E
Emerite
Guest
Sorry, correction. In my above reply to Memaw, I meant to write Pope Benedict XVI, and not Pope Clement, as Catechism by our current pope, former Cardinal Ratzinger. Mea culpa!
In reply to Memaw, I’m thankful to my parents and godparents for rearing me in the Catholic faith, as well as to all the religious in my parochial schools. Without them, if I were reared as an Episcopalian, Baptist or whatever, it would be difficult, but not impossible, to become a Roman Catholic. Therefore, I understand where Protestants are coming from, respect their beliefs, especially those in common with the Catholic Church, yet pray for their conversion and for Christian unity. Intellectually, I think research and logic would have led me to believe the Catholic Church is the original, true Church of Christianity. But many won’t realize this truth, and our Catechism of the Catholic Church states that if a Protestant lives a good Christian life, yet through no fault of their own don’t know Christ and his Church, they can merit salvation. Not so lucky are fallen away Catholics and Protestants who realize, yet deny the truth of our Church.
Emerite,
You pretty much repeated what I had just said, the clue is, “through no fault of their own.” Vincible ignorance," (one wills not to learn), never excuses one from the responsibility. God Bless, Memaw.
I’m Catholic, there is no denying it, that’s all that matters now, what I learned from the church hopping is that there is clear division, in most cases, unwarrented due to the poor leadership telling their congregation lies about the Catholic’s and others within it through ignorance propaginating them. At the same time, it’s frowned upon to be Catholic and find fellowship with the protestants, that too is a wrong point of view for it creates division, not unity, of which we should be focused upon the latter element more then the former.So where are you now, Brian?
Thanks, Brian, for the insight. You too, Sodak.I was raised Catholic, so it was not a matter of later finding in that regard. I used to go church hopping every weekend, some of them were really dissapointing, seeing the agenda’s by the leaderships were based upon making it run more like a business rather then keeping their focus more in alignment with the bible.
Certain things, such as the Eucherist, the saints, Mary, traditions were simply not present at these services, the leadership seemed to be pretty unclear with not enough focus and direction and unitiy within it. I even attended a methodist service that happened to be residing at our former location. This is not to say that there were some good things I feel the Catholic church should be emulating from them, such as longer sermons and intensive bible study right after service such as what I experienced with the baptists for example. Yet, there are certain things the protestants should embrace that the Catholic church clearly is in the lead with, mainly in regards to charity and missionary work.
I attended one really weird one, they are apostolic Lutherens, absolutely not mainstream by any means, they even support arranged marriages and the service was outright bizzar, it seemed they were trying to emulate the middle ages, and was a very depressing service to attend. I did steer clear of the usual’s crazy’s, ie. mormonism and JW, but took note with how they operated, I even lost a friend that got caught up in mormonism.
This shouldn’t be true in any parish. Ecumenism is a alive and well. On one block in our town there are 4 churches. At one end the Catholic Church is across the street from the Episcopal Church and at the other end the Presbyterian Church is across the street from the Lutheran Church. My family always attends Mass but there is much fellowship with the other churches. My daughter and I play in the bell choir and take vacations with the Presbyterians and we share parking space with the Episcopalians and we have a hugh, joint, vacation Bible school in the summer where children from all four churches and churches from all over the town participate. It’s great. The street is blocked off and kids are running back and forth for the different classes and activities. Our town has a ministerial organization where the pastors and our priest can get together and plan joint ventures and different things for the community at large. The only frustrating thing is you can’t really discuss the details of religion and what exactly divides everyone. That’s what this forum is for.it’s frowned upon to be Catholic and find fellowship with the protestants, that too is a wrong point of view for it creates division, not unity, of which we should be focused upon the latter element more then the former.
This shouldn’t be true in any parish. Ecumenism is a alive and well. On one block in our town there are 4 churches. At one end the Catholic Church is across the street from the Episcopal Church and at the other end the Presbyterian Church is across the street from the Lutheran Church. My family always attends Mass but there is much fellowship with the other churches. My daughter and I play in the bell choir and take vacations with the Presbyterians and we share parking space with the Episcopalians and we have a hugh, joint, vacation Bible school in the summer where children from all four churches and churches from all over the town participate. It’s great. The street is blocked off and kids are running back and forth for the different classes and activities. Our town has a ministerial organization where the pastors and our priest can get together and plan joint ventures and different things for the community at large. The only frustrating thing is you can’t really discuss the details of religion and what exactly divides everyone. That’s what this forum is for.
Likewise, it is not enough for us to say we love God, or that we have a “personal relationship with Jesus”, if we do not act as though that were the case.
The most important “personal” relationship we can have is when we receive Jesus Christ, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity in the Holy Eucharist. Everything else pales in the comparison. That is why its Called Holy Communion, because of our communion with Christ. Jesus said to the Apostles, “Would you leave me too?” and Peter said, Lord to whom shall we go??. You have the words of Eternal life."
Personal relationship is important, but it matters what kind of relationship! It can be said that I have a personal relationship with my next-door-neighbor, but there’s certainly no love lost between us.
I hear you there. I’m hoping the 11th Commandment doesn’t turn out to be, “Do not aim your lawn clippings toward the neighbor’s yard.”
Personal relationship is important, but it matters what kind of relationship! It can be said that I have a personal relationship with my next-door-neighbor, but there’s certainly no love lost between us.
I suppose that your denomination is nowhere to be found in this list.
- Sexual abuse by priests is an abomination
1. What one believes is more is more important than the denomination said:That is simply not true. But, I guess that is one way of looking at it if you are trying to prove something negative about Catholocism.
Why I left the Catholic church
I will pray for you. People left the Catholic church because it was difficult to follow the Church rules (i.e., King Henry VIII); hurt feelings, or lack of understanding.
Code:What one believes is more important than the denomination. (I believe the in the Church's traditions, from earliest centuries. St. Peter as the first leader of the Church -- the papacy.) The material riches in the Vatican are obscene and many should be sold .... (Vatican museum represents Church's history. The Church helps the poor.) Mary has been declared as “co-redemptress”....(Ask the mother for her Son's favor. Catholics venerate Mary as mother of Jesus.) The infallible Pope can’t discern between creation and evolution.... (God followed His own plan in creating man.) The church is confused as to how one gains Heaven....(Catholics, who are faithful and keep God's commandments (1 Jn 2:3), are assured of salvation. We have free will to choose between good and evil -- wouldn't one reward good and punish evil?) The church gives no clue as to the assurance of salvation. (Read "all" the versus of 1 Jn. Further, St. Paul does not regard salvation as a one-time event, but as a goal to be sought after, one that can be lost. " Sexual abuse by priests is an abomination,,,, (Priests are human and can err. I think the press often exaggerates and over reports, to the delight of many anti-Catholics.) Having an ex-priest as good friend, he admitted very sparse and limited knowledge of Scripture .... (How long ago? Priests today are knowledgeable about Scripture. At Sunday Mass, there are readings from the New and Old Testaments, a Gospel, and sermon, plus bible study groups.) The church does not seem to have a firm understanding of what is meant by being “born again” .... (This should coincide with Confirmation. Once a luke-warm Catholic, I treasure my faith,and now a devout, Christian-living Catholic.) Purgatory is a church invention as no mention of it is in the Bible, Luke 23;43 (References to purgatory in the Catholic Douay-Rheims Bible,originally written in the year 300's, which includes 2 Macc.12:46, among others.) When Jesus was hanging on the cross,, He told the repentant thief, “Today you shall be with me in paradise”.Not purgatory! (Jesus forgave and absolved that thief. Confessing sins, in contrite sorrow, with penance, absolves sins.) The Bible refers to “born again” believers as “saints”. The Catholic Church reserves ... rights of who becomes a saint. (I know self-proclaimed "born again" believers, way far from sainthood!)
- The Catholic Church seems clueless on …, namely, what must be done to gain Heaven and what assurance there is of getting to Heaven. (This “assurance” has to be understood in light of St. John’s teachings, "For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments (1 Jn 5:3, and 2:3-6). St. Paul does not regard salvation as a one-time event, but as a goal to be sought after, one that can be lost.)
The inevitable response from Catholics when asked if they will go to Heaven is, “I hope so” … (I hope to continue the good Christian life, meriting heaven. I’m really not God – He has the final word about who goes to heaven.)
When Jesus died on the cross, His last words were “It is finished” He had paid for our sins, … what is accomplished through communion? Does a Catholic go to Heaven for taking communion? (Jesus did say, at the Last Supper, when offering bread and wine, “Do this in commemoration of Me,” therefore establishing our Catholic Mass. A Catholic, being in the state of grace [free from sin] to receive Communion, should merit heaven.)- At the expense of sounding crude, the substances of bread and wine taken at communion, would go through the human…(God created our bodies, so what’s so crude about that? I feel a spiritual closeness to God, upon receiving Communion.)
The only thing you have proven to me is all those years of Catholic education, went in one ear and out the other. You sound like a typical protestant that doesn’t know what hes talking about. If you really believe all that garbage, then you should go talk to a priest, (please, NOT and ex one). If a priest doesn’t know scripture as you put it then where was he when he was saying Mass?? Sounds like more of the lies that some enjoy throwing around for others to grab onto. Get a LIFE.Why I left the Catholic church
I was raised a Catholic, attended Catholic grammar and high school and was in a Catholic fraternity in college and married in a Catholic church. I also visited the Vatican.
I left the Catholic church and these are the major reasons for leaving;
- What one believes is more is more important than the denomination
- The material riches in the Vatican are obscene and many should be sold and used for better purposes than rotting in a warehouse.
- Mary has been declared as “co-redemptress”. This is blasphemy. “No one cometh to the Father but by Me”, John 14:6
- .The infallible Pope can’t discern between creation and evolution. If the church believes that God needed evolution, then in the person of Jesus Christ, He, too, being human, had to be a product of evolution and evolved from apes like every other human. That is not the Jesus that I worship!.
- The church is confused as to how one gains Heaven. It is a religion based on good works, in spite of what scripture states in Eph 2:9
- The church gives no clue as to the assurance of salvation, Scripture does in 1 John 5:13
- Sexual abuse by priests is an abomination
- Having an ex-priest as good friend, he admitted very sparse and limited knowledge of Scripture whereby encyclicals, synods and all manner of human intervention takes precedence over Scripture.
- The church does not seem to have a firm understanding of what is meant by being “born again” but John 3;3 is very explicit and Jesus was very specific that you must be born again. It is not a process of baptism, confirmation, communion and a bunch of rituals in order to qualify.
- Purgatory is a church invention as no mention of it is in the Bible, Luke 23;43
- When Jesus was hanging on the cross, He told the repentant thief, “Today you shall be with me in paradise”. Not purgatory!
- The Bible refers to “born again” believers as “saints”. The Catholic Church reserves exclusive rights to the designation of who becomes a saint.
- The Catholic Church seems clueless on the two most important questions for any Christian, namely, what must be done to gain Heaven and what assurance there is of getting to Heaven .
- The inevitable response from Catholics when asked if they will go to Heaven is, “I hope so” None seems to have any assurance with the impediments of confession, absolution, penance, lighting candles, sacraments, mortal sin, prayer, mass, indulgences, communion etc. None of these works can provide salvation and the vast majority of Catholics remain confused as to how to use these human contrived works to gain eternal salvation.
- When Jesus died on the cross, His last words were “It is finished” He had paid for our sins, once and for all. He does not need to shed any more blood at every Mass. Even if this was true, what is accomplished through communion? Does a Catholic go to Heaven for taking communion?
- At the expense of sounding crude, the substances of bread and wine taken at communion, would go through the human intestinal tract and eventually the toilet. This is not fitting for any atom of the Precious body and blood of Our Lord!
I was raised Catholic, so it was not a matter of later finding in that regard. I used to go church hopping every weekend, some of them were really dissapointing, seeing the agenda’s by the leaderships were based upon making it run more like a business rather then keeping their focus more in alignment with the bible.
Certain things, such as the Eucherist, the saints, Mary, traditions were simply not present at these services, the leadership seemed to be pretty unclear with not enough focus and direction and unitiy within it. I even attended a methodist service that happened to be residing at our former location. This is not to say that there were some good things I feel the Catholic church should be emulating from them, such as longer sermons and intensive bible study right after service such as what I experienced with the baptists for example. Yet, there are certain things the protestants should embrace that the Catholic church clearly is in the lead with, mainly in regards to charity and missionary work.
I attended one really weird one, they are apostolic Lutherens, absolutely not mainstream by any means, they even support arranged marriages and the service was outright bizzar, it seemed they were trying to emulate the middle ages, and was a very depressing service to attend. I did steer clear of the usual’s crazy’s, ie. mormonism and JW, but took note with how they operated, I even lost a friend that got caught up in mormonism.
That is wonderful, but now you need to learn the “rest of the story.”Our bibles have minute deviations. Three portions of Scripture are quoted below:and three points are made clearEphesians 2-8) For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
(Ephesians 2-9) Not of works, lest any man should boast.
It seems clearly stated that no amount of works,sacraments, Marian devotion, confession, extreme unction, masses,stations of the cross etc. etc.are all works.
1 john 5:12 He that hath the Son hath life; and he that hath not the Son of God hath not life. 13 These things have I written unto you that believe on the name of the Son of God; that ye may know that ye have eternal life, and that ye may believe on the name of the Son of God.
(John 3-3) Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God.
( Ephesians 2-8) For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
(Ephesians 2-9) Not of works, lest any man should boast.
And yet James says:Our bibles have minute deviations. Three portions of Scripture are quoted below:and three points are made clearEphesians 2-8) For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
(Ephesians 2-9) Not of works, lest any man should boast.
It seems clearly stated that no amount of works,sacraments, Marian devotion, confession, extreme unction, masses,stations of the cross etc. etc.are all works.
1 john 5:12 He that hath the Son hath life; and he that hath not the Son of God hath not life. 13 These things have I written unto you that believe on the name of the Son of God; that ye may know that ye have eternal life, and that ye may believe on the name of the Son of God.
(John 3-3) Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God.
( Ephesians 2-8) For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
(Ephesians 2-9) Not of works, lest any man should boast.
Indeed, you cannot read the Gospel, nor the whole of Scripture, without the clear priority God places upon what we do over what we say.14: What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
15: If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
16: And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what doth it profit?
17: Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
18: Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
19: Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
20: But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?
21: Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he had offered Isaac his son upon the altar?
22: Seest thou how faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect?
23: And the scripture was fulfilled which saith, Abraham believed God, and it was imputed unto him for righteousness: and he was called the Friend of God.
24: Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only.
25: Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot justified by works, when she had received the messengers, and had sent them out another way?
**26: For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also. **