Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks Teflon, I appreciate you’re jumping in here. I got busy today. I wonder where Atemi is. I see the conversation got picked up by kay cee. Interesting. I love this. The debate can keep going without you if you get busy. Pretty cool.

Kaycee, Hi.

Why can’t you see the possibility that faith itself is a combination of belief and behavior just like love is a combination of affection and behavior?

Why cant’ you discern the difference when the inspired author is talking about works of the Old Covenant Law as opposed to faithful acts of charity performed under the New Covenant?
 
Why cant’ you discern the difference when the inspired author is talking about works of the Old Covenant Law as opposed to faithful acts of charity performed under the New Covenant?
This is a most crucial question, given that St Paul, in context, is referring to the works of the Law; circumcision, dietary laws, and so on.

Moreover, no matter how narrow a reading we give, we must contend with the fact that St Paul had Timothy circumcised. Was he trying to damn his most faithful aide?

Of course not. He did so to remove an obstacle to the conversion of the Jews to whom Timothy preached the Gospel.

We must always pay attention to the purpose of each epistle, and the audience to whom it is addressed.

To the larger issue, if fundamentalists believe works, even the works of the Law are dead and damning, why do so many insist upon the tithe?
 
To the larger issue, if fundamentalists believe works, even the works of the Law are dead and damning, why do so many insist upon the tithe?
Hi Teflon,

You know this is brilliant. I never thought to ask this question. I’ll bet you’ve never gotten a logical answer to this question from a fundamentalist/protestant.

So many questions…so few answers.

Can you tell me where in the NT Saint Paul has Timothy get circumcision?
 
Hi Teflon,

You know this is brilliant. I never thought to ask this question. I’ll bet you’ve never gotten a logical answer to this question from a fundamentalist/protestant.

So many questions…so few answers.

Can you tell me where in the NT Saint Paul has Timothy get circumcision?
Sure—Acts 16:
Code:
1: Then came he to Derbe and Lystra: and, behold, **a certain disciple was there, named Timotheus**, the son of a certain woman, which was a Jewess, and believed; but his father was a Greek:
2: Which was well reported of by the brethren that were at Lystra and Iconium.
3: Him would Paul have to go forth with him; and took and circumcised him because of the Jews which were in those quarters: for they knew all that his father was a Greek
 
Wow this is a long thread. But back to the original concept. Sola Fide at the least has some flaws and God does expect obediance. So the bigger question is what does entail salvation? Would a person exposed to Christianity though not Catholic be able to attain salvation?
Ray
 
The general consensus here is that Christians can attain salvation and not be catholic, but it makes it alot harder to do so. From personal experience, having attended service and fellowship with the protestants, there always seemed to be certain elements that lacked, like it’s only part of the story here and these missing elements are filled in once you become Catholic and fellowship with them and follow the church and what it teaches.

I hope this helps.
 
Wow this is a long thread. But back to the original concept. Sola Fide at the least has some flaws and God does expect obediance. So the bigger question is what does entail salvation? Would a person exposed to Christianity though not Catholic be able to attain salvation?
Ray
‘To be Christian’ always meant ‘to be Catholic’.
For the last couple hundred years, or even the last few decades, ‘to be christian’ could mean anything.
So the answer to your question is ‘we don’t Know’, Christianity was Catholicism, from Biblical times.
 
The general consensus here is that Christians can attain salvation and not be catholic, but it makes it alot harder to do so. From personal experience, having attended service and fellowship with the protestants, there always seemed to be certain elements that lacked, like it’s only part of the story here and these missing elements are filled in once you become Catholic and fellowship with them and follow the church and what it teaches.

I hope this helps.
Hi Brian,
I found your post interesting. Could you tell me what protestant churches you visited or were involved with, and what you found missing there and later found in Catholicism?

Thanks,
Jon
 
I was raised Catholic, so it was not a matter of later finding in that regard. I used to go church hopping every weekend, some of them were really dissapointing, seeing the agenda’s by the leaderships were based upon making it run more like a business rather then keeping their focus more in alignment with the bible.

Certain things, such as the Eucherist, the saints, Mary, traditions were simply not present at these services, the leadership seemed to be pretty unclear with not enough focus and direction and unitiy within it. I even attended a methodist service that happened to be residing at our former location. This is not to say that there were some good things I feel the Catholic church should be emulating from them, such as longer sermons and intensive bible study right after service such as what I experienced with the baptists for example. Yet, there are certain things the protestants should embrace that the Catholic church clearly is in the lead with, mainly in regards to charity and missionary work.

I attended one really weird one, they are apostolic Lutherens, absolutely not mainstream by any means, they even support arranged marriages and the service was outright bizzar, it seemed they were trying to emulate the middle ages, and was a very depressing service to attend. I did steer clear of the usual’s crazy’s, ie. mormonism and JW, but took note with how they operated, I even lost a friend that got caught up in mormonism.
 
Thank you for the replies. I think that there are things the Catholic church has such as the apostolic succession that are not found in most protestant churches. Since I began attending a traditional Anglican church, I may be headed towards becoming Catholic. I certainly find myself agreeing more with Catholic doctrine.
Ray
 
Hi Brian,
I found your post interesting. Could you tell me what protestant churches you visited or were involved with, and what you found missing there and later found in Catholicism?

Thanks,
Jon
I’m not Brian, but I did the same thing, and would like to answer your question also.

I fell away from the Catholic Church for a long time, and when I started going back to Church, for a variety of reasons, I chose the Episcopal Church. I went there for about 5 years before coming back to the Catholic Church - for good, I hope and pray!

Some of the things that I missed were:
  1. The Sacraments. I missed most of all the Eucharist, but also going to Confession. I missed being able to go to a confessional and hearing a Priest say those words - I absolve you. Unless you have personally experienced this, you have no idea how powerful this is. Especially when you know that you deserve to hear something different!!!
  2. Direction. I missed having specific instructions. I would hear catch phrases all the time that sounded good, but with no concrete direction as to how to carry them out or achieve them.
  3. Consistency. I missed having a consistent message. We had several pastors (called rectors), and depending upon their personal beliefs, they could teach some very different things.
  4. A common set of values. I missed having a good, well defined statement of beliefs that weren’t watered down to appeal to everyone without offending anyone.
I missed having all of the Truth, even when I didn’t want to hear the Truth. It needs to be preached, no matter how it is received.
 
I’m not Brian, but I did the same thing, and would like to answer your question also.

I fell away from the Catholic Church for a long time, and when I started going back to Church, for a variety of reasons, I chose the Episcopal Church. I went there for about 5 years before coming back to the Catholic Church - for good, I hope and pray!

Some of the things that I missed were:
  1. The Sacraments. I missed most of all the Eucharist, but also going to Confession. I missed being able to go to a confessional and hearing a Priest say those words - I absolve you. Unless you have personally experienced this, you have no idea how powerful this is. Especially when you know that you deserve to hear something different!!!
  2. Direction. I missed having specific instructions. I would hear catch phrases all the time that sounded good, but with no concrete direction as to how to carry them out or achieve them.
  3. Consistency. I missed having a consistent message. We had several pastors (called rectors), and depending upon their personal beliefs, they could teach some very different things.
  4. A common set of values. I missed having a good, well defined statement of beliefs that weren’t watered down to appeal to everyone without offending anyone.
I missed having all of the Truth, even when I didn’t want to hear the Truth. It needs to be preached, no matter how it is received.
AMEN, you have just given most of the reasons why those who leave the Catholic Church, eventually return home to Her. God Bless.
 
No, that wouldn’t be fair at all as that is not the Catholic position.

I would say that they are being rather ahead of themselves in saying that they are 100% sure.
Are you sure that is not the Catholic Position, it certainly is according to Mr Karl Keating and that other rarely mentioned Roman Catholic authority the Council of Trent!

Maybe I simply just don’t understand Roman Catholicism, even though, as far as I am aware, I am still, after half a century, a Roman Catholic and have been studying Catholic Theology for over a decade.

Please enlighten me.
 
Wow this is a long thread. But back to the original concept. Sola Fide at the least has some flaws and God does expect obediance. So the bigger question is what does entail salvation? Would a person exposed to Christianity though not Catholic be able to attain salvation?
Ray
 
You asked if those exposed to Christianity, however not Catholic, can be saved. As I mentioned earlier, it is the Catholic Church’s belief, stated in its Cathechism by Cardinal Ratzinger (the present Pope Benedict XVI) that the Church does believe that a non-Catholic, living a good Christian life and believing he’s correct in his method of salvation, without the realization of the real truths of the Catholic Church, should merit salvation. The Catechism further states that salvation is not guaranteed to one who knows (i.e., realizes) that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, and refuses to enter or remain in the Catholic Church. Therefore, the Church believes that one reared as a Protestant, living a good Christian life, without the knowledge and realization of the truths of the Catholic Church, can merit salvation. Hope this answers your question on the Catholic viewpoint.
 
You asked if those exposed to Christianity, however not Catholic, can be saved. As I mentioned earlier, it is the Catholic Church’s belief, stated in its Cathechism by Cardinal Ratzinger (the present Pope Benedict XVI) that the Church does believe that a non-Catholic, living a good Christian life and believing he’s correct in his method of salvation, without the realization of the real truths of the Catholic Church, should merit salvation. The Catechism further states that salvation is not guaranteed to one who knows (i.e., realizes) that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, and refuses to enter or remain in the Catholic Church. Therefore, the Church believes that one reared as a Protestant, living a good Christian life, without the knowledge and realization of the truths of the Catholic Church, can merit salvation. Hope this answers your question on the Catholic viewpoint.
Yes but in this day and age with our state of the art communications, that is harder to do because there are probably millions that know about the truth of the Catholic Church but still refuse to look into it. and I think that is a big problem for them. I am not saying this to be judgmental but it seems that millions have bought into the LIES that protestants have perpetuated against the Catholic Church for many, many years. I would think that ANYONE who wished to know Jesus Christ, and have a true “personal” relationship with HIM, (and how much more personal can you get than the TRUE Presence of Jesus in the Holy Eucharist), would want to find out if what the Catholic Church says is really true. And today that is not hard to do. Not only that, but the graces from the Sacraments of the Catholic Church are priceless, and will be ours forever. To go to Confession to a priest and be sincerely sorry for your sins is so cleansing in itself, but the Sacramental Grace it brings to the soul is beyond our grasp.
You CAN"T get that Grace in your bedroom, or on a hill or anywhere else. You may be forgiven, thats up to God, but you cannot receive the Sacramental Grace without the Sacrament. And to receive the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus in Holy Communion. Learn about the Eucharistic Miracles, The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, the Saints, all the beautiful devotions in the Catholic Church, Anyone who turns their back on the Catholic Church cheats themselves out of soooo much. God Bless.
 
I was raised Catholic, so it was not a matter of later finding in that regard. I used to go church hopping every weekend, some of them were really dissapointing, seeing the agenda’s by the leaderships were based upon making it run more like a business rather then keeping their focus more in alignment with the bible.

Certain things, such as the Eucherist, the saints, Mary, traditions were simply not present at these services, the leadership seemed to be pretty unclear with not enough focus and direction and unitiy within it. I even attended a methodist service that happened to be residing at our former location. This is not to say that there were some good things I feel the Catholic church should be emulating from them, such as longer sermons and intensive bible study right after service such as what I experienced with the baptists for example. Yet, there are certain things the protestants should embrace that the Catholic church clearly is in the lead with, mainly in regards to charity and missionary work.

I attended one really weird one, they are apostolic Lutherens, absolutely not mainstream by any means, they even support arranged marriages and the service was outright bizzar, it seemed they were trying to emulate the middle ages, and was a very depressing service to attend. I did steer clear of the usual’s crazy’s, ie. mormonism and JW, but took note with how they operated, I even lost a friend that got caught up in mormonism.
So where are you now, Brian?
 
Yes but in this day and age with our state of the art communications, that is harder to do because there are probably millions that know about the truth of the Catholic Church but still refuse to look into it. and I think that is a big problem for them. I am not saying this to be judgmental but it seems that millions have bought into the LIES that protestants have perpetuated against the Catholic Church for many, many years. I would think that ANYONE who wished to know Jesus Christ, and have a true “personal” relationship with HIM, (and how much more personal can you get than the TRUE Presence of Jesus in the Holy Eucharist), would want to find out if what the Catholic Church says is really true. And today that is not hard to do. Not only that, but the graces from the Sacraments of the Catholic Church are priceless, and will be ours forever. To go to Confession to a priest and be sincerely sorry for your sins is so cleansing in itself, but the Sacramental Grace it brings to the soul is beyond our grasp.
You CAN"T get that Grace in your bedroom, or on a hill or anywhere else. You may be forgiven, thats up to God, but you cannot receive the Sacramental Grace without the Sacrament. And to receive the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus in Holy Communion. Learn about the Eucharistic Miracles, The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, the Saints, all the beautiful devotions in the Catholic Church, Anyone who turns their back on the Catholic Church cheats themselves out of soooo much. God Bless.
 
40.png
Emerite:
In reply to Memaw, I’m thankful to my parents and godparents for rearing me in the Catholic faith, as well as to all the religious in my parochial schools. Without them, if I were reared as an Episcopalian, Baptist or whatever, it would be difficult, but not impossible, to become a Roman Catholic. Therefore, I understand where Protestants are coming from, respect their beliefs, especially those in common with the Catholic Church, yet pray for their conversion and for Christian unity. Intellectually, I think research and logic would have led me to believe the Catholic Church is the original, true Church of Christianity. But many won’t realize this truth, and our Catechism of the Catholic Church states that if a Protestant lives a good Christian life, yet through no fault of their own don’t know Christ and his Church, they can merit salvation. Not so lucky are fallen away Catholics and Protestants who realize, yet deny the truth of our Church. We, however, are encouraged to evangelize non-Catholics, with love and respect. See this Catechism, by Ligouri Publications, with imprimi protest by Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger (current Pope Clement), Part One, The Profession of Faith, at page 224, #'s 846, 847 & 848.
 
In reply to Memaw, I’m thankful to my parents and godparents for rearing me in the Catholic faith, as well as to all the religious in my parochial schools. Without them, if I were reared as an Episcopalian, Baptist or whatever, it would be difficult, but not impossible, to become a Roman Catholic. Therefore, I understand where Protestants are coming from, respect their beliefs, especially those in common with the Catholic Church, yet pray for their conversion and for Christian unity. Intellectually, I think research and logic would have led me to believe the Catholic Church is the original, true Church of Christianity. But many won’t realize this truth, and our Catechism of the Catholic Church states that if a Protestant lives a good Christian life, yet through no fault of their own don’t know Christ and his Church, they can merit salvation. Not so lucky are fallen away Catholics and Protestants who realize, yet deny the truth of our Church. We, however, are encouraged to evangelize non-Catholics, with love and respect. See this Catechism, by Ligouri Publications, with imprimi protest by Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger (current Pope Clement), Part One, The Profession of Faith, at page 224, #'s 846, 847 & 848.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top