Senate Scuttles Gun Limits

  • Thread starter Thread starter MattinTex
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
gun control can be greater in DC or NYC than it is in Montana. but it cannot go past a certain constitutional threshold. DC could ban 30 rd magazines, it cannot ban pistols for home defense.

F/
And why should pistols for home defense be banned? You are held in the stratijacket of a gun hating ideology and apparently will not be satisfied until the 2nd Amendment is overturned (which wouldn’t do any good given the hundreds of thousands of guns in circulation not to mention the ease of making your own)

Most people are for reasonable restrictions…like not selling guns to bad guys or deranged teenagers. But as you can see from the violence in Chicago and Adam Lanza, these laws didn’t stop the violence.

You seem determined to focus on harrassing law abiding citizens and ignoring the real problem which is criminals and violent mentally ill individuals who can get guns even in areas where gun laws are MOST restrictive…Chicago? Connecticut?

Please address the issues rationally.

Lisa
 
…Please address the issues rationally.
we’re on the same side. but you’re not reading my posts correctly and/or you don’t understand constitutional issues, so I’m not interested in continuing this.
 
Ugh, can we start a new thread on Franco, please??

For the record, the Toomey - Manchin bill in the Senate isn’t “dead”. It failed to pass a special procedures cloture vote, which would have closed the amendment process and debate.

The bill is very much alive, but has been shelved by the Majority Leader for the time being.
 
Ugh, can we start a new thread on Franco, please??

For the record, the Toomey - Manchin bill in the Senate isn’t “dead”. It failed to pass a special procedures cloture vote, which would have closed the amendment process and debate.

The bill is very much alive, but has been shelved by the Majority Leader for the time being.
its effectively dead for the policy reasons already given. don’t expect to see Reid revive it anytime soon. the administration put on a maximum effort to get this passed and still failed. its a poison pill.
 
It’s best to actually read an article rather than just read the title and then make a fool of one’s self by wrongly assuming what the rest of the article says.
I have read the article and other articles reporting the same subject .

If telling the truth is making a fool of myself , then may I always make a fool of myself .

You don’t like the truth do you ? So the only course you seem able to follow is the path of personally attacking the one who tells the truth . And that is sad .
 
MODERATOR NOTICE

This thread is wandering, please return to the topic of the original post.
 
Pat Toomey confirms it: Obama is right about GOP
Via Amanda Terkel, Toomey admitted in an interview that expanded background checks went down to defeat because Republicans opposed the bill out of a desire to deny the president a victory. Here’s what Toomey said, according to a write-up in the Times Herald:
“In the end it didn’t pass because we’re so politicized. There were some on my side who did not want to be seen helping the president do something he wanted to get done, just because the president wanted to do it,” Toomey said.
washingtonpost.com/blogs/plum-line/wp/2013/05/01/pat-toomey-confirms-it-obama-is-right-about-gop/
 
“I’m shocked … shocked to find that gambling is going on in here.” Casablanca
Thanks a lot Bob…now I’m going to have to borrow my brother’s DVD of that film. Round up the usual suspects.
 
In all fairness, I heard a number of very specific objections to the bill as written. It was put together hastily (don’t let a crisis go to waste!) and even DiFi said it would NOT have done anything to stop a Sandy Hook or a Aurora Theater shooter.

Philisophically we need to get over “do something itis” as if doing SOMETHING even if ineffective, expensive and difficult to administer is better than thoughtfully considering what might actually address the problem.

But hey it’s easier to bash fellow Republicans who didn’t take the bait than, as SamH noted, admit your bill was gravely flawed.

Lisa
 
While you’ve made a habit of promoting leftist causes on here, I don’t think too many conservatives are going to follow Pat Toomey’s lead anytime soon.

Even some democrats are apprehensive about gun control measures.

How does that explain “denying the president a victory”?
I’m sorry if my posts bother you…guess that’s why there is an ignore feature. Regarding the rest, there are varying opinions on this subject, as you point out. That would seem to indicate that this is not a “leftist” cause, but a matter that is open for discussion.

Plus, I did not say anything about denying the president a victory, so why would I explain it. In fact, I made no statement what-so-ever…merely posted a link. You’ll have to ask Senator Toomey what he meant.
 
I wanted those gun laws to be passed. It would not have prevented responsible citizens who were not criminals from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun. I have nothing against responsible, law-abiding citizens owning guns and this law would not have prevented responsible, law-abiding citizens from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of the hands of criminals or at least it would have helped to do so. What is so wrong with that?
I am shocked at your post.
The new laws would do nothing to keep guns away from criminals
Feds don’t prosecute failed background checks of felons
Feds don’t prosecute strawman purchases for felons, which is illegal.
New laws would not have affected any recent shooting, nor would they disarm criminals.

The only people impacted will be responsible, law-abiding citizens
 
Ted Cruz slams Senate GOP ‘squishes’
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) said Friday that his fellow GOP senators lambasted him and Sens. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) and Mike Lee (R-Utah) for threatening to filibuster gun control reform.
“They said, ‘Listen, before you did this the politics of this were great — the Dems were the bad guys, the Republicans were the good guys. Now we all look like a bunch of squishes.’ Well, there is an alternative — you could just not be a bunch of squishes,” Cruz said Friday at a FreedomWorks event in Texas.
Read more: politico.com/story/2013/04/ted-cruz-gop-senate-squishes-90746.html#ixzz2SHLPT5Sb
 
I wanted those gun laws to be passed. It would not have prevented responsible citizens who were not criminals from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of criminals by ensuring that anyone who didn’t pass the background check was unable to purchase a gun. I have nothing against responsible, law-abiding citizens owning guns and this law would not have prevented responsible, law-abiding citizens from owning guns. It would have kept guns out of the hands of criminals or at least it would have helped to do so. What is so wrong with that?
It would NOT have kept guns out of the hands of criminals…generally, criminals don’t buy their guns through legal routes. This measure would have made it more difficult for law-abiding citizens to own guns and not prevented criminals from owning guns at all.
 
It would NOT have kept guns out of the hands of criminals…generally, criminals don’t buy their guns through legal routes. This measure would have made it more difficult for law-abiding citizens to own guns and not prevented criminals from owning guns at all.
Since it was never passed…your statement begs the question…how do you know?

A bit of inconvenience for law-biding citizens seems like a good trade-off to me…that spoken as a lawful gun owner.
 
Since it was never passed…your statement begs the question…how do you know?

A bit of inconvenience for law-biding citizens seems like a good trade-off to me…that spoken as a lawful gun owner.
oldcelt, a ‘bit’ of inconvenience? Do you know what the new proposed law would have done? Are you aware that we already have extensive background checks that cover a huge percentage of all LEGAL gun sales. They keep harping on the “gun show loophole” but in fact dealers at shows still have to run the checks and some states require them for private sale.

The reality is that the DOJ is NOT using the background checks to catch felons trying to buy guns. What purpose would be served adding another layer on a law that isn’t even being enforced?

Further there isn’t the slightest bit of evidence that criminals would be stopped from getting guns since they aren’t stopping by Cabelas to pick out a new weapon. Nor is there evidence, admitted by DiFi herself, that anything proposed would have stopped the kind of gun violence that ginned up the new legislation.

Honestly I don’t know how many times this has to be repeated…the new law would do nothing but give smug satisfaction to our basically useless and ineffective Congress that they “did something.”

Lisa
 
oldcelt, a ‘bit’ of inconvenience? Do you know what the new proposed law would have done? Are you aware that we already have extensive background checks that cover a huge percentage of all LEGAL gun sales. They keep harping on the “gun show loophole” but in fact dealers at shows still have to run the checks and some states require them for private sale.

The reality is that the DOJ is NOT using the background checks to catch felons trying to buy guns. What purpose would be served adding another layer on a law that isn’t even being enforced?

Further there isn’t the slightest bit of evidence that criminals would be stopped from getting guns since they aren’t stopping by Cabelas to pick out a new weapon. Nor is there evidence, admitted by DiFi herself, that anything proposed would have stopped the kind of gun violence that ginned up the new legislation.

Honestly I don’t know how many times this has to be repeated…the new law would do nothing but give smug satisfaction to our basically useless and ineffective Congress that they “did something.”

Lisa
Lisa, I don’t think that enhanced background checks would have much of an impact on criminals…as has been said…they’ll get them one way or the other. Where I think it could have at least a modest impact is the area of unstable people.
This proposal was worked out between tow gun-owners, and I don’t think that anyone would describe either as anti-gun. My read on the situation is that the senators who opposed this compromise position have placed themselves in a very difficult position. Many are already seeing their approval ratings tank because a sizable majority of people in this country view this as a reasonable effort.
I completely agree that current laws should be more rigorously enforced…and that the proposal is not a panacea…but I don’t see where it will do any harm.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top