Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Sodak, you posted:
Thanks Mizer,
I thought I’d try and get one off before I go to bed! At least people that come later and read this thread can hopefully glean from it.
This is very true indeed. So I will leave sandusky in your capable hands as I am out of time for now.

May the Grace of God go with you.
 
I see guanophor is back today. You guys have fun, I gotta go.

Sandusky, I’m looking forward to answering your posts to me.

Later,

Helen
 
Perfectly said. How could anyone not see that we were taught by Jesus and taught forth His teachings and traditions? We are the only Church that claims that. We are the only Church that can claim that. We wrote the Bible. How could they believe in the Bible, but think we are not the One Church founded by Christ, but theirs that was founded 1500 years after Christ, is?
Just a little extra information here… There is at least one other church making the claim to apostolic succession and that is the Landmark Independent Baptist church. If I understand them correctly, they claim to be the church founded by Jesus and can supposedly trace their lineage back to John the Baptist. Clearly, they have no historical support for their position, but they claim it none-the-less.
Just FYI
 
40.png
MIZER:
Sandusky, There is so much to reply to here. Would you please consider the fact that you have offered no support, what so ever for any of the arguments you make. Your statements aren’t really arguments they are more like unsubstantiated claims.
So were your statements ”not really arguments they are more like unsubstantiated claims.”

But you’re unable to understand that concerning your arguments, thus my initial statement that your claims would turn out to be fallacious special pleadings.

In my post #321, I said:
While you unquestioningly accept the arguments you put forth concerning what I believe (and obviously, you do; otherwise, why would you make those arguments?), you would either reject those same arguments when applied to what you believe, or, you would attempt to make some kind of exception in the case of what you believe, thereby exempting your beliefs from the same standards you apply to mine.
So which is it for you when your arguments are applied to your beliefs?
Rejection of the arguments, or exemption from them?
When your arguments are applied to your beliefs, you don’t accept the argument, but reject it.

Therefore, you’ve chose rejection, thereby proving my point that your arguments would turn out to be fallacious special pleadings.

But, I’m certain you don’t understand that, and will reject my point with respect to special pleadings as well.
40.png
MIZER:
Do you see the sillyness of your point? It doesn’t respond to the point I am trying to make to you that this process is not only contrary to what you believe is the process Christ intended for our faith education, it is also the process used, by not only Catholics but non-C’s as well. You non-C’s don’t really use the process you claim is the one intended by Christ, ie, Bible alone.
I have responded to your point by calling it what it is—fallacious special pleading.
40.png
MIZER:
I think that’s called hypocrissy. Feel free to correct me if I am wrong but I will expect some support for your argument if you wish to argue that it is not hypocrissy.
The hypocrisy is yours, in that you reject your argument when it’s applied to your beliefs. 😦
40.png
MIZER:
What do you think? Please, Sandusky, run this through your grey matter and then, and only then, tell me what you think, don’t just call me a hypocrite in reaction. We all are very interested to know what it is you think. Can you articualte that?
You’ve continually told me that I lack the ability to reason, that I’m not logical, and now that I need to run what you’re saying through my grey matter.

Methinks it’s time you heed your own advice. 🙂
 
40.png
guanophore:
Yes, of course they do! However, human disagreement does not nullify God’s Truth…Disagreement does not alter the facts.
Thank you guanophore. (I cut-out your bias to get the point).
40.png
guanophore:
We know it in the same way that you know you are saved. We choose to believe God’s promises, and trust Him that He will keep His word. It would be hard for you to “prove” to anyone that you are saved, would it not?
Are you infallible, or fallible?
40.png
guanophore:
That we are to be obedient to the Bishops as we are to Christ.
Grammatically, that’s not an interpretation; try again.
40.png
guanophore:
You seem to believe that God’s preservation left the Church after the Apostles died, and that the holy men who produced the NT under the inspiration of the HS had no other holy men follow them that could propagate the faith properly.
Not at all.
40.png
guanophore:
If scripture has always been the solr rule of faith, then everything Jesus said, unless he was quoting scripture, is invalid!
What Jesus said is recorded in the scripture; what Jesus taught from, and what He held the Jews responsible for knowing was the extant scripture of His day.
40.png
guanophore:
Sola Scriptura creates disunity, which is a road to no where. Jesus commanded unity, which is found in the Truth (Himself).
Sola scriptura binds the true church together.

Christ did not command unity, but prayed to the Father for unity; since the Father always answers the Son’s prayer, it’s specious to claim that Christ’s true church is not united.
40.png
guanophore:
No, because Catholicism has never claimed to be “bible based”. From the beginning, all of our Teaching has come from outside the NT. The NT represents part of the Sacred Tradition, but not all.
Thanks for admitting once again that Catholicism “never claimed to be bible based.”
 
OK Sandusky, since I’m too dense to figure this out on my own, suppose you baby step me through this.
The hypocrisy is yours, in that you reject your argument when it’s applied to your beliefs
Suppose you take me through the steps I would need to go through to understand what you are saying. Take one of my arguments, apply it to my belief and show me how I reject it.

I have no idea what you mean. How do I reject my own argument when it is applied to my belief?

Thanks
 
Sandusky: I am beginning to question your sincerity.
If opposition to something proves that it’s wrong, then you must admit the error of the Papacy.
No one ever said “opposition to something proves that it’s wrong.” And you know full well that no one ever said that or even implied that?

Are you really this confused, or are we to assume you are merely here to kill time?
 
I didn’t raise the issue of literacy—you did.

What I stated is that all of inspired scripture that was to be written was written before 100 A.D.

It doesn’t matter; either way you look at it, in response to my statement concerning the writing of scripture, the literacy argument is a very poor argument; in fact, it’s a non-sequitur.
No, it’s not. Literacy was not even commonplace in the Middle Ages, and even if people could read, there weren’t nearly enough Bibles to go around. That’s why they were chained up at churches, so they wouldn’t be stolen. So for the first 1400 to 1500 years, they weren’t available to the “common person”, nor available to non-Catholics.

It seems to me, that if salvation is dependent upon reading the Bible, then for 1500 years, it wasn’t very attainable. That’s why Christ founded a Church based on St. Peter.
Sola scriptura binds the true church together.
Tell that to the thousands of Protestant denominations with different beliefs.
Christ did not command unity, but prayed to the Father for unity; since the Father always answers the Son’s prayer, it’s specious to claim that Christ’s true church is not united.
The 23 different Catholic Rites are united by the Bishop of Rome. Christ’s prayer certainly was answered. There’s your unity, and there’s your one true Church.
Thanks for admitting once again that Catholicism “never claimed to be bible based.”
Right on! The Bible, rather, is Catholic based.
 
Ah Sodak,

You beat me to it.
Right on! The Bible, rather, is Catholic based.
First I was going to congratulated Sandusky for being so cleaver in his smug little way. Then point out the the true church can’t be based on the Bible becasue the Bible is based on the true church.

This is one of the signs to look for in seeking to find the true church, but I don’t really think that is of any interest to sandusky.
 
And this would be a good time to thank Johannes Gutenberg, good Catholic, who invented the printing press and printed off the Catholic Bible (Latin Vulgate translation) on it.

Because, you know, Catholics were so worried that ordinary people might read the Bible that we preserved Scripture down through the centuries then devised a method to mass produce it.
 
So for the first 1400 to 1500 years, they (printed Bibles)weren’t available to the “common person”, nor available to non-Catholics.
What non-C’s? There weren’t even any non-Catholics at the time.

Now you watch, I’ll bet sandusky doesn’t have a cleaver retort for this.😉 :cool:
 
Because, you know, Catholics were so worried that ordinary people might read the Bible that we preserved Scripture down through the centuries then devised a method to mass produce it.
We only preserved the Scripture we didn’t burn. And wasn’t Guttenburg burned at the stake by the Catholic empire for inventing the printing press? That’s what I heard.😉
 
40.png
MIZER:
Suppose you take me through the steps I would need to go through to understand what you are saying. Take one of my arguments, apply it to my belief and show me how I reject it.

I have no idea what you mean. How do I reject my own argument when it is applied to my belief?
You argued concerning the manner in which new protestant converts are instructed. I argued identically concerning the manner in which new converts to Catholicism are instructed.

You argued that scripture doesn’t support many protestant beliefs. I argued identically that scripture doesn’t support many Catholic beliefs.

You argued that protestant interpretation proves that protestants can make the bible say anything they want it to say. I argued identically that Catholic interpretation proves that Catholics can make the bible say anything they want it to say.

IOW, when I turn your manner of argument against your beliefs, you reject the argument as not valid, all the while insisting that the argument, when used against my beliefs is valid, and it disproves my beliefs.

It’s a double-standard.

You’re going to have to think about it for while because you’re either using the argument of some other Catholic apologist, and assume that all Catholic apologetics are air-tight and true; or, you’ve been using the argument for so long, and no one has recognized the manner of the argument for what it is, and so, you’ve never been called on it.
 
We only preserved the Scripture we didn’t burn. And wasn’t Guttenburg burned at the stake by the Catholic empire for inventing the printing press? That’s what I heard.😉
That was Steve Guttenberg, burned at the stake for Police Academy IV.
 
40.png
MIZER:
Sandusky: I am beginning to question your sincerity.
You’re just beginning? 😃
40.png
MIZER:
No one ever said “opposition to something proves that it’s wrong.” And you know full well that no one ever said that or even implied that?
Here is your statement:
If the Bible was the sole rule of faith it would, firstly, tell us so and secondly there would be no opposing interpretations as every sincere reader would come to the same conclusion as to it’s meaning.
To which I replied:
If opposition to something proves that it’s wrong, then you must admit the error of the Papacy.
What you’re implying, IMO, is that opposing interpretations of scripture negate the bible as the sole rule of faith; correct?

If that’s true of sola scriptura, then why doesn’t the great schism over the papacy negate the papacy?

Is that another double standard?
 
…
You argued that scripture doesn’t support many protestant beliefs. I argued identically that scripture doesn’t support many Catholic beliefs.
Yet the fact is that by comparison it supports far more Catholic belief than n-C. Frankly, I would even say that the poster is correct to say that scripture supports Catholic belief and that, (for the reason I point out below) it does not support n-C beliefs.
You argued that protestant interpretation proves that protestants can make the bible say anything they want it to say. I argued identically that Catholic interpretation proves that Catholics can make the bible say anything they want it to say.
In your errant opinion.

Which particular n-C sect will you now tell us has that fullness of truth? Your own? Not that I have seen in many long months of reading your posts.
IOW, when I turn your manner of argument against your beliefs, you reject the argument as not valid, all the while insisting that the argument, when used against my beliefs is valid, and it disproves my beliefs.
It’s a double-standard.
So… do you feel better now that you made a carnal argument appear as if it is meritorious?

I and others here have refuted your arguments using both scriptures and historic facts, and yet, just as you say here, “…you reject the argument as not valid, all the while insisting that the argument, when used against my beliefs is valid, and it disproves my beliefs.”. So how are you any better than the person above?
You’re going to have to think about it for while because you’re either using the argument of some other Catholic apologist, and assume that all Catholic apologetics are air-tight and true; or, you’ve been using the argument for so long, and no one has recognized the manner of the argument for what it is, and so, you’ve never been called on it.
And again…how does that make this Catholic you speak of any much different than you or any other n-C they talk with?

In fact, most of the better Catholic apologists actually are far more sound than any of their n-C counterparts. I know because I have seen both in action.

It’s even more simple than this really.

So long as n-C apologists begin their apologetics with Sola Scriptura, (which none of them have yet to make a convincing case for in the 500 years since the error came into being) then their every argument fails because of that fundamental error.

It’s simply a house built upon sand that cannot withstand the tide of apologetic facts. 🤷
 
Sandusky,
Please prove, with valid facts, that our arguments are
fallacious special pleadings. You just keep blanketing us with that as if it is true. Just because you have not been taught the Truth of Catholocism by your Church, doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist. It just means that you have never been taught it. We are trying to teach you and show you, but you just won’t consider anything we have to say as even possibly being true. We were around at least 1500 years prior to your Church. Please, just let that gate open for a minute!!! We are not teaching heresy, fallicy or anything else. We are interpreting, teaching and practicing the exact way and exactly what all of the Early Church Fathers taught and practiced. We are answering you. You just won’t take anything we have to say. Find out exactly why your Church changed from Catholocism. Look at those changes and find out the truth of them. Until you do that, all you are doing is quoting your Church and it’s teachings.
 
Just a little extra information here… There is at least one other church making the claim to apostolic succession and that is the Landmark Independent Baptist church.
Thank you for correcting me. I knew there was something about the Baptist’s thinking they were original, but I didn’t know which one or how original they were claiming to be. I learned a little of that in high school and just remember learning that there was no proof to back up their claim and there is no mention of them in by any ECF, any early writings or even the Bible. I just chalked that up to wishful thinking.
 
OK Sandusky, since I’m too dense to figure this out on my own, suppose you baby step me through this.

Suppose you take me through the steps I would need to go through to understand what you are saying. Take one of my arguments, apply it to my belief and show me how I reject it.

I have no idea what you mean. How do I reject my own argument when it is applied to my belief?

Thanks
Mizer,
Sandusky is just using circular discussion. There is no real reasoning or proof to what he/she is saying because there is nothing to base it on other than what he/she has been taught by his/her church. There is no way that a church founded in the 1500’s or better, that splintered off of the original trunk of Christianity due to reformation (note, the real reasons for the Reformation), could EVER be the One, True Church founded by Christ. Christ founded that on Peter and the Apostles. They are not in any lineage with them, so, again, they could not possibly be the True Church founded by Christ. They have just convinced themselves, somehow by changing the truth, that they are.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top