooters generally) from getting guns.

Lisa
 
So you’re saying that one’s right to display a weapon in one’s car, rather than hiding it from the view of possible criminals, is just as inalienable as one’s right not to be limited in freedom as a woman, even though one may become the target of rape. The same principle of freedom applies to people who carry guns as to women. And thus guns and women are equivalent means by which criminals commit crimes. I just want to make sure I understand your argument.
What is so hard about it? Both are restricting the acts of law abiding citizens in order to hopefully limit the acts of criminals.
 
As we saw a few days ago, pressure cookers can be used to make bombs.

Why hasn’t congress acted on creating common sense legislation to restrict the ownership of pressure cookers? Why would a household need more than one?

We need common sense, universal background checks for pressure cookers.

We need bans on pressure cookers that are capable of holding more than 2 quarts of food.

We need mandatory 5 day waiting periods, and we need to prohibit new models.

We need to close the Bed Bath and Beyond Loophole.

Even if it saves just one life, it is worth it.

Now we can wait to see how long it takes before “but a pressure cooker’s main purpose wasn’t to kill” is posted.
 
As we saw a few days ago, pressure cookers can be used to make bombs.

Why hasn’t congress acted on creating common sense legislation to restrict the ownership of pressure cookers? Why would a household need more than one?

We need common sense, universal background checks for pressure cookers.

We need bans on pressure cookers that are capable of holding more than 2 quarts of food.

We need mandatory 5 day waiting periods, and we need to prohibit new models.

We need to close the Bed Bath and Beyond Loophole.

Even if it saves just one life, it is worth it.

Now we can wait to see how long it takes before “but a pressure cooker’s main purpose wasn’t to kill” is posted.
Why focus on the preassure cooker when we should be asking how they got their hands on all that black powder and why we can’t trace the powder back to the source. I realize that focusing on the preassure cooker is much funnier, sorry to be a stick in the mud.

ETA: Also, Sean Collier wasn’t killed by a preassure cooker.
 
Why focus on the preassure cooker when we should be asking how they got their hands on all that black powder and why we can’t trace the powder back to the source. I realize that focusing on the preassure cooker is much funnier, sorry to be a stick in the mud.

ETA: Also, Sean Collier wasn’t killed by a preassure cooker.
Realize too that much of the carnage resulted from the nails, bee bees and other projectiles. Should one be able to buy more than 10 bee bees at a time? More than ten nails?

Of course this is tongue in cheek but if gun opponents looked at this honestly, they would see a consistency of argument that is hard to counter.

Lisa
 
Realize too that much of the carnage resulted from the nails, bee bees and other projectiles. Should one be able to buy more than 10 bee bees at a time? More than ten nails?

Of course this is tongue in cheek but if gun opponents looked at this honestly, they would see a consistency of argument that is hard to counter.

Lisa
The only reason you can call the bb’s and other items projectiles is because there was black powder involved. I do look at it honestly and I see it as the absolute worst event to use to promote gun rights.
 
The only reason you can call the bb’s and other items projectiles is because there was black powder involved. I do look at it honestly and I see it as the absolute worst event to use to promote gun rights.
Uh what? I don’t get your drift at all. I think the point is that the objects that by themselves are harmless, guns, pressure cookers, nails or even black powder become deadly due to a combination of factors including the operator of the bomb/gun/knife. Even factors that are meant to be helpful such as medications can be an element in the destructive stew of murderers.

The bombers had a number of guns, none of which were obtained legally according to reports. The younger brother would have been too young to purchase a firearm and the older would have failed a background check. I don’t know how the brothers obtained the guns. But again would the proposed gun laws have stopped them from purchasing either guns or the tools necessary to build a bomb?

Like the Batman shooter and the Gabby Giffords shooter and the Newtown Shooter, these men were known not only to their families but also authorities as potentially dangerous. Again, why is the focus on the object rather than the subject?

Lisa
 
Why focus on the preassure cooker when we should be asking how they got their hands on all that black powder and why we can’t trace the powder back to the source. I realize that focusing on the preassure cooker is much funnier, sorry to be a stick in the mud.

ETA: Also, Sean Collier wasn’t killed by a preassure cooker.
On the other hand, three people at the finish line weren’t killed with guns and fertilizer is just as volatile and even harder to trace. I find it about as humorous as most gun legislation.
 
The only reason you can call the bb’s and other items projectiles is because there was black powder involved. I do look at it honestly and I see it as the absolute worst event to use to promote gun rights.
Was this any worse then 20 children the president used at Sandy Hook to promote his agenda?
 
Some RealPolitik on the Senate bill failure:
The Senate did not vote against gun-control legislation. On the contrary, a majority voted in favor. So why didn’t the measure pass? Because this was a procedural vote. Under Senate rules, 60 votes are needed to close off debate, and only 54 Senators voted for cloture. That vote was a setback for proponents of the gun-control legislation, who wanted to rush the measure through the Senate without debate or amendment. But the cloture vote did not, by itself, kill the bill. The campaign for gun control petered out because proponents were not willing to proceed under ordinary parliamentary rules, allowing the possibility of amendments to their legislation.
As he withdrew the bill, Senate majority leader Harry Reid complained that 90% of all Americans would support the background checks that the legislation would have required for gun purchases. That may be so (although a 90% approval rate for anything seems impossibly high), and quite likely the Senate would have approved background checks. But the ordinary legislative process would have allowed for amendments to ease the concerns of gun owners: for instances, a proviso allowing fathers to transfer gun ownership to their children, or a clause forbidding a national registry of firearms. Those measures might have been popular with the public as well. The gun-control bill died because the White House and the Senate leadership would not entertain any such amendments.
catholicculture.org/commentary/the-city-gates.cfm?id=555
 
What is so hard about it? Both are restricting the acts of law abiding citizens in order to hopefully limit the acts of criminals.
According to this logic, should we also refrain from enacting laws that limit alcohol consumption while driving since such laws infringe upon the legal rights of responsible, law-abiding citizens to drink a legal substance? Perhaps we should target only those people whose medical records indicate they are alcoholics and leave the rest of the population alone to drink as much alcohol as they desire? After all, how do we know they might injure or kill others or themselves while driving under the influence? These are law-abiding, non-alcoholic drivers who should have a legal right to consume alcohol whenever they wish provided they are old enough to do so. Should we leave it entirely up to them to decide how much alcohol they wish to drink before driving?
 
The only reason you can call the bb’s and other items projectiles is because there was black powder involved. I do look at it honestly and I see it as the absolute worst event to use to promote gun rights.
Who said black powder was involved?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top