Should I ask husband to leave

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rebecca2009
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for the replies!

My husband is not Catholic. He is a protestant Christian, and I myself was a Protestant until 2006. I do pray the Rosary by myself, and have prayed it sometimes with some of my children. Only my 13 year old is really open to the Catholic Church. My Priest said not to push conversion with her though, and I certainly don’t want to make her feel at odds with her father. I homeschool her and my 16 year old daughter, and I use Catholic materials.

I would love to have my son baptized but as of now my husband is opposed. 3 of my children were baptized in the protestant fellowship that we’ve all attended for several years. I go there with my family and go to Mass by myself for the most part.

I am not thrilled with this situation but right now this is how it is. Jesus has been SO faithful and kind to me, and Mary is very precious to me. I struggle with doubts sometimes because of the anti-catholic stuff I heard for many years. But I love her!!
I apologize. I forgot that you mentioned, in the original post, your husband was not Catholic.

Nevertheless, family prayer is a staple of all Christian households. Please include your son during this time. He may lead some prayers at his age. You should establish some common ground with your husband, prayer and scripture. All families need a spiritual life that they can share.

There is a special spiritual bond between a parent and child. It is totally appropriate and encouraged for parents to perform blessings on their children. A little holy water can go a long way.

I don’t know what you can do about your son’s baptism. In an emergency, a lay person can perform a baptism.
 
Very, very difficult situation. While my heart goes out to the OP we should remember that we are getting only one side of the story. Not saying that the OP is being deceptive, but I bet the husband has a very different view of the situation.
Call the police.
This is unacceptable, do whatever you need to do, if that means throwing your husband out, then do it.
Take your kid and get the heck out of there ASAP. RUN.
I think a phone call to your local social service agency, Catholic Charities or other resource would be the best course of action.
Over-react much? We don’t have near enough information to suggest such drastic actions. Regarding the involvement of outside authorities…when the police or social services agencies get involved, the situation typically spins WAY out of control. Don’t even think about contacting these folks unless the situation is hopeless.
I do think that we need a lot more information here before people talk about separation and calling the police. Slapping someone who is biting you is a pretty understandable response. Also, have you considered that your son does behave worse when you are there as he senses that you take his side in this? I have a son with high functioning autism, and while he could never figure out a social situation, he was,and probably still is at 27, capable of playing me against his dad. Children, even autistic children, can and do learn to manipulate their parents.

Also, and I am sure that no one wants to hear this, but I have seen many special needs children negatively impacted by over coddling on the part of their mothers.
Ah…the sweet sound of the voice of reason.
 
I think your husband needs anger management classes. Have him stay with another family member till he gets himself back on track.
 
Hello,
I have a young son with special needs (autism). My problem in a nutshell is, my husband is too rough in handling his behaviors. It is certainly not easy, as my son does at times act out, and can be physically aggressive. He will try to bite and scratch if he is having a meltdown.
My husband generally tries to be a good dad. But it has happened a few times now that he would hit our son which is completely unacceptable. He is basically non verbal and just screams if he gets mad. I have tried to tell my husband that it is abusive to hit him in any way.

I have spoken to him and straight out told him I cannot and will not stand by and allow this to happen to our son. But my husband does not apologize or show any sign of repentance in his attitude about this. I am not perfect either and have had to go to confession to ask forgiveness for losing my own temper. Thing is my husband shows no sign of being sorry, and actually blames me for his hitting…he said that our son acted up worse because i walked into the room.

I feel like I should tell him to leave our home at least for a while, I don’t feel comfortable leaving my son alone with him any more. We have older children too and I don’t like having them witness this. My husband is a Christian but not a Catholic.

Just trying to figure out what would be the right thing to do at this point.
You would have to be more specific on what is going on. It is not abusive for a parent “to hit a child in anyway”. Physical discipline is not condemned by the Church, and is in fact spoken of highly in many places within Sacred Scripture. There is a difference between discipline and abuse, but not all hitting is abuse. If your husband is disciplining your son, then he is not doing anything sinful, and as his wife you should submit to his leadership of the family.

Pax Christi
 
You would have to be more specific on what is going on. It is not abusive for a parent “to hit a child in anyway”. Physical discipline is not condemned by the Church, and is in fact spoken of highly in many places within Sacred Scripture. There is a difference between discipline and abuse, but not all hitting is abuse. If your husband is disciplining your son, then he is not doing anything sinful, and as his wife you should submit to his leadership of the family.

Pax Christi
The child has special needs and is autistic. Hitting would not be an appropriate discipline because the child does not have complete control of his behavior due to his disability. The child’s outbursts would not be due to being undisciplined. They usually have neurological causes.
 
As I said I am not familiar with the families particular circumstances, however a child doesn’t need to be culpable for their behavior for a parent to use physical discipline. A 4 year old without any health or developmental problems doesn’t have complete control or understanding of their actions either. That doesn’t make it abuse for a parent to spank them.

Pax
 
There are neurological reasons that the child acts out, that he might not have control over. You wouldn’t spank an epileptic for having a seizure.
 
There are neurological reasons that the child acts out, that he might not have control over. You wouldn’t spank an epileptic for having a seizure.
No, but you might use physical force to restrain a child having a seizure from harming himself or others.

There is also a danger when a child has real neurological problems, of chalking up every act to the problem and in effect treating the person as if they have no will of their own. Each case is different, but many times someone who has a real handicap could still be much more functional if treated more like a full human being- who does good things and bad things. *Note, I am speaking in general here and not specifically addressing the OP’s situation. *

You might not spank a child with epilepsy for having a seizure, but that doesn’t mean you wouldn’t when he steals a cookie from the cookie jar or talks back to his mother or punches his little sister.

My point remains, the simple act of a parent hitting their child is neither abusive or sinful. Can it be both under certain circumstances? Yes, but not in all.

Pax
 
I do think that we need a lot more information here before people talk about separation and calling the police. Slapping someone who is biting you is a pretty understandable response. Also, have you considered that your son does behave worse when you are there as he senses that you take his side in this? I have a son with high functioning autism, and while he could never figure out a social situation, he was,and probably still is at 27, capable of playing me against his dad. Children, even autistic children, can and do learn to manipulate their parents.

**You need family counseling badly. **Is your husband open to this? He needs to learn some better discipline methods, and maybe you do too. Do not allow the stress of special needs parenting to drive a wedge into an otherwise sound marriage. If you two have other issues, than you have other issues. Don’t confuse them.

Also, and I am sure that no one wants to hear this, but I have seen many special needs children negatively impacted by over coddling on the part of their mothers. Protecting your child from real abuse is your job, but protecting them from all the consequences of their actions is not. I say this as a mother of 5, 28-12, two of whom have special needs.
Excellent advice from someone who has been there. OP, you and your husband need help from a specialist on how to appropriately train, discipline, and control your son. It will do no good to send your husband away if your son continues in out of control behavior.
 
You have a son, he has problems, the only way he will be able to survive and thrive is for his DAD to take control and teach him as best as he can learn what it means to be a MAN. There are too many men and not enough MEN in our society to teach our boys how to be MEN. I suggest to look for a Scout trroop either Cub or Boy to help you, your husband and your son. I was involved for years with my son- Cubmaster etc.- and am also an Eagle Scout. We had two special needs kids in Boy Scouts when I was involved with my son and they flourished- the boys really took to helping them- but not smothering them- amazing how a 13 yr old can figure out when a fellow scout needs or wants or asks for help.

My Brother in law is also an Eagle as are his two sons- the oldest is Autistic but a Soph in college with a 4.0.

It took amazing patience and perseverence from my sister’s hubby but he worked long and hard to get his son to where he is- brilliant but absolutely no social skills- read at age 3- but doesn’t look both ways when crossing the street. How do you plan for your future and your kids future when you have a kid like that. They are both Saints.
 
Also the parent of an ASD son who is 9 years old. There are organizations who specifically deal with parenting special needs kids, and they often do it at no cost. Your school’s special Ed department should know of these organizations.

Often it is hard for a parent to readily accept a special needs child, as there is a sense of loss for the idealized life the child will never lead. Also, your husband may be worried about providing for the needs of your son well into adulthood. I know that this is still a major concern for us. It is sobering.

I think a counselor trained in dealing with special needs families would be a welcome relief. Prayers your way.
This post, your family needs outside help.
 
Hi. Just wanted to say that I agree that you all, as a family, need outside help in learning to survive together and to create an atmosphere in which your son—and the rest of you—can thrive and be happy. Tall order. Hard to do. But with concentrated prayer and counseling, you’ll succeed.

You mentioned that your son was frightened. Don’t forget that kids are quite clever little actors, even autistic ones, and as others have verified, become expert at manipulating, so although he may, at times, be frightened by your husband (his father?), he may also be laying it on a little bit thick for your benefit. A boy at his age is often jealous of his father’s role in his mother’s life.

My grandfather, a farmer, was drinking a glass of water, just outside the porch door, when I, as a 3- or 4-year-old, threw a temper fit because I wasn’t being permitted to go with him. Family legend has it that I threw myself on the concrete floor, banged my head and fists and legs, kicking and biting. Both Grandma and Mother were unable to stop me, and Grandpa’s words weren’t enough, either, so he poured the water on my head. I sputtered, stopped crying, and began telling him he was a bad Grandpa. My mother ran and got another glass of water and I never had another tantrum.

Fast-forward to when my ADHD and dyslexic son, who wore leather and metal leg braces from the waist to his toes, began pitching his tantrums. I’d have bleeding cuts and bruises from the braces, and was at my wit’s end when I remembered that embarrassing family tale. I stepped to the kitchen counter, got a BIG pan of water, and really baptized his head and shoulders. Marvel of marvels! That was the last temper tantrum he threw. Everyone I’ve told this to, who’s tried it, has had good results. Now my son, to his chagrin, stars in the family lore: he immediately stopped screaming and flailing and kicking, sat up, and said in a very hurt, disbelieving voice, “Mommy, you tried to kill your poor little boy!” There were a few times that he appeared to be ready to start another tantrum, but quickly remembered the end result. Don’t know whether it would work with your son or not, but I’ve had several mothers tell me that it was a real magic trick!

When he went through the biting stage, and nothing else worked, I bit him, hard, with tears running down my face at the time, and for many nights in my bedroom. It hurt me for a much longer period of time than it did him. Unfortunately, that had to occur three or four times before he stopped biting. Yes, I know what today’s “experts” say, but you have to do whatever will work when the situation arises, and, as parents, we usually have to ad lib on the spot; we don’t have the luxury of spending a few semesters reading (often questionable) child psychology books before deciding what to do.

I agree with others that your course of action should be discussed and agreed upon, with the help of others, by both you and your husband. He is your life’s partner, not your son. I think you should crawl all over the Web for diet implications in behavior of autistic children. Many exciting new research discoveries link foods, allergies, deficiencies, and even poisonings to autististic and other special needs children.

I am puzzled as to why you repeatedly say “my son,” “my daughter,” instead of “our son,” “our daughter.”

Please, as others have stated, be very aware that in many communities today, alas, your husband might wind up with a jail sentence if you said to any kind of authorities what you’ve said to us.

To you who are reading this post, will you plese take time now to utter fervent prayer for this family? Peace be with all of you.
 
No, but you might use physical force to restrain a child having a seizure from harming himself or others.

Pax
Actually you don’t restrain an epileptic except in very rare situations where you actually are a medical provider and know that the air way is blocked or something such as this and have the proper tools and number of people to do it. It is usually at least two preferably four. You would NEVER try to restrain someone who is out of control neurologically by yourself by hand especially by hitting. So what are you saying makes no sense and is just barbaric.

OP, I think contacting Catholic Charities as a first step in order to get counseling would be a good way to go. They will be able to assess the needs of your family from there. God bless.
 
I have not been online much recently, but just checked back here today.

THANK YOU SO MUCH to all of you that took the time to reply, and Especially for your prayers!!! Jesus has really turned things around. And I saw the wisdom already of what someone wrote above…Yes my son needs his Dad in his life. I put myself before the Lord and thankfully He showed me several points where I was wrong myself.

We talked and my husband is being more careful with how he acts. And yes my son needs a firmer hand than what I was doing. And honestly, he is getting so strong now that when he does have a bad meltdown (thankfully they are decreasing significantly, due to more diet changes and other interventions), I have to get my husband or my adult son to deal with him.

It is a long story but I wanted to update and again say thanks to all of you who cared enough to respond.

God bless you all.
 
Spare the rod and hate the child.

Might be Proverbs or more probably Wisdom.
 
Glad things are getting better. My heart was breaking reading some of the bad advice a couple people had given. There is NEVER a good reason to strike a a child. Have many of us lost our temper and smacked, hoping it would “get through”? Yes. But to justify it as a right and proper way to teach a child is bunk. It doesn’t work, particularly with a special needs kid. If your husband realizes that now, amen! If not working with a person trained in helping families with special needs kids is in order. If his smacks get harder and his justification firmer, think seriously about taking that as a warning sign.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top